Not inconsistent using different adhesives
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I believe that the available adhesives have properties that are better and worse for a given application. My glue shelf has yellow, white, cyanoacrylate, epoxy, JB Weld, E6000, liquid hide and now hot hide. I am willing to use the best adhesive for the application at hand. And I make note of what professionals are using, and why, to guide my usage.
I saw first hand the ease of sticking down a wrinkled sheet of crotch mahogany with white glue as compared the the aggravation and eventual failure to stick the matching sheet down with hot hide. The white glue approach I can repeat with 100% chance of success when I need to and the process took a half day to learn. Having seen 2 highly skilled professionals struggle with hammer veneering I concluded that this was a skill I had no interest in pursuing. I have enough other obstacles in my path to making stuff. If one path is assured and easy to learn I will not avoid it just because it wasn't done 200 years ago.
You all need to appreciate that some of us are at the beginning of learning to design and build fine furniture. I have the choice of do I learn to hammer veneer and cut tenons with a hand saw before I can make something that looks good, holds together and will be useful in the home? Or do I get the veneer stuck and the tenons assembled by an approach that was not used 200 years ago, that is easier to learn, and more assured of success? The end result looks the same and I believe equally functional. If the goal is furniture in the home, or product out the door, the choice is clear.
I have stopped being amazed that someone would spend their time learning to perfectly plane a board. Others should not be amazed that people will use a mix of new and old technology that is best for them to get something made.
As an example of my pragmatic approach to making stuff I once cut sliding dovetails with a router. I even designed a slick jig that resulted in a good fit. In the Headley shop I was shown a hand tool approach that was so fast and assured that I used it on my project with speed and success. I will use it in the future. It requires a big chisel, which is why I am looking for one.




