Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Chisel questions

Posts

Chisel questions

#1

Chisel questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First bear with some background. I feel I may need to convince some that I do listen to advise, eventually.

Some time ago, smitten by the success of the short dovetail chisels I made, I asked on this forum why long chisels were made. Time has passed and I am using chisels more now and I am seeing the benefit of a long chisel for paring. I am left with needing/wanting a set of paring chisels (or at least chisels with long blades, what ever they may be called).

The only set of chisels that has come up on Ebay has been a set for $400. I have no interest in spending the time to accumulate a set one at a time and I have ground the pits out of the back of the last chisel I ever intend to. New chisels are $30-75 depending on size and manufacturer. That's a pile of money for a set of chisels.

I said some time ago that I was done fabricating metal, but the situation compels me to make a set of paring chisels. The dovetail chisels cost only a few bucks each and not much work. I have to make them out of some kind of metal so why not 3V? It remains the best metal for the task so long as one can use diamond sharpening techniques. They will be tanged chisels because that is the only kind I can make.

1. Will someone send me, or post, a picture of a tanged (as opposed to socket) paring chisel? I am particularly interested in how the tanged versions are handled.

2. Given that I have a set of bevel edged dovetail chisels is there any reason to bevel the edges of paring chisels? I currently have one Swan paring chisel with square sides and one with beveled sides. For what I have used them for I see no difference. But then there is more wisdom here than my limited experience. Both kinds seem to be made. Where is one better than the other? It is easy for me to bevel the chisels I make, if for some reason I should.

Thanks in advance for some thoughtful responses.

Re: Chisel questions

#2

Re: Chisel questions

Hank Knight

>Bill,

A large stock of unused (new old stock) Swan chisels surfaced in New England recently and many have been sold on eBay over the last couple of months. These are unhandled and many are tang chisels. Most of the firmer chisels have bolsters, but not all. Do a search for "Swan chisel" on eBay and you will find a half dozen current offerings with pretty good photographs. My guess is (I didn't try this) if you search for completed auctions over the last couple of months you'll find a lot more.

Hank

Re: Chisel questions

#3

example

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>this is what I had in mind. This handle is a bit small in diameter; would enlarge about 1/8". Suggestions?


img

Re: Chisel questions

#4

Suggestions? Well, shoot, yeah

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Don't make it from wood, Bill. Way too hard to get a good edge on it.

Sorry...

Only time I ever saw paring chisels in use was by Ian Kirby, who had some old, lovely, long Sorby chisels. I was struck by the fact that he gripped them about halfway along the blade, with the handle appearing to serve no function whatsoever, unless it was, like a squirrel's tail, for balance. No wisdom to offer on the subject - just that observation.

Re: Chisel questions

#5

Some chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

For myself, what sets apart "a paring chisel" from other chisels that are used "for pairing" is the ability to take a delicate cut. In other words, a chisel that maximises the ease with which one may do detail work, as opposed to a generalist chisel that one simply makes do with.

The main feature of a pairing/detail chisel is the slimness of the construction. They are lightly built This is also why they also tend to be tanged. I do not view length of blade as a factor, although traditionally pairing chisels are long in the blade. No doubt others will disagree here. The other feature that is not necessary is that they have bevelled sides. Some do and some do not.

I have two sets of chisels that I could call paring chisels using this definition. The first is a set of Berg chisels. The other is a set of Blue Spruce chisels.

The Bergs have long blades and are lightly built with thin blades. In their own right they make good dovetail chisels since the bevelled shoulders are narrow. Mine are honed at 20 degrees (since they can cope with this low angle).

The other feature I must point out is that I replaced the handles on all mine. The original Berg handles where designed to be hit with a mallet. Mine are desined to be pushed only. They are similar to those on Japanese slicks (as long as ..). While you ask about blades, the handle and balance are as important in my book.



Here is the original Berg handle, and a Japanese chisel for comparison.



Sized 1/8" through 1 1/4". I have little desire for a wider pairing chisel.



Some time ago, shortly after Dave Jeske began offering his dovetail chisels, I bought a few and ordered a custom 3/4" (which was not being made at that time). It duly arrived, beautifully made, but the blade was 3/16" thick as opposed to the 1/8" of the others. It did not feel right in the hand - too heavy, too stiff. Dave made another, this time 1/8" - and it was/is perfect.

Here is the 3/4" ..



A growing family (with a hole waiting to be filled with a 3/16").



Hope this all helps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel questions

#6

Re: Chisel questions *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Below see my favorite paring chisel, exquisite, makes me feel good to pick it up, extra bonus when I use it. You don't need to spend extra for the wood grain version or the ebony, I have the plain black with gumi (boxwood) handle, there is no performance difference.

Pam


Akio Tasai very thin paring chisel

Re: Chisel questions

#7

LN Paring a la Charlesworth

paul womack

>DC simply put long handles on the as-supplied dovetail chisel when he first tried them. This was so successful that LN now offer this as an option.

Clearly a shop-made handle (perhaps on a shop made chisel) could follow this example. Certainly the Japanese model for paring chisels puts a lot of length in the handle, as opposed to the traditional UK patternmaker's chisel where the blades are long.

BugBear

Re: Chisel questions

#8

Re: Suggestions? Well, shoot, yeah

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That is the hold I seem to have on them also. The dovetails chisels I made have sharp edges from grinding the bevel and they are NOT comfy in the hand. Hence, the desire to acquire the paring chisels. Do you think if I use iron wood for the blade it will be better!

Re: Chisel questions

#9

Quite helpful

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Dave does nice work.

Your thoughts on chisels will help me wind up with a serviceable set. I suspect they will look a lot like Dave's.

Re: Chisel questions

#10

starting at $239.80?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Holy smoke! You must have missed the how cheap I am part of the question!

Re: Chisel questions

#11

Re: Chisel questions

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have made small chisels out of flat stock; they do not seem to miss the bolster. However, I do prefer a bolster and a taper from the neck down to the edge. This keeps the neck area a little stiffer and stronger, while overall the chisel is lighter and being thinner at the edge, faster to sharpen. You do notice the flex on a paring chisel.

I think 10" is a good length. I use right hand on the handle and left hand on the steel. If the chisel has a bevel edge, it is somewhat more comfortable for the left hand, but it doesn't take much of a bevel to feel good. At 8" length my hands are starting to pile up on top of each other and I am wishing for a longer tool.

I think you definitely want a shoulder right next to the handle (like your chisel in picture) if you go without a bolster. Most tangs are about 2" long, square, and tapered from 1/4 or 3/16 down to 1/16 or quite a bit less. But on cheap chisels made out of flat stock the tang usually tapers in width only from 5/16 or 3/8 down to 1/8.

My inclination would be to go with two high quality chisels and put out good money for them.

Re: Chisel questions

#12

Re: starting at $239.80?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think that was for the set of 3, and I said that you didn't need to pay extra for ebony and woodgrain, that plain black with plain handle would work just as well. If you look at the price list (popdown menu), you'll see the smaller sizes are fairly cheap.

Pam

Re: Chisel questions

#13

Re: Chisel questions

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I've got a hodge-podge of chisels and use both beveled and unbeveled for paring. I haven't found a beveled-edge to be particularly superior, nor do I find it weighs so much less as to make a difference in feel. I pare quite a bit with my 2" bench chisel. It's an Ashley Isles, beveled-edge chisel that I have a 25 degree bevel on the edge. I'm guessing it's water-tempered high carbon steel (as opposed to oil-tempered). Larger chisels seem to hold an edge better with a lower bevel angle than narrower chisels do. Common wisdom always brings up the adjectives "long" and "thin" when discussing paring chisels. Long chisels with flat backs are very useful when paring a tenon but I have found myself prefering shorter chisels for other paring jobs (an inch or two or less wood to be removed). Thin seems to be a psychological advantage, within reason. The quality of the edge has been a more important issue than thinness. I do find that a lower bevel angle on the edge produces an easier slice. The chisel's ability to hold an edge at this reduced angle has been the most important issue for me. I'm more or less thinking out loud here. I agree with Derek's observations and can second his opinion on the Berg chisels. I have two that were given to me. They have very thin blades of good quality but the handles are better suited for general bench work with some malleting. My Pexto chisel is not beveled-edged but is relatively thin and holds a nice edge. It has a socket handle that is really very short and I tend to wrap my hand half around the handle and the socket. Both of these chisels are on my round tuit list for new handles. I've held off partly because I'm not sure about what I want yet.

Re: Chisel questions

#14

Tasei

paul womack

>My interpretation of the site's pricing is that 239 dollars is the base (mininum) price of a chisel, and the larger sizes have increments over the base.

So, the 6mm is 239 (239 + 0) and the 24mm is 377 (239 + 138).

A little rich for my blood. I make no comment on "value".

BugBear

Re: Chisel questions

#15

Sets?

roninkokomo

>I think for those of us who really do use out tools on a regular basis, the concept of a "set" of chisels is overrated. I do have most of a set of Chas. Buck chisels that are OLD.. By the way they are wonderful for paring and hold an edge very well.

Buy a couple on e bay and see if you like them and then add the others based on your own confidence of use.

I have a coupole of friends who have a delightful hodge podge of Japanes and Western chisels and do wonderful work with them

Re: Chisel questions

#17

Re: Sets?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I keep the set of dovetail chisels in a rack on the bench. With them in reach I find I use every size I made. So my inclination is to do the same approach making paring chisels.

It is not an exaggeration that the time I would spend buying chisels on Ebay and getting them in usable condition would be greater than making a set. The steps are easy- buy steel, hire a machine shop to saw the blanks, grind or saw tangs, grind bevel, heat treat, turn handle, drive handle onto tang, sharpen, done. The only approach that makes sense is to amortize some of the steps like heat treating over a set of several chisels. Chisels are both easy and cheap to make and one can be sure of the quality of the steel by buying high quality steel and having it professionally heat treated, which is cheap.

Re: Chisel questions

#18

Re: Tasai

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I certify that I didn't pay more than $120 or so for an at least 36 mm wide ultra thin. Harrelson is in the process of driving away business with his web site, so you have to call to verify prices. To be honest, I checked a couple of other sites that I know carry Tasai, but they didn't show the ultra thin parer.

Pam

Re: Chisel questions

#19

Re: Sets?

roninkokomo

>From that perspective, I have to agree with you.

We are in different places in what we are doing with the craft ( which for me right now, is next to nothing) I hope to remedy that very soon

Ron

Re: Chisel questions

#20

Ellis Walentine

Paring chisel characteristics

Ellis Walentine

>I prefer long paring chisels because they are easier to hold straight up and down when paring a dovetail or a mortise cheek. The added length can be in the handle or in the blade, but the handle is where it makes more sense to me.

Paring chisels can be thin because they aren't subjected to heavy pounding, and, for the same reason, they can have low bevel angles, like 20°. Further, they need to be thin so they can get into tight spots. I've always liked Japanese paring chisels because they have all these characteristics, plus slightly offset handles that let you get a lower angle on the wood.

Yeung Chan makes all his own paring chisels from industrial hacksaw blades, which are something like .090" thick. They seem to work well for him.

Ellis

Re: Chisel questions

#21

thanks to all

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The advice has been most helpful in deciding the details of what will be made. While making the dovetail chisels we blundered into the best way to tang a chisel made from bar stock that turned out to be very strong and very simple. In the end they will look like crude versions of Dave's chisels. I have no patience for refinements that don't improve functionality. I am still torn between a simple "barrel" shaped handle and one like what is on the wooden model.

Re: Chisel questions

#22

Bill, can you tell us about how you make the tang

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>And could you possibly show a picture? Thanks in advance.

Re: Chisel questions

#23

Re: Some chisels

ThomD

>Good idea to ask around, but at the end of the day you are using the chisels, they should be custom to you. In the past, you have put a lot of work into making something distinctive and tried to suggest they were perfect for everyone. The advantage to making stuff is you only have to please yourself, and what everyone else thinks is irrelevant. So do you want short blades or long ones, back bevels or flush ones, angled handles, smooth transitions or whatever, it should be determined by your work. A really custom made tool can o utperform a top of the line one made by a much better craftsman, because it is ultra specific to the task and preferences at hand.

The attached photo shows 5 chisels with tangs. Of the four with short handles, one I bought and I think they go for about 80 dollars from Hock/LMII, and three I made to flesh out a set the way I wanted. The Japanese one was about 350, and oddly, it cuts like that. No tourist tech there. The one that works best depends on the job. If I was making a set for fun I might make a 3mm set out of O1 tools stock that looks like the japanese ones. In that blade delicacy there isn't a melted forged shoulder, and the home made one would look like they were expensive, not that it maters.


img

Re: Chisel questions

#24

Re: Chisel questions

ThomD

>Thanks for posting this. What happened to all the stuff at Harrelson's site. I couldn't get in even this far, but he used to have about 5 different weights of Tasaoi push chisels? Inclusing ones that were very light flat stock.

Re: Chisel questions

#25

Re: Chisel questions

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Who knows? Maybe lost his web site builder? I have about zero contact with Harrelson/Hiraide these days.

Pam