Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

tool chest designs

Posts

Re: tool chest designs

#26

Re: How are those speculations different, than say

gregforster

>Wow!, great stuff. This is the type of discussion on 18th c woodworking alot of us have been hoping for.

Re: tool chest designs

#27

Moxon'

Adam Cherubini

>"It is speculative as to whether Moxon meant a saw with a back attached to the blade. They did exist dating back to Roman days (at least wooden backs on blades--the straightish handle extending down the blade). But I don't think they came into their own until...whenever."

Good example of my point (which I'm sure you got). There are other sources including images of tools from this period. And none of them show anything even remotely resembling a back saw, Roman or otherwise. So like the 18th c tool chest story, I'm using the lack of data to support my conclusion. And that's a difficult footnote to write, right? I mean, how do you provide a source for that? Moxon has a quote that sounds like a description of a backsaw. And that makes a good footnote that guys will find credible. But that quote also sounds like a frame saw. And there are no other hints that back saws existed in 1680.

This is archeology 101. You find pottery because pottery survives in the earth and people throw broken pottery into wells or down the privy. So you do your master's thesis on pottery. But when you get to your PhD, you spend your time thinking about what you didn't find and why you didn't find it.

And while we're on the topic, Independance Hall area is under construction. New visitor centers and a new home for the liberty bell have brought backhoes to the city of brothery love. But because those backhoe drivers are getting paid by the federal governement, (Independance Hall is a Federal Park) archeologists have been consulted. They've uncovered a lot of interesting things, including Philadelphians' varied diets of various game meats, and fruits and veggies from the West Indies. They've also found that our ancestors were fairly big drinkers. I forget the guy's name, but it was somebody in Adams' cabinet. They found so many bottles, they thought they had unearthed a tavern! Apparently not. It was teh guy's house. I immediately thought of a Schwarz ancestor. But they were wine bottles.

Adam

Re: tool chest designs

#28

Re: Moxon'

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>What if we make the assumption that there has always been a need for a backsaw and that all woodworkers/saw makers were driven to invent it? The technology isn't that hard, some thing blade steel, some thick backbone steel/bronze/whatever. So then the question becomes one of expense. What would a backsaw have cost in 1600? Could furniture makers have afforded that? And on and on...

Pam

Re: tool chest designs

#29

Should be "thin" blade steel.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: tool chest designs

#30

Re: Moxon'

MikeW

>Yeah, I understood. And I also understand it is difficult to prove a negative. I have more questions than answers as well. I guess I am more reluctant to draw, or extrapolate, seeming conclusions from lack of data.

For point of interest, there is a Roman saw with a back "intact" and one showing rivet holes down the top edge. Gotta expand your reading material selection ...At least if I looked at the pretty pictures and can read the captions and corresponding text correctly. Seems no mean feat these days. Roman Woodworking is the book.

As I have only read quotes of Moxon, I am uncertain what to understand from him. One of these days I'll have a copy. Hopefully soon, eh Chris? Though I doubt it'll do more than provide fodder for my own brand of speculation.

Backed saws is a harder thing to determine than tool chests I suspect.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#31

Re: Moxon'S BACK SAW

Adam Cherubini

>I'm not sure I get your point, Pam. We work without back saws at Pennsbury Manor. We have an open, narrow bladed saw (depicted in Moxon) that resembles a bread knife. I sharpened it cross cut, though they may or may not have. And we have an 18" frame saw with a fixed blade. These saws are effective and fairly easy to use.

Making a back saw, especially the broad thin saw plate, is a really huge deal technologically. And you really need steel to make such a saw work (due to "out of plane" bending stress that would easily kink or bend an iron saw plate). If you don't have steel, or you are making your own steel in a forge (i.e. not crucible steel, and no rolling mill like Medieval Europeans and Japanese) you are really better off pulling your saws or tensioning thin blades in wooden frames.

I think backsaws were produced due to a combination of manufacturing cabailities/technologies and a large domestic market for tools (party due to the rebuilding of London after the 1665 fire) combined with global trade and colonization. I don't think necessity was the mother of all invention in this case.

Backsaws are certainly better than what we use in Pennsbury. When I know I'll be doing a lot of tenons, I do sometimes bring a few backsaws with me. I rarely think to bring the bread knife saw home! That said, I've made many many hundreds of fine tenons with the 18" frame saw now hanging in Pennsbury's joinery. That was the only tenon saw I had until I made my own about 4 years ago.

Adam

Re: tool chest designs

#32

sorry about the caps

Adam Cherubini

>

Re: tool chest designs

#33

Re: Moxon'S BACK SAW

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>My point is that I would assume a backsaw (or dozuki in my case) would have existed forever. Then the task is merely to find confirmatory documentation, Mike's Roman Woodworking, for example.

Pam

Re: tool chest designs

#34

Pam's Observation

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>One problem I have with your idea is that the technology of making saw plate was not as developed. It would have been unnecessary for the back if the blade couldn't be made thin enough to need it. A pull saw or a tensioned blade served the purpose. Still, Mike's reference to a Roman saw with holes at the top presumably for anchoring a back needs to be addressed.

Re: tool chest designs

#35

Re: Pam's Observation

MikeW

>I think like other arenas, "tecnhology" comes and goes from a given scene. The Roman saws might have been an utter failure, an idea ahead of their time. They certainly are not widespread enough to have dozens of examples, much less leading up through the middle ages.

So I have no problem conjecturing that a "something" might have been lost due to whatever reason: didn't work, didn't sell, or simply was different enough that it wasn't widely adopted.

I think the overwhelming evidence we have on hand does support framed saws. Whether it be tomb carvings, engravings and even found examples, frame tensioned saws are in abundance.

The Moxon reference is still unresolved for me. Most likely will always be unless someone finds examples (perhaps continiental examples) or a dig uncovers one or two. Or, it'll be other printed matter. Who knows.

Certainly the Plumley inventory Adam refers to (it is available on the PopWood site as a download) is one seemingly coroborating source for an early backed saw. I doubt it was the first one in existence. So the when of it becoming available for Plumley to have bought one is a good question. Back only a couple decades and we are to Moxon's date of printing his book. It isn't a big stretch to support the notion he really was talking of a backed "tenant" saw. But...it is still conjecture.

All fascinating to this newbie of looking back that far.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#36

Re: Pam's Observation

ThomD

>I'm not sure one has to conjecture that a back saw was only possible at a given point in the development of steel. It could have come into being when similar relative material technology existed. If steel makes it possible for steel to be thin enough that it now seems unsuported, then the same could have happened earlier with a given earlier material brought to a relative degree of pliancy with regard to a given wood. Weren't saws at one time copper? That material can be worked out very thin. This could explain why the technology waxed and wained, if it did. You get a given material pushed to it's limit, then along comes iron and it's like carbon fibre today, and a cycle of development is undertaked, then along comes steel.

Re: tool chest designs

#37

Re: Moxon' *LINK*

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Mike et al,

I have been chasing whatever information I can find regarding the evolution of the backsaw (see the link for progress to date) whilst Moxon's reference is problematic, I am coming to think the key phrase comes in the glossary section where he refer's to turning the blade through 90 degrees to make it a "tennant" saw. This tallies with the armorial depiction of a tennant saw that appeared dictionaries some time in the 1600's. This sounds more like a frame saw to me.

The earliest backsaw (of the modern style) seems to appear in the mid 1700's. The jury's out however on what might have been the trigger for this development.

Regards

Ray


backsaw evolution

Re: tool chest designs

#38

Re: Accuracy of probate inventories

Dave Anderson NH

>Hi Mike, I disagree partly with you on the accuracy of probate inventories. Those inventories were as accurate as they could make them vis a vis the actual contents since they were legal documents. Where the "accuracy" issue falls apart is in how we interpret the meaning of arcaic usages and descriptions and in how both we and the original probate examiners valued a particular item. If the examiner was a cabinetmaker or joyner, maybe the values were accurate, at least in relation to a tool's condition. If it was the local magistrate, it's anybody's guess. What bothers me about the inventories is the tendency to lump groups of things together with an aggregate value making it really hard to understand what is actually there. Kind of makes you wish for a time machine.

Re: tool chest designs

#39

Re: Accuracy of probate inventories

MikeW

>Hi Dave,

I *think* we actually agree. I have only really meant that, using the example I already used from the Dunlap probate, "Handsaws." Like you wrote, these (plural) are lumped together. No way of know what or how many.

Maj. John bought lumber in various thicknesses and widths, veneer from a supplier, etc., for his furniture. I doubt that if he had a rip hand saw it was used for more than I do, that is ripping through the thickness of a board. But whether one of the "Handsaws" was a rip is anyone's guess.

Values used is another thing altogether. I agree it in part depends on who did the valuation. As well as what perceived then-current values of used tools was. So too, was the valuation done during the excessive inflation of the Rev. war and following or had the market value for used tools subsided by 1793 or there abouts? Was the value of used tools ever inflated? Those are things I do not know. And of course, I don't know what I don't know.

fwiw, the Dunlap probate, while having several items on a line, have values for the individual types of items and a total for the line at the right to be carried down. Still, it doesn't help as regards being more specific on number of same items when grouped together.

Too many variables for the noggin. It is fun to read through and attempt to understand as well as I can, though.

Hope all is well with you and yours.

Take care, Mike

back to ordering widgets...

Re: tool chest designs

#40

Great Link!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: tool chest designs

#41

Re: Accuracy of probate inventories

Dave Anderson NH

>Hi Mike,

All is well here. I'm hosting the first meeting of our guild's new hand tools special interest group tomorrow morning. It should be fun.

I have a great interest in Dunlop. While he was born in Boston, he grew up right here in Chester NH and did some of his early work here before he moved to Bedford NH. Last month I got to see one of his original high chest on chests on display at the NH Historical Society Tuck Library. What made it really nice was that there was a reproduction of the same pieces sitting 15 feet away still in its "white" state. The repro was made by Donald Dunlop a 5th or 6th generation direct descendant.

Re: tool chest designs

#42

Re: Accuracy of probate inventories

MikeW

>Ah, seeing one in the flesh would be great! I also have Donald's book. Between it and the Parson's book, I became a bit enamored with the family.

I recently tried to pull up Roger Dunlap's (Donald's nephew) web site for the first time in a few months. The link was bad and so with a little web searching I see that Roger very recently died. My deep condolances to the family.

The family has a long and rich tradition in cabinet making.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#43

Hey Ray

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>The Bayeaux Tapestry is not a good piece of evidence in this case. Those were boat builders, not carpenters. Landis' Workbench book has a good section on boat building where work was done in situ and saws and planes were replaced by adzes, hatchets and slicks. I believe the 15th century Book of Hours shows house carpenters using saws that look like the "bread knife" style of saw. Because Joseph was a carpenter there are many medieval representations of carpenters and their tools in iluminated manuscripts. Check the Book of Kells and some other well known ones and I believe you will find saw representations.

Re: tool chest designs

#44

Re: Where is the evidence?

Ray Gardiner

>The curious thing about this subject is the lack of surviving examples, we have evidence of organized saw manufacturing as early as 1660, but very few examples of actual saws for around 100 years, until mid 1700's and from then onward we have more examples.

I will go out on a limb here, and say that I suspect we have more examples of Roman and Egyptian saws than we have saws from the 1600's.

The very lack of evidence might be a clue in itself?

Regards

Ray

Re: tool chest designs

#45

Not necessarily

Adam Cherubini

>Ray,

Roman things have been found because Roman sites have been dug. Early man is found in Africa because Africa is ripe for archeology. What we need is to excavate London. In Philadelphia, the I-95 interstate obliterated the first few and oldest streets in the city. Pretty sure no archeology was done. Since then a law has been passed that projects using Federal money must not disturb archeologically significant sites. But expansion at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital this very moment has no archeological support. My guess is, the early saws just don't spark the fancy of British or American backhoe drivers like the jewelry and bits of pottery do.

In the Independence Hall area digs, graves of British or American rev war soldiers were found near a building that was used as a hospital. 12 young men lied shoulder to shoulder in a shallow grave without coffins. Were it not for the State Archeologists, their graves would likely have been desecrated, and their knee and shoe buckles would have turned up on ebay. Check any rev war sutler. They all have original buckles from which they made molds. Some have pairs of buckles. Where do you think those buckles came from? A "battlefield" is sort of a sterile way of putting it, don't you think?

So I think the lack of data isn't necessarily indicative of anything. Earliest man may have lived in downtown Manhattan. And if so, we will never find out. If you want to know more about early saws, somebody has to get on Antiques Road Show and have a Keno brother proclaim it's value $25,000. "And if it had it's original tooth filings, it could have gone much higher!"

Adam

Re: tool chest designs

#46

Re: Not necessarily *LINK*

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Adam,

Thanks for your reply, I am sure that 17th Century English style handsaws exist somewhere, we have illustrations and carvings from as early as 1627 showing wide bladed pistol grip style dutch saws (see Goodman pp145) Which shows a Dutch saw from c1698, the other examples are a meager few swedish saws from the late 1600's. And of course the A.C.Ralamb hand saw from 1691, which is very much a modern looking handsaw. (overlooked by Moxon BTW).

The excavations at Port Royal Jamacia, turned up many well preserved hand tools (see link below http://nautarch.tamu.edu/anth/abstracts/franklinm2.html) None of the excavated tools are saws, although they are mentioned in the Port Royal probate inventories. I am unclear as to what the significance of this absence is, perhaps they weren't looking in the right places. It is known that George Sitwell exported saws to Jamacia in the mid-late 1600's (where did they go?)

Summarizing, I can't think of a single surviving English sytle handsaw from the 1600's, although they were apparently manufactured from the 1660's. There is a wealth of other material that has survived quite well, even saws from the 1700's have survived, so I doubt it's a question of fragility/survivability.

Someone once suggested that early "Moxon" tyle hand saws may have been mistakenly identified as pruning saws and thus overlooked. Perhaps we should be trawling ebay for antique gardening tools!

Regards

Ray


http://nautarch.tamu.edu/anth/abstracts/franklinm2.html

Re: tool chest designs

#47

Re: Not necessarily

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Earliest man in Manhattan? I don't think so. Archeologists go to Africa to do archeology because that's where the dirt erodes, and that erosion exposes remains, primate or otherwise. Also, genetic work has been done tracing homo sapiens to a single woman somewhere in Africa. Nothing discovered to date even hints at early man in Manhattan. You were kidding, right?

Pam

Re: tool chest designs

#48

Re: Not necessarily

Ray Gardiner

>Sorry Pam, you are wrong.

I have hard evidence of Neanderthal's working in Wall Street as recently as last week.

(yes he was kidding, as am I, no Wall street Neanders, they are all

power tool users..) or is it just tools...

Regards

Ray

Re: tool chest designs

#49

Re: Not necessarily

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hmmm, they seem like homo sapiens sapiens sapiens to me. After all, whenever they've got everything we had, they go out and manage to get more from the government. Very clever, very advanced, survivors.

Pam