Re: The truth hurts.
ThomD
>"The idea of a reference surface seems largely naive
Sure, you can trim a tenon or a dovetail pin with a spoon gouge, if you really know what you're doing..."
I'd like to see that...
"The fact is that, if using a single hollow Japanese chisel to chop, pare, whatever, and that the surface is wider than the chisel, then it's easy enough to register the chisel by the flat sides on each side of the hollow."
Yes an no. This works largely when the chisel is doing something baby like trimming a screw hole plug where there is an ocean of material to support the chisel. In dynamic mode there is both accuracy and the dynamic motion of the chisel to contend with and you are not as supported as you think, the chisel rounds in from the bevel, and it is, no mater what, balanced by the flat to the rear of the edge. For that flat to be longer gives you no better control than having a car with locked steering would give you.
"However, if you need to trim a dovetail pin that's a trifle thick,"
Already someone appears to have goofed the sawing job and are chasing a line... Exactly why that person needs a 300 dollar chisel is not clear to me.
" then the multiple hollow makes sense."
Well not really, because
- there may be a properly fitted chisel there somewhere in the box. Is it too much to hope that in a set of 10 or more chisels with probably a fairly small number of dovetail case etc... sizes, that one of the chisels would actually fit the work, the "expert" person who is chasing a line, bought them for?
- Because it won't work anyway, because stuff is moving around. Ever ride a bike and you are riding really straight, just flying along, then you look back and notice a wet track off the wheels, and they weave back and forth a lot, constantly crossing each other's paths; ever see a perfectly set up bow fire an arrow at a target, it flies like a dart, like a curved laser beam no deviation, But in slow mo, it is a highly dynamic system the arrow "swims" to target oscillating several inches to either side. Stuff moves around, even for the expert, but we know we aren't even talking about that here because we have someone who goofed the saw cut and thinks they have registration, and believes goodness knows what is happening before the chisel reaches the area where the hollows actually are. And that first part is the part that shows, etc...
" Let's say for the sake of argument that the pin is 9/16" wide. You only have 1/2" and 3/4" wide, single hollow Japanese chisels. Two choices: you can use the 1/2" chisel and trim in two passes, or use the 3/4" one and do it in one shot (as one would do with a western chisel).
Or could use the L of the side and end of a wider chisel
"But then, once passed the small flat in front of the single hollow you have no support to keep the cut straight,"
Already dealt with this stuff
" as opposed to the western chisels that keep a flat reference surface to keep your paring straight."
Thereby making it difficult to do anything because chisels do not cut straight they naturally undercut, and the presence of more back actually means you can't effect turning control in the direction you have to.
"Not that it can't be done, but multiple hollows solve that issue by providing better support to the intended direction of cut."
Right, good support for the intended direction of cut which is not the actual, or necessary, direction of cut.
"Steering cuts will get a poor fit, that's what carving chisels are for..."
You have no choice all cuts are steered, that's presumably the kind of thinking that lead to the dovetailer's problems in the first place.
"There are some "skills" that can be learned with practice, but there's something to say for tools that allow you to get the job done without having to fuss with a specific tool."
Even if you were on the right track you would have to deal with the fact that both these formats exist on Japanese tools and the single bevel is the predominant form by far including on the very best tools that exist out there. There is little difference in production cost, and often lesser tools have pimped their ride with multi bevels.
" It's like trying to cut DTs or tenons with a saw that has a kerf twice as wide as the plate. You can manage to make those cuts straight with practice, but in reality a saw with a kerf appropriate for the task at hand will,"
That's a taultology, But even in the case of the finest set the saw needs to be started in the right direction, steered to the right depth, etc...
" ceteris paribus,"
Both my parents are world famous Latin and Greek scholars, so they would enjoy that...
"In the future I would appreciate if you could use a less demeaning tone... Not agreeing with you doesn't make one a nincompoop..."
Your didn't agree with my post. Before we just weren't in agreement, and that doesn't bother me a bit. If you can't take the (unintended) heat, you should hear what these guys really think about us, and occasionally let us know by the tourist crap they slide our way. Multiple bevels aren't crap, they just aren't useful, and represent a "feature" that the rationalist over here like to debate and fall in love with. Always look for the fundamentals. And a fundamental is that if you don't have to steer it it wouldn't take any skill, but it does, or you wouldn't feel you need registration.