Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

I must have great sharpening form

Posts

I must have great sharpening form

#1

I must have great sharpening form

wilbur

>I was doing a sharpening run tonight, and was being careful to apply pressure to the front of my chisels and plane blades. I have a bad habit of shifting the pressure on the tool away from the edge so that I'm abrading the bevel instead of the edge. I was pretty pleased with my results, and felt that I was doing a better job sharpening than I usually do.

Then I noticed some blood on the tool.

I had kept my fingers so close to the front of the tool that I had abraded the skin on the tips of my index and middle finger on the waterstone to the point that they were bleeding.

At least my tools are sharp. Pfft.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#2

Re: I must have great sharpening form

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've convinced myself that blood adds a certain quality to the stones. :)

Pam

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#3

Re: I must have great sharpening form

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wilbur

I usually cut myself on the side edges of the blade backs while freehanding them. Some, like those from LV, are really sharp. I keep meaning to round them off but forget ... until the next time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#4

ouch!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>those don't heal quickly like a simple cut. (I will not go into how I acquired this abrasive woodworking experience)

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#5

first aid solution

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I have never abraded myself on a sharpening stone but being around a 36" disc sander with 40d will earn a few similar injuries. I found the only suitable bandage was to apply super glue directly to the open wound. it will sting a bit at first but as it dries it will protect the wound from contamination and further injury from continuously bumping it. I asked my doc if there is any diference in the formulation of the CA glue used in surgeries, if it contained any antibiotic or other medication. Apparently it is the same stuff with the only difference being the single use applicator for medical CA.

Robin

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#6

Re: ouch!

ThomD

>I've done that, though in my case it was because I was trying to stabilize my hand by resting fingers on the stone, bad habit.

I think trying to put weight on the edge is a bad idea, you should be trying to abrade the whole bevel, so that as it migrates the edge is sharpened. Of course it is all relative since one can have a tendancy not to have the weight in the right places and need to redress it. I find I have to be careful with Japanese bevels since even though they are nice and wide, they aren't even in density and I have to be sure to keep the weight on the front, though I try not to tip the blade up.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#7

not the only difference

Alex Yeilding

>The other difference is that those single-application packets get marked up from $0.15 to $8.75 as soon as they cross the threshold of the hospital or surgi-center.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#8

Been there, done that...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Not a fun experience. As said super glue makes a great band-aid.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#9

Re: first aid solution

wilbur

>What also works well for any cut is putting a dab of antibiotic ointment (any one will do) on the gauze pad of the bandage. The ointment helps with coagulation, and the antibiotic and the ointment help a great deal with healing.

It is true that the Dermabond is pretty much the same thing as thick CA glue. It has a slight purple tinge, so as to make it easier to see where you've applied it to the skin. It also has to go through an FDA approval process, unlike the Hot Stuff folks, FWIW.

Personally, I like the bandaid with antibiotic ointment approach myself.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#10

Re: ouch!

wilbur

>Actually, I was sharpening Japanese chisels and plane blades, and it seems that more of the soft layer rubs off than the hard layer.

I'm sure I'll figure out the happy medium of finger positioning someday.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#11

Re: Been there, done that...

Ken Romines

>Regular super glue works really well on some wounds. It will not stop a bad bleeder from bleeding. It will, however, glue your makeshift bandage to the rest of your fingers. And our fine physicians complain when they have to pick super glue out before and after they sew up a cut. DAMHIKT.

Ken

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#12

Very interesting, Robin, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#13

This isn't a good idea!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The generic description of this adhesive is cyanoacrylate. This name describes the family of chemical that is the adhesive part. But there are several members of this family, differing in one part of the molecule. This difference would be like the difference in methyl alcohol, ethyl alcohol , propyl alcohol. It may be that the medical grade is some different from what we used for wood. Additionally, these things can contain stabilizers of one sort or another. These components may also be different between a medical grade and a shop grade. And perhaps even more important, a medical grade will be made under strict FDA rules to prevent contamination by other stuff that will be made in the chemical factory.

Given the paranoia on these forums about whether some wood in a cutting board will harm, or fumes from a finish, putting some industrial adhesive on flesh unprotected by a skin barrier should give pause. I suspect that the only reason that the stuff in the bottle is not at least moderately toxic (cyano means the molecule contains cyanide) is that as soon as it finds any protein it polymerizes into a solid and becomes inert, more or less.

Bottom line: Putting a potentially toxic chemical made in a Chinese chemical factory on raw flesh entails some risk. At one time I worked for the person that invented this stuff, should that add any credibility to my concern. .

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#14

Know a good Doctor?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#15

Been there - done that also!!

John Aniano - in NJ

>

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#16

Guess that's better than...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The Doc pouring acetone into the cut to remove it, now isn't it.

I wasn't saying it a cure all, especially for large cuts.

Scott who has never had to have a stitch form woodworking.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#17

Re: first aid solution

Wayne Anderson

>I use CA glue to close-up those cracks in my fingertips that usually appear during the cold months up here in the (sometimes) frozen north. It beats having to wear clumsy fingertip bandages. I couple days later when the crack is healed I just sand/file off the hard spot of dried glue.

BTW...I've done the sharpening stone thing as well, and once or twice I've caught my fingertip with the blade and took a neat slice. Happens quick as a wink too. -wayne

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#18

Re: Know a good Doctor?

wilbur

>I know an okay doctor, but I'm not a kid with cancer, so he'll be of no help. :@)

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#19

Re: Been there - done that also!!

goodolboy

>Of possible interest...

I try to always hit those inconveniently placed cuts or sanded thru areas of flesh on MY fingers, thumbs, etc. with soap and water, peroxide, alcohol, Betadine, or lacquer thinner at the very least if I can't locate any of the others, BEFORE using super glue, Liquid Bandage, or (or even my wife's clear nail polish in a pinch)to at least attempt to kill the surface germs that may have migrated into the wounded area.

Oh yeah, I use a rolling type sharpening guide for doing hand sharpening of most plane and chisel blades now-it makes it much quicker and easier to end up with a more uniform edge and less likely to start the blood flowing too! (and BTW, try not to let your anti-tetanus shot "protection" get too old either!)

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#20

That's quite a list!

John in New Mexico

>Laquer thinner is the only one I'd be hesitant to use, chemically speaking.

That's gotta hurt too!

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#21

Re: That's quite a list!

goodolboy

>Well, you caught me. When you work around lacquer thinner and maybe aren't careful enough with ventilation, sometimes it's cheap high affects your judgement.

Re: I must have great sharpening form

#22

Don't worry about the cyanide

wilbur

>The cyano (CN) group that's in CA glue isn't quite the same as the C-N ion that makes up cyanide that's poisonous. Once the CN group is incorporated into an organic molecule, it's very stable, and it takes quite a bit to break it off. To put things into comparison, to add the CN group to a molecule requires relatively severe conditions, so once it's on, it takes an equal amount of effort to get it off.

If you are still worried, the blue nitrile rubber gloves that woodworkers use contain the same cyano group. No one is being poisoned from their gloves.