Re: How are those speculations different, than say
MikeW
>Seeing how there is a Seaton chest with the original tool list/costs, as well as a list in Benjamin's writing as to the tools he added, there's not a lot of speculation. Mainly the speculation revolves around whether his intention was to leave England.
Tools available during the 1790s, the period Benjamin's tools were accumulated, is fairly well documented. Not much to speculate on there.
One can speculate on other aspects, such as the techniques the respective tools were used. This I think is where Adam is running ahead of many people--he at least is actively engaged in the task. I'm not. Many of the techniques I use may have been used for a given tool, marking out or what have you. May not have in the 1700s. I don't know. I think this issue is one being investigated by others, too. For instance, Don McConnell and the snipe bill plane usage.
Not certain what about my post was speculation that I didn't identify as such. What I wasn't doing is drawing conclusions and extrapolating to other furniture makers across a broad time period.
Please note I am not writing that I think speculation is wrong. Drawing broad conclusions on an inherently small subset of available data is misleading, though. I would rather people point to such specific data as a probate as applicable certainly to the subject it was written about insofar as the probate is or is not compete. But stretching it to be broadly inclusive is inaccurate and a bit misleading I think.
Heck, I was speculating today was going to be a fine partially cloudy day. Sun breaks to warm the heart and all that. In the last 30 minutes it has begun raining pretty well. I'm wrong lots.
Take care, Mike