Re: Update 3: Finished molding and installed------
Don McConnell
>Bjenk et al,
I truly appreciate your (and Ace's) very kind words regarding the DVD. My main hope in doing it was to encourage/enable people to experience the freedom of designing and making their own custom mouldings. So I've followed this thread with a good deal of interest and satisfaction. And, as Ace indicated, sticking a moulding of one's own design can be a lot of fun. There is another moulding DVD in the works - a bit more on that later.
Meanwhile, I thought I'd use your project to delve a little further into the general conversation about drawing and sticking mouldings using H&R's, etc.
Out of curiousity, Bjenk, before you provided information about the scale of the larger ogee and the size H&R you ultimately used, I had attempted to scale it out at my end in order to see what challenges you might run into. Apparently I goofed a bit in that effort, but I thought others might be interested in the thought process involved - as I think it speaks to the issue of designing mouldings, swinging arcs, etc.
As I scaled it, the resulting radius of the concave and convex arcs of the ogee appeared to be about 7/8" (app. 2.2 cm). I then assumed that if your H&R's were an even set, that your #12 H&R might have a width/radius of about 3/4" (1.9 cm) while your #14 H&R would have a width/radius of about 1" (2.5 cm).
If that had been the scenario, a couple of strategies to deal with the radius discrepancies come to mind. One would be to scale the overall moulding up or down so that the radius of the arcs of the ogee coincided with your #12 or #14 H&R. Not always possible or desirable. The other would be retain the overall size of the moulding and slightly alter the radius of the arcs to match your planes. That can easily be done by setting one's compass at either the hypothetical 3/4" or 1", swing a couple of short arcs, using the endpoints and midpoint of the sloping line (e, f & i), to locate the new centers, then swing the new arcs between those points.
But, this really only works in one direction. If you go with the larger 1" radius, the resulting arc is less than 60 degrees (7/8" rather than 1"), so one's #14 hollow can't be used to create the convex arc without fouling the concave portion. In other words, at 1" wide, it is wider than the 7/8" chord of the arc. An issue to keep in mind in designing any moulding.
If, on the other hand, you go with the smaller 3/4" radius, the resulting arc is more than 60 degrees, and your H&R planes will be able to negotiate them. The arcs will be a little "quicker" than the originals, but that will be barely, if at all, perceptible in the final result. I've included a drawing (see below) to illustrate this, with the dotted arcs indicating the originals and the solid arcs indicating the 3/4" radius with arrows pointing to the new centers. The #12 H&R's will simply have to be axially rotated a bit to complete the full width of the arc.
I've gone into this in some detail because I think it illustrates, at the very least, that it is a good idea to keep in mind the width/radius of your H&R's as you design a moulding. If there is no correspondence between your drawing and your planes, the best you can hope for is to painstakingingly creep up on your design with an ill-sized/profiled plane. At the worst, you simply will not be able to get any of your "approximately right" planes into the intended space to carry out the work.
I was quite interested in Bjenk's translation of Roubo, where he indicates that one could free-hand mouldings, but it really is better to design them geometrically (swinging arcs). In part, my interest arises from having read the following text from Peter Nicholson's _Practical Carpentry, Joinery, and Cabinet-Making_:
"But architects, most esteemed for their good taste, never draw the forms of mouldings by these mechanical methods; they always make them of the most beautiful figures they can by the hand; and, like the ancient Greek architects, they avoid circles for mouldings, in consequence of their want of variety, both of outline and of light and shade. Hence, though we give the usual mechanical methods, they are not here recommended to be used in practice."
Well, I guess this is Nicholson paying lip-service to the supposed hierarchy of the fine vs. decorative arts. But it is a complete and utter pose. As he indicates in the text, itself, his own illustrations of various mouldings are all done geometrically. And I don't believe this is only for the sake of convenience, as he seems to imply. He knew, as do we (and Roubo), that the profiles of the soles/irons of the H&R's that the workmen would be using to stick any of these mouldings are all portions of arcs. Quite simply, the most efficient and direct way to design and stick these mouldings with H&R's is to base them on true arcs.
Yes, there is the question of Greek mouldings, as Bill H. brought up earlier, which appear to have been based on sections of ellipses. If one insists on mouldings to be truly elliptically based, then, probably, the best bet would be to use a dedicated/complex moulding plane of the correct profile and size. Or, possibly, to approximate the shape with H&R's, then finish up with an appropriately shaped scratch stock or sanding block. Not as direct or efficient, though.
On the other hand, approximations in the form of ovoid figures can be done fairly directly using H&R's. In other words, a four-center ovoid form (i.e. a curved form consisting of combined longer/slower arcs and shorter/quicker arcs) can be used, and the ovoid moulding executed with two different sized hollows or rounds. Takes a bit of layout skill, but it can be done.
Another thing often done is to design ogees or cove/ovolos using only 60 degree arcs, such as Bjenk has done. Since these aren't "square" in feel, they can seem to simulate elliptical curves. In fact, I've seen examples of such mouldings completely misidentified by writers as being elliptically based.
In my upcoming DVD, focusing on complex sprung cornice mouldings, I follow a method which I believe to be period based. My reason for mentioning it, here, is that the only way that method will work is to have the entire moulding completely and accurately designed before any tool touches the wood. And the curves of that moulding, based on a period drawing, are all true arcs (including one ovoid curve). I had a blast doing that shoot.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR
