Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

Posts

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#26

;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Describes mine exactly.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#27

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

ThomD

>You are probably right about what could be the "normal" one.

"I find it interesting that most users appear to choose a block plane with an eye on end grain, and are then likely proceed to apply it more for face/edge grain (just my assumption)."

The other assumption being that low angle planes aren't suited to general use, which I don't really agree with. I think the whole endgrain thing makes more sense if you are talking about a shop that has 2 planes in it,rather than 200. I come closer to the latter, and have 8 (started at 4 and every time I entered a number I thought of another)block planes for various uses. But a more average consumer may have to rely on the blockplane to span more than one use. Another reason for the endgrain thing is the trim carpenter.

I like the table saw definition, which explains why my super shop isn't likely to make the current shop contest. I got rid of my saw a few years back just because of that. I recently bought 2 table saws of vintage design because they were offered for 20 bucks and 40 bucks, and I couldn't turn them down, Oh woe...

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#28

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I used a block plane when the task is small. They are nice for fitting miters on door and window casing when the dust from a chop saw would be a problem. Otherwise the weight, inertia and ergonomic attributes of a larger plane work better for me. I have both a regular and low angle block and they are the least used planes in the shop.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#29

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>With more thought, I realize that I use my Millers Falls #10 (Stanley 4 1/2 size) for endgrain or I use my LN LA jack. My blocks are used more for trimming and refining, usually on long grain.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#30

Ears burning

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Derek and all,

Derek, this is a great subject to discuss, especially given the ubiquity of the block plane. I appreciate the mention, but it must have been someone else who preferred one block plane over the other. I don't happen to own a block plane, of all things.

This is a great thread though, so I would like add a couple of things. The first harks back to what Warren said about the equivalence of various BU vs. BD configurations. Once you get to 20 degree bedding in a bevel-up plane, an interesting (to me) equivalence occurs. Think about a 50 degree BD plane, honed at 30 degrees included angle, with 20 degrees clearance. Compare that to a 20 degree BU plane with the same 30 degree included blade angle--it is also attacking at 50 degrees. Both planes have the same clearance, the same attack angle, and the same honing angle. So the choice between these two comes down to other factors, such as ergonomics of the plane and whether you would prefer to sharpen a BU iron or a BD iron. A similar equivalence would be between the 20 degree clearance BU plane honed at 25 degrees for a 45 degree attack, with a 45 degree BD plane, also honed at 25 degrees, for a clearance of 20 degrees.

Given these kind of overall equivalences, I'm inclined to decide between them based on ergonomics and sharpening. I prefer sharpening the BD iron, with the critical wear on the bevel side rather than on the back side. Others think that is a minor consideration, I suppose. Ergonomically, even in a small plane, I prefer a small bench plane over a block plane. To take a few examples, Clark & Williams make two small smoothers, one with a 1-1/4" wide blade; one with a 1-5/8" wide blade--I like these specifically because they tend to fill up the hand, so you're not 'pinching' the plane to get a purchase (Warren mentioned his cramped hand). I also like a small Japanese plane, such as a 42 or 48mm. The Japanese plane has enough width that you can pretty accurately judge a chamfer angle; the C&W plane has enough height that you can accurately judge the chamfer also. As a third example, when Konrad Sauer made his small No. 4 (1-7/16" blade width), he scaled it down from a standard No. 4, but with slightly more height than direct scaling would indicate, and that plane also fills up the hand so that it is a small bench plane.

I agree with you totally that my impression is that people use block planes for all sorts of odd jobs, and do not consider them as end-grain specialists. As for end grain, I think a 60 degree Japanese plane is about perfect, because it has pretty good heft, a fairly low angle, and a long registration before the blade hits the wood. But like others, I'm inclined to use the first plane I can reach for this purpose. A 5-1/2 is real good.

Overall, I kinda think that block planes are fantastic for trim carpenters, or anyone doing on site work--it's easy to carry and extremely useful to hit a final lick on something.

My take going into this thread, was that block planes will do a zillion small jobs, but for any given job, there is always a better choice. However, Neal's example of the squirrel tail block plane has turned me around--there seem to be specialty block planes that will do their job better than anything else.

Wiley

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#31

Well said Bill

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>My is a finishing table right now.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#32

Typo?

wilbur

>"As for end grain, I think a 60 degree Japanese plane is about perfect, because it has pretty good heft, a fairly low angle, and a long registration before the blade hits the wood."

60 degrees? That's a fairly steep angle, no? Not to mention that I have no idea where to get a Japanese plane bedded at 60 degrees, other than making one yourself. I know that the HNT Gordon planes are bedded at 60 degrees.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#33

Re: Typo? Yes, a typo! Bad one too.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thank you Wilbur! Had a senior moment. I meant to say a 60 mm Japanese plane. Typically they are bedded in the low 40's, say 42-43 degrees.

Wiley

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#34

Re: Typo? Yes, a typo! Bad one too.

wilbur

>Of course, it now occurs to me that if you skew the heck out of a plane bedded at 60 degrees, it could do a good job on planing endgrain. :@)

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#35

Re: Ears burning

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi Wiley,

Yes, you pinch the hand over a block plane - or you press the palm against the bulb of the cap iron. And then maybe fingers are too long. The grip on a bench plane is far more comfortable.

Nonetheless I see a big advantage on all this. Fingertips are very near to the work. The plane body is compact. There is no wobbling on a high axe. My block planes have cambered irons and it is convincing how direct a touch can be and how precise. Planing end grain, I first reach for a bench plane and adjust squareness with the LA pitched at 42�. I would not use the block plane for coarse work on end grain, but I have one dedicated to this special task.

I don't have a japanese plane, nor a small wooden smoother. So I compare to the bench planes and BU planes (#164 and #62) I have.

Best regards,

Marc

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#36

Re: Typo? Yes, a typo! Bad one too.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Again, thanks for giving me a chance to fix my dumb mistake.

Dean J. did a real nice job using his 55 degree plane. Sharp blade overcomes a lot of theory.

This just in from the Dept. of Extraneous Information.....regarding angles. Specifically, what skewing angle is required to produce a desired effective cutting angle. It depends on the plane's bedding angle. The formula connecting these angles:

tan (effective angle) = cos (skew angle) x tan (bedding angle).

If you do the math, it works out--just like you said--that it takes a heck of a skew to lower the effective cutting angle very much. Would take a 55 degree skewing action to make a 60 degree bedded plane attack at 45 degrees effective.

Wiley

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#37

Re: Typo? Yes, a typo! Bad one too.

Dean J in MN

>Dean J. did a real nice job using his 55 degree plane. Sharp blade overcomes a lot of theory.

I just grabbed the plane out of my toolchest, I have no idea how sharp the blade really was. And, I didn't skew, at least nothing that would be of any real use.

In my shop, not much (if any) endgrain shows, so I'm not looking for a mirror finish. The hunk of wood was an offcut from a drawer side, in that case I'm just looking to correct any miss-cut -- you can't tell from the resolution but the knife marks are still there, the endgrain just needed to be taken down a little bit on one side to correct the wayward cut.

Cheers!

Dean

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#38

Be comforted

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I own three table saws, none of them currently functional: a Rockwell contractor's (that's the most likely to become functional first), a pre-war Delta Milwaukee tilt-table ($60 with a jointer and a 1 hp motor the size and general shape of a prize-winning watermelon), and a similar-vintage Walker-Turner (I think it is) home-owner grade tilt table that may eventually become the use-in-driveway-for-remodel-work saw. IF I had a bigger shop, it'd be tempting to get the Delta running, because it's such a cool-looking saw; but it's hard to fit even one table saw in a shop 11 feet square.

And, fond as I am of hand tools, I do kill electrons.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#39

Maybe I'm doing something wrong

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I find myself gripping my 7" long No. 65 with both hands more often than not. I bought a 60-1/2, thinking I'd resell it (it's got lousy bedding for the iron), but have been grabbing it more and more often for quick chamfering (long grain), because it's a nice one hand plane.

I find it interesting, because I've got fairly long fingers, and am comofortable with a lot of tools than others comment are too large for them.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#40

Re: Low angle for endgrain?

Tony Z.

>Go a step further Warren: How many guys like me, that free hand sharpen know for a fact that a blade is 12 degrees, or 15 degrees or whatever!

I use several low angle blocks regularly, and free hand sharpen the blades. I really don't know what the angles are, but I do know what works!

Tony Z.

Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?

#41

good to see the orange "special" on show

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>and in the middle of the front rank too !!

I'm going to follow this discussion with interest