Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Pass that plate of Crow...

Posts

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#26

My last entry...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>To summarize, you say that a single hollow is preferable, as it allows one to steer the chisel in the cut. I don't agree with that, and all that you've said hasn't convinced me of that. I'm not stubborn in any way, maybe you didn't explain your point of view right, or I don't pick up on what you mean.

I say that the multiple hollows allows one to have a reference surface to guide the chisel with. I see paring cuts as being a straight operation. Sure, the chisel is steered before making the cut, but once started the chisel is guided in a straight motion. A flat reference on the chisel back helps with guiding the chisel in straight, and the wedging action of the bevel is negligible in such thin cuts. If one takes heavy cuts then steerability becomes a desirable trait IMHO. But this not what we were talking about.

Hooped chisels... That's all I have (a dozen or so), and so I use them for paring too. Maybe that's where the confusion (and ensuing debate) arose from.

DC

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#27

Re: Kayoko

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>She may not be a woodworker, but the makers she carried (Imai, Yataiki) suggest that somehow she knew the "good names" in the field...

As for steering, please look at my last reply to Thom above.

DC

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#28

Re: Kayoko

Hank Knight

>I don't know if Kayoko is a woodworker or not. I doubt that she is. From my experience with her, she is a "broker" who knows a lot about her product line and the tool makers she represents, which include a number of acknowledged masters of Japanese toolmaking, all of whom she knows personally. Her function is (was) to match the needs of her craftsman customers with the products she represented and to arrange the sale. She would often act as a go-between to communicate the special needs/deesires of her customers to the makers and to arrange the manufacture of "custom" (or "bespoken" in the English tradition) tools by the maker for her costomers. In my dealings with her, I never felt like she was manipulating me to sell me the "tourist grade" stuff. In fact that analogy is like comparing her to a "hawker" and I find it offensive. She knows far more about Japanese tools than I ever will, and I have been happy and comfortable trusting her judgment and advice. I'm sorry she's gone and that her talent and knowledge are no longer available.

Hank

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#29

Re: Kayoko

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

> I never felt like she was manipulating me to sell me the "tourist grade" stuff

Amen to that!

DC

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#30

Re: Kayoko

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, she certainly is well connected; but that doesn't mean she would choose to sell multiple hollow chisels because she thinks they're superior in any way.

Steer? You really think we don't do the following when using a chisel?

Steer

�verb (used with object)

1. to guide the course of (something in motion) by a rudder, helm, wheel, etc.: to steer a bicycle.

2. to follow or pursue (a particular course).

3. to direct the course of; guide: I can steer you to the best restaurant in town.

�verb (used without object)

4. to direct the course of a vessel, vehicle, airplane, or the like, by the use of a rudder or other means.

5. to pursue a course of action.

6. (of a vessel, vehicle, airplane, etc.) to be steered or guided in a particular direction or manner.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#31

Re: Kayoko

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I agree with what you just said; but there's nothing there that says she'd only sell multiple hollows if she thought they were superior. Don't any of you guys read/understand plain English?

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#32

Re: Kayoko

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Me, neither; but with the election in full blow I've about had it with fake umbrage.

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#33

Re: Kayoko

Hank Knight

>Pam,

I think this is one of those personal preference things, of which there are many in woodworking. I don't know that multiple hollows are superior to a single hollow in larger chisels, but some people prefer them, including me. That's one of the nice things about made-to-order tools: you can get them the way you want them.

Hank

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#34

Re: Kayoko

wilbur

>I remember when I first contacted Kayoko about chisels, back when I really didn't know anything about hand tools. She spent a good amount of time between emails and the phone helping me understand the difference between the regular Imai chisels and the sword steel ones. Although I was thinking a little about the sword steel chisels, and probably would have bought one if she suggested it, she told me that since I was a beginner, the regular Imai chisels would be better for me.

I'm sure that she knew that she could have made a sale of the more expensive chisels that she carried, and she still suggested that I get the regular chisels instead.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#35

Yes, indeed, my attitude precisely.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#36

Re: Kayoko

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Same here, first time I contacted her was to buy an excellent Japanese saw. She suggested a $40 wonder that I still love rather than the $500 Yataiki (which I bought from her later). That saw could do a lot of work quickly and easily.

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#37

Re: Kayoko

James Watriss

>I still remember taking a class on Japanese tools from John Reed Fox, at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Maine. He's a professional furniture builder, at it for years, and had been dealing with Kayoko for pretty much the whole time. And there was still one plane she refused to sell him, because she knew him, and that he had kids, and it wouldn't be worth the extra cost to him.