Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Pass that plate of Crow...

Posts

Pass that plate of Crow...

#1

Pass that plate of Crow...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>as I must eat some. Having dismissed oriental tools as 'backwards' and made fun of them, in good humor but still I didn't think of trying the chisels that are 'laminated'. What was I thinking.

Well Wilbur, et al, I bought a Japanese Chisel today and other that that troublesome hollow grind on the flat (that is going away on a coarse stone), nice tool. The sides are relieved and I don't like that but it is 9mm, so I may square up the sides, but for $30.00. fine with me.

What was odd was that it was sharp out of the box, well plastic bag. I whaled a bit on some lignum vitae, so it passed the first test. Then on some pine, that went smoothly.

Did I mention that they are laminated chisels! Hard steel forged welded to softer backing material, what a clever idea. Well if I can't get a European or an American new made laid steel chisel blade, then this is an excellent substitution. I will change out the hooped handle.

It appears to be quite hard, so I probably won't re-harden it, but I do want to try that after I have its initial hardness checked.

Stephen, pass the salt

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#2

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

Tony Zaffuto

>Stephen,

If you do remodel this chisel, kindly post before and after photos. I have a shop full of western chisels--both modern and vintage. I have only one Japanese,I beleive Matsumara, from The Japan Woodworker. I absolutely love the Japanese chisel, which I have had for about 4 or 5 years, but I'm afraid of buying another for fears of disappointment in even the same brand not feeling the same(Plus, I don't need anymore chisel)!

Tony Z.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#3

Welcome Grasshopper.....

Brent in Montreal

>In the not so distant past I felt the same as you Stephen. then I got a few Miyanaga furniture chisels and a saw from Japan Woodworker and everything changed ( and my wallet started litening LOL). Most of the time I'm reaching for Japanese tools now.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#4

Second that...

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>The modifications will be very interesting. I'm curious why the hollow back is a problem.

The box cross-section ('kakuuchi') that Stephen is after was prevalent in Japan before 1950, according to So Yamashita (http://www.japan-tool.com), and he's got some collectible older chisels with this very shape.

Wiley

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#5

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

wilbur

>Well, actually, for chisels I think it's more of a lamination thing than a backwards thing, but I'm glad you're giving one a try. But I think I'll pass out if you start writing about your new ryoba. :@)

I know why you like a non-hollowed back, but good luck. Having worked on the back of used beat up Japanese chisels I've run across, I know that to get rid of the hollow is going to be a LOT of work. You might want to consider leaving it as is, and "Vive la Diff�rence". After all, if I managed to run across an old laminated Witherby, I wouldn't try to put a hollow in one. :@)

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#6

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Welcome to the east. This topic almost always reminds me of book banning, with the banners yelling "I don't need to read this trash to know it's bad. Ban this book!"

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#7

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

ThomD

>None of the proposed alterations sound like progress. If you are just now realizing the benefits of the lamination then you might wait a while until the rest of it sinks in. On the other hand I have modified some older ones to the Krenov style and nothing stops me from making an alteration if I feel I need it. It is your tool.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#8

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I bought a Japanese Chisel today and other that that troublesome hollow grind on the flat (that is going away on a coarse stone), nice tool...

Stephen, that will not be a nice tool much longer if you insist on lapping the sole until the hollow disappears. You are removing the hard steel lamination!

What is your objection to the hollow?

What was odd was that it was sharp out of the box, well plastic bag. I whaled a bit on some lignum vitae, so it passed the first test. Then on some pine, that went smoothly.

Japanese chisels (even the cheap ones) are the only type that withstand the stress of being hammered into hard eucalypts and not only do not fold, but keep on going and going and .. I sold my Witherbys and Stanleys a while ago. The romance of using them was lost in the frustration of having to frequently resharpen them.

I will change out the hooped handle.

Now that you are trying something new, why not go the whole hog and just use them the way they are designed and intended to be used. Hooped handle and all. The bench chisel is designed to be hit with a hammer, preferably a heavy steel one (not a wooden mallet). They are uncomfortable for paring, so you may want to try a Japanese slick as well.

It appears to be quite hard, so I probably won't re-harden it, but I do want to try that after I have its initial hardness checked.

You are having us on, aren't you? :) Re-harden a nomi?! You are such a card, Stephen! :)

As Pam said, welcome to the East!

Regards from Perth (East to some, West to others)

Derek

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#9

Not sure what you mean by "troublesome hollow"...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>...but if my guess is right, what you don't like is the "loss of reference surface" that the hollow causes. That's something that had been bothering me as I was contemplating the purchase of Japanese chisels...

Kayoko provided the solution on her web site. In the Imai chisel page there was this mention: "double or triple hollow upon request"...

That clinched it for me! I thus decided that anything narrower than 1/2" is OK with a single hollow, 1/2" to 1" is double hollow, and triple hollow for anything wider than that.

What this does is to keep that reference surface that western chisels provide, while keeping the hollows that make sharpening that hard steel faster. Remember that Japanese chisels need to be done both back and bevel in order to keep the hollow from reaching the edge.

As someone else mentioned, you might not be left with much if any hard steel left if you grind out the hollow.

As for hardness, I would caution against trying to "improve" on that. Especially for inexpensive Japanese chisels ($30 is inexpensive in these circles). Often manufacturers of these inexpensive chisels push the hardness too high in order to claim high Rc numbers, but the steel can't take it without getting brittle, then the edge chips.

Hoops... I must say that I don't really care for them. In theory one is supposed to strike the chisel with a steel hammer, in which case the hoop makes sense. I use a mallet, and the hoop is more an annoyance than anything else to me. My view is that using a small hammer to strike requires paying more attention to the strike motion, which takes away from the part that matters, i.e. what happens at the business end. I'll try working more with the hammer, I'm sure the Japanese do it for a reason, and maybe I'm committing heresy here. Still...

Furthermore, in many cases the handle needs to be mushroomed to seat the hoop (some manufacturers do it for you, others don't), but even then, my experience is that many hoops get loose during the winter, somewhat annoying... What I might end up doing is taking one of the cheaper ones that I have, remove the hoop, and round the end � la LN (love the shape of their handles). But the thought of doing that to my Imai makes me cringe 8-O

Have fun with your new purchase, you've just started down the slope :-)

DC

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#10

It occurs to me ... *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>... that I did not take into account a few issues that all newcomers to Japanese chisels must deal with.

The main one is to correctly seat the hoops on the chisels. Few manufacturers do this for you. Unset hoops are not nice to use. The edge of the steel lies high on the back of the handle and the hammer will glance off it. The hoop should be set lower, and the protruding handle above it is mushroomed onto the steel. The hammer does not then strike or be affected by the steel. Setting the hoop will alter the characteristics of a Japanese bench chisel.

Below is an short article by So on chisel set up. It contains all that is important.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Setting up a new chisel

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#11

Re: Tourist thinking

ThomD

>"Kayoko provided the solution on her web site. In the Imai chisel page there was this mention: "double or triple hollow upon request"..."

What the multi hollow chisels really tell us is that they aren't necessary. Here is a fairly simple addition that would solve all the "problems", yet it is not employed by the vast majority of makers, and while I don't think it is explicitly a tourist item, it comes close. There are makers who use multies on all their chisels, but also those who just stick them in when they are slaping on the sandlewood or sharkskin handles.

The idea of a reference surface seems largely naive. There are situations where a reference is required, and in most instances is provided by:

- full contact with the edges. Keep in mind that the hollow means most chisels can be lapped flat to a greater degree than with other chisels, at least more easily.

- Is irrelevant because in most uses the chisel is in a dynamic mode and is diving away from the back. This means the chisel needs active direction, which if anything would be made easier if the back wasn't there at all.

- There is a flat directive surface behind the edge at all times anyway.

- A lot of chiseling in competent hands will be done with bevel reference, where we have the nice deep bevel on most Japanese chisels.

- In some cases chisels have handle interference for a back reference, but Japanese chisels are carefully designed to avoid this. That isn't the direct issue here, but it is an example of how the design is overall better, if you understand it.

The main advantage to the hollows are that they allow a higher degree of polish to be given to the edge. This is another reason that multiple hollows are slightly adverse. If you grind the hollow(s) off you are giving that up. They shouldn't be a thin point on the chisel and will eventually grind away, if not at tourist rates of consumption. However, you will reduce the thickness at the new edge slightly. I had some very good chisels where the hollows all but disappeared when I prepped them, on one or two of the smaller ones. Whatever. Presumably the fact that HSS steel chisels can be buffed with power, is one reasons why they don't always put the hollows on HSS Jap. chisels. So if a person were, joking aside, thinking of removing them, they would save a lot of effort just buying Japanese chisels without them.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#12

Re: Not sure what you mean by "troublesome hollow"

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>What about the practice of "tapping out" the bevel to roll the edge and restore the flat between the edge and the hollow? Done before the back was re flattened. Has this gone out of favor? The practice reduces the removal of the laminated tool steel during the back preparation.

JR

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#13

Tapping out

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sure, Joe, you do that if things get out of balance and you need steel to make a proper back to hollow relationship; but it's not something you want to do routinely, especially for smaller chisels.

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#14

Setting up a new Chisel *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Stephen here are some valuable guidelines for setting up a new Japanese chisel.

Pam


Setting up a new chisel

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#15

Re: Tapping out

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Used primarily when the hollow encroaches too close to the arris correct?

JR

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#16

Re: Tapping out

wilbur

>Yes, but on a Japanese chisel you can accomplish the same thing by going through the back flattening process. This removes a little metal from the back, which moves the hollow away from the edge.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#17

Re: Tourist thinking

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The idea of a reference surface seems largely naive

Sure, you can trim a tenon or a dovetail pin with a spoon gouge, if you really know what you're doing...

The fact is that, if using a single hollow Japanese chisel to chop, pare, whatever, and that the surface is wider than the chisel, then it's easy enough to register the chisel by the flat sides on each side of the hollow.

However, if you need to trim a dovetail pin that's a trifle thick, then the multiple hollow makes sense. Let's say for the sake of argument that the pin is 9/16" wide. You only have 1/2" and 3/4" wide, single hollow Japanese chisels. Two choices: you can use the 1/2" chisel and trim in two passes, or use the 3/4" one and do it in one shot (as one would do with a western chisel). But then, once passed the small flat in front of the single hollow you have no support to keep the cut straight, as opposed to the western chisels that keep a flat reference surface to keep your paring straight. Not that it can't be done, but multiple hollows solve that issue by providing better support to the intended direction of cut. Steering cuts will get a poor fit, that's what carving chisels are for...

There are some "skills" that can be learned with practice, but there's something to say for tools that allow you to get the job done without having to fuss with a specific tool. It's like trying to cut DTs or tenons with a saw that has a kerf twice as wide as the plate. You can manage to make those cuts straight with practice, but in reality a saw with a kerf appropriate for the task at hand will, ceteris paribus, make for a faster, easier, straighter cut. Even "non-tourists" benefit from that...

In the future I would appreciate if you could use a less demeaning tone... Not agreeing with you doesn't make one a nincompoop...

DC

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#19

Re: Tapping out

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, I understand that and it sounds right to me.

Pam

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#20

Oops, Derek, not trying to steal your thunder.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#22

Re: The truth hurts.

ThomD

>"The idea of a reference surface seems largely naive

Sure, you can trim a tenon or a dovetail pin with a spoon gouge, if you really know what you're doing..."

I'd like to see that...

"The fact is that, if using a single hollow Japanese chisel to chop, pare, whatever, and that the surface is wider than the chisel, then it's easy enough to register the chisel by the flat sides on each side of the hollow."

Yes an no. This works largely when the chisel is doing something baby like trimming a screw hole plug where there is an ocean of material to support the chisel. In dynamic mode there is both accuracy and the dynamic motion of the chisel to contend with and you are not as supported as you think, the chisel rounds in from the bevel, and it is, no mater what, balanced by the flat to the rear of the edge. For that flat to be longer gives you no better control than having a car with locked steering would give you.

"However, if you need to trim a dovetail pin that's a trifle thick,"

Already someone appears to have goofed the sawing job and are chasing a line... Exactly why that person needs a 300 dollar chisel is not clear to me.

" then the multiple hollow makes sense."

Well not really, because

- there may be a properly fitted chisel there somewhere in the box. Is it too much to hope that in a set of 10 or more chisels with probably a fairly small number of dovetail case etc... sizes, that one of the chisels would actually fit the work, the "expert" person who is chasing a line, bought them for?

- Because it won't work anyway, because stuff is moving around. Ever ride a bike and you are riding really straight, just flying along, then you look back and notice a wet track off the wheels, and they weave back and forth a lot, constantly crossing each other's paths; ever see a perfectly set up bow fire an arrow at a target, it flies like a dart, like a curved laser beam no deviation, But in slow mo, it is a highly dynamic system the arrow "swims" to target oscillating several inches to either side. Stuff moves around, even for the expert, but we know we aren't even talking about that here because we have someone who goofed the saw cut and thinks they have registration, and believes goodness knows what is happening before the chisel reaches the area where the hollows actually are. And that first part is the part that shows, etc...

" Let's say for the sake of argument that the pin is 9/16" wide. You only have 1/2" and 3/4" wide, single hollow Japanese chisels. Two choices: you can use the 1/2" chisel and trim in two passes, or use the 3/4" one and do it in one shot (as one would do with a western chisel).

Or could use the L of the side and end of a wider chisel

"But then, once passed the small flat in front of the single hollow you have no support to keep the cut straight,"

Already dealt with this stuff

" as opposed to the western chisels that keep a flat reference surface to keep your paring straight."

Thereby making it difficult to do anything because chisels do not cut straight they naturally undercut, and the presence of more back actually means you can't effect turning control in the direction you have to.

"Not that it can't be done, but multiple hollows solve that issue by providing better support to the intended direction of cut."

Right, good support for the intended direction of cut which is not the actual, or necessary, direction of cut.

"Steering cuts will get a poor fit, that's what carving chisels are for..."

You have no choice all cuts are steered, that's presumably the kind of thinking that lead to the dovetailer's problems in the first place.

"There are some "skills" that can be learned with practice, but there's something to say for tools that allow you to get the job done without having to fuss with a specific tool."

Even if you were on the right track you would have to deal with the fact that both these formats exist on Japanese tools and the single bevel is the predominant form by far including on the very best tools that exist out there. There is little difference in production cost, and often lesser tools have pimped their ride with multi bevels.

" It's like trying to cut DTs or tenons with a saw that has a kerf twice as wide as the plate. You can manage to make those cuts straight with practice, but in reality a saw with a kerf appropriate for the task at hand will,"

That's a taultology, But even in the case of the finest set the saw needs to be started in the right direction, steered to the right depth, etc...

" ceteris paribus,"

Both my parents are world famous Latin and Greek scholars, so they would enjoy that...

"In the future I would appreciate if you could use a less demeaning tone... Not agreeing with you doesn't make one a nincompoop..."

Your didn't agree with my post. Before we just weren't in agreement, and that doesn't bother me a bit. If you can't take the (unintended) heat, you should hear what these guys really think about us, and occasionally let us know by the tourist crap they slide our way. Multiple bevels aren't crap, they just aren't useful, and represent a "feature" that the rationalist over here like to debate and fall in love with. Always look for the fundamentals. And a fundamental is that if you don't have to steer it it wouldn't take any skill, but it does, or you wouldn't feel you need registration.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#23

I have no problem with the truth

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>It's opinions that are presented as "truth" that I have a problem with.

I don't know what you mean by "dynamic mode", a chisel that is static doesn't cut anything. Simple physics. If what you mean is that you steer the chisel in operation, it can mean only one thing, you will not get straight cuts, and by extension, poor joints.

It's easy enough to grasp that if one takes a heavy cut the chisel will veer off the intended course because of the wedging action of the bevel. But this effect becomes nil as the cuts get thinner (like for paring). So if one wants to get a straight cut, having a flat reference on the back helps achieve that goal. If you want to wiggle your way to a straight cut, have fun, I have no use for that personally.

The bike and arrow examples, I got a good laugh off those. They have no relation whatsoever with pushing a chisel straight into a piece of wood. You're clutching at straws here, man...

As for the dovetail pin example, it was just that, an example. No one said that one needs a $300 chisel, I don't know where you got that idea (unresolved anger issues?). I didn't mention that I don't need to trim my DT pins, as it was not relevant to the discussion. I could have used trimming of tenon cheeks as an example, or any other trimming task, doesn't matter.

And I do take issue to your thinly disguised statement that Kayoko would peddle "tourist" stuff. She's a much nicer person than that. Ask anyone who's done business with her.

I didn't bother answering many of your other statements, I could, but to be frank with you I've spent too much time in this discussion already. But the bottom line is that you haven't brought any valid argument as to the uselessness of multiple hollows. Only put-downs.

Have a good day.

DC

Who still loves his Japanese chisels, BTW

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#24

Re: I have no problem with the truth

ThomD

>I own lots of Japanese chisels both cheap and very expensive. At least six sets. The earliest partial set going back to the late 70s. Jealousy has nothing to do with it.

"But the bottom line is that you haven't brought any valid argument"

as to the uselessness of multiple hollows."

Well as you are the apparent the arbiter of validity, let me just thank you for your consideration.

Only put-downs."

That would be a stylish attack if I hadn't brought any reasoned arguments, I brought reams of stuff, that you may discount, except as to actually counting their number. I can hardly be accused of only offering put downs: You may not like the other arguments, but that isn't the same as their not having been made.

I consider myself to be a tourist, someone who only does stuff part time, and on holidays. I have done this stuff full time too, but never nearly enough to qualify me on even the first rung of the Japanese tradition. Part of what I know about the pitfalls of this stuff comes from making a fool of myself in the past buying tourist tools. My opinion based on stuff I have bought and passed over, is that sometimes, when they get a set of crappy chisels, they slap fancy handles on them, do some multiple hollows, and ship them to Germany, etc... I own lots of grinders and have put in my time. I couldn't have missed some of the crap I see on my first day in the shop over 30 years ago. Yet it arrived at my door (but not only mine) in a "presentation" box, and I didn't send it back because it would have cost me more than it was worth to do so. The best shops in America pass this stuff on as well as other places.

I don't think I claimed those examples of what happens at speed are interesting except as regards the fact that what appears to be the case often isn't. In this case as regards registration.

This discussion (I think) started about hooped chisels not paring ones. If you opinion is that the better guys with this stuff, for whom this stuff is designed, nibble away with light cuts when powerful moves would do, then I think that is more tourist thinking at work. If the rear 2/3rds of the back were ground away, it would work better/as well as a chisel, but be harder to sharpen, and not last as long. This is essentially where things stand when the chisels are worn down to mere nubs and by your logic very unregistered, yet highly prized by their users for one reason or another.

Re: Pass that plate of Crow...

#25

Kayoko

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't think Kayoko is a woodworker. Most vendors sell what their customers want, only way to make a go of it.

As to multiple hollows, I basically think of them like fancy woodgrain work, nice to look at but no performance gain. I might allow for a little more structural support for very large chisels, say in the 42 mm range and above; but that's a guess.

One always steers a chisel in use, the very act of pushing and/or guiding the path taken after a hit. No?

Pam