Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

preventing metal overheating while grinding....

Posts

preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#1

preventing metal overheating while grinding....

Ed DeLauter

>I thought I would mention a little trick I have been using to prevent loss of temper on tool steel during bench grinding. I did a search and did not get a hit but it may have already been suggested.

After jigging up a tool for a grind I take a small square of old blue jean cotton, fold it over once, and place it underneath a 1/4" round disc (neodymium) magnet and place it at the very tip of the cutting edge. I then dip it in a bowl of water.

Since going to this method I have not "blued" an edge. The soaked cotton wicks the heat away quite effectively. You can easily reposition the magnet for a better look at the edge condition and then move it back into place before grinding again. Just keep the cotton good and soaked and it is good to go.

It is not near as messy as a squirt bottle.

These little magnets are handy for ALOT of stuff and they're CHEAP!

FYI,

Ed DeLauter

Mountain View, Arkansas -in the good ole Ozarks

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#2

Neat trick Ed, I'll keep it in mind.

Parisian, VL

>

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding...

Moses Yoder

>You should send that in to Fine Woodworking quick before someone else takes your LV gift certificate.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#4

thanks for great tip

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#5

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Does the steel still give off sparks when you grind?

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#6

For Sure! Get it in there.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#7

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding...

Adam Cherubini

>I'm sorry, but this doesn't sound like a good idea to me. I'm glad if it's helping you. The secret to grinding without over heating is having the right stone, keeping it dressed, and using a light touch. If you are bluing your blades, the best solution is following good technique and using well cared for stones, correctly chosen.

The problems with over heating steel and quenching are legion. Conducting heat out of the steel at the edge can actually increase the heat transfer exactly where you don't want it. A better approach is to draw the heat up into the metal. You would be better served getting a larger magnet and just sticking it to the chisel an inch or two back from the edge to serve as a heat sink.

Quenching high carbon steels is risky in any case. If the water is sizzling, you are already over 200F. The temper temperature for a hard HC blade could be as low as 350 or 400. I think blue is like 600F. If you find you are bluing your HC steel tools, you are really WAY out of the range of good grinding technique and need to rethink.

I've heard of other issues- molecular distortions, micro-cracking etc, that can result from even low temp quenches. I don't think any of this is a good thing. A light touch and a Norton SG wheel from Joel is such a better solution.

Lastly is the issue of the dreaded HAZ or Heat Affected Zone. The damage to the temper extends beyond the area that's blue. So if you are visibly overheating your tools, you are really wrecking your tools.

All said, I think you SHOULD send your tip to FWW. They'll probably love it! (How do you type that cat sound?)

Adam

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#8

Another cooling tip

Steve Elliott

>Rather than quenching an already-heated blade I use a different method to avoid overheating in the first place. Before I start to grind, I place the back end of the blade in a container of ice water and cool the blade below room temperature. As I grind, I often check the bevel end of the blade to feel it just start to warm up. If it's warm I place the back end of the blade in the ice water and wait for the whole blade to cool down, which doesn't take long. The cutting edge of the blade never goes in the water and there's never a temperature shock to any part of the blade.

Adam's advice about using the proper wheel is right on the mark, and good equipment plus good technique make overheating problems completely avoidable. I only use the method I described when I'm doing a massive regrind to refurbish a badly ground or damaged blade. Ordinary sharpening should only require the removal of small amounts of steel.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#9

needs reconsideration..........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Reconsider what has been suggested .

Heat transfer is proportional to the conductivity of the metal times the gradient. The suggestion cools the region behind the edge thereby providing a steeper gradient and better heat removal from the edge. There isn't any hot metal quenching going on. The point of the suggestion is that the conductivity and heat of evaporation of the water keeps all parts of the tool below the original tempering temperature. It is no different that the accepted practice of misting the tool while grinding, just cheaper to implement.

But you point of selecting the right rock and a light touch is the ounce of prevention that avoids the need for a cure.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#10

Re: Best method

ThomD

>Hey, if it works keep at it. I just dip the ends of my blades in water and some water adheres to the blade. When that water is dried off from the heat of grinding I redip. That way you aren't going above 200, and the method is simple and doesn't require any gear or special care. It can happen that after each dip the body of the iron heats up further and becomes too warm even though the edge is fine. So the period between dips can get too short. In that case I just get a rotor of several blades under way and leave warm ones to cool more completely as I grind another. I normally rest the cooling blade on a big lump of steel.

The additional advantage to this method is that blades can heat up real fast, particularly the sharp corners, the more you grind the worse the problem get. The water is right up to the edge with this method. The key issue is keeping the edge cool. A more remote heat sink may still not save the heat concentrations at the edge.

I agree with Adam that the first principle is to use the freist cutting grinder you can find, preferably a belt. Grind as coarse as you can for least heat concentration. When you are hollow grinding you will find the honing very fast since the contact points are Razor thin. A coarse grind does not really make maters much worse. If you have a coarse flat bevel it will take a while to wet out.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#11

you may be right

Adam Cherubini

>Thanks. You're right. As I reconsider I'm not sure. I crown my stones like Joel told me to. I think I can blue an edge without touching it. I think the HT rate may be the highest there due to the increased surface area. That's the thought I had about the rag.

But you could be right. HT could be lowest there, the heat could conduct there and have no place to go. The reason I don't think this is the case, altho my stomach tells me you are right, is that conduction is still k(T1-T2) As the temperature of the edge rises (T1) relative to the center temp (T2), HT should lessen preventing the edges from getting hotter than the center. But I think we all know that the edges do get hotter than the center.

So I really think its the former is correct. i think heat energy flows along the edge regardless of where you grind and the HT is greatest at the ends due to convention. But this really isn't my area of expertise. I could ask someone who would know.

Adam

P.S. As for the quenching, I meant real quenching. I didn't mean that the wet rag was quenching.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#12

Why the edge gets "hotter"

John in NM

>is just that steel is a pretty lousy conductor of heat, compared to other metals like brass, copper, and aluminum. This is why the steeper gradient helps. If you were grinding brass with the same technique that causes an edge to blue on steel, the piece would quickly be too hot to hold, but the edge itself would not get significantly hotter than the rest of the piece.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#13

Adam, I wasn't bluing my tools on a regular

Ed DeLauter

>basis but when it happened it was a bummer. I forget right now but A2 or HSS will overheat faster. I have both types and must be VERY CAREFULL with the one type. The use of the magnet gives me room for a little error.

A Light touch is DEFINITELY the rule of thumb. For one thing your tools will have a much longer service life. Keeping the metal from ever getting hot in the first place is what I like about using the cotton and magnet.

Cheers,

Ed

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#14

Re: HSS

ThomD

>You don't have to worry about HSS it is designed not to loose it's hardness at elevated working temperature, including blued edges and smoking hot. Of course blued edges are going to be surface oxydised, which isn't an advantage, and you could burn your fingers, but you won't affect hardness. Makes this catagory of steels very grinder friendly, though the point is more working temperature in metalworking etc... So for something like wood turning where edge wear is a problem, HSS lasts longer cutting, and is grinder friendly for sharpening. I have some nice Japanese hand tools in HSS also.

Re: preventing metal overheating while grinding....

#15

Random nitwit theorizing

James Watriss

>I think it's an interesting idea, this wet rag thing. In essence, it's not necessarily quenching, or even bringing the temp down. As I half-backwardly understand it, it's a way to vent off a portion of the energy absorbed during grinding, without necessarily allowing it to heat up the steel. A liquid-cooled chisel... who'd a thunk it?

I think you're right, of course... anyone who's bluing their blades on a regular basis really needs to take a second look at their technique. But this might be a viable "speed grinding," technique, wherein the user might be able to grind a little harder and faster than normal, for a slightly longer period of time. For that, this might be a viable method of keeping the tool within an acceptable energy range. And even if it's not a technique for the every day usage, it might be worth using for tasks like grinding a camber on an existing blade for use in a jack plane.

My issue? I don't like using magnets on my chisels and plane blades. I'd just as soon let the swarf flow away from the tool than have it attracted to the edge while honing.