We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Joel
>Recently there was a thread started by Adam on some defect in a chair.
In London chairmakers belonged to a separate union and were paid differently than cabinetmakers.
This a copy of their book of prices from 1829 - about the time when a good wage was 30 shillings a week in the summer. (although I might be off and the it bears checking as I don't know if cabinetmakers and chairmakers got the same wage) Everyone worked on piecework and this was the wage pade to the workman. I am reasonably sure that the workman would have to find his own materials.
I haven't read the thing yet - just skimmed it but it is important if you are interested in how tasks were priced and broken down. Also if you make reproduction chairs I bet it is still a good guide for prices - just add a multiplier to convert the old rates to new.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>Hi Joel,
This is a fascinating book! If not plain amazing. I did a quick google search to see if I could find any comparable furniture price lists from colonial or Federal America.
Attached is a link to the 1772 Philadelphia Furniture Price Book, authored by Alexandra Kirtley, who is a curator at the Philadelphia Museum of Art. If I am reading the description of this book correctly, there is a listing of 56 furniture forms, each with variations, and what is most interesting--there are three columns of figures associated with each piece. The first two columns are the retail price ("price to be charged") in mahogany or walnut, respectively, and the third column is the amount to be paid to the journeyman who produced the components.
Has anyone seen this book and studied it? The information given seems to say that for each of the furniture pieces, there is a retail price in two different woods, along with the labor component listed separately. Which would mean you could calculate the markup over direct labor instantly. If true, this is a standard of transparency in pricing which has long been lost to the world!
By the way, neither the London Price Book nor the Philadelphia Price Book give me the impression that the culture of the day would have been permissive of hammer tracks on carved furniture. Rather, these books smack of an industry that is both highly evolved and highly exacting. Apparently, in the case of the Philadelphia book, it was a group of journeymen who took the initiative to have the prices published.
In this sort of regularized trade culture, I can understand how plane marks on hidden surfaces would be considered OK, but outright, and deep, steel hammer tracks on an external surface seem to fall into a category of carelessness (Thom pointed this out) that I have a hard time believing would have been tolerated, at least on a regular basis. Perhaps Adam's example was an exception, rather than an exception that demonstrates a principle. But then I'm just guessing, based on common sense. It's a fascinating subject, trying to recreate the past.
Much thanks to both Joel and Adam for bringing their data forward!
>price books were fairly common. just very few survived. I have the 1811 london price guide which is incredibly comprehensive except for chairs (covered in this book) and regional books and book for specialist trades existed.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Chairs - plate 10 on the lower portion of the plate what are they showing? Is this the front (long) edge variations as looking down from the top? Plate 13 - Is this some sort of mechanical adjustment variation for someone with disabilities? very peculiar.
Victor - In rainy Houston.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Has anyone seen this book and studied it? The information given seems to say that for each of the furniture pieces, there is a retail price in two different woods, along with the labor component listed separately. Which would mean you could calculate the markup over direct labor instantly. If true, this is a standard of transparency in pricing which has long been lost to the world!
I've had the book for a few weeks now. Not enough time to say I've "studied" it, but I've gotten comfortable with it. There will be more to dig up/read/research. But, it is worth the price, I recommend anyone interested in the topic get a copy.
The price book is printed in facsimile and a great piece of history, it does show the retail price in mahogany and walnut (or mahogany and poplar for bedsteads) along with the journeyman's wage for that piece. I'm not sure what you mean by transparency, if you mean between master and journeyman then yes. If you mean consumer, no, these books were to never be shown to outsiders.
A few interesting things, labor, even in Phily, was a small part of the cost of the good. Price differences between mahogany and walnut are of interest. And it is amazing how fast they built things. If you use the 15-25s per day they were faster than I can even fathom. If you use a 5s per day wage I've seen elsewhere -- well, they were still amzingly fast. Interesting stuff.
-Dean
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
I bought a copy last summer while at the Philadelphia Musuem of Art for the SAPFM mid-year meeting. It's been a while since I read it, but they are not kidding when they say it is a treasure trove of information for those of us who like to build their pieces either wholly or partially in the traditional manner. I highly recommend it as a part of your library. Like most books of that time, I also have the Philly carpenter's and jointers price book, it can be read on several levels. There is first the obvious written text with information taken as a"data mine", then there are the between the lines attempts to make assumptions and guesses about things methods of work. A great book to use as daydreaming fodder.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
Dean J in MN
>Yes, but even the "11-hour" workday has problems. Light for example. But that is an area of debate as well -- we can't say they worked 11 hours. Did they take a mid-day break? It isn't an agreed upon number by any means.
Regardless -- Even if you say a day was 11 hours. It is still amazing how quick they are.
As an example:
Breakfast (Pembroke) table plane: labor 12s 6d
Assume an 11 hour day --
At the 5s a day rate: ~31 hours (about two and a half workdays)
At the 15s a day rate: Complete in less than a workday
At the 25s a day rate: Better build two of these in a day.
That is pretty quick either way.
(Add a drawer to that table -- labor goes up to 14s 6d. Pretty quick drawer builders!)
-Dean
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
James Watriss
>I have to wonder then, because I can't remember, what was the typical policy regarding apprentices? Were they paid, unpaid, how many of them were there, etc, and who paid what to whom to seal the deal? Did parents pay an artisan to take their son off of their hands? "Please, take this money here, get this kid out of our house, and teach him a trade, we can't afford to feed him anymore." Or was it the reverse? "Here, I'll pay you this money here, because I think I can get some good use out of your kid for a while, and I don't plan on paying him."
I think it is possible that, if there was a large enough shop running, that the work could be done. Almost every little detail is covered here, so it's possible to figure out how long each operation was intended to take. Mid 1800s was prime industrial age time, so maybe they were working in huge mill buildings, and there were workers working on specific parts all day. In that case, doing the same procedure all day every day, yeah, it doesn't surprise me that they'd be fast.
Issues of speed and workers aside, there's something else to consider... namely profitability.
I'm in the process of moving into a new space right now. I and 2 friends have found space, and are about to sign the lease. It's in a huge mill building in an old mill town. There are a number of these buildings collected around the river, but it's very clear that there was a lot of work involved and a lot of expertise. My building has 7 floors, all on top of a foundation that is broken up with enormous tunnels, through which water would flow to power machines. Then there are the canals that fed the water to the tunnels, all coming after a dam in the river. It's an ENORMOUS infrastructure, the likes of which I really wasn't clued into until now. I thought of river power as a waterwheel or something like that... this is clearly way above and beyond. But the scope of the work to be done is immense, and while there was clearly a lot of lesser skilled labor, there was also a lot of really wild engineering involved.
The amount of effort, translated into money, to build even one of these buildings is mind boggling. The fact that they were made to house many workers, with same machines, but without all of the automated processes that we have today, is even more staggering.
How much money does one entity have to be able to make, over what period of time, to be able to justify such a construction? And as a result of this, how much money would the average artisan really be able to make, if the employer and owner of the building still had to make enough just to pay off the building?
No surprise they were fast. They'd have to be, doing piecework, or they'd starve.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Of course "it's possible that the work could be done." Duh.
What I think I was trying to say is that it could be done with less effort than we probably think it took. Day in day out repetition builds skill, and with enough workers, all building specific parts of the chair... sure, why not? Big projects are made up of a lot of little ones. And individually, they didn't take so much time.
phooey... I'm quitting. I need more coffee.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Day in day out repetition builds skill, and with enough workers, all building specific parts of the chair... sure, why not? Big projects are made up of a lot of little ones. And individually, they didn't take so much time.
For sure, these workers were highly skilled. Repetition builds speed no doubt. But it doesn't seem that they were each working on specific parts of a chair (or chest or whatever). If you set aside high end carving the journeyman probably built the entire piece start to finish. Same for the apprentices, they were just given easier projects which matched their skill set. I don't think it was common to have an assembly line feel to the shops.
None of that discounts the fact the journeymen were much like professional athletes of today. The field in any PGA event is far advanced in skill compared to the common golfer, just as the cabinetmakers of the day are far advanced from we mortal duffers.
-Dean
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>in furniture the cabinetmaker at the bench (for which these rates apply) involved milling the wood (see below) joinery, hardware installation, and prepping for finishing. carving, inlay, etc was done by specialists.
milling wood was done from prices already in good shape and sawn out to the right thickness. for drawers you used drawer stock, for carcarses you used carcass stock. So milling was mostly a case of planing for accuracy and finish not lots of stock removal. also the air dried stock would be sawn for stability so you typcially didn't worry about warp and wayne as much as we do today.
MY guess is that high end London chairmaking was similar to furniture making in work breakdown but in lower end chairs where qunaity was important and the chairs were really custom there was an incredibly complicated set formula for who did what, how much they got paid, and dozens of specialists worked on each chair.
It was generall acknowledged that when you are paid piecework it's impossible for a generalist to compete with a specialist - so just about every craftsman tried to specialize - if there was enough work in the region for specialization.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
MikeW
>Hi Dean,
Well, one purpose of shooting you a couple direct emails was so I wouldn't expose either my incredulity nor ignorance publically ...
I keep looking at these numbers and those I have. And I don't believe our common perception/understanding of the time/money ratios. At the high extreme of the 25s rate, it is simply impossible.
But I have problems even with the 5s rate in believing a 2 1/2 day turn time from wood on a pile to a stained and finished piece. Even with the simplier forms. In fact, kinda hard to believe even a completed but unfinished piece. Their simple forms are not quite my idea of a simple form.
Now, all that is not to say I do not think these guys were competent nor in general highly skilled and effecient. I do. And I am supposing that there were patterns for nearly all aspects of the construction. It does make it as close to plug & play as one can get.
As I mentioned in my emails, I still do not know whether in the 18th century these guys were paid in who's money--British, American, regional or local pounds, shillings, pence. I am not certain that makes a difference if the units in are the same as units paid out.
Too much rambling, not enough coffee.
Take care, Mike
PS, I want to publically thank Joel for starting this thread. This stuff has bugged me for a while. And thinking in a vacuum of ignorance is fairly unproductive for me.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
John W
>I believe the apprentice system was a benefit to all involved. The parents sent the son to learn a life skill from a master. The young man was bound by a contract to work for the master for a pre-determined number of years. He would be paid a small amount and his food, clothing, and shelter would be provided. The contract stipulated that at the end of the apprenticeship he would be skilled in the �arts and mysteries� of the trade and was usually provided a small kit of tools so he could leave and go to work for someone else or start his own business. The Master agreed to teach the apprentice the skills of the trade and whatever else may be stipulated by the contract and in turn received a helper for his shop. I have seen these contracts drawn up by hand, and also some that were pre-printed and just the names and dates were filled in.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Also in piece work, the worker is paid for a good piece and debited for a piece that doesn't make the grade. Sometimes the piece is partially paid for in the case of a useable but imperfect piece. I would assume the item it goes into is discounted accordingly as a second. Would be nice to know the percentage of acceptable pieces the average worker produced on a weekly basis.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
James Watriss
>Absolutely to all of that. Old working processes are really a marvel when they start to surface.
Maybe it's just me... I think sometimes that it's so easy for most of us to think that, in this silicon age, that we're so much smarter, and so much more advanced. It's easy to forget that for all the change in the fundamental knowledge base, that there have always been some very smart people. Technology may change, but there haven't been significant advances in the production of people, or their ability to work and innovate with whatever's at hand.
And ditto the thanks to Joel. It really is pretty cool to see any kind of quantifiable time/money stuff as related to fine furniture. Sure does provide an interesting benchmark for us moderns.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
Dean J in MN
>Mike --
I'm with you, I have a hard time squaring the data with my experience in the shop. I struggle to come to grips with the apparent speed, but I'm pretty much a hack so I know there are greater efficiencies and overall speed.
It is a great conversation to have regardless. And I welcome the dialog here as the more views the better. The context is very important, looking at the data in a vacuum is likly to lead us to the wrong conclusion. The economics of the time/region can't be left out, the culture is very different in many ways, and these all play a part in interpreting the book. As I said, there is so much more to read/research/dig up after reading the price books. I would love to pull in the collective wisdom of the guys at Williamsburg for example. I've read Mack's article in Chipstone and his timing data is quite different than what seems to be suggested here.
It is all very interesting, and I think relevant to working by hand as well as by machine. It affords another view into the minds of the craftsmen of the time.
-Dean
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
>Something that's hard to understand for most is that money did not work the same in the last century as it does now. The gold standard in various forms kept inflation fairly stable in the various countries that used a standard for many years. So during the period we're talking about, gold was approximately $20/oz or 4.25 pounds sterling. Thats roughly 50 shillings. So 5 s would be about $50 to $80 dollars today, depending on the current price of gold (its a bit inflated at the moment, it will either drop in the future or the rest of the market will inflate to catch up). I know this is a very gross oversimplification, but it does give us an effective rule of thumb for keeping these prices in perspective.
When I worked for a furniture shop about ten years ago, I made $10/hour, our sanders made between $5 and $7. Gold was around $300/oz, so 5 s in 1800 would be equivalent to about $30, a little on the low side, but in the same ballpark. One of the reasons this type of conversion is very rough and not universally reliable is it doesn't take into account either improved manufacturing efficiencies in the production of food - which directly effects the cost of living, or our ever changing social view of what is a fair wage.
Overall, I think the figure of 5 s a day for a skilled worker in 1800's is accurate as a low end member. Our lowest paid skilled workers today make a lot more, but we have different ideas about what is fair now. We also have retirement, vacations, atv's and bass boats, and often try to put our children through college.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things.
Dan Donaldson
>Above, I mentioned the challenge that Adam put out some time ago. The task was to build a cabinet from rough to finish in less than 24 hours (working time) using only the tools available at that time. (allowing some lattitude for metal planes and a few other items that it would not necessarily be reasonable to expect everyone to have) The cabinet had a door, a drawer,(dovetailed) and molding around the top. There were several people here that tried it and did pretty well. It was just a personal challenge, no prizes, just bragging rights. It was quite interesting. Maybe if enough are interested, it could be done again. I will see if I can dig up some of the results.
Re: The London chair-makers' and carvers' book of pric *LINK*
Re: "And it is amazing how fast they built things. *LINK*
Dan Donaldson
>I misremembered. It had just drawers. I am attaching a link to one of the projects that was done as a part of it. You can find a bunch more stuff if you eearch through the hand tool archives.