Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes
Bob Demers
>I have dabbled with electrolysis, other chemicals (dont like the results) but have not tried evaporust yet. It sound promising, but would never commit a tool to it before doing some test on lesser metal objects first.
Bottom line, I still use good old elbow grease in mechanically removing rust: sandpapers, rust erasers, lots of WD40, razor scrapers etc. Messy, yes, but i'm comfortable with the method and the results.
Less is better.
The goal to acheived is to return a tool into working order, not show room condition. When i first bring home a new to me tool, the first thing i do is to photograph and dissasemble it to assess its condition and document it. I will then attend quickly to major rust concerns, do a quick clean up. My goal here is simply to stop further deterioration and preserve it while I research what it is, its rarety and value etc...before i commit to more serious work on it to put it back to work (thourough cleaning, repair/replace parts if needed, sharpened the blade(flatten the back, polish the edge etc) refinish the wood parts if need be (more often i simply clean them with murphy oil) etc
I have never bothered to refinish a tool, to make it, look like new. Although im mighty impress with Vik's MF hand drills, and may send him one to try that someday.
Monetary value of tools? Oh please, such an overblown subject. Why does a LN or LV cost so much? Because you are paying for a real tool, that cost money to produce! What is my great grandfather's plane worth? I could quote you a book value, but condition is everything. Most people seems to think that there's is automatically worth the top dollar...A familiar quote from Ebay dealers: in good condition for its age. Translation: its a hunk of rust, but eh, its old, what do you expect!
There are many variable that enter into the price equation, and most are very subjective. Bottom line is this:
Take care of your tools, new or old, and enjoy them. Either in the shop or in a curio cabinet.
Cleaning? As necessary, but never overdone
Tools are tools are tools, not an edge against monetary market instability or part of a retirement plan
My two cents..oh no wait, stock market went down, my 1 and a quarter cent worth :-)
Bob, who enjoy his tools including his trusty Bedrock No 602 and never worry about what a collector may think of that.