Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

Posts

Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#1

Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have put together an article on post-construction testing of a shooting board. I think some of you will find it interesting.

There are a couple of new features as well.

This is also the last board I shall make for some months - too many projects to build for home. I am more than happy to provide help if you want to build your own.

The link is below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Shooting for Perfection

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#2

That's a definite keeper, Derek

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Printed and saved for the round tuit file. Nice design.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#3

Thanks for sharing, Derek!

Frank Mutchler

>I've got to make a shooting board soon and your ideas are very welcome.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#4

ramped question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>How important is the ramp? It certainly complicates construction so the one I made was not ramped and it seems to work fine. I have used it for pieces up to 1" x 4" walnut. But then I have never used a ramped version so I don't know if I am missing something.

The plane I use makes a big difference. Heavier is better. The LV low angle seems ideally suited for a shooting board.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#5

Re: ramped question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>How important is the ramp?

Hi Bill

The ramp is not critical but it does add a good effect - it seems to take some of the jarring out of the cut and ends up being a more gentle action. I would not say that the ramp is angled enough to create a true skew cut, but it does enough to make the effort worthwhile.

The feel is different again to my #51/52, which is a flat board with a true skewed cut. The #51 cuts very sweetly and, in spite of a higher (45 degree) cutting angle than a LA Jack (37 degrees), it still produces as smooth a finish. One of the reasons I stopped using a HNT Gordon Trying Plane, in spite of the way it "glides" wood-on-wood, was that the finish was not in the same class.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#6

Re: ramped question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe I missed something, but I thought all the cuts on the board in the article were made with the HNT. If so, seems like you got a high quality finish. What's wrong with this picture?

Pam

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#7

Re: ramped question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Pam

There is a very definite qualitative difference in the smoothness of cuts to end grain when made by different cutting angles. The 60 degrees of the HNT Gordon Trying Plane creates a "matt" surface while the 37 degrees of the LA Jack creates a "shiny" surface. I would not view the Gordon's cut as finished. I would want to use a little sandpaper still. I have had cuts on the #51/52 that were glossy to the point of looking polished. I am not sure what cutting angle the #51 wnds up at when taking into account the skew blade .. probably similar to the LA Jack.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#8

Re: ramped question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, and does the polished finish glue up just like the matt?

Pam

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#10

Squareness question

Jack F

>Looks nice Derek. The ramp seems beneficial for a 90 deg cut, but if you angle the workpiece 4 deg on the X axis, then 45 degrees on the Y or Z axis, aren't you going to get a compound miter. The cut surface may be at 45 degrees to the edge, but the cut surface won't be at 90 degrees to the face. Or am I missing something here?

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#11

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#12

Re: Squareness question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jack

No to compounding an angle.

All that occurs is equivalent to cutting with a 4 degree slicing action. Imagine that you were doing this on face grain, that is, pushing forward with the plane at a 4 degree angle.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#13

Ramp ≠ skew

wilbur

>Not to be too techno-weenie, but compared to a shooting board without a ramp, the ramp on a shooting board doesn't produce a cut like a plane with a skewed blade, or by angling a plane relative to its direction of travel. The ramp on the shooting board still causes the plane's blade to meet the wood at the same angle.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#14

mouldings

paul womack

>but compared to a shooting board without a ramp, the ramp on a shooting board doesn't produce a cut like a plane with a skewed blade,

Ah, the old "ramp vs skew" flame war.

You're quite right, geometrically speaking.

However, SOME of the EFFECTS are the same, include "gradual" start and end of cut, and reduced rear-face tearout.

BugBear

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#15

Re: Squareness question

Chris Friesen

>Not quite...it's equivalent to pushing the plane straight ahead with the workpiece at a 4-degree angle. There's still no compound angle involved, but the cutting geometry is slightly different.

Compared to a straight cut, if you skew the blade it gives more gradual entry/exit and the effective angle is reduced. If you skew the workpiece, it makes for more gradual entry/exit but the effective cutting angle is unchanged.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#16

Re: Ramps

ThomD

>If you are selling someone a shooting board it better have some bells and whistles!

I would prefer the angles to be in the opposite direction so that the plane is running downhill on the cut, and the cutting action is seating the workpiece. The japanese ones (planing beams) have everything on the same canted level.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#17

Re: ramped question

Bob Demers

>I thought that the main point of the ramp was to 'equalise the wear' on the plane, that is to say, that a bigger portion of the blade engage the wood versus the actual wood thickness?

Im only asking because, it did not seems to be picked up so far in this discussion. Is this wear issue a moot point?

Bob, with snow tires on both cars, ready for snow, aye ready

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#18

Re: Squareness question

Jack F

>There is no compound angle for a 90 degree cut, but once you add the miter fence or donky's ear you have rotated the piece in 2 dimensions and, although the miter might be at 45 degrees, the cut will be 4 degrees off square in the other direction. That would be about 1/16" for a 1" thick piece.

Jack

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#19

Re: Ramps

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I would prefer the angles to be in the opposite direction so that the plane is running downhill on the cut, and the cutting action is seating the workpiece

Hi Thom

I would say that the effect here is that the plane is indeed running downhill into the work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#20

Re: Squareness question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jack

Your theory sounds right to me. However in practice I did not see this error - look at the box I made. The sides are 2" high. According to your calculations I should have a 1/4" gap (1/16" every 1", doubled for 2" and doubled again for two angles meeting).

But I am intreged and shall take a closer look. Fortunately, if you are correct, it is easy enough to tune out with the leveling screws under the donkeys ear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#21

Re: Squareness question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Jack,

The ramp will not introduce a compound miter, provided the ramp is rising uniformly (e.g., 4 degrees along the left edge and 4 degrees along the right edge). In other words, the ramp cannot have a left-right tilt.

To see why this is so, go to the last photo in the sequence in Derek's link. Note that the HNT Gordon plane sole is flush up against the edge of the ramp. Now imagine that the ramp is rotated upward a bit higher--it would still be flush against the plane sole, provided there is no left-right tilt. As the ramp is raised, its edge is sweeping out a dead vertical plane. Of course, I'm asking us to imagine something--to actually make the ramp with zero left-right tilt is a fine achievement!

Wiley

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#23

The ramp is in the same plane as the miter...

John in NM

>Therefore, no compound angle. Alternatively, imagine turning the workpiece 90 degrees. No change in cut angle there either.

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#24

Re: Squareness question

Jack F

>I think I get it now. I think I was imagining the piece rotated up 4 degrees along the back edge of the piece while rotated at 45 degrees, but the axis of rotation is really perpendicular to the cut edge. Thanks.

Jack

Re: Shooting for Perfection *LINK*

#25

Re: Ramps

ThomD

>Thanks for that Derek. That would make sense to me. But from what I am looking at in the pics, and I may have it wrong, the plane is on the right and the board is on the left, and the left ramp is higher than the right one. I don't see how that uses gravity to advantage. The plane seems to either be prallel to the bench or less sloped than the workpiece. In the former case, the plane's weight would drop, but it would still be wedging up from under the board; In the latter, the plane wouldn't even be travelling downhill.

I just assume if you make it, it works and your happy with the design, but I don't get it from my end. I could see how it would be a more ergonomic angle for holding the stock...