Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

Posts

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#26

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

ThomD

>I've never had a problem with the Tarrant saws I bought before they sold out to LN. Particularly on wood that hefty. Did they change the teeth? Tom Law used to sharpen the Tarrant saws I heard.

What was your thinking on the saw till dovetails? The tails seem really wide. Does it hang on the wall? Seems like the lower one is missing a pin Most of my stuff hangs on racks so it needs tails on the side. Always interesting to know about designs.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#27

Does this mean

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that at some point hidden mitered dovetails will become the rage? With X-ray photos pasted to the drawer bottom to demonstrate that there are dovetails there?

Just joshing, but you never know...

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#28

Re: Does this mean

Bob Demers

>Heh dont laugh, i have actually seen in a WW catalog, dovetails tape.

Thats right, a rows of pins on a roll of tape that you applied to the drawer sides to simulate the look of dovetails when opening the drawer...ohh ahhh

That was a few years back, and i havent seen that product ever since.

Wonder why it didnt catch on ?? :-)

Now talk about fast dovetails, as fast as you can unroll and stick them up!

Bob, who has now applied simulated laser beams on a tape to his snow banks. Beat mounting a real laser on my snow blower :-)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#29

OT - Home shop laser

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Dig a flashlight out of the kitchen junk drawer. Replace the batteries (of COURSE they've gone flat). Go to your local keep-the-beater-running auto parts store and buy one of those "taillight repair" kits that consists of red cellophane tape, with instructions that make applying cellophane tape to your taillight sound like an actual, the-police-won't-bother-you solution to the fact that most of the lens is missing. Apply tape to flashlight lens.

Most effective after dark, when you can actually see the red light.

Bill, offering this idea in honor of the early years of Mad Magazine, which once described a do-it-yourself hifi* unit involving, among other parts, a cat.

*For the benefit of the young: this is what "sound systems" were called back then, back then being when Corvettes could be ordered with "Blue Flame" 6-cylinder engines.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#30

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I've never had a problem with the Tarrant saws I bought before they sold out to LN. Particularly on wood that hefty. Did they change the teeth? Tom Law used to sharpen the Tarrant saws I heard.

Thom, I have both the LN Independent dovetail saw and the Independent Tools dovetail saw, from whence the LN sprung. There is a comparison on my website (under reviews).

The IT was brand new when I bought it on eBay (it feels like a couple of years ago now). Because I was not inspired by the difficulty starting my, then, newish LN, I had Mike Wenzloff look it over. He added some fleam. It definitely starts better than the LN, but they cut the same. I prefer the slightly thicker grip on the LN.

What was your thinking on the saw till dovetails? The tails seem really wide. Does it hang on the wall? Seems like the lower one is missing a pin Most of my stuff hangs on racks so it needs tails on the side. Always interesting to know about designs.

The dovetails are all pretty excellent. They are spaced about 2 1/2" apart, as I recall. No missing pins. I had not planed back the excess when I took the picture - I will post another when it is complete. The reason I posted the picture in the first place was that I was responding to the thread, showing that I had time (I was not racing) and somehow managed to reverse where the pins and tails should go.

So this is no special "design". :) I was tempted to start again, but this is just shop furniture and it ranks quite low on my list of priorities (although it will be nice to have a planned and organised workshop for a change!). I think that the glue and the glue area will be enough to provide sufficient strength, and I have reinforced the saw rest with Jarrah dowels. It should be completred next weekend, and I'll post a final picture then.

Here is a blow up.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#31

Re: Watch closely

adam Cherubini

>Honestly, I'm just not a big fan of this particular demo. Call me a wet blanket. I just don't see the point of it. And you don't strike me as someone who wants or needs to impress us. Was it fun to watch? Absolutely. But I like your dvds in general and have seen them all.

Let me just give you a for instance- When I go to shows or clubs, I like to do a similar demo. I get out my cross cut backsaw and saw as thin a slice as I can from the end of a board. The goal is to get it thin AND uniform AND unbroken. And some in the audience may ooh and ahh, so there's a component of showing off. But it's a real job that folks who work by hand must learn. And I explain my technique while I'm doing it. Then I hand off the saw for others to try. So it's a similar kind of thing, but has a deeper purpose. There's a use in it.

I'm looking for that use in your demo and I want to make sure I'm not missing something that you're trying to tell me. I'm not being negative. Critical would be fair. Interested is more accurate. I'm paying VERY close attention. The question I asked was a real one. Sounds like you weren't really thinking about any of that. What did Freud say? Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar?

Adam

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#32

Re: Watch closely

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>And when there is no cigar, is that a negative? :)

Pam

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#33

Nope. Just no cigar.

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#34

Re: Watch closely

wilbur

>Well, I know what I've taken away from this demo.

1. Quick summary of Rob's method of cutting dovetails.

2. Proof that you don't have to mark every line when sawing, with sufficient practice.

3. An idea as to how quickly you can cut dovetails, so as to give me a benchmark to shoot for in efficiency.

4. Knowledge that using a dovetail jig and a router may not actually be saving as much time as I thought.

Not too bad for a YouTube video.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#35

I like your way of thinking

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#36

Re: Watch closely

Alan DuBoff

>Adam wrote

"Honestly, I'm just not a big fan of this particular demo."

That's fair, but as someone that wears 18th century clothing, I would have thought you would be big on demonstrations.

I was entertained by the demo, and would also garner a similar video from you to show how you use your 18th century tooling to accomplish the same joinery. I think others would like to see such a video as well, please consider it.

It's not about who is the fastest, or which method is more popular, that is all up to each of us to decide for ourselves in how we approach our work. To some extent the results speak for themselves, and Rob's certainly do just that.

Thanks for taking the time Rob, speaking for myself I enjoyed it quite a bit!

Regards,

Alan (still curious about Rob's marking knife and saw;-)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#37

Your showing are age!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Ummm, I mean yours...

Yea... that's the ticket.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#38

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

ThomD

>I knew that pin had to be there somewhere! That really helps.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#39

Re: Does this mean

ThomD

>Now there is a joint that always seemed like a lot of trouble for ending up looking like it was biscuit jointed. I never much liked the mitered look in corners, and it is so easy to pooch that a little and need to bring out the burnisher.