Re: Jointer/Planer
ThomD
>I have tried quite a few different combinations and there really isn't any satisfactory replacement for a really big space with some really big machines in it, which I have never had. Currently I have an 8" jointer and a 16" planer. I also have an Inca 10.625 over under. Everything you can get will have some limits to it, and they fall into format issues and individual machine characteristics.
For instance the idea of a smaller jointer and a larger planer, comes from a culture that assembles smaller boards into larger pieces, may not believe in actually planing flat those boards before or after assemly. The word "Jointer" vs. the UK version "Planer", shows the edge jointing orientation of the machines. The guards are normally only safe for edge jointing. Etc... Over under planers are better for solid wood use, but the examples in shops do not have sufficient capacity. There are 24" version of these, and the fact some upper end dealers sold 10 inche ones may falsely suggest these machines are large enough for everyday use. They were large enough for Krenov, because he was willing to work small. Those machines like the inca came into showrooms at Lee Valley, and Garrett Wade, in the wake of Krenov's books. I remember looking at those books and doing the calculations. In the late 70s we didn't even have the Ryobi, so these were the low cost option, but they didn't really cut it unless you were willing to work to the scale.
Ultimately this is all part of the larger struggle of whether one does woodwork for a hobbie or for production. If people come up to you and ask why you can't make a new door, then you need some production tooling. But if you just do it for fun you can get by with all sorts of smaller gear. A lot of standard household stuff is in 16", 24", and 32" widths.
By the way, there is a way of using the smaller american machines to joint wide boards. You set the machine to rebate one edge of the boards, and just hog away a relief. With that material missing, you joint one face from the other side. Then you run the board through your planer using the narrowed, jointed, face as the index. Then you flip it and plane the other face flush removing the rebate. Can work quite well.