Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Sharpening with loose abrasives?

Posts

Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#1

Sharpening with loose abrasives?

paul womack

>Such as diamond paste, or Veritas Honing Compound.

Unless one is using a very hard, very smooth substrate (e.g. cast iron), I do not understand why the tiny particles don't simply sink in such their upper surface is parallel with the top of the substrate, and thereafter do nothing at all.

I know they don't, since stropping has a long and serviceable history, especially amongst carvers; it works.

But how the hell do small particles in a soft substrate achieve anything?

BugBear

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#2

my experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When I charged a hardwood block with diamond paste I saw two differences compared to cast iron. First, it took many times more diamond to accomplish abrading. Second, the scratch was finer. I think both these observations suggest that the abrasive is indeed more embedded and most of it is inaccessible to the metal being sharpened.

I charge a 3 x 12"diamond plate with a few mm "worm" of paste or a milligram or two of dry powder. These amounts would be inconsequential on a wood block.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#3

Thanks Bill

Hank Knight

>I've been using a piece of MDF charged with diamond paste. I keep having to add paste wondering what in the world I'm doing wrong. Maybe nothing. Thanks for confirming my observation that soft substrates suck up diamond honing compound.

Hank

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#4

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Coupla years ago I got the notion from somewhere to put diamond paste on an Arkansas 'surgical black' stone. Kinda turbo charge it. I used 1/2-micron I think. I charged it with probably a quarter of a 5gm syringe. The diamond sunk without a trace. So I cut my losses and quit. I'm curious if anyone else has tried this, and whether they were able to build a base on the Arkansas stone.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#5

Speculation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you think of, say, leather as a form of stiff Jello*, in which the material will creep out of the way in response to continued pressure, then I agree, using a soft substrate charged with abrasives makes no sense.

I suspect, at the particle-size level, that many of the soft materials like leather have enough structure to provide some resistance; and enough "bounce" to return the particle to near its original position after the item being stropped passes over.

But this is all speculation, advanced as a way of avoiding going out to the garden to add more drip emitters to the watering system, since LOML adds new plants as soon as I've brought it up to date.

*Not sure if "Jello," a trademarked name, is specific to American culture - if it is, it refers to a gelatin product, firmer than custard but similar in texture and structure.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#6

alternatives

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you don't have cast iron, acrylic (Plexiglas) is much better than porous substrates. The Plexiglas is not as nice as cast iron because the tools don't slide on it as nicely. Antifreeze or glycerin thinned with a bit of water are good lubricants for the Plexiglas. Something a bit "oily" makes the metal slide easier.

On cast iron a 5g tube of paste will last a lifetime.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#7

Why doesn't someone sell a cast iorn plate?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>With all the "plates" that are sold for lapping this and that, including the latest LV entry for what must be a limited plane bottom market, why won't someone set up and sell cast iron? Surely there must be more market for sharpening stuff than flattening plane bottoms. And then there are all the other "plates" of glass, and steel. It can't be more effort to sell something inappropriate like glass or steel, than what is perfect, gray cast iron.

A company with foreign casting connections could get the blanks cast for next to nothing and it doesn't cost much to Blanchard grind them, or for the Cadillac version, surface grind. Even from foundries in the US the cost of the blank is not much. The plates we made, in small quantity, were less than $20 finished. Certainly for no more than the cost of a water stone a plate could be sold.

Do people not get how easy this way of sharpening is and hence, they don't believe a market will develop? If the tool is hollow ground about 5 strokes on the plate and its done, and it is immaterial what the alloy is. They all abrade easily. There is never any stone flattening like water stones. No water, only a drop of WD 40. Only one grit is necessary, 1 micron and $15 worth will literally last a life time. The tool slides so nicely on the cast iron it is easy for even a beginner to free-hand the sharpening process.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#8

Impossible?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't see how that much diamond could impregnate the stone. Are you sure you didn't wash it off. If the particles don't penetrate they will simply wash away with the lubricant.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#9

Re: Why doesn't someone sell a cast iorn plate?

Hank Knight

>"Only one grit is necessary, 1 micron and $15 worth will literally last a life time."

That may well be the problem. Once the original sale is made, there is no return business. Nobody wants to market a one-time sale.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#10

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

ThomD

>"But how the hell do small particles in a soft substrate achieve anything?

BugBear"

They are normally applied in a wax base so they stay on the surface, it seems. I doubt that, say, the material in the green stick, would stay around if it was offered in an oil.

There are lot of cast iron things out there. The backing plates for chucks are round but not sure they would work any the less well. Also there are lot of tools made of cast iron that are being chucked, I found a table saw complete with motor for 20 bucks, lots of grey there. It will be simpler when one can just order the plate. LV was down that road back in the 70s, I gues it depends how many people really want them.

http://www.japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&mimid=GO4FKUDW18GQCFO3LLNRFDCAE7FRK34A&pf_id=02%2E654%2E10&dept_id=13610

Don't know if it is steel or iron.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#11

theory

John in NM

>1/2 micron is equivalent to about 60K grit, which is way, way finer than the surface of even a black Arkansas stone. Even if the stone itself puts a finer polish on your tools, its surface is not ground that fine (it would look like a granite plate if it were). So I'd guess that your diamond did get lost in the valleys of the polishing stone's surface. Though not knowing how fine the polish on the stone is, I can't say that definitively.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#12

Re: theory

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>John,

I'm sure you're right. Each one of those 1/2-1 micron particles would have prolly felt like pea gravel in a wagon rut. One of these days I'll try it with 15 micron, just to get back on the horse that threw me.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#13

Re: Impossible?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Bill,

Nothing left the stone. I laid it down about an inch at a time. The carrier oil would just settle in as I worked it with a blade, and within 20 seconds I was looking at the status quo ante. Then I tried it again, and again, and again. Then I quit. I don't think the stone ever even saw the diamond. Don't try this at home.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#14

exactly...

paul womack

>which is the point I made in the first place.

Given that carvers sharpen their tools using fine abrasives on soft rough surfaces(*), how does it work?!?!?

BugBear

(*) all terms used fairly comparititively

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#15

Only one grit is necessary?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I must have missed something important. How is it that 1 micron is the only diamond dust needed?

Pam

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#16

see Bill's posts, passim

paul womack

>

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#17

How to sharpen with "one" grit size

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Do you suppose if we coined a name like "Speedy Sharp" for this porcess someone would then sell cast iron plates?

I'm not counting the 80 to 120 grit on the grinding wheel which is done occasionally.

Indeed it is not only possible, but best, to go from the grinding wheel to 1 micron diamond (or 3 or 1/2 or what ever your pleasure) and be done.

Step 1. Hollow grind the tool. Wash and wipe to remove any contaminating grit. If the edge is straight proceed to step 3. A crowned wheel makes this task much easier.

Step 2. While learning to grind on the wheel, the edge may not be perfectly straight after Step 1. In this case straighten the edge by stroking a few times on a fine, fixed diamond stone. I use a 6" "fine" with a water based lubricant used to cool cutting tools in a machine shop. This slimy stuff makes the tool glide easily. It is not essential. (I have 11 gallons of the concentrated stuff (long story) and no machine shop and I am trying to find uses for it.)

Step 3. Pull the tool across a cast iron plate charged with XX micron diamond and lubed with WD 40 (or whatever).

Why it works: Diamond cuts like you can't believe unless you have tired it. And, only a small fraction of the bevel is being ground because of the hollow. When this part gets so wide that Step 3 takes too long, then revisit the wheel and grind this flat away.

As an illustration of how well diamond cuts, with a few minutes of grinding it is possible to flatten the hollow grind using 1 micron diamond even on a tool made from highly abrasion resistant 3V steel.

Notes: Maybe because of the scratch profile, or inclusion of carbon from the cast iron, the surface reflection from 1 micron diamond looks dull compared to 1 micron alumina. If a mirrored surface makes one feel better (I am doubting it will cut better) then 3 strokes on leather with the green chrome oxide stuff will do the trick.

There is one significant disadvantage to this approach. Unlike a water stone, the surface of the cast iron does not wear away. If you get the cast iron contaminated with coarse grits it is there forever, or until you get the plate surface ground again. Warning- do not store your 15 micron diamond next to the 1 micron.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#18

Re: Smaller but cheaper from Joel *LINK*

Dave Mount

>This one's steel, but advertised for use with diamonds. My brief Googling suggests "kanaban" are generally steel. Joel's is smaller and thinner than the one you linked to, but less than half the price. Whether that's a savings or a false economy depends on the user's needs I guess.

Best,

Dave


Kanaban plate at TFWW

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#19

Re: Impossible?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Had no idea this rock is that porous. So I guess the answer is that the oil and grits simple absorbed into the pores. Because the matrix is not deformable, unlike wood , MDF and leather, once absorbed the grits were unavailable.

I suspect in wood and leather that the grits are located in pores, held there by oil or grease. Because the matrix deforms the tool presses against these abrasive laden pores.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#20

If steel worked....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That is what would have been used for the past hundreds of years. The structure of cast iron is what makes it the material of choice for diamond tool grinding or diamond gem "cutting". While they are a bit harder to find, there are suppliers of cast iron blanks that could be turned into the ideal plates with the same effort as steel.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#21

Re: Old Plane's

ThomD

>Why can't one just use an old plane? There are tons of crap planes around cast of iron nicely dressed, wouldn't do them any significant harm even if someone later decided to use them as planes.

I reiterate that the carvers use a grit suspended in wax.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#22

speculation

John in NM

>Given the quantities of compound used to charge the softer materials, I would guess that the compound effectively fills in the valleys while the high spots do the rubbing. The higher areas will compress to some degree too, no idea how much, but some.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#23

I think I'd stick to cast iron

John in NM

>If you get too coarse with the diamond, you risk contaminating a nice oilstone. I tried sharpening with diamond on a granite tile once. Worked fine, but the diamond didn't last very long. They will crush to finer grit under pressure - which I think is why cast iron and copper work so well (copper is more for stone cutting), they aren't hard enough to crush the grit quickly between the lap and the tool or stone.

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#24

planes are an excellent idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>and a marketing idea for Todd!

Re: Sharpening with loose abrasives?

#25

Thanks, Bill.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>