We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am sorry to see the injury. I would have needed a long walk afterward.
Recall the discussion a few weeks ago where I professed the importance of toughness in a mortise chisel steel. Some dismissed the importance of this attribute. A better balance of toughness and hardness would have prevented this break.
>I know that sinking feeling, although in my case it happened with a $50 DT chisel from LV...
By the looks of it the chisel can be saved without problem, there's enough steel left in front of the hollow. And since you'll have to lap the back, you'll gain even more wiggle space.
Might be a good idea to increase the bevel angle while you're at it.
What angle did you have on that chisel? I think my vanilla Imai mortise chisel is at 35 degrees, but I'll have to check when I get home.
It's no problem to fix that chip -- it's just a lot of grinding on the bevel side. If you find that you are getting too close to the hollow, work on the flat side to "move" the hollow back.
I happen to have a Tormek, and I've used it to deat with chips and changing the bevel angle on used Japanese chisels. Because of the waterwheel, I don't really need to worry about overheating the tool with grinding, so if you have one handy, you can use that to do the grinding, unless you want the upper body workout. I would be careful about using a dry wheel grinder on it.
If you don't have a Tormek, and your arms get tired, I'd be happy to fix it for you, as long as you don't mind me giving it a test workout. For a while. I'll send it back eventually, I promise. :@)
>ShazBut &%$@#@$$#! is putting it mildly. Sorry Jim, that chisel is now worthless. Just send it on to me and I'll dispose of it for you. While you're at it you may as well send the rest of the set....looking at the 1/8" empty spot on the rack will only cause you more grief.........
Naw, as mentioned above, you still have plenty of meat there without even worrying about the hollow.
>As others have said... It's very sad to see but easily fixable.
For bevel-edge chisels, it's recommended to "tap out" the edge on a break like this to collapse some of the steel down into the Ura (hollow). But I don't think that could possibly work on a thick mortise chisel like this one. That would only work on a thin paring chisel.
Looking at the lamination line on the 2nd photo shows that this has a very thick steel layer so it looks like it was intended to lap the back if sharpening reduces the length at all to move the start of the ura up towards the handle. I would sharpen to a steeper bevel (since you have learned the painful way already that the current bevel is too shallow). I would leave the corner at the top of the chisel (the opposite face from the back whatever that is called) where it is, and grind a steeper bevel from that point that removes the chip. You shouldn't need more than a little touch up on the back itself as you will not get into the hollow.
That's one of those heart-stoppers that, once you walk away and come back later, turns out it's not so bad. If there was going to be an overhard place on the chisel, it would be out there on the edge. So maybe the RC65 part is gone, and now you're going to work your way back into the RC63.5 part of the chisel.
I agree with the others that you likely won't need to tap out. Because you'll just barely get to the hollow. However, tapping out is still a pretty good idea, so you won't end up with fat corners on the back. If you want to do it, just say so, and I can vector you in (as could others here). If you were going to, I would say get a lump of lead for an anvil to get real solid dead bedding, even up into the hollow. Clamp the chisel down onto that, and use a nail set to deliver hammer taps into the middle of the soft backing. It is utterly important that the hammer taps feel dead--absolutely dead--if there is any ping sound or rebound, that's bad and will crack the hagane. Which would be like playing an infield roller into an inside the park home run (of badness).
But for right now, all you need to do is grind the chisel back. Do you have a Tormek? If not, you could take Wilbur up on his offer. However, grinding back by hand won't take too long, because that soft backing will offer no resistance. Use 100g stone or 80 grit abrasive paper, or 220g diamond. I mention diamond last, and reluctantly, because although diamond stones are great for most metal removal, a coarse one will tear that super-hard steel to pieces at the edge, and you'll have to take off another 1/64" with regular stones just to get past the ragging from the diamond.
Beautiful chisel! It'll be sounder than before when you're done.
>I disagree. On a softer chisel, the blade still eventually gets really mangled. Instead of chipping, you have to grind back the edge, and then re-bevel. You still lose the steel, it just feels less catastrophic at the time.
I really don't think this is a hardness/toughness issue either... or not strictly. It's a bevel angle issue. Even a soft steel can be made to snap if it's thinned out enough. I think this chisel was not ground to the right angle for something as hard as a burl. Can it cut once or twice? Sure. But it'll slowly start to chip. (small chips... visible as twinkles at first) Once those small chips are there, they become stress risers very quickly, leading to bigger chips, like this one.
I've had similar experiences using japanese chisels in oak. It started out looking like any of the softer chisels I was used to, like any other chisel. But these chisels are harder, and rather than bend, they fracture, even at a microscopic level. After a while, small chips you can't see at all become little twinkles along the edge. And then those turn bad. The key is to stop at little twinkles and try a steeper bevel. What I ended up doing is stropping a LOT. After almost every mallet tap. Pretty quickly the soft strop started to dub the edge, and the effective cutting angle at that edge became a lot higher. At some point along the way, things leveled out and I didn't have to strop so often.
It's not the end of the world. You can't even see the end from here. Jim, deep breath, it's ok. Live, learn, try again.
This is an opportunity to learn what the chisel wants in order to be able to mortise through really hard stuff like burls. The right bevel angle on those chisels will be able to cut all day long, and then you'll know why you paid the premium for harder steel. The wrong angle will either be too fragile (not necessarily brittle), or it'll take too much effort to cut. Mortise chisels spend their useful lives playing the part of a nail, with side work prying out chips. The right bevel will work all day long. Too thin, and the chisel will let you know. And sometimes different woods call for steeper bevels. White oak, Ipe, and burls... those are really strong, and they need a strong bevel to cut them. I've met some people who keep a separate set of chisels for working with ugly woods. It's easier for them to have one set that's ground to a much higher angle, than to keep regrinding the same set back and forth, depending on what they're working with.
Like any other good, productive relationship, it takes a while to get to know your tools. And once in a while you'll do something... on purpose, or not, and there will be a disagreement. And it'll take some time and effort to patch things up... but in the end, you'll learn something new. Maybe it's bevel angles on chisels or plane blades. Maybe it's mouth opening on a plane. Or a certain grind shape on a carving tool. Or a new way to use your bench fixtures or clamps. Maybe your sharpening will be ok for a while, and something will click, and suddenly you're planing reflective surfaces on things.
All of this takes time. All of it takes heart. (sometimes it takes a lot of heart... like when your mortise chisel breaks) But it's worth it. Once in a while you get reminded of just how far you've come, and it's all worth it in the end. For me, it was moving out of my first shop, and finding old forgotten tools and small projects... small bits of wood that I was scrounging for when I first started out. And a lot of "wow... I've come a long way."
>I dunno James, I just whack the living daylights out of my Sorbys with the plastic handle and the worse thing that ever happens to me is that I need a quick touchup about every third mortise or so (all the usual suspects as far as hardwoods are concerned).
I can live with that.
I'm a lazy SOB, I hone the entire bevel. The Sorbs haven't seen a grinder since they left the factory. I've never chipped an edge, only dulled them.
>Now I have a question, would it be possible to remove the entire hollow from the underside of one of these chisels to convert into a laminated Western blade?
Serious question, would there be enough steel left?
>Definately salvageable. For starters, regrind the primary bevel. You can keep the same bevel angle, or go somewhat steeper (that will make it harder to pound the chisel in, but less material to remove).
In either case, you might want to consider a steeper secondary bevel right at the tip. The manual for my English-style mortising chisels suggested an angle of around 35 degrees. Your steel may be different, but in general the steeper bevel right at the tip will reduce any tendency to chip or break.
>I don't think there would be enough steel left. Why the question, if I may ask? The hollow is there to ease the honing of the back, removing it would make honing a lot longer endeavour...
The hard steel layer is thick enough to have the entire hollow ground out and still be intact. The hollow is not as deep as it seems. It appears to be pretty deep because of the contrasting appearance between the hollow and the surrounding metal, but the depth of the hollow is usually on the order of 1/32" or less. Such a project would take a really long time, though.
But as Denis said, why would you want to do such a thing to a perfectly good Japanese chisel? You should spend that time grinding a hollow into the flat side of your Witherbys instead. :@)
>It is impossible to buy new made laid steel chisel blades in the Western pattern, but if a Good Oriental Chisel could be ground down to resemble a nineteenth century laid steel blade, then I would go to the trouble.
>An easy solution for handmade chisels is to ask the maker, like Imai, to not grind the hollow.
Here is an archived website link from a Japanese tool dealer that used to sell Hisasaku chisels. Hisasaku makes a laminated western style paring chisel.
The hollow on a japanese chisel is very shallow, as Wilbur said. Shallower than on a plane blade for example. The chisel hollow is in the low thousandths deep. In fact, people sometimes have problems keeping the hollow there, if they work the back too much when sharpening. So if you want to try a japanese chisel without the hollow, it's very doable. Let me know if you want one.
>I am indeed interested in trying out one of these. I don't know if it is possible to get one with a tang instead of a socket? I would like a firmer (will take one with bevels) about a half inch but up to 5/8"?
All Japanese chisels have a heavy tang on them. What looks like a socket is actually a tapered ferrule holding the assembly together and distributing the shock of hammering.
Judging by the number of layers your chisel maker appears to be using quite basic folded steel. But I doubt that higher-quality folded steel would prevent this kind of failure mode.
As others pointed out, with some careful grinding that problem should be recoverable.