Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Aurious Back *LINK*

Posts

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#26

Footnote on John Aniano's 'Bamboo leaf knife' *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

As mentioned above, there are some interior surfaces that can only be scraped clean (as far as I know, anyway). In my project, it was those intersecting convex surfaces.

John Aniano, the bowmaker, makes a tool he calls a 'bamboo leaf knife'. See link. He makes these from old files (especially Grobet's when he can find them), and wraps them as shown in lizard skin. This little knife has a compound curve to it, and the effect of the curves is to allow you reach into almost any carving (or any interior intersection) and scrape a final surface to make it ready for finish.

This is a fantastic little tool, and it shows great attention to detail, as one might expect from an instrument maker. See bottom of linked page.

Wiley


John Aniano's 'bamboo leaf knife'

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#27

price/quality

paul womack

>I have every belief, based on opinions from people I trust, that Aurious are the best rasps made. This is a splendid thing for people who either want or need the best.

However.

To me, that does not justify "any price". There's ALWAYS a cost/benefit ratio, and "the best" has a nasty habit of triggering the law of diminishing returns.

For example, I have also read favourable reports of these rasps:

http://www.dick.biz/dick/category/dickcatalog/Schwertfisch-Raspeln-107_109/detail.jsf

which are ... cheaper. Are they as good as Aurious? No, not according to people in a position to make the comparison.

Are these Chinese rasps a proposition worth considering? Only you can decide.

BugBear

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#28

Re: grain comparison to...

Brent Smith, Montreal

>Hi Mike,

Yes I would agree with you that Nicholson's do quickly lose their 'bite' as you lighten up on the pressure. I think this is one of the main reasons I like Aurious. Even as you lighten pressure the rasp is still removing a decent amount of material, just leaving a smoother finish behind.

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#29

Aurious Back and the fine rasps are sold out

Pedder

>Had a quick look and found the fine modeller rasp already sold out. Price can't ne that wrong.

Cheers Pedder

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#30

Re: Crazy prices

Paul M.

>The main problem that guitar builders have is that their customers are musicians. That's a rather low-income class of customers for a very high-labor product. The economics are completely upside down on that one.

What's the difference between a luthier and a 16" pizza? The 16" pizza can feed a family of four. ;-)

-- Paul (budding luthier, but not expecting to make much money)

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#31

Precisely!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>The market has a way of figuring out what folks can charge for their work. Auriou will make it, or they won't. But I wish them well, and am looking forward to that big grain 15 cabinet rasp about Christmas time.

Wiley

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#32

Not surprising......

Brent Smith, Montreal

>I think all the finer rasps will sell out quickly. To just hog off material any rasp will do the job, though IMO not as nicely as an Auriou. To get down to the finer detail work, again IMO, nothing compares to an Auriou. Add to that the fact that the finer the rasp, the more labor intensive stitching it is. Having only one person doing the stitching right now, it's probably more profitable for them to turn out larger runs of the coarser rasps till they get a few more people trained.

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#33

Re: Not surprising......

Pedder

>Yes and Auriou is the only resource for really fine rasps.

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#34

Re: Crazy prices

Todd Hughes

>They are not really selling a rasp but rather they are selling an experance and an idea that you are buying some exclusive tool that is made by hand using methods that only one man knows.

If an identical rasp that performed exactly the same was sold by a company that showed them on thier web site being cranked out by a machine in China do you think many would get sold at that price? of course not.

...Actually the high price of these things is probably as much of the experance of owning one as there being made by hand and how they perform is. Some People WANT to pay big prices for stuff because that way they "know" they are getting quality.Of course always gives a bit of bragging rights to I imagine

.....gee now I feel bad for not buying that mint in the paper old Black Diamond rasp today at the flea market that the seller wanted $3 for...I thought he was on the moon with a price like that!.....Todd

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#35

Re: Crazy prices

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, and I'm so pleased to see that now that Michel got rid of his lazy old workers (Wouldn't work through their vacations? The slugs.), he's now got a new bunch much, much cheaper. NOT. The prices seem about 20% higher than before.

Pam

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#36

Not so crazy prices

wilbur

>Whenever anyone brings up that sort of argument I like to remember that the same line of reasoning leads to the conclusion that we should all get our furniture from Ikea, and leave this woodworking thing by the wayside.

But for these rasps, I'm going to take Michel Auriou at his word that their stitcher can only do the stitching on 150-180 rasps per month. To make the math easier, and to provide a more conservative estimate, suppose they can actually stitch 200 rasps a month. With a 40 hour work week, and 20 work days in a month, that's 1.25 hours per rasp for the stitching time. But the rasps also have to go through a forging step by their blacksmith, and a grinding step by their grinder, and heat treating fits in there someplace as well. With these additional steps, the total labor for a single rasp is probably at least 3 hours or more. Again, let's be conservative and estimate 2.5 hours of labor for a single rasp.

The Auriou cabinetmakers rasps are priced anywhere from � 78-148, which works out to $98-186. Given typical retail markup, the actual cost of the rasp is about half that, or $48-93, which works out to a conservative labor cost of about $20-38 an hour. I think most people here would say that $20-38 an hour for skilled labor is pretty reasonable.

The real labor cost is probably much less than that, given the conservative estimates above. In addition, this isn't even including raw material cost and other overhead, which probably reduces the actual labor rate.

So it seems to me that "the high price of these things" is probably related to the actual cost of skilled labor and production, and not "the experance [sic] of owning one as there [sic] being made by hand".

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#37

Could it just be.....

Brent Smith, Montreal

>That some prefer a New York Sirloin if they can afford it, while other's will settle for a Macdonald's burger? I think that your example of an assembly line made rasp against a hand made rasp is about as reasonable as the Sirloin versus Big Mac example. Having eaten both, and used both types of rasps I can definately say I feel my money is well spent on the more expensive of the two examples. Have you ever used an Auriou Todd?

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#38

Re: Could it just be.....

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Probably not. Todd would probably rather use a farriers rasp that he found at an estate auction holding up the corner of an old anvil. And rusty too!:-)

Joe

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#39

Re: Not so crazy prices

Todd Hughes

>When I buy somthing to use I could care less how long it took to make or who made it or how much they made doing it... I am only concerned with the product and if I can get a simular product for less that will perform as well or close enough not to make a diffrence.

If I need a hole dug in my yard I don't think I should pay a guy more to dig it because he is an experanced hole digger and is using a table spoon so can only dig so much dirt per hour ...not my concern if I can get the same hole dug for less by paying a guy that uses a shovel.

I will admit to never using one of these rasps, and if I had I would never say so because I would be to embarrased to admit I spent so much money on somthing like that!

...I HAVE spent many, many hours working a rasp or a file and definitly know the difference between a good high quality example and cheap junk even if the rasps I was using I paid $1 for at the flea market...Do these expensive rasps work better then my New old stock Nicholson pattern maker rasps I used alot? Maybe they do, the question is do they perform $80- $180 better? Are they that much faster? does the wood look that much better when done? I think for them to be worth this price they would have to get up and fly out to the shop and do the work on thier own and then come back in and make you lunch.

.... I look at tools like this sort of like a Humvee, people that buy them will tell you the reason they buy them is because how powerful they are, how they can climb up mountains and this and that but in the end does any of it really make a difference while you are driving to the 7 11 in it to get a slurpy ?.......Todd

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#40

Nah

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Given Todd's propensity for pruning trees with shotguns, I'm willing to bet what he uses is stranger yet.

Re: Aurious Back *LINK*

#41

Trying to recall, Bill, did

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>he use a shotgun for the tree-trimming, or was it the Maxim machine gun?

Wiley