Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

odd plane blade angles

Posts

odd plane blade angles

#1

odd plane blade angles

David

>I've finally gotten around to sharpening the blades on a couple of old planes that I acquired over the last month and was struck by the angles at which a number of the blades have been ground.

The first is a Stanley 16, where the blade is ground at 32 or 33 degrees, the other is a 78 ground to 35. Do you think these are simply someone's favored angles or maybe his/her eye is like mine and could benefit from a honing guide?

The 16 and a 4 that came with it are something of a long story. I got them as a package deal, only wanting the 16 which the seller thought was a 9 1/2, as by the picture did I. Turns out that the 4 is a Canadian Sweetheart (old type logo). With the rust off the 16's blade, turns out that it too, is a Sweetheart (newer logo). Both came out of Quebec. The box they were shipped in looked like the post office kicked it all the way to my doorstep. Both planes completely apart, knicks and a crack in the 4's handle that weren't there when it was shipped, bent knob screw, and the front knob of the 16 MIA. Screw is now straight, wondering if I can CA glue the crack, "new" 16 knob from Bob Kaune. With a little honing and despite the weird angles, both still work great, trip from up north notwithstanding!

Re: odd plane blade angles

#2

Re: odd plane blade angles

John Aniano in Central NJ...

>David,

Yes, it could be that the former owner(s) might not have been able to properly hone the blades OR...

In order to plane hard, tropical woods, I often increase the blade angle to those kind of numbers, sometimes more, especially for my 9 1/2 block plane. Perhaps the former owner simply planed very hard woods.

My $0.02...

John

Re: odd plane blade angles

#3

Re: odd plane blade angles

Dean J in MN

>The 78 is bevel down, 35 is fine, still gives you 10 degrees of clearance. Probably just the pervious owners preferred grind.

The 16 is a bevel-up, correct? If so the 32/33 is reasonable as well. 32 + deg angle puts you somewhere in the 40-50 degree range.

I don't get hung up an perfect angles, I think the lesson here is you shouldn't either. The planes are going to work with a wide range of angles, even the bevel up.

Cheers

Dean

Re: odd plane blade angles

#4

Re: odd plane blade angles

ThomD

>I once fitted a 30 degree scraper plane blade into a 35 degree bedding angle plane. The gives 5 degrees of clearance, and worked as well as any plane i have ever owned. One theoretical advantage is that when the angle is more obtuse the striations from sharpening create a lower pattern of marks in the cutting edge. This means a given degree of polish works out to a finner finish, better cut, stronger edge.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#5

Re: odd plane blade angles

David

>Thanks for the info. I'm still kind of new to dealing with anything other than "standard" grinding and honing. I was having fun this afternoon playing with the 16 taking translucent shavings of pine, thin enough to read through.

Interestingly, despite similar non-standard angles, the 78 and the 16 are from different people.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#6

non-standard angle

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>David, I'm not sure that I would call 35 degrees non-standard. Some of the cutters for my 45 plane retained the factory grind when I bought it. I think they were 35 degrees. I have an idea that my 78 plane, which was old and unused when I bought it decades ago was also 35.

The idea that the angle needs to be precise to a certain degree is relatively recent. Although there is an optimum angle for a given wood, a given steel etc., it is much more important what kind of edge one is getting. I think those who are concerned with whether the angle is 31 or 33 tend to be finicky professionals or dilettantes. I have often been in a shop where the guy will tell you he sharpens at "30" but you can see that some tools are closer to 35. And he is doing fine work. I am sure some have them, but after decades of nosing about in other shops, I have yet to see a honing guide in a professional shop.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#7

Re: non-standard angle

ThomD

>"I think those who are concerned with whether the angle is 31 or 33 tend to be finicky professionals or dilettantes."

While small differences in bedding angle can be noticeable, though in general I don't fuss, I would agree on grind angle. Of course it is a precision exercise so if a person started with 25 and ended up at 31, I would be worried. :)

Re: odd plane blade angles

#8

Re: odd plane blade angles

David

>I really appreciate the comments. If I hadn't been using a honing guide I don't think I would have known the difference between 31 and 35 degrees (or probably 25 for that matter). Given what folks have said about blade angles and what works best for harder woods etc. I'm wondering if it wouldn't make sense to have duplicate planes with different grinds (now that's a good excuse for more tools!).

Re: odd plane blade angles

#9

Re: non-standard angle

Sgian Dubh

>"I think those who are concerned with whether the angle is 31 or 33 tend to be finicky professionals or dilettantes.

Warren, I can see the logic in your claim with respect to the dilletante woodworker; but speaking as a professional that is acquainted with a wide circle of other professionals I can't think of more than one or two that has any idea precisely what honing angle or grinding angle they put on their chisels and irons.

Of the one or two that I suspect do know these angles, one is a woodworking author; I imagine this author knows because the readers would be unhappy if such details were omitted from the text. Amateur woodworkers do so like cure-all certainties in my experience-- it is only as they develop experience and knowledge that they realise all this adherance to precise cutting edge geometry is largely unimportant, and near enough is often more than good enough. Slainte.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#10

Re: non-standard angle

ThomD

>I can't really refute that perception because I know very few professional woodworkers who aren't also authors, teacher, etc... That's were we are these days. If we are talking carpenters I don't know very many of those who sharpen anything, everything has a disposable blade.

But I do find the overall contention odd, who out there doesn't know the angle they grind their tools at? How do you grind a tool without in some sense knowing? I can do a rough grind on a blank and hit it within a few degrees without a rest, check it against an angle gage and then burn the rest in by feel. It is like anything in woodworking where you can choose to go by numbers or by eye. Over the years I can probably read an angle by eye, but more likely I will just look at it on the grinder rest and bring it up for good contact and grind away. So a person can choose not to measure it, but I think most people who are around measurements every day will know what they are looking at pretty closely anyway.

I was looking at this device the other day in a catalogue, it hangs over the end of a board and reads for thickness. I kinda wondered how people don't know just looking at it. It all comes with familiarity, I was looking at some collets for a lathe I have had fo not yet a year. I wanted to figure out the missing sizes. I had to pull out my glasses and look at the stamped sizes because I wasn't $16.95 a collet sure of the sizes. A little round hole in the end of a collet isn't something I have an eye for yet. I'm not horrible at picking out box wrenches for bolts though. I can probably pick out the wrench first time most of the time in metric or imperial. It gets crazy though if one doesn't know which one is looking at. 9mm or 3/8"? Gotta get out the calipers, or just try for a fit.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#11

Re: non-standard angle

Sgian Dubh

>What I am saying Thom is that I really don't know to within a few degrees what angle I use to sharpen most of my tools. I have never measured the angle and I've never used a jig or a guide to either grind a tool or hone one.

I can hone or grind to the same angle repeatedly on a series of chisels sharpened one after the other, or hone or grind three or four plane blades one after the other, again maintaining the same angle for each iron. Whenever I pick up a chisel to sharpen I instinctively go for the same angle every time, even if days or even weeks have passed since I last sharpened. I just don't know what the angles are that I use to do those tasks.

I guess I probably grind most of my own plane irons or chisels somewhere near 25� and hone at about 30�, but I've never measured either to know for sure. If I have to demonstrate honing to a learner using their tools, which is common, I adjust the angle I hone at to suit whatever state their tool is in. In other words I might raise or lower the angle according to what my instincts say the tool needs to get a sharp edge quickly.

Certainly I am fully aware that steeper angles are better suited to certain tasks, eg, a steeper honing angle is useful on mortising chisels; I just jack them up a bit from my usual angle.

I'd say you make a fair point-- I consistently go for the 'right' angle or angles each time I sharpen, even though I don't really know what those angles are. Slainte.

Re: odd plane blade angles

#12

Re: non-standard angle

ThomD

>I agree with you, also. My main thing is I don't know how people don't know, though I am as likely to believe your summary of how people act as mine. It's like walking through the woods. There are a lot of things I know about nature, but the names of plans (unless they are convertible to lumber), is not one of them. A person could probably be a lumberjack and not know much Latin. My wife knows a lot of plants, I know quite a few insects. The naming of things, including angles, isn't always necessary.