Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

Posts

289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#1

289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

dave brown

>Veritas has come out with their skew rabbet planes -- in right and left handed versions.

A question to those of you that own and use a Stanley 289: have you ever wished you had a left handed 289? Would you use it as often as your right handed 289?

thanks in advance,

Dave


img

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#2

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version

Tony Augruso

>I'm left handed and I don't have a 289. But every right handed plane with a fence is unusable to me. I have to think opposite to what I consider normal.

I tried the LV plow plane and I couldn't get it to work because I was left handed. It left me disappointed. If they came out with a left handed version I would buy one.

Thank goodness bench planes and saws don't care that I'm left handed.

Tony

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#3

Re: standards

paul womack

>

Thank goodness bench planes and saws don't care that I'm left handed.


I have a Preston jack plane where the tote has enough shaping that it is handed!!

BugBear

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#4

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version

Rob Lee

>Hi Dave -

If I can read between the lines here...

No - not everyone will want to buy a pair, most of the time, grain orientation will not be an issue with either hand of skew plane. I suspect that 90% of the time, whichever skew you have will work just fine. However, if you make your living doing woodworking - then for 10% of the time - it's well worth having the pair.

We made both right- and left-handed planes really for right- and left-handed users. As has been pointed out - the other handed plane is not as intuitive to use.

At the same time - we have a ton of tooling in these planes, and can offer a substantial discount for either right- or left-handed users to pick up the opposite hand... really - with the intro offer, you are getting the second plane in the pair for $149... (find a buddy of the opposite hand, and get both, and split the savings... :) )

Cheers -

Rob

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#5

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version *LINK*

dave brown

>Hey Tony, I just posted over on woodnet. I'm a righty that is looking for a lefty to split the Veritas into deal savings. Let me know if you're interested.

thanks!

Dave


woodnet post

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#6

Re: new phenomona!

paul womack

> (find a buddy of the opposite hand, and get both, and split the savings... :)

Wow - Rob just made lefty woodworkers a sought after demographic!

BugBear

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#7

Where are they??

Dean Lapinel

>I just looked at the Lee Valley web page again and I can't find these planes. Link for the hopeless?

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#9

OH, no, Rob!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>And here I'd convinced my non-professional self that I should have both...

And, as Bugbear points out, being left-handed, I'll probably be at a premium over the next few weeks.

Actually, I use a lot of right-handed planes, and have learned how to be right-handed tolerably well. It may be because, as I learned recently, I'm right-eye-dominant even though left-handed. Or maybe it's just that my handedness is more mixed than I realize (although I've never learned to hammer with either hand, as my maternal grandfather could - hammering turns out to be an extremely sophisticated action).

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#10

But I never...

Rob Lee

>... said anything about *wanting* both...!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#11

Yup-per ! . . .

steve mackay

>WOULD be handy ! Can't see justifying the cost though.

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#12

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version

Dean Lapinel

>I'll have to back track on some old articles but I thought that the old wood raised panel planes came in pairs and often had skewed blades.

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#13

Service

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"(find a buddy of the opposite hand, and get both, and split the savings... :) )"

I was in a local tool store today, buying parts for a recently acquired neanderbuddy, and heard one of the sales staff explaining how to check the fuse in Makita cordless battery chargers, thus, possibly, NOT making the sale of a new one and saving the customer $$.

Nice to know that this kind of attitude is still alive and well in local and certain internationally known businesses.

I suppose the ambivalent ambidextrous should buy both...

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#14

I'm a lefty, hint, hint...

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I have the Record rabbet plane and find it's perfect for a lefty to use to shave tenons using the left hand. But actually using it for rabbets requires using it in my right hand. I can do it, I just don't like it.

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#15

Aesthetics and several questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I do like the "wall" side of the plane - the side with the depth stop. The shiny lines around the dark parts reminds me of the Stanley 289, which IMHO is prettiest from the same vantage point.

It looks from some of the production pics that the fence rods are removable. Is that right? Dean Lapinel makes reference in another post here to panel raising planes coming in left and right versions - one reason to talk myself into a set would be for panel raising, which would require removable rods, I think. Rob, are these usable for this purpose?

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#16

Re: skew

paul womack

>Interesting - I recently tried to get information about the degree (!) of skew in older planes.

Most came in at 65-70 degree.

So 60 (aka 30) degree skew is a lot of skew.

BugBear

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#17

Re: skew

paul womack

>which would require removable rods

Unless LV went to the effort of putting "stops" on the ends of the rods, I don't see any way the rods COULD be captive.

BugBear

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#18

old panel raisers didn't come in pairs

Larry Williams

>Old panel raisers didn't come in pairs. At least there's no evidence of it. I think it was a Leon Robbins attempt to make completely machine made wooden panel raisers and overcome performance problems he encountered.

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#19

Re: Aesthetics and several questions

Rob Lee

>Hi Bill -

Yes - the rods on this one are removable... in fact, the projection stop screw for the nicker is inside the hole the front rod mounts in (you only adjust it each time the nicker is sharpened).

If you click on "View" and "Instr" in the price line on the web page, you can see much more detail...

Paul - loctite (I forget which color) fixes rods pretty well...!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#20

How did they deal with going against the grain?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#21

That's a nice looking plane.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#22

Re: How did they deal with going against the grain

MikeW

>Hi Pam,

Panels (and drawer bottoms) are often done with some degree of cathedral grain--flat sawn wood. Other than at times needing to take a less agressive cut one side of the panel, the skew blade of the panel fielding plane does a great job.

It is more an issue if one is using QS wood. The grain runout is the main culprit. But if one doesn't cut the panel so the grain is very square to the sides (to minimize runout) the QS panel looks off anyway.

Take care, Mike

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#23

I see, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#24

actually, it's not much of a problem--never was

Larry Williams

>Pam,

I believe David Denning was pretty accurate in his book, The Art and Craft of Cabinet-Making, first published in the 1890's. He wrote:

"....For instance, our friend the joiner, working, as has

been said, principally in pine, would find that the fillister

is not so suitable as the rabbet-plane for making a rabbet in

hard-wood furniture, a fact which the trained cabinet-maker

is aware of, and so very probably does not even possess a

fillister, the use of which would be somewhat inconvenient to

him on that account even in 'deal' work. ..."

In other words, the moving fillister was a carpenter's tool. You might find them useful for roughing out rabbets in hard woods but I'd stay back from the gauge lines in that case. Finish up with a rabbet plane with the appropriate pitch. I've found I favor straight rabbet planes, straight as opposed to skewed. This way even grain reversals within a board are no problem. Just turn the plane to work with the grain through any difficult situations.

I've gotten quite fond of straight rabbets, so much so I can't imagine obtaining a skewed one until I had a full range of sizes of straight rabbets.

Re: 289 users -- ever wish 4 a left-handed version?

#25

Larry, how about a moving fillister

Kevin Adams

>with a higher pitch, say 55 degrees? I've never tried one, but would think it would work OK on standard hardwoods. Does the skewed blade effectively lower the angle of attack though?

Thanks.

Kevin