Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

gouges for tenons and mortises?

Posts

gouges for tenons and mortises?

#1

gouges for tenons and mortises?

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi everyone,

I was having a discussion with someone on another forum who was telling me that one can use shallow gouges to clean up mortises and tenons. I was quite surprised that anyone would use a less-than-flat tool to clean up a surface that will be glued. I was wondering if this might be a (forgotten) practice that I've just never heard about. Has anyone done this or heard of this before? I'm still having trouble believing it would work well, but what do i know...

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#2

Darrell in Oakville

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

Darrell in Oakville

>Frank,

Are they indicating what sweep the gouge is? I have a broad but very shallow gouge (I think it's 1 1/2 inches wide with a #3 sweep) that does a fantastic job trimming protruding end grain.

Maybe I should give this a try on joinery...

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#3

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Frank,

Not quite, however I have chopped mortises with a twibil and the hatchet end had a severe camber (flat sweep) on the end, double beveled at a very low angle.

The chisel end is for end-grain and the hatchet end is for the inside cheeks of the mortise. The sweep helps get the sides (with the grain) nice and flat. Every chop is on the skew.

Stephen

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#4

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used a chisel for trimming tenons since before I owned any gouges, but I think this is not a bad idea. The advantage is that the corners do not dig in so it is a little cleaner cutting cross grain. It would be similar to using a camber on a smoothing plane.

Now that I am used to working with gouges, I think I would prefer a gouge to a rasp or plane or router. A wide shallow gouge is handy, but I don't think one need buy one and learn to use it just for this operation.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#5

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Frank, I am certain that you are not even supposed to clean up tenons. Roubo says so himself: tenons must retain the sawed surface as it makes them adhere better in the mortise. Touching up a tenon is a byproduct of sawing it too thick for the mortise or having chopped the mortise too narrow.

The only thing that comes close as far as mortises are concerned are cranked neck chisels I believe.

Not sure if that's what you meant.

How are you by the way?

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#6

Folklore that makes no sense

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I bristle at statements such as this one from Roubo because it needlessly risks dissuading many woodworkers from using hand tools to make and fit joints.If I had to wait to build some useful furniture until I could perfectly saw dovetails and M&T joints my house would be empty of furniture and I would be seeking another hobby.

The bond between two perfectly smooth planed surfaces joined with any currently used woodworking adhesive is stronger than the wood. How can it be that a sawed surface would provide even better joint strength?

Wood is sufficiently porous that any useful wood adhesive will penetrate these pores and provide mechanical as well as adhesive strength to the joint. It is a moot point which is more important because adhesives that "wet" the wood surface (essential for adhesive bonding) will also wet and penetrate the pores, according to experts in the wood adhesive field. .

The difference between a perfect fitting tenon and one that is too loose or too tight for optimum gluing is less than 0.005". It might be a goal for some to saw mortises and dovetails to this precision and require no additional fitting. But most of us don't do these operations daily and hence never hope to gain the experience to reliably do it on a furniture project. I purposely oversize tenons and fit with a shoulder plane where I can remove thin shaving until the joint is perfect. Perfect fitting is vastly more important to joint strength and ease of assembly than whatever means resulted in the perfect fit. And a gouge would be the last tool in the shop I would use to fit a tenon. It seems the equivalent to suggesting a scrub plane for edge jointing.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#7

Re: Folklore that makes no sense

Adam Cherubini

>I think the folklore is right here, Bill. I think the sawn tenon is like a series of hill and valleys. When inserted into the mortise, the hills compress easily resulting in a decent fit with no slop. The valleys provide a space for the hide glue to hide (sorry for that). Hide glue will extrude out of tighter joints. And the requirement of a smooth, perfect fitting joint (I.e. a joint that PVA will work in) is really much stricter than is needed and by no means advantageous.

So I think the folklore is right, just not for the reasons we and possibly the originators believed. You are correct that smooth surfaces are better for adhesion. But this case really is different. In my industry, we use an open weave fabric or scrim to maintain a bondline to keep the glue in the joint. I think the roughened surface of a sawn tenon is the same.

Adam

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#8

Re: Folklore that makes no sense

Joel

>Butt joints which are commonly used for holding boards together are planed and consequently dead smooth. They hold fine and the joint if done right is invisible.

I was taught to pare to scribe lines on the mortise mostly because it's faster than chopping to a scribe line but also for through mortises you want really smooth joint side.

On the tenon we would aim for straight from the saw - and a rip saw cuts very smooth - but if accidentally cut fat a shoulder plane was the cure.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#9

Butt joints

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Joel, I always think of butt joints as involving end grain, and certainly not candidates for rubbed gluing (vs smoothing long grain edges and rubbing).

Pam

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#10

Stanley

paul womack

>Don't know about cleaning up, but IIRC Don McConnell wrote an article on using gouge for roughing out tenons, especially large ones e.g. bread board ends.

BugBear

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#11

Re: Butt joints

Joel

>We always called them butt joints but just to be clear I mean edge joints where long grain is glued to long grain - used to make a wider board.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#12

still makes no sense, a fitting discussion follows

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am failing to understand why a rough surface is going to glue better than a smooth surface under any circumstances. The argument that the smooth surface will be glue starved may be true if the joint is too tight. (see below) The opposite argument is that the roughened surface will only be optimally bonded in places.

As far as the potential for PVA glue to result in a different case than hide glue, data in the literature shows that PVA glue makes stronger M&T joints, and especially so with M&T joints cut too loose.

Of course the practical side of all this is that the M&T joint is so strong that failure is unlikely even with a less than perfect fit, so long as the glue maintains its properties. I suspect the best argument for a sawed joint is speed and the rest is the rationalization.

In the class I recently took in the Mack Headley and Sons cabinet shop (Class name is "Woodworking Shops of the Shenandoah Valley") I learned an important lesson in fitting. (Every one that has not had a joint set up prematurely upon assemble raise your hand). This shop uses white glue, as does College of the Redwoods. The shop does a lot of veneering and the white glue does not stain like yellow glue (we were told). To lessen inventory they use white glue for everything. ( and I could make a compelling case for why white glue is vastly better than hide for veneering should anyone care to listen.) Anyway, everything is dry fitted before glue application. For the dry fit they wanted to be able to tap the joint together with the palm of the hand. Using this criteria for acceptable fit, I had no trouble assembling dovetail, long sliding dovetail, and M&T joints after glue application. I was particularly terrified of the 10" full sliding dovetail, but it went together effortlessly. This shop assembles hundreds of joints in a year, so this criteria has been thoroughly tested in practice. In the future, if the joint is not sawed perfect it will be pared till it meets the criteria.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#13

Re: still makes no sense, a fitting discussion fol

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Well, in 1768, Paris' boutiques already had more than one hundred years of testing and practice with these joints. Adam's explanation is how I would also describe the working of the sawed surface and glue.

However, I do agree that it might not be that important today with engineered modern glues. The glues we use these days is fantastic and once glued, I doubt a tenon would fail any time soon.

To me, it is more a principle of simple and efficient work. Why should it be such a problem to learn how to cut straight? Its the basis of our craft! I consider myself a beginner and I already can saw my tenons straight. I think this should be the goal: to be able to saw them straight and make them fit with the less amount of fiddling. Tenons are like dovetails: you practice to saw them straight.

The learning process certainly involves paring a tenon to size after the cut. I still do it when I am not doing it right(it's better than throwing the piece!) However, I would not plan and setup my tools in order to develop and nourish the habit of correcting tenons. Buying tools to correct tenons is doing that. A chisel should suffice to correct an off cut.

Does that make any sense?

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#14

Bill, you said...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>' ( and I could make a compelling case for why white glue is vastly better than hide for veneering should anyone care to listen.)'

I for one would like to listen to this!

Stephen

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#15

Just goes to show you Bill....

John in NM

>Woodworking authors never change either!

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#16

Re: still makes no sense, a fitting discussion fol

Adam Cherubini

>All I'm saying is that 200 years ago, a roughened surface resulted in a better bond than a tight joint with smooth surfaces. That's where the "folklore" came from. They were right about their glue and their conditions. I've seen this in my own shop. It's easy to push hide glue out of a tight joint.

Adam

P.S. I was talking to a museum conservator a few weeks ago about PVA glue. They hate it. They say it lasts about 20 years and then is next to impossible to repair. Last time I was in the conservation lab they were working on this veneered plywood speaker cabinet from the 50's or 60's. It was a nightmare. Just imagine trying to release a PVA joint non-mechanically or re-gluing a PVA'ed veneer. I suspect that the real reason 18th c furniture still survives is because it was so easy to repair.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#17

Difficult to do with hide glue

Adam Cherubini

>I find long joints difficult to do with hide glue. I've had better success with watery glue on a warm day. Shorter joints have come out okay. But you really can't "pull up' a long joint with clamps. Once the glue gels, you've had it. Or at least, that's my experience.

Adam

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#18

Re: Difficult to do with hide glue

Joel

>I don't have much personal experience with hide glue but FWIW I can tell you that Charles Hayward wrote that it was typical to stick furniture parts that needed to be glued in the stove so they would be really hot and the glue would stay liquid longer. He also mentioned that sometimes the furniture pieces would char.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#19

Re: still makes no sense, a fitting discussion fol

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Bill, it seems like only yesterday you were asking how to mix up hide glue. And now overnight you are ready to debate its merits relative to white glue?

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#20

"We" being?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#21

Re: "We" being?

Joel

>We being the people in my classes, the people who taught me, and most people I know. MAybe it's a regionalism. Sorry if it was confusing.

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#22

Re: "We" being?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think a problem may be that the joints are completely different and behave completely differently; but I'm not trying to override the experts, instead I'd like to end some potential confusion.

Pam

Re: gouges for tenons and mortises?

#23

Re: still makes no sense, a fitting discussion fol

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>All I'm saying is that 200 years ago, a roughened surface resulted in a better bond than a tight joint with smooth surfaces. That's where the "folklore" came from. They were right about their glue and their conditions. I've seen this in my own shop. It's easy to push hide glue out of a tight joint.


Not saying that you're wrong here, but the "folklore" part irks me. Unless there is a scientific study that can demonstrate that a rough surface results in a better bond, I'll remain skeptical.

I liked FWW glue test they did about a year ago. Unfortunately they didn't test for rough vs. smooth surfaces, I would have liked to see that. And the result might very well be glue-dependent, as hide glue did best with porous woods, therefore suggesting the "folklore" has a basis to it. But then I'm a numbers man... :-)

DC

I'd also like to hear Bill's rationale for white glue being best for veneering...