Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

gouges for tenons and mortises?

Posts

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#26

Not inconsistent using different adhesives

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I believe that the available adhesives have properties that are better and worse for a given application. My glue shelf has yellow, white, cyanoacrylate, epoxy, JB Weld, E6000, liquid hide and now hot hide. I am willing to use the best adhesive for the application at hand. And I make note of what professionals are using, and why, to guide my usage.

I saw first hand the ease of sticking down a wrinkled sheet of crotch mahogany with white glue as compared the the aggravation and eventual failure to stick the matching sheet down with hot hide. The white glue approach I can repeat with 100% chance of success when I need to and the process took a half day to learn. Having seen 2 highly skilled professionals struggle with hammer veneering I concluded that this was a skill I had no interest in pursuing. I have enough other obstacles in my path to making stuff. If one path is assured and easy to learn I will not avoid it just because it wasn't done 200 years ago.

You all need to appreciate that some of us are at the beginning of learning to design and build fine furniture. I have the choice of do I learn to hammer veneer and cut tenons with a hand saw before I can make something that looks good, holds together and will be useful in the home? Or do I get the veneer stuck and the tenons assembled by an approach that was not used 200 years ago, that is easier to learn, and more assured of success? The end result looks the same and I believe equally functional. If the goal is furniture in the home, or product out the door, the choice is clear.

I have stopped being amazed that someone would spend their time learning to perfectly plane a board. Others should not be amazed that people will use a mix of new and old technology that is best for them to get something made.

As an example of my pragmatic approach to making stuff I once cut sliding dovetails with a router. I even designed a slick jig that resulted in a good fit. In the Headley shop I was shown a hand tool approach that was so fast and assured that I used it on my project with speed and success. I will use it in the future. It requires a big chisel, which is why I am looking for one.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#27

Warren's point

Adam Cherubini

>I think Warren's point is that hot hide glue is a skill that must be learned. It's not something you mix up apply and done. It takes some experimenting and practice, but it's worth it. You have an analytical mind. I think if you are patient, you'll find you prefer hot hide glue. It really is quite advantageous to work with.

As to veneering, did you ask Rob Millard for help? If you are interested in "the other side of the story" email Rob, tell him I said hello, and ask him about what you saw.

Adam

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#28

glues

paul womack

>You are correct that smooth surfaces are better for adhesion.

Oh yes - the science is unambiguous on that. The old wives tale of roughing a surface to key the glue got exploded a long time back. It didn't really survive proper testing and microscopes. I've always found it surprising how long the myth survived - you'd have thought one of the "old guys" would have noticed!

If you want to see some guys really worrying over joint strength with hide glue, check out the trad bowyers making laminated bows - and I assure you their surfaces are planed, and freshly planed (to avoid oxidation) at that.

However, history says that M&T joints work "well enough" at sub-optimal glue strength, so one can get by with a lesser fit quality.

BugBear

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#29

Glue starved...

James Watriss

>I think it depends on the adhesive being used.

PVA clearly benefits from a smooth surface, but I have yet to read anything that really explains why it bonds so much better than the wood tannins. But it clearly does... and I've glued edge joints off the power jointer that also hold perfectly well, without needing to be perfectly smooth.

But on other glues, I think a rough surface is a virtue. It seems that a mechanical bond, rather than a chemical one, is the goal for some glues. I've helped friends glue up maple benches using Uni-bond (urea formaldehyde) and we clamped holy hell out of that bench. Well, it seems we squeezed out too much glue, because the joints didn't all hold. Maple's not so porous, so there's less for the glue to hold on to, and if squeezing too much glue out results in a weaker joint, then it would seem that it's not actually bonding the wood... it's bonding TO the wood, ie, the glue seeps in to whatever texture or crevices are there, and hardens, and then does the same with the other piece of wood. So the strength of the joint is reliant on the strength of the glue. And it seems that similar things hold true with epoxy, though I don't have any personal anecdotes to share... just the advice of my teachers.

I was in a class with Brian Boggs, who was complaining about a then recent magazine review, that said hide glue wasn't very strong. He took issue with that, saying they weren't using it properly. He said he'd done butt joints with hide glue that were incredibly strong, but that it was important to coat the end grain surface first, and let the glue seep in for a bit before reactivating it with more warm hide glue, and then clamping the joint. And the end grain joint to face grain was just as strong as a PVA joint, face grain to face grain... and he showed this to us in class. Break off the butt joint, and some of the face grain tears out. I was intrigued.

So my guess is that the hide glue joint IS a mechanical joint, and that the strength of the glue is what holds the joint together. So a rougher surface might have some virtue in this case. That's speculation on my part though.

Bill, I agree with you on hammer veneering. I didn't particularly enjoy learning it, and I had an easier time with PVA. Well, mostly. The reversability of hide glue did win me over. Yes, I use PVA most of the time.

But hide glue is on my short list of things to use more often, because I think the benefits outweigh the problems. I've had some really hairy glue ups where the assembly was either too large to align in time, or too complicated to get everything in place in time... and I almost always had to break something to pull it away and fix it.

I've also had an inlayed fan medallion come partially undone. In the middle, there are a few lifted edges, and I used PVA. They lifted when I was finishing, so my guess is that the alcohol in the shellac caused some of the PVA to break down, and so there are a few weird spots that I still haven't figured out how to fix without replacing the whole thing. Had I used hide glue, I could have simply ironed them back down again, and continued on with finishing.

It's clear that hide glue has a learning curve to it, and that seems like a strange thing to say about something that's supposed to be as simple as an adhesive. So I completely understand where you're coming from. But I think the benefits make it worthwhile to learn.


img