Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

Posts

US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#1

US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

David

>Recently I started increasing my "collection" of Stanley bench and block planes via Ebay and Craig's list. I've noticed that planes made in England and Australia tend to go for less than their American-made equivalents. Would anyone know if this a collectibility issue or because the English planes tend to be heavier?

FWIW, I'm not a tool collector other than firmly believing that: 1) more tools are always better, and; 2) one should always use the right tool for the job (see #1). I short, like to buy and use good tools.

Thanks!

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#2

Stanley

paul womack

>English (Stanley) tools tend to be NEWER, so they're from the later cost cutting era.

It's an age thing more than a country of origin thing.

BugBear

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#3

Thank you, NM

David

>

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#4

As far as I know...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The English made planes are lighter than the US ones. As stated the quality of the English ones are below that of US ones because they were made at a later date.

Also just so you know Stanley made planes in Canada too.

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#5

Not to stereotype, though

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have an English No. 78 that's a perfectly fine tool, including a very thick cutting iron.

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#6

Good for you Bill! Unfortunelly I have a

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>English No. 5 that's best suited as a door stop. I have a feeling a maroon or ol' blue US made one would out preform it.

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#7

Stanley

paul womack

>I should probably add that Stanley made planes in the UK for rather a long time, and I don't suppose anyone will be surprised to hear that (in general) the older ones are better.

BugBear

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#8

Quality building vs. quality control

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My impression from limited examples of later Stanley and Record stuff is that it often suffers from both low-quality engineering (as in, the engineering decision to build something while spending as little money as possible on it, and always choosing the cheaper solution rather than the better-quality one) and poor quality control. The former will lead to all tools being garbage; the latter to unpredictability of quality. Stanley and Record may have decided that high quality hand tools could not sell (possibly quite correctly - got to remember that they're in business to make a living), and so skimped on both kinds of quality, but they did make the occasional mistake and let a good piece through.

My No. 5 jack is a later plane (not sure of exact vintage, but post-WWII), and it's also quite a decent tool.

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#9

Well stated Bill, I agree complety.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

#10

Re: US vs English/Australian made Stanley planes

David

>Didn't mean to start anything, sorry. I thought I had read that Stanley's British made planes were heavier but think it was that the H designation on American made planes, e.g., 4H, was a heavier plane designed to appeal to the British infill plane using market.

FWIW I have no complaints with my Record #7 (the only Brit plane I own)