It's just a chisel.
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Jim
That is a beautiful chisel. Really is. Moderately expensive. But just a chisel and replacable if necessary.
Grind it back and use it. You will lose about 1/4" at most, probably less.
I agree with Pam. If you have been using it for 8 months it is unlikely that the fault lies with the steel. It sounds more like you struck an unpenetrable force, and something had to give. Sadly.
This situation is one common amongst woodworkers in Australia. Chopping mortices and dovetails in a hard eucalypt tests steel to a high level. I was saying to Wiley a little while ago that I would love a chisel that I could both use to pare and also hit with a hammer. I have sold all my vintage Witherbys and Stanleys. The only chisels that hold an edge for me are my Iyoroi bench chisels and slicks, Matsumura and Koyamaichi dovetail chisels. My Blue Spruce, as great as they are for fine work, are not often too delicate - the dang timber here can be brutal. And that is why we have HSS plane blades and now D2 chisels on sale locally.
Your mortice chisel is a tool, a beautiful and joyful tool, but just a tool. Grind it back, hone it, and put it back to work.
Regards from Perth
Derek