Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Rust removal and cleaning planes

Posts

Rust removal and cleaning planes

#1

Rust removal and cleaning planes

David

>Related to the earlier post about cleaning a handsaw, has anyone used Evaporust for cleaning hand tools? I've used it for power tools, e.g., bed of a jointer, 6x48 belt sander, misc shafts and pulleys, with good success, but have never seen any comments here for hand tools.

Also, whenever I get a "new" plane, I typically start out with a routine of cleaning everything with mineral spirits and a soft brush, lapping the sole and sides, sharpening, waxing, etc. Does the lapping effect the plane's value? Most are Stanleys from the 20s to the 40s and I'm not a collector, per se, but don't want to destroy something either.

Just wondering what prevalent opinions are.

Thanks,

DGW

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#2

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

ThomD

>The question is presumably prospective. At some future date you will want to sell it, or executors will, and have you ruined the tool by using it. The question in a sense is what affect does use have, and what constitutes use.

We are engaged in using old tools for legitimate reasons today. Just as early American users used English planes because of then current factors, some use certain old planes today because it makes sense to real craftsmen to do so, and dabblers also. So leaving aside the still in a box plane from 1920 that will possibly be more valuable, in the year 2200 will people look at tools like yours as having an interesting working life, or will they discard them because 1920s original use was ligitimate but further use is not. If the tool comes to be seen as only legitimately used in it's original period of purchase, which is sorta how it is currently, then every thing you do from cleaning it to sharpening the blade is an assault on future value, whether that maters or not to a user today.

At the current time the monetary value is just one measure of value, with broad currency admitedly. But leaving aside the pain of destroying the value of the object, there is nothing inherantly higher order about sellection the monetary value. Take housing housing. Generally #1 financial asset, gets run down through use, could often be sold more profitably if we market-timed our activity and lived with our parents while waiting for prices to fall to new lows. I knew a prominent stock broker who actually sold his house out form under his familly during a later 80s market bubble in Toronto. But few do that. I don't really accept the idea of monetary value as the only guide. We do what we want to with lots of stuff, without regard for value, like drive new cars off lots. I'm hot on tools and nothing is going to make me see some other value prescription as higher than the one I have myself. I'm not saying I wouldn't go for the cash, if I was so lucky. But if I was inclined not to do that, I would have zero respect for some argument from some other hobbie that purported to be on a higher level than my own concerns. If a collector is crying while I am planing, I am unmoved.

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

Moses Yoder

>There are so many #3, 4, 5 and 7 Stanley bench planes out there looking for good homes, and I don't know of any collector who will cry if you paint them red. They might wonder about your sanity, but they won't cry over the plane. I was at a tool meet one time looking at a #3 with a few good parts on it when the dealer told me I could just take it home with me. I rejected the offer based on my prior acquisitions of #3 planes. When he picked up the plane and said "Well since nobody wants it I am just going to throw it into the dumpster" and started walking in that direction I of course stopped him and did him the favor of removing it from his pile. I would be pretty careful aout what I did to a #1 or #2 plane, or a plane that I am not familiar with. I would learn what I can about a plane before messing with it.

I have never used any "Evaporust" or anything of that sort. It just seems to me that if it eats into the metal it can't really be all that great to put on a plane. I use electrolysis with good results. Some people have bead blasted their planes with good results. I have re-japaned a few planes also and that is kind of a fun hobby but it is not woodworking.

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#4

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

Todd Hughes

>Ok Talking common tools now...

A properly cleaned plane is worth much more then one that is still rusty or dirty.

An improperly cleaned plane is worth less then a properly cleaned tool. A properly cleaned tool should be clean but show no signs of being cleaned. I should not be able to pick it up and say...Boy that guy has those sides polished up bright or see that the wood has been refinished. Most people I think that do this to thier planes do it because they don't know what they should look like or they want to make them "Better" or "New"...File these guys in with the folks that like to spray thier planes all black because they think it makes them look pretty.

...Flattening the sole on a user plane probably doesn't hurt the price and may actually be a selling point if sold to another user.Probably not enough to make it worth your while to do if you are doing it to get more money.Check how the plane wors befor doing it as you probably don't even need to. I am always amazed at the number of people that do all this work befor even trying the thing out.

...In my experance these chemical cleaners leave you with a tool that looks like they have been cleaned with a chemical cleaner which is somthing you don't want. I clean up lots of tools and it is just as easy and fast to do it the "right" way...Also try not to buy junk that needs lots of work....Todd

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#5

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

Bob Demers

>I have dabbled with electrolysis, other chemicals (dont like the results) but have not tried evaporust yet. It sound promising, but would never commit a tool to it before doing some test on lesser metal objects first.

Bottom line, I still use good old elbow grease in mechanically removing rust: sandpapers, rust erasers, lots of WD40, razor scrapers etc. Messy, yes, but i'm comfortable with the method and the results.

Less is better.

The goal to acheived is to return a tool into working order, not show room condition. When i first bring home a new to me tool, the first thing i do is to photograph and dissasemble it to assess its condition and document it. I will then attend quickly to major rust concerns, do a quick clean up. My goal here is simply to stop further deterioration and preserve it while I research what it is, its rarety and value etc...before i commit to more serious work on it to put it back to work (thourough cleaning, repair/replace parts if needed, sharpened the blade(flatten the back, polish the edge etc) refinish the wood parts if need be (more often i simply clean them with murphy oil) etc

I have never bothered to refinish a tool, to make it, look like new. Although im mighty impress with Vik's MF hand drills, and may send him one to try that someday.

Monetary value of tools? Oh please, such an overblown subject. Why does a LN or LV cost so much? Because you are paying for a real tool, that cost money to produce! What is my great grandfather's plane worth? I could quote you a book value, but condition is everything. Most people seems to think that there's is automatically worth the top dollar...A familiar quote from Ebay dealers: in good condition for its age. Translation: its a hunk of rust, but eh, its old, what do you expect!

There are many variable that enter into the price equation, and most are very subjective. Bottom line is this:

Take care of your tools, new or old, and enjoy them. Either in the shop or in a curio cabinet.

Cleaning? As necessary, but never overdone

Tools are tools are tools, not an edge against monetary market instability or part of a retirement plan

My two cents..oh no wait, stock market went down, my 1 and a quarter cent worth :-)

Bob, who enjoy his tools including his trusty Bedrock No 602 and never worry about what a collector may think of that.

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#6

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

ThomD

>Yeah you definetly don't want show room condition, they mostly don't work at that.

Don't forget about using them as laping plates for diamond sharpening.

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#7

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#8

OK, let's try that again...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Sorry for blank message.

I use SOS pads and warm water, followed by WD-40. Wax on the operating surfaces, wax or oil on screws. The plane looks like it's been working and just got cleaned up as best it can for going out Saturday night, which is about right for me.

I can appreciate the interests of those who insist on cleaning up planes, re-japanning them, etc.; but aerodynamics and drag coefficient are rarely much of an issue with hand woodworking tools, and scruffy but clean planes seem to work about as well as pristine ones.

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#9

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

David

>Thanks for all the comments.

At least for the moment, my planes are pretty common, 3, 4, 4 1/2, 5, 6, 7, 40, 220 and a couple of Miller's Falls that were my father's. For me, I guess there are a couple of issues. First is that I use them, or at least try. Given that, I'm not concerned about discoloration and the like, and don't need something that's all polished and shiny (which I don't really like anyway). I do try to get off the dirt and grunge, maybe a real goober of a paint spatter. After learning the delights of using sharp tools, I usually sharpen before playing and used to take a straight edge to the sole to see if it was flat. After watching a video on tuning bench planes I just started lapping the soles. Side lapping is probably more ascetic than functional for me. I don't touch the Japaning, although I've been tempted to varnish over it to keep any bare spots from rusting (saw that on a guy's plane restoration blog). Right now I use carnuba wax. Since I am a historian, I do worry about obscuring a tool's history. Like was mentioned in one of the responses my thinking has always been to do things that can be undone, lapping aside.

Even though I'm buying pretty common stuff, my aim is to buy good stuff that won't be junk in the future, whether in the hands of my kid or my estate.

I stumbled across Evaporust on the Old Wood Working Machine website. Found some at a local hardware store on sale and figured I'd give it a try on an old sears combo belt/disc sander I was given. With minimal rubbing I liked the results enough to use it on an Atlas jointer with a good layer of surface rust on the bed and fence. After final cleaning and waxing, the surfaces still look old, but clean and shiny after waxing. FWIW

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#10

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

I have used Evapo-Rust. It does a good job on tools such as rusted old C-Clamps for example. I've used it on handsaw blades but don't like the dull light grey finish that it leaves. It is not an acid so it does not eat into the metal. It is biodegradable, so does not do bad things to the environment. It works great on castiron and or parts that will be painted.

I didn't like the high price for something that wears out in a short time. One gallon cost me well over $30. One gallon only cleaned 3 or 4 saw blades. Once it turns black, it loses it's strength.

I still keep a gallon of it around for cleaning small intricate, hard to clean parts. I probably won't be buying anymore of it though. Just too expensive for my cheap wallet. QVC used to carry it for a little less cost. Last I checked, they no longer sell it.

Marv

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

#11

Re: Rust removal and cleaning planes

David

>Hey Marv,

The stuff is expensive and I do like the fact that it isn't corrosive. If you find yourself wanting to use it on something big, like too big to submerge as recommended, I found that it works fine if you cover whatever you're cleaning with a rag soaked in Evaporust and keep it wet.

Something tells me the Evaporust will stay in reserve for either small parts, as you mentioned, or for the real big and nasty stuff (stationary equipment).