Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

Posts

3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#1

3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>And the result looks quite good!

DC

Thinking of selling his tools (not!)


Rob Cosman dovetailing a corner

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#2

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner!

David Cockey

>I wonder how Rob's demonstration compares to what one would have seen wandering into a 18th or 19th century shop building draws on a piecework basis? Assume 4 minutes per corner and dovetails on all four corners, it would be 16 minutes per drawer for the dovetailing.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#3

God, that's just depressing.

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#4

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Well, Rob's result was prettier than Frank Klausz'. Frank did it "much" (!) faster in 3 minutes dead. :) It seemed obvious to me that this video was made to compete against the time of Frank, and Rob could be seem straining to keep up - that is, there is little chance that he would attempt to maintain this pace to meet production demands. Then again, neither would Frank work at this pace since his dovetails were not that nice looking. Just two bulls slugging it out.

Both are woodworkers and teachers I respect and enjoy enormously.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#5

Bill Tindall recently reported on drawer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>production time, which he learned from an older woodworker who had apprenticed in England and worked in the furniture-making trade there. Bottom line: 2 hours per drawer. Don't know if that included cockbeading or special veneer, etc, but that was a real-life number for sustained production to meet the English market's quality standard.

Wiley

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#6

Mine were more leisurely today ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>... but I stll managed to screw them up. Talk about spatial problems!

I decided to make a start on a saw till, cut, shot, spokeshaved and planed boards to size, then dovetailed the ends (what neither Rob nor Frank include in their times in the set up that is needed before sawing! The sawing and chiseling is the easy part).

Well, my dovetails are tight and beautiful ... if you could see them, that is! Mixed up the board direction, didn't I! ..... still very much a WIP ..



I guess I will keep the cabinet. I am sure it will still be strong enough. It will serve to remind me which way is up.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#7

Re: Mine were more leisurely today ...

Paul Kierstead

>Heh, now that is why I now draw joinery on sides of my pieces and kinda hold them togather with clamps to scope it out. Been there a couple of times :)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

New Saw

Jim in Burlington On

>What's that new saw he mentions? Doesn't look like a LN saw.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#9

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner!

ThomD

>Frank's dovetails on Dovetail a Drawer are nice though the material was not challenging. He said he billed 20 minutes (?) for the drawer which includes everything. Though that sounds awful fast, maybe another senior moment for me.

The twisted saw, I haven't seen the current video, but when he first spoke of it, it was for making crates, and stuff like that not cabinetry.

I wouldn't put Rob in the same catagory as Franz Klausz, though I don't really know enough about either. If you have seen the Peters video that Rob did, left me wanting more in a good way, I got the feeling Rob was not at risk of showing up his teacher. Klausz actually runs a shop and does business in the real world, in addition to his teaching. So far we don't have a Lumberjack games format for dovetails, considering what has happened with planes, it may come.

Funny thing, in the old days even little towns had real cabinet shops. I know a few that still have the signage from the 19th century painted on their brick walls. And I am talking Canada, in the US they are storied. I know that Saint John, in Rob's neck of the woods, had some real shops. Many of these shops probably would have given Klausz' shop in Philly a run on some level, at least, but serious work is a lot thinner on the ground these days.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#10

That's still not as bad as...

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>having dove tails with the flare going in the wrong direction.

greg -guilty as charged.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#11

I wonder how he compensates...

Alan DuBoff

>After all it seems Rob is still using that old Stanley utility knife as a marking knife...it was pointed out to me recently that the Stanley utility knife I use doesn't produce a proper kerf for a marking knife as it is v shaped. Seems to work out pretty well for him though. Just proves that it ain't rocket science...:-)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#12

Red Ink

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>and neither is that Bic red pen,

so much spent on such simplicity...LOL

And I have a few DT's around my shop that cost thousands!!!!

I've watched Rob cut a ton of DT's in person.... that You Tube was not unexpected...

take it easy

Jim

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#13

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Alan

I have not tried this, but it occurs to me that a skinny blade with a v-shaped bevel will place the line a tad away from the sidewall - just in the right place to use it as a saw guide. And that should produce tight dovetails. What do you think?

Regards from Perth

Derek (who saws alongside the fine line that he scratches)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#14

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Alan DuBoff

>Derek,

I know that your correct, and in use the blade I use which is also v-shaped is flushed up against the edge as much as possible.

Some of what Gorman advocated works well, like tilting the blade so that it registers against the edge, I find this the case with my v-shaped blade. I could be bias though, since I saw Rob using the old Stanley Utility Knife in his dovetail video, and decided to try to newer 10-049. As it turned out, the blade is very thin which is what I had been looking for, and it is long enough to fit in most all dovetails I cut, at a length of 1 3/4".

After doing some slight modifications which were suggested in Rob's video, of rounding the tip so that it slices the grain rather than the pointy tip tearing the grain, it works fine.

I have learned enough about metal to make my own marking knife if I wanted, but the Stanley 10-049 works well, is very reasonable, and the replacement blades are readily available. For that matter, you/others can buy the blades and use them in your own markers, should the v-shape not bother yourselves.

Speaking for myself, the mark is just a mark, it's not something to completely register the saw blade. It is something I cut to when I cut dovetails and other joinery. My work is not good enough to know if it's .001" off...and even if it is I can tap it with a ball pein hammer and close up the gap. I don't need to do that though.

I still admire the way Frank Klausz cuts dovetails and think it's an excellent way to practice where one doesn't need to worry about any layout, and can just focus on getting joinery cut. I usually always mark my dovetails out with dividers like Rob advocates.

Regards,

Alan

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#15

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

ThomD

>My feeling personally is that half the diff. in learning dovetails is just dialing in your marks. There are a bunch of things happening where a person is inside on this and outside on that, and it ads up to sloppy joints. Then one day it comes together, and I for one, don't want to mess with it. I have all these fancy marking knives etc... but it came together for me when I was experimenting with a particular bevel on a pencil. So that is what I used for DTs to this day. Actually on really tight work in hard woods I use a knife, but it's the same idea just a different set of tolerances. I don't find the process is like machinist work where you actually identify the target to .001" or better, find the edge zero, in on the co-ordinate and execute the cut. It's more a feel thing. Tolerances can be similar though.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#16

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>My feeling personally is that half the diff. in learning dovetails is just dialing in your marks.

Hi Thom

It is great when it comes together. The saw till above has really nice, tight dovetails straight off the saw. As I cut them I could feel in in my bones that everything was just right. I was thinking about it as I sawed. It is partly confidence in the line you draw/cut, and partly comfort with your saw action.

I was using a LN saw, which has a reputation for being hard to start. I like the tote - it is a good size for my grip. It is a matter of laying the blade against the line and allowing the saw to do the work. There was no problem with starting the cut, or jumping off line (and into the knifed line). Because the knifed line is very thin, I must saw as close to the line as I can. The more relaxed one is, the easier it gets.

Regards from Perth

Derek (with Monday afternoon off, and away to the workshop to finish the till)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#17

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Bob Demers

>Quote I still admire the way Frank Klausz cuts dovetails and think it's an excellent way to practice where one doesn't need to worry about any layout, and can just focus on getting joinery cut. Unquote

I struggle for a while with my dovetails, that is until I came accross that video of Frak Klausz. (it came with my subscription to Time -Life The art of cabinet making, in the early 90s)

It was such a revelation, it removed all the intimidation I ever had with that joint, and made it so uncomplicated. I then started to used it everywhere, I felt liberated, and the rest is history like they say

Now, im dabbling with measurements to make them neater looking, but most often than not, especially for utility drawers, I just free hand them a la Klausz.

Bob, with is snowblower at the ready (must install laser snow banks cutters)

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#18

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Bill Collier

>I think that in one of his videos Rob says that he regrinds the blade to a shape he prefers.

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#19

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>For the past couple of years, all I use is a utility knife, a high end metal-case Xacto knife. It works fine as long as its snug along the edges of the tails or pins. They're great for marking the very narrow pins. I think they're $1.99 apiece.

I've got 3 of them on my bench..

Norman

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#20

Parlor trick?

Adam Cherubini

>Anybody else having trouble seeing the relevance of this? In my shop, drawers all have half blind dts up front. This is where I spend my time. Some carcases have half blind dt's as well. Keeping the boards flat is important. And the wood is harder and the dt's bigger. These pine samples aren't really representative enough of anything I do (save drawer backs) for me to get much out of them.

I guess it's just fun. Rob's divider use seemed to cost him seconds unnecessarily. I'm impressed by his ability to cut square without a line. I always draw the line. Allan Breed just eyeballs teh sqyare as well. I too would like to know where he got that saw. Looked like it had a maple handle? It was pretty white. Maybe it was PLASTIC!!

Adam

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#21

Watch closely

Rob Cosman

>Adam, you seem a bit on the negative side! If you watch it again please pay closer attention to my "smile" and the "lilt" in my voice. Being a tails first guy I was just throwing a little fun Frank's way to keep the "tails vs pins" argument alive and hopefully give "most" people a bit of enjoyment. With all the doom and gloom of late isn't it nice to be just "entertained" for a few minutes.

No I don't do them like this when I work (as stated on the clip), and yes Pine is easy to saw, easy to chisel and relatively cheap. I don't use it for drawer sides, in fact until last week I have never used it to demo with at woodshows. You remind me of the guy that is always in the audience with the comment "Yeah, let's see you cut them that fast in Ebony"! My response is always "you pay for it and I'll cut it"!

So in as nice a way as possible, Lighten up! get some pants and quit wearing your PJs in all your photos! :)

Rob Cosman

ps I will have a "fast 1/2 blind" clip in the near future for you!

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#22

Re: I wonder how he compensates...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

Rob Cosman's method (actually it might be Alan Peters method) of measuring with dividers works XLNT for me.

There are many ways to skin this cat, and Rob's method is but one. However, it is one that has been known to work for a good many folks. You might give it a try.

Regards,

Alan

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#23

Your Stanley Utility Knife

Alan DuBoff

>Rob,

Was some discussion here on WoodCentral not long ago about marking knives. I use a fairly new Stanley 10-049, which has a thin blade. I have rounded the tip as I believe you suggest in one of your videos, and it works well for me.

I know that you have used your old Stanley Utility Knife for a long time. Was curious if you use a v-shaped edge or not? I have a v-shaped edge on mine and I don't worry about it being a proper marking edge or not. It was pointed out to me that you need a flat side for a proper marking knife, but I just use the Stanley and it works for me. I do tilt the blade to register it against the edge, but haven't noticed any ramification in my work, that might be because I do substandard work. :-)

This is what I use:


I use this stock blade, but end was rounded over with a hand grinder.


Works well for me, the blade is thin and gets between the tails nicely, and is long enough for most all dovetails I do (1 3/4" long). Also cuts leather when I need to, whittles the end of tenon pins, and a host of other good stuff that crops up in the shop. For any marking that this knife is not long enough, I use an awl.

Regards,

Alan

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#24

And don't forget to tell us about your saw!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: 3:40 for dovatailing a corner! *LINK*

#25

Re: Parlor trick? Some 80s history

ThomD

>Do you use half blinds on the rear of the drawer? In Klausz' video he is making dovetails for a drawer with a, yuck, applied front, but it is a real world piece of furniture. He uses through dovetails on packing cases. There are other uses like door frames, work bench vises and trays, etc... Of course the original taunton vid, was made in the early 80s. At that time all the jazz was for exposed, through dovetails. I'm just guessing but I assume that was the reason they sorta melded the through dovetails with a practical project. And a star was born! As opposed to folks like Krenov or Alan Peters, I associate Klausz' with traditional forms, certainly he is well familiar with half blinds, but at the time it wasn't what the market wanted. Took 10-15 years for the market to catch up. When I was doing dovetail demos about 10 years ago, I only had one person out of a half dozen classes I did that wanted to know how to do half blinds, and or at least spoke up about it. So you are right that there are lots of cases where half blind were the ticket on older furniture, I guess the guys who can nail the through dovetails fast are going to have all the time needed for the half blinds. As far as demos are concerned the Frid trick for half blinds gets a smile.

Also, speaking of the 80s history and earlier, the deal about through dovetails is that pre-Leigh they couldn't be cut by machine as HBs regularly are, so they spoke loudly of hand work, which was the pitch. The other aspect is that exposed dovetails fit in with the architectural ideas of exposed structure. Those got swept under the rug more recently with the return to ornamental forms, but that's the way it was then. If you stuck with the rivival from the 80s on, it was pretty obvious stuff would go back to earlier forms if only to keep it interesting. Cutting through dovetails is a basic technique.