Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

Posts

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#26

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Every One...

I feel a bit better....well not yet. I will see about getting it fixed and see what the results are.

Pam, yes, I have used it for about 8 months, honing the edge as I go, I really think the burl had an inclusion perhaps, it was such a shock.

I have thought about mailing it back to Imai if possible as well, it is such an amazing chisel....now I am more respectful.

Take it easy,

Jim

Thanks again every one for the great discussion

Brent...not a chance!!

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#27

European chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I don't think it is quite right to take a Japanese chisel, omit the top ring and the hollow back and call it a European style paring chisel. It still has all the heaviness (maybe more) and clumsiness of a socket chisel. European parers have a delicate neck, small bolster and a thin tang. It would be nice to have them with laid steel.

I once saw a video of a Williamsburg blacksmith making a chisel with forge welded steel and forge welded bolster. I think it took about 20 minutes.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#28

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Since you've used it quite a bit, most likely it isn't a flaw (as in some sort of forged inclusion) or a work hardening issue; but it is a matter of choosing your target. Therefore, I wouldn't send it back to Imai, what would he say or do? After all, there are some wood formations that no chisel will handle without bending or cracking, it's important to choose your target. (:

Pam

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#29

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Pam....

Yes I learnt something and you have highlighted something I did not know.

If I sent it back to Imai it would be for repair at my expense, not a warranty issue,

I agree, special cases require some careful thought.

Take it easy,

Jim

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#30

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

Brent in Montreal

>Then You're just going to have to live with them yourself Jim LOL. I just finished doing some DTs in a jewelerie box with my Imais.... they are sweet!!! Post a pic once you get that chip ironed out.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#31

Re: European chisels

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>Hi Warren and everybody,

You make a good point about the problems in making 'hybrid' products. The pure article--whether western or Japanese--evolved over a long time and got the way it got for good reason.

Just for the sake of clarity....the chisel Manny linked to is not a Japanese pattern without hollow and hoop. It is the Japanese maker's vision of what a western paring chisel looks like. Perhaps he has made a clean miss, but he is trying to show a western paring chisel. None of the Japanese patterns--there are various ones, as shown in the link--have that big slab of steel for the blade section. They do all have the heavy square tang shown in Wilbur's link, and the tapered ferrule which surrounds the tang's insertion into the wood.

Warren's point remains correct.

Wiley

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#32

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

ThomD

>That's nothing. My biggest loss was when some apes my parents had hired to take out an oil furnace and tank, used my Ouchii tourist grade chisel as a cold chisels. Actually it did fairly well all things considered but it sickened me. Back then I was a student and what those chisels cost was like a week's pay each. That chisel isn't even seriously bruised. I once saw a whole slew of mortise chisels that LV had returned by various thugs that had all been snapped separating the laminaie.

Yours doesn't really look like a mortising chisel though, though an an accute angle like that is quite useful, I have some bench chisels ground that way for dovetails, and some chisels for timber framing also similar. Heck all chisels are used for mortising cuts of a sort. Shallow angles have some geometric implications for mortises, it might be just the ticket for some stuff, but with less shear angle it puts the temptation on prying...

There is this old stuff about the pride of the short chisel, but they didn't mean short as a result of abuse or failures in materials or workmanship. That kind of stubby in the box is not a source of pride and can make of a set, an ugly reminder. But other than that kind of scar is certainly perfectly useable as a tool.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#33

It's just a chisel.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Jim

That is a beautiful chisel. Really is. Moderately expensive. But just a chisel and replacable if necessary.

Grind it back and use it. You will lose about 1/4" at most, probably less.

I agree with Pam. If you have been using it for 8 months it is unlikely that the fault lies with the steel. It sounds more like you struck an unpenetrable force, and something had to give. Sadly.

This situation is one common amongst woodworkers in Australia. Chopping mortices and dovetails in a hard eucalypt tests steel to a high level. I was saying to Wiley a little while ago that I would love a chisel that I could both use to pare and also hit with a hammer. I have sold all my vintage Witherbys and Stanleys. The only chisels that hold an edge for me are my Iyoroi bench chisels and slicks, Matsumura and Koyamaichi dovetail chisels. My Blue Spruce, as great as they are for fine work, are not often too delicate - the dang timber here can be brutal. And that is why we have HSS plane blades and now D2 chisels on sale locally.

Your mortice chisel is a tool, a beautiful and joyful tool, but just a tool. Grind it back, hone it, and put it back to work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#34

Re: It's just a chisel.

charlie belden

>Derek wrote

Your mortice chisel is a tool, a beautiful and joyful tool, but just a tool. Grind it back,

hone it, and put it back to work.

========================

You did notice the slight hollow in the bottom,

behind the flat back of the bevel right? And

if this is a "laminated" chisel, which it appears

to be, the hard steel is only for the end of the

chisel - not all the way back down it.

So, the back needs to get flattened some

before the bevel can be restored. How much

"hard steel" will be left - I have no idea.

That's been my concern with japanese chisels

- though they do take and hold a nice edge.

charlie belden

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#35

Re: It's just a chisel.

ThomD

>"steel is only for the end of the

chisel - not all the way back down it."

Not quite sure what you mean by this, the whole of the base of the chisel is hard, the whole area with the hollow and the area surounding it are hard. The chip in question is pretty minimal, and the average low mileage user, if he didn't cause more chips might never reach the hollow from the regrind position in any case.

"So, the back needs to get flattened some

before the bevel can be restored. How much

hard steel" will be left - I have no idea."

No problem, one can use virtually the whole length of the chisel of which only a few percent have been dubbed. It is possible to tap out chisels even if it isn't normally done. That would drop in more steel without reducing the hollow. I've done it on expensive chisels and it seemed pretty easy.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#36

Re: It's just a chisel.

wilbur

>Here are two examples as to how far back you can sharpen a Japanese chisel.

Yes, both of those chisels are still in use.


img

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#37

Re: It's just a chisel.

ThomD

>Pictures like that seem to show up on ebay regularly! :)

I do wonder how they hold the hollow in place. I have some higher mileage chisels and I lost the hollow on one of them. I think to keep it all the way back like the right one would require tapping out.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#38

Wow!

Paul M.

>I think the user got their money's worth out of the one on the left. I've seen stubby chisels before, but nothing like that one!

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#39

Re: Wow/Thanks

ThomD

>Yeah, I wonder what good it really was. Imagine chopping a dovetail with that little support or with the fats bit impeding penetration.

By the way, I thank Jim for posting this thread. A younger me, and possibly the current me, would not be airing the dirty laundry.

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#40

Man Wilbur!

John in NM

>I bet your car's got half a million miles on it too! ;)

Re: ShazBut &%$@#@$$#!

#41

Re: Man Wilbur!

wilbur

>I can't take credit for those chisels. It's a picture of the toolbox of a Japanese woodworker who was giving a demonstration out in the Bay area. You can tell those chisels aren't mine because the box is too well constructed. :@)

I did get 180,000 miles on a Geo Prizm before selling it, and then I heard that it got sold to another person, so it must have been in really good shape.