Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

tool chest designs

Posts

tool chest designs

#1

tool chest designs

Jerome B

>I am looking to make a new tool chest. I would the design and workings of the one that is shown in Adams column in Pop Woodworking. I thought that at one time we had discussed that chest here, but I can't find it in the archives. I think that it is a derivation of the tool chest that Roy Underhill details in one of his books.

Can anyone point me in the right direction of where to find this info in the archives or towards plans that are similar.

Thanks,

Jerome

Re: tool chest designs

#2

Re: tool chest designs

Adam Cherubini

>Jerome,

I studied 18th c tool chests (or tried to) before I built my box. What I learned was that there are only a few documented chests from this period and each is unique. So I looked at 19th century chests. 19th c chests are much more similar to another another. As I began listing their similarities, I began to see the ways in which 18th c chests were not similar. As I thought more about it, I began to see 18th c chests in the negative.

-19th c chests are all often 40" long or so. The few 18th c chests are longer, as long as 48".

-19th c chests are tall, usually in excess of 2'. 18th c chests are all lower than that.

-19th c chests have strong paneled sides and tops. 18th c chests typically don't.

-19th c chest are generally identifiable by their bank of tills, often 3, or a fancy "fitted" till consisting of drawers. None of the existing 18th c chest have multiple tills. And their low height wouldn't permit them.

So the conclusions I came to were:

-18th c chests were low long boxes, similar to dovetailed blanket chests.

-A single till running width wise or depth wise was typical.

-The Seaton chest, though made in 1797, reflects the 19th c design\

-Black or blue green paint was common (this from Jane Rees) Personally, I think blue green was more prevalent and the paint turned black- just like Windsor chairs.

My advice is to make a blanket chest out of some cheap wood- pine or tulip poplar and paint it black or blue green. Use strap hinges with bean ends for the lid. And fit it out however you choose, but don't make it too nice or too fancy. I suspect 18th c chests were considerably cruder than 19th c boxes. So don't veneer the inside or anything.

Adam

P.S. Jay Gaynor's book "Tools:..." is a helpful resource. When I was working on my chest years ago, I gave Jay a call and chatted with him about this subject. He was very helpful. I don't know if I had anything to do with it, but I've since seen a few boxes like mine floating around, including one in Williamsburg.

Re: tool chest designs

#4

ditto, thanks Adam

Jerome B

>

Re: tool chest designs

#5

? for Adam

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Do you think that 18th century chests were smaller because saws were not as important as they were for 19th century craftsmen? In a thread a while back I had asked about if 18th century shops had saw tills and Joel related how wood came from the mill in a closer size to what was needed thus precluding the need for rip and crosscut saws.

Re: tool chest designs

#6

Re: ? for Adam

MikeW

>I think it is erroneous to think that all 18th century chests support Adam's view. Perhaps American 18th century chests, I don't know.

The Seaton chest et al from the 18th century in England reflected then design--they didn't come from a vacuum or "suddenly appear" and, well, how can they "reflect 19th century design" when they were made in the 18th century? ;-)

"In a thread a while back I had asked about if 18th century shops had saw tills and Joel related how wood came from the mill in a closer size to what was needed thus precluding the need for rip and crosscut saws."

I would have to look the thread back up. I think *if* Joel made the statement concerning the lack of need for cross cut and rip hand saws, that too is erroneous and there isn't data to support the assertion. I suspect this will be one aspect we haggle over in Berea at our joint presentation if so.

Back to chests. It would be a fascinating study in itself. Especially if one were able to figure out whether the extant chests in America came over on ships or largely were built here. I think there will be a difference, as well as to whether the immigrant was already a joiner or cabinet maker, whether he primarily was a carpenter, etc. The depth to me would be staggering.

Take care, Mike

feeling a bit cantankerous today...

Re: tool chest designs

#7

Re: ? for Adam

joel

>"Joel related how wood came from the mill in a closer size to what was needed thus precluding the need for rip and crosscut saws. "

I just want to clarify what I said:

I said the first part. but not the second. If you are buying (which they did) wood already sawn into - say drawer stock you don't have to mill it thinner and you just have to quickly plane out the saw marks. But you still have to cut it to length - so you need a crosscut saw of some sort and maybe to width. Now with drawer sides you can use a small saw but if you are assembling a carcass with 3/4" timber you might not have much surfacing to do but you will still have to cut boards to length and cut stuff to width.

Re: tool chest designs

#8

Re: ? for Adam

ThomD

>In a lot of chests every drawer is a different size anyway. In my Granfather's UK shop, which lasted up to and through WWII, every day started with ripping the stock, according to my dad. Not to say they did as much ripping as they might have in an earlier time. Frank K.'S memories of his dad's shop also involve ripping and even resawing stock by hand in a somewhat later period.

Re: tool chest designs

#9

Re: ? for Adam

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know whether the 18th century tool chests were smaller, but the average person certainly was. Their clothes were smaller, probably houses but that's more a function of wealth, shoes were smaller, etc.

Pam

Re: tool chest designs

#10

Myth or folklore

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Pam,

Current scholars don't believe people were smaller back then. The surviving examples of small clothing and diminutive foot ware, in museums, survived because they didn't fit anybody.

People are the same size, G. Washington was over 6 feet tall, as was a number of early presidents.

As for tool boxes, I know of only two tool boxes that were made in America, of the half dozen I have owned all were European and I have seen a dozen or so other tool boxes and all were not made in this country.

I actually have what Adam would describe as an 18th century tool box, low and with only a single till, which is made of poplar with cut nails and blunt screws so it is early nineteenth century, and made in America.

Stephen

Re: tool chest designs

#11

convexity

paul womack

>G. Washington was over 6 feet tall, as was a number of early presidents.

The wealthy have always been tall; they can afford plenty of good food.

Medieval nobles would be perceived as tall by their peasants.

c.f. recent trends in the height of the Japanese population.

BugBear

Re: tool chest designs

#13

Response to Joel

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Joel, I was writing too fast and overstated the case. I didn't mean to suggest you said that saws weren't needed, only that there was not a need for a lot of them. As you have pointed out here again, sawing was not a gross operation but more a refining step for the work. The need for hand saws seems to have grown in the 19th and 20th centuries. That was intent I got from you. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Re: tool chest designs

#14

Another Observation

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I've read others talking about, and my own experience bears it out, ripping is not the most fun thing to do in the shop. Adam's article in A & M's column in PW a while back on the use of a hatchet made a lot of sense to me. A fast way to waste wood that would be too small to utilize makes a lot of sense. Hewing hatchets seem to be commonplace in old tool collections. If you work with green wood you're not going to use a saw very much. Not for dimensioning. Yes you'll use saws, but not nearly as much as a modern woodworker depends on his table saw, band saw or skill saw.

Re: tool chest designs

#15

Mike

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I think I'm really going to enjoy Berea. Can't wait to meet you and talk.

Re: tool chest designs

#16

Re: Response to Joel

Joel

>The OVERWHELMING number of surviving hand saws from the 19th century and beyond were used in house framing.

THe biggest, most important invention in house building came in the 1840's when somebody figured out that if you saw up the wood into 2 x 4's before you ship it you save oddles of weight. And the American Framed house was born. Suddenly you didn't need a standing housewright's shop to pre-make timberframe. you needed lots of guys, on site with handsaws.

On the cabinetry side even as early as 1850 in the US most furniture was mass produced in factories with specialized machinery.

Very few 18th century saws used for cabinetmaking by comparison. 1- they were used up. 2: there just weren't nearly as many cabinetmakers out there as house builders. (I think in London it was 1:8 but I have to look that up.

Re: tool chest designs

#17

Re: ? for Adam

Adam Cherubini

>I think saw storage actually drives the length of a tool chest. A 28" saw might need a chest over 3' in length. You can't fit much of a saw in a 30" chest.

The 18th c chests in Gaynor's book, or at least one I'm thinking of, didn't have a saw till, but rather saws were attached to the under side of the lid. I had intended to do the same, but my stock just wasn't wide enough. You have molding planes on end in the bottom, then the till, then you need a couple more inches for the saw handle and the cleat that secures it.

As far as the earlier chests being lower in height and having fewer tills, I don't think there's any great mystery to it. The 19th c guys just had more tools than folks did in earlier times. Or at least, this is what probate inventories suggest. Look at the Seaton chest. That guy had close to 40 chisels, none of them carving tools. Oh, and the additional tools seems to be large sets of small tools- bits, chisels, stuff like that, stuff that needed to be stored in tills.

Adam

Re: tool chest designs

#18

Re: ? for Adam

MikeW

>I am uncertain the value of probate records for determining what tools a particular person--or a great number of other people--have regarding being all-inclusive of a person's tool estate. There really aren't that many as compared to how many furniture makers there was.

For instance, I don't have Parson's book on Maj. John Dunlap in front of me right now, but he had somewhere around 22 chisels when his estate was reckoned in 1792. "Handsaws" is a singular listing. How many? Which type? A single "tennant" saw is listed. A couple bow saws listed distinct from the hand saws. And some carving tools...

Is Dunlap's estate records, an arguabley "country" maker (not in a "major metro area) typical? Atypical? How do we know? Would such a "country" maker have more or less tools than a metropolitan maker? How would we know?

I'm not trying to be argumentative. Rather, there is so little we know and I am uncertain as to the utility of probate records confined to few being applied to the industry of furniture making as a whole.

I think the same (and more) questions applies to chests. How many furniture makers had them versus what we might consider a carpenter? Where are they? What type were they? Stylistically, what percentage had decorative inner elements? Probate records offer little hope to satisfy those and far greater number of questions regarding chests and thei contents.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#19

Re: research

George Makowski

>Paul, A good article that disproves your assertion about the height of individuals in the period this thread addresses. Please see the data for West Point cadets in the early nineteenth century, a cross section of relatively affluent young men.

That said, historical height doesn't equate to expected physical performance in documented areas, like the trades and military service. The average weapon and pack weight on active duty has been relatively close over varying personal height periods. Similarly, expectations for load carrying and work completed in many occupational areas have also stayed within a narrow range be the people of the time small or large.

Good ergonomics!

George in Alabama

Re: tool chest designs

#20

Re: ? for Adam

Adam Cherubini

>You just need more data. Probate inventories usually include prices (that's their function afterall). By looking at many inventories, you can get a sense for the value of individual items, at a given time and place. You can then make an educated guess based on the values given. That's the best any of us can do. No serious or "real" historian does any better. All of it is sort of like a court case. You base your conclusions on the evidence available. Unlike a court case, it can be helpful ot have a "feel" for the period.

For instance: There is NO evidence of the back saw before 1720 or 30. But the Plumely inventory includes tenannt saws that are really expensive. So some (Jay Gaynor for one) have suggested that the very well equipped Charles Plumley may have had back saws in 1708. Of course we don't know for sure. But this is an example of how probate records are used for this sort of thing. Personally, I don't think Moxon described a back saw. My guess is the tool was invented sometime between Moxon and Plumley.

Adam

Re: tool chest designs

#21

Re: ? for Adam

MikeW

>Yep, more data is needed before conclusions beyond generalizations have a basis.

The probates do hold interest to me and do yield basis for speculation. But it is that, speculation. And that's fine to me.

It is speculative as to whether Moxon meant a saw with a back attached to the blade. They did exist dating back to Roman days (at least wooden backs on blades--the straightish handle extending down the blade). But I don't think they came into their own until...whenever.

I personally surmise the tension created by a back wasn't needed until the ability to consistently produce thinner metal blades connected to a handle more or less that we would recognize, whether a broomstish type or a more vertical handle. Even then, saw blades tensioned by frames were what seems widely used.

But...the 16th, 17th centuries are not really on point as regards the tool chest designs of the 18th century.

All very interesting to me. Tool storage included.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#22

How are those speculations different, than say...

Alan DuBoff

>Mike,

How is that type of speculation any different than speculating on a single toolchest, such as the Seaton chest?

There is quite a bit of speculation based on the Seaton chest, in that same regard...what tools were used, what tools were available, tool design, etc...Isn't some of that just as speculative as probate records?

Cheers,

Re: tool chest designs

#23

Re: How are those speculations different, than say

MikeW

>Seeing how there is a Seaton chest with the original tool list/costs, as well as a list in Benjamin's writing as to the tools he added, there's not a lot of speculation. Mainly the speculation revolves around whether his intention was to leave England.

Tools available during the 1790s, the period Benjamin's tools were accumulated, is fairly well documented. Not much to speculate on there.

One can speculate on other aspects, such as the techniques the respective tools were used. This I think is where Adam is running ahead of many people--he at least is actively engaged in the task. I'm not. Many of the techniques I use may have been used for a given tool, marking out or what have you. May not have in the 1700s. I don't know. I think this issue is one being investigated by others, too. For instance, Don McConnell and the snipe bill plane usage.

Not certain what about my post was speculation that I didn't identify as such. What I wasn't doing is drawing conclusions and extrapolating to other furniture makers across a broad time period.

Please note I am not writing that I think speculation is wrong. Drawing broad conclusions on an inherently small subset of available data is misleading, though. I would rather people point to such specific data as a probate as applicable certainly to the subject it was written about insofar as the probate is or is not compete. But stretching it to be broadly inclusive is inaccurate and a bit misleading I think.

Heck, I was speculating today was going to be a fine partially cloudy day. Sun breaks to warm the heart and all that. In the last 30 minutes it has begun raining pretty well. I'm wrong lots.

Take care, Mike

Re: tool chest designs

#24

Re: How are those speculations different, than say

Alan DuBoff

>Mike,

I understand your position, was just curious to how conclusions are drawn upon a narrow sample and/or why you feel propate records are less accurate?

Pricing for the tools in the Seaton chest is a good example, it is fairly conclusive data, but it is but one sample of data. Saws from primarily one maker.

To some extent drawing conclusions to anything is speculative, and was my main point, unless we were there and living in the era.

I used the Seaton chest as an example as I feel there's a lot of weight put on that single chest since it is one of the better pieces of data we have available today. Yet it is but one sample. Not to worry...you speculated correctly on the weather where I live! :-)

Cheers,

Re: tool chest designs

#25

Re: How are those speculations different, than say

MikeW

>There are other tool pricing data available from the same period. While all but one I have are wholesale instead of retail pricing, they are out there.

I don't think probate records are less accurate per se. They do give an indication as to what one or more people thought *used* items were worth at the moment in time they were drawn.

But mainly, my "issue" with probate records is that they seem less than accurate enough to draw much from regarding what tools that person--or a broader group of people-- may have had. (eg, "Handsaws" isn't very descriptive of number or type).

Well, my stuff is printed. Gotta go.

Mike