Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

Posts

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#26

Sounds like bldg deserves documentation.

Chuck Nickerson

>Is there a local school with a student photographer and writer who could record what you're seeing?

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#27

Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.

Dean J in MN

>Yes Mike that is the article I was referring to.

-Dean

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#28

Re: Historical money

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If you price labor by determining what an hour of labor will buy at any given time, you have more of a common value mechanism, whether we're on a gold standard or not (btw, there was no gold/silver standard a couple or three hundred years ago, took quite a while before banks adopted a common standard to back their issued currencies).

Pam

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#29

Patrick Edwards' paper re Period Productivity *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Hi All,

Thanks much to Joel and to Dean J. for his bringing out the specific example of the Pembroke breakfast table.

Attached is an interesting paper by Patrick Edwards (he of the unbuildable reproductions, which he nevertheless manages to build)--where he uses price guides from the Winterthur's collection to derive completion times for specific furniture pieces in the early 19th century. If you scroll down to the completion times for tables in Patrick's paper, they do not appear to be out of line with Dean J's information, if you assume 5 shillings/day in 1772. Patrick is using 7 shillings/6 pence per day as of 1800, which appears well-documented, and he relates that wage rates were increasing rapidly during this period and after. So perhaps the 5 shillings is about right for a generation earlier in 1772.

Bottom line: Making reasonable assumptions, both Patrick's info and the 1772 Philadelphia Price Book imply very rapid build schedules--2-1/2 to 3 days for simple forms, and a week for more complex pieces.

Like Mike W., I have to believe that the cabinet shops had work stations, fixtures, and patterns pre-set up for their standard wares, so that there wasn't ever any head-scratching and mocking up about what to do next (like I'm always doing). Nearly all of the time had to be what we used to call 'wrench time', as opposed to planning, meetings, going to the credit union, coffee, etc etc.

Wiley


"Period Productivity" by Patrick Edwards

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#30

Define rough

James Watriss

>Rough to finish... meaning boards are rough cut to approximate thickness, or are we milling down from 4/4, or something like that? If it's true that the old timers, per some comment posted in this thread, used stock that was already rough sawn to appropriate thickness, like drawer stock, then I think milling wood down seems a bit much.

Sounds like a fun challenge though.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#31

Thats right...

John in New Mexico

>I only mention the gold standard because it makes the historical charts one can find on the web look rather strange, so its worth knowing why the price is essentially flat for so long. England instituted a gold standard in the early 1800's as far as I know, just after the Napoleanic wars. In the US we officially followed a gold standard much later, around the turn of the next century, though I believe there was some kind of de facto standard earlier. Obviously, I'm not an economist, I'm a geologist - hence the interest in gold. One can certainly do the same sort of thing with any commodity, though gold is the most effective over long periods as it has little use other than as currency and currency backing so it is least effected by supply and demand cycles and changes in farming/manufacturing efficiencies. Unfortunately, like any other commodity, the price will swing fairly wildly during periods of intense speculation (such as, say, now), throwing off one's rule of thumb by quite a bit. But since its all fun and games in this context, thats not a really big deal.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#32

Re: Patrick Edwards' paper re Period Productivity

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

As one approaches into and following the war years, the rate of inflation was great. For instance, according to one account book it was not out of line for a chest on shest to fetch 80 to this person's hisgh of 126 pounds. I have to imagine not only was the sale price inflated, but the wages paid out as well. In this account book, in the 1790s, proces were brought more in line to "normal."

However, what is unclear to me is whether these were British pounds during the war with England. Point being, it might be difficult to base wage calculations during this time, at least once the war was near.

Take care, Mike

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#33

Re: long term...

paul womack

>trying to use a single compensating factor for inflation over any period much over 50 years doesn't really work.

If you pick a single commodity, its value is massively effected by availability, technologyu of production and demand.

If you aim for "comparable standard of living", you're equally doomed.

Does the lack of a flush toilet make for a lower standard of living? Or white bread? Or central heating? You end up makign so many assumptions and caveats that the exercise becomes meaningless.

Even in the realm of tools in the last 100 years (during which many tools have continuously existed) there is no single "scaling factor".

I am always shocked at how cheap the big stuff is (sledge hammers, anvils) in the old catalogues, and how expensive precision stuff is (vernier calipers, engineers squares).

BugBear

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#34

Why a 50 year magic number?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#35

Re: threshold is arbitrary - point remains

paul womack

>

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#36

Re: Define rough

Dan Donaldson

>It was done both ways, depending on how involved the person wanted to be. The goal was from total rough, but realities also said that you could use what you could get. It was not a "hard rules" type of competition with prizes, just a personal challenge to see what you could do relative to what it was believed the old craftsmen did. the goal was to stay as close to the old ways/tools as possible and see what you could do.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#37

Re: another reference

paul womack

>From The Village Carpenter:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Village-Carpenter-Walter-Rose/dp/0854420657

"The making of a gate was considered a

day's work for a qualified carpenter, and was

expected to be done in the ten hours which

at that time constituted a day of labour.

No one ever suggested that it was possible to

make one in less time. The oak was hard with

long seasoning, and all the work - planing,

morticing, tenoning and fitting in of the rails -

was done by hand"

BugBear

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#38

Re: Define rough

Dean J in MN

>Regarding the old timers using stock close to the needed thickness -- It seems from what I can gather (I'm sorry I can't recall the article, Cooke in Chipstone, not sure what issue) that they did buy the stock in useful thicknesses. Secondary woods in 1/2" from the mill for example. That would be very nice, I can't do that today as a "stock" option.

Thicknessing in general is something to think long and hard about anyway, do you really need to do it? I avoid it whenever I can. There are times you need to have things the "same" thickness, but rarely do you need all your stock at some defined thickness like I see power shops working. I resaw my secondary woods to have 1/2" stock at hand, but they had it available right from the mill. I asked one of the cabinetmakers at Williamsburg if they "buy" their secondary wood at various thicknesses, he said they did not, rather they resaw. But recognized that other options were present in the period.

Having stock near the finished thickness is a great efficiency.

-Dean

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#39

Were These British Pounds?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>The answer is yes. At the time of the revolution, the mindset was that money was money. Coins were made of precious metal; gold, silver, copper. These were intrinsically valuable. Pieces of Eight, Spanish Reals, were in circulation as were other foreign coinage. The individual states had the right to coin money under the Articles of Confederation and the US Mint produced its first coinage in 1793. A timeline at the US Mint site relates that Jefferson, in 1776, issued a report to Congress valuing various coins in circulation in the rebelling Colonies. Obviously the value of coins relative to others was not an easy issue. The British Pound Sterling was a benchmark around the world then and the prevailing coinage in the British North American Colonies. The way to inflate a currency was to debase the currency, make lighter coins and retain their original face value. That's the whole point to a gold standard. It's the gold that's valuable not the pound per se.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#41

Hence the term "rule of thumb"

John in New Mexico

>There seems to be some confusion as to how a historical 5 shillings or 1 dollar could possibly be related to modern money. I'm not attempting to provide a rigorous acedemic theory here, with a arithmatic precision of 1 modern dollar = X dollars of the year 18XX. Looking at the relative value of a commodity - hopefully one whose use does not change much over time - provides "context". Thats all. Nothing more.

Since you don't appear to approve of my method, perhaps you can provide a substitute. Or is it impossible to ever understand another historical period by comparing it to our own?

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#42

Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.

Ray Gardiner

>An example:-

I did piece work years ago making hardwood pallets, someone starting out would barely manage 20-30 pallets in a day. After a month or so we were doing 100-120 a day. (a hammer would last less than a day between dressings) Don't underestimate the level of skill and speed that one builds through repetition.

Also, work was broken down into smaller repetitious tasks, apprentices would perform a lot of menial supporting, fetching and prepping stock, sharpening tools, taking away finished parts to the next step in the process.

I think it is necessary to look at the work flow and organization before passing judgement on how fast a journeyman joiner had to be. Especially compared with the way a small one man shop would work today.

Regards

Ray

PS Rarely visit here, but this discussion I find fascinating. I Should come back more often.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#43

Even during the six months I did sheet metal

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I was a lot faster with it than my occasional tin bending now. I can't imagine how much faster I'd have been if I'd passed the apprentice test and earned my journeyman's card.

Of course, if I had, I'd now be a rambling wreck.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#44

Re: Hence the term "rule of thumb"

paul womack

>Since you don't appear to approve of my method, perhaps you can provide a substitute. Or is it impossible to ever understand another historical period by comparing it to our own?


Yes, probably impossible, if the understanding is to be good. I was attempting to point out that value comparisons over a long time scale verge on the meaningless.

The various "living in the past" programs demonstrate fairly well how non-comparable living standards are, even in a short time scale.

(the programs are generally poor, but that's another issue)

BugBear

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#45

Re: Hence the term "rule of thumb"

Adam Cherubini

>John,

I use $1000=�1 That makes a craftsman's 5s/day about $250 which is a low wage for a skilled craftsman in my area. His weekly pay is about $1500. If you look at lumber prices, you'll find they weren't much different than wholesale rough lumber is today. Mahogany is more expensive today I think, but not by much. If you look at prices for furniture, even houses, $1000/�1 make sense.

Just to be clear, my number is entirely subjective. As you said, standards of living are so wildly different now than then, any objective comparison seems irrelevant. The only comparison that makes sense to me is to look at acceptable wages of comparable workers. I think it's best to compare modern auto mechanics to period cabinetmakers.

Adam

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#46

Price book wages

Adam Cherubini

>The 15-25s/day wage in the price book is rubbish. (Ask me about this when you see me.) We have lots of data about wages in Philadelphia at this time. Journeymen were paid 5s day. Apprentices were unpaid. Their labor was probably billed at 5s/day, which the master put in his pocket to offset the cost of room and board and tuition. Builder Thomas Nevell had several journeymen and many apprentices. He billed 8s for his own time, 5s for his journeymen and billed IIRC 2s6d for "uppr prentices" and less for "lowr prentices". In this case, he billed according to the capability of those on the jobsite, which was very fair of him. We know some Philadelphia carvers got 10s/day for their work.

Adam

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#47

Re: Were These British Pounds?

Adam Cherubini

>The problem is that under the articles, States issued their own money and several states used � s d. So without knowing more about Mike's �80 source we can't be certain it was BPS. We know there was inflation during the war. People wanted sterling if they could get it. But as the colonial economy really ran on a complex system of credit, I don't know that anyone actually got paid �80 BPS for a chest of drawers or a rifle. That may have been what they wanted in colonial money. It also could be the price of goods essentially smuggled from Britain.

The key to understanding colonial economy requires the understanding of two important concepts: debtors prison, and probate inventories.

Adam

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#48

Thats interesting...

John in New Mexico

>If for no other reason than the variation in modern wages across the country. Out here wages exceeding $20/hour are still fairly rare for craftsmen, though not unheard of. I imagine that they're higher in the west coast cities.

I do understand that your number is subjective, and as I keep repeating, mine is extremely subjective as well. I would agree with Paul that the whole practice is meaningless if I really felt that most people understood why historical wages seem so low to us (I have no doubt that you get it though, one need not explain context to a guy who wears period clothing at work!)

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#49

I can't agree I'm sorry to say...

John in New Mexico

>I don't think its impossible, but then I don't require a hard conversion factor to think that I understand the difference between two eras. Standards of living, expectations, and even social practices are very different, but you see the same effect on a smaller scale between modern cities and rural areas - in this country at least - and for roughly the same reasons.

Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*

#50

Re: Hence the term "rule of thumb"

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>The best thing is to compare relative wages of contemporary occupations. Who was paid more? A cabinetmaker or a wheelwright? A printer or a shopkeeper? etc., etc. Do these comparisons hold in New Hampshire as they do in Virginia? How do they compare to London? Did a shop in London produce more work than a shop in Philidelphia? A farmer would make nails or Connecticut nutmegs for cash to buy those consumer goods which couldn't be made at home. An urban cabinetmaker was necessarily earning cash to buy a greater percentage of his daily needs, i.e. food, clothing, etc. Money economies are mainly urban economies. This thread was started to discuss how quickly 18th century woodworkers could build furniture. Price lists were used to ascertain this. Assumptions were then made about daily wages so prices could be translated into time. It seems to me that the reason for promulgating price books begs the question why some would feel it necessary. Did some shops have a labor advantage that allowed them to build faster and charge less for similar work if no price fixing were in place? Or less overhead? Or a technical advantage? I think price books do give us an indication of how much time it took to build furniture. This discussion has also convinced me that a craftsman working alone, today or then, is going to produce much slower than how most of these pieces were produced. I conclude that 18th century pieces were produced faster than we think because of the fully developed system in place but to say a piece was made in 30 hours (or however long) is irrelevant. Without a similar system, I could never duplicate their times.