Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

Posts

Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#1

Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

Bjenk Ellefsen

>I am not sure if Adam approves of the designation but I feel I need to give him credit.

I have started to build a Nicholson Workbench based on the original as detailed in The Mechanic's Companion edition of 1845. However, I need a light and movable bench because I move around a lot and until I settle down, this is what I want.

Adam was very generous in offering his suggestions and he even provided details for a knock down version of this simple bench that he built for himself. Adam's design is really good, it works well and makes the bench even simpler to build.

My goals were to keep the price down and to build it as quickly as I can (within the available time I can dedicate to it).

Stuff: I bought two 3.5"X4.5" in 8 feet of length for the legs and rails and 5 2X12sX8' for the side boards and top.

Dimensions: Nicholson is giving a general idea of the dimensions which must be adapted to the worker: about 32 inches in height, 30 inches deep and 10 to 12 feet in length. I went for a height at about 31.5, 24 inches deep and 8 feet long.

Notes: I no longer have power tools as I sold them all four years ago except some of my carpentry family "heirlooms". I have been training with my old tools "collection" since then. I am a beginner even though I have years of woodworking behind me. I thought I had become very good at sawing but the 3.5X4.5 were not that easy to crosscut. I did well nonetheless. The lap joints were tricky but I found that a tension bow saw with a large blade for resawing worked well.

I attached the legs with the same lap joints we see in Nicholson's engraving. I'm done with the sides so on to jointing and gluing the top.

Jointing the 8 feet long 2X12s for the top is going to be a challenge. I never jointed stuff this big before and I only have a wooden 22 inches Try to do it.


img

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#2

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

John Aniano in NJ...

>Hello Bjenk,

Nice work!

You said you are planning to make your bench top height 31.5" tall. May I ask, how tall are you and whether your height was a factor in making the bench at 31.5" tall?

Adam C. is quite tall and his bench is correspondingly taller than most. Either Bjenk or anyone else out there - is there a "rule of thumb" for worker to bench height?

I fear that if I ask Adam directly how tall I should make my new French/Roubo-style bench, I'm sure he will say "very short" since I'm a good foot (or more?) shorter than he is!

Thanks,

John

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#3

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

wilbur

>Hi John,

The "let your hand fall to your side and make the top the height of the base of your thumb" rule worked well for me.

But a great way to test this out is to take your bench top, or a long, wide, thick board (and I know you have one :@) ) and make a temporary workbench by putting it on saw horses at the height that you think will work for you. Then give it a test run, and adjust the height as you need it. Then you can know what height works best for you.

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#4

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Hi John,

Well, Adam is a giant so he must have adjusted the height to himself. Basically, I followed Roubo's guideline:" The height must not be greater than the top of the thighs". Nicholson says that it is ordinarily about 32 inches after saying that it depends on the worker. As with everything he wrote, Roubo has given a lot of details. The top of the thighs is a general guideline based on the size of the worker. Too high and the bench will rob the worker of his strength, too low and it will expose him to bad posture and injuries and hurting his efficiency and craftsmanship down the line.

Between 30 and 32 inches is about good for a normal person (male). I was considering 35 inches at first but Adam noted that it would certainly be too high.

Wooden planes are higher than metal planes so this guideline was determined in the context of these tools. I am 6 feet tall and I have long arms. So I determined the height in relation to the top of my thighs. I have tried planing on the dinner table (while my wife was out with my son!) which stands at 30 inches and I found it very nice indeed but a bit too low.

:)

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#5

low benches

Adam Cherubini

>I'm happy to see guys entertaining lower benches. 10 years ago, woodworkers seemed to pattern their workbenches on the bar in their favorite pub! "Hey pull up a stool, let's do some planing! Can we get some peanuts down here?"

It can be really nice to have a high bench. I find them really great as long as I'm not doing any actual work. A high, clean work bench is the perfect place to wrap Christmas presents, build model airplanes or assemble huge lego kits. But planing? Yeah, not so good.

My current Nicholson bench is a good 1-1/2" under palm height wearing my favorite work shoes (high top basketball shoes).

Adam

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#6

Re: low benches

Bjenk Ellefsen

>I can't stop laughing!

But Adam is right! I am trying to convince my wife that my inherited "European" bench would make a great kitchen island! No seriously, it's the right height and it would make the kitchen an instant success!

Problems with a slippery bowl when mixing? No longer with these fantastic kitchen island dogs and tail vise!

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#7

Re: low benches

ThomD

>I do like low benches and have several 4-6 depending on the definition. High benches are practical for some kinds of work though. One thing is what kind of plane one is using, wooden bodied western planes from our colonial past need lower benches than say Japanese ones or ones with thin metal soles. With some planes my fingers are draggin on the work as I go, and for others they may be 4-6 inches above the work. Courses for horses I guess, doesn't pay to oversimplify. There are some real furniture makers who prefer high benches, like Michael Fortune, though I need a lower bench because of all the planing I do.

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#8

Re: right height benches

paul womack

>Bench height needs to suit the work you do.

Simple as that.

BugBear

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#9

So.... Adam, Are you

Parisian, VL

>wearing anything else?

Running and ducking here. hee hee hee

Victor - Gouging my eyes out at the image of someone planing in just a pair of high top basketball shoes.

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#10

"and always remember these, safety glasses."

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>

Re: Nicholson-Cherubini Workbench

#11

Re: "and always remember these, safety glasses."

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Hehe, I always had a thing for Norm and his show.

There was one in particular where Norm used a huge Porter Cable router and a jig to make a mortise for a small cabinet hinge. When he was done, he said "and that is called progress!" Norm is a showman!