Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>The usual recommendation for a block plane is to get a low angle type (12 degree) over a standard angle type (20 degrees). The argument for this is that a low cutting angle is the better choice for planing end grain.
LN and LV LA block planes
I have block planes with both bed angles. My favourite is the bronze LN #103, a standard angle. This is a small plane and I also have a larger vintage Stanley #18 Knucklejoint (used with a Japanese laminated blade). These have no difficulty cutting end grain and, although not quite as good in this regard as either the LN or LV LA block planes, they are still excellent in this regard. Standard angle block planes have other advantages that make them a better choice in the end.
In my opinion, a standard angle block plane is a more appropriate choice than a low angle one. Why? Because much of the time a block plane is used for trimming edge and face grain, not end grain. Planing a chamfer, cleaning up a little saw mark, etc. Just how often do you use it to plane end grain? I do use it in this context, but I am more likely to turn to a shooting board if it is possible. The trouble with a low cutting angle is that it is more at risk to cause tear out in face grain than a standard angle.
Some have argued here that they do not even own a block plane but instead simply use a bench plane.
I was using a HNT Gordon block plane the other day (I have it for a review). I needed to trim a Maple door (it had swollen in the damp and no longer fitted the frame). Just a few spots here-and-there. I had not used this plane before. It was just terrific at this task. In earlier times I had wondered where this plane would fit into the scheme of things - it has a 55 degree cutting angle. Clearly end grain is not going to be its forte. So it really makes you think about what you really do with a block plane.
Perhaps we should poll what tasks to which users actually put their block planes?!
A few of the vintage and new block planes I have on hand at present (.. Ok, They are for mini reviews) :)
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#2Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
ThomD
>I prefer whatever is at hand on the bench. If I can find it it's just right. With a low angle plane you can use a steeper blade bevel if you want the high angles. With a high you can reduce bevel somewhat and also skew for the lower angles. It's a toss up. There is the option of planing with the grain if all else fails.
The low blade does make for a smaller plane, and that may help some hands.
I find the little all bronze LN in the second photo is a great plane for size etc... I Hid it somewhere safe when I went on a trip a few years back, and I haven't resurected it since. Otherwise excellent.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#3Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)
>Derek,
I have both the low angle and standard angle block.
I tend to use the Std. angle block as a small one-handed smoother.
I'm not a big fan of changing blades for different applications and like to have the best plane for the job nearby ready to go.
Norman
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#4Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Marc in Luxembourg
>Derek,
Nice little collection of block planes!
I have both models too, two LNs with adjustable mouth. I need the 20� for the last touch on long grain (cambered edge) and the low angle for end grain. They fulfill different tasks on my bench and so each has a pigeonhole in the tool cabinet.
Marc
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#5Definite maybe
Neal in San Jose
>I don't have quite as many as you do, Derek, but I have corralled my share. I tend to tune them for different jobs. I have a LA LN that I keep set for a VERY fine shaving and is my go-to plane for difficult grain, and have even used it as a smoother on occasion. The other end of the range is a wide open Stanley 220 that I use for very rough carpentry, etc. Between those two I have several Stanley and Ohio Tool LA and SA set for different jobs. I also have the LN rabbet block plane that gets used for lots of things other than rabbets if it happens to be the closest to hand. I have a little 101 1/2 (squirrel tail) that I bought because it was "cute", but has proven its worth several times, the latest was leveling out the middle of a pie crust platter after I removed the bulk with a router. I guess my mantra is "whatever works".
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#6What the heck is that painfull looking...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>Orange monstrosity with the screw sticking out of it (Middle of the last photo)?
Nice collection there!
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#7What is a block plane? Adam?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I look at LN's block plane page and find all sorts of planes there. So if you're asking is my LN LAJ better low angle, I have to say the question is nonsensical, it's LA by definition. Same with their mitre plane and LA smoother. Normally when someone talks about block planes, they seem to mean small planes of various sorts. Adam proposed a way out of this particular categorization mess a couple or three years ago in PopWW. He suggested that we characterize planes according to function rather than shape.
I have very few "block" planes, the LAJ and a LN 140, and don't feel more are necessary. However I have lots of little Japanese planes that look like block planes, but probably aren't, and they were purchased/made to perform specific funcions; so the ones that needed to be low angle are, etc.
Pam
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#8Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
wilbur
>Hmm. I have a low angle block plane. I use it pretty much only for planing endgrain. For trimming edge and face grain, I use a Japanese plane. Sometimes I'll just skew the Japanese plane to deal with endgrain when I'm on a roll, like when I'm cleaning up a dovetail.
So although a standard angle block plane may be best overall, to say that either a low angle or standard angle is better really depends on what and how you are using it in relation to the other tools you have.
If you only really have to choose between a low angle and standard angle block plane, I think having one block plane is better than not having one at all. :@)
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#9Low angle for endgrain?
Dean J in MN
>Hmm -- Here is a photo of endgrain I cleaned up with my smoother, pitched at 55 degrees. White pine, and as smooth as can be. I'm not so sure you need a block plane... Traditional bench planes work just fine on endgrain.
-Dean
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#10Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
ThomD
>Makes sense, but since the question was which then you have to choose, though not in real life.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#11Some of the smoothest end grain I've ever planed
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>was with a box stock Wards Master Bailey-type No. 4. The extra mass over a "block" plane helps.
It was years before I thought to do this, because ALL the books say you have to have a low-angle plane for end grain.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#12A tool you can't find is no tool at all
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>"I Hid it [LN block plane] somewhere safe when I went on a trip a few years back, and I haven't resurected it since."
Or, putting it in general terms, �Better to have it and not need it than to need it and not have it�better yet to have it and be able to find it.�
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#13Re: Low angle for endgrain?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>It seems that everyone involved in plane discussions on this forum can calculate that a 20* block plane sharpened at 30* acts like a bench plane at 50*, (or a 12* block like 42*). A generation ago, many could not see this. I often had people tell me that a block plane should be used for endgrain because it was 25 (or 33) degrees lower than a bench plane. And they thought you were nuts if you tried to explain. As I recall, this error was even printed in Fine Woodworking. I think the block plane for endgrain convention comes from this time.
One day around 1976, I was planing the endgrain of a thick piece of maple with a block plane and my hand got a little crampy. I thought "something is wrong here, this is too much work". I switched to my smoothing plane and have not used a block plane at all since.
Dean, my guess is that you will get a little better clarity on your end grain at a lower angle.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#14Re: What the heck is that painfull looking... *LINK*
Bob Demers
>Ah well, that would be the infamous orange block plane which belong to Derek's son and that he reviewed here :-)
Bob, back from an awesome Paul McCartney concert in Qu�bec city last nite
Orange plane review
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#15Re: A tool you can't find is no tool at all
ThomD
>I think it is curently functioning as that foundation required to support the working part of my hoard.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#16Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX
>I've never understood why people don't use higher angle blades on a standard block instead of a low angle one. 20 degrees + 35 degree blade is 55 degrees with the blade angle not as tough to push as a 42 degree angle (13 + 42 = 20 + 35). I can see why Veritas sets up their low angle plane for all the extras. One buys one plane that can be used for low angle all the way up to full pitch. To answer your original question, yes I think a standard pitch block is very useful and handles end grain just fine in most cases. I do use my block more for trimming with the grain.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#17Does that mean
Dan Donaldson
>That I don't have a tablesaw anymore? I know that there is one in my shop, but haven't been able to find it in awhile. There is a pile in the middle of the shop about the right shape. Does that count? ;-)
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#18Re: What is a block plane? Adam?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Pam
You raise a couple of interesting issues. The definition of a block plane may be used to cover a range of planes, of different sizes, that have in common a low angle or bevel up configuration. This is outside the colloquial useage of a block plane, which we tend to refer to those planes that are around 6" or under. Typically they are bevel up, but not necessarily low angle, and the rules here are broken in both areas, for example, by HNT Gordon.
I have a plane that might just as well fit the block plane category, but it is not a block plane. This is my little Mujingfang mini smoother (another is the HNT Gordon Palm Smoother). These are short (3") high angle (60 degrees) smoothers. They make wonderful planes for breaking edges and chamfering, and I'd feel safer using this than most low angle block planes as the latter may well tear out the grain.
I think that your point is that function precedes form.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#19Re: Low angle for endgrain?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>One day around 1976, I was planing the endgrain of a thick piece of maple with a block plane and my hand got a little crampy. I thought "something is wrong here, this is too much work". I switched to my smoothing plane and have not used a block plane at all since.
Hi Warren
Your story reminds me of the one that is intwined with my original post here.
Anout 8 or 9 years ago I decided to splash out on a decent block plane, an upgrade on my LA Stanley #60 1/2. I remembered all the praise heaped on the bronze LN #102, a low angle block plane, and so I went off to buy one on a rainy Friday afternoon after work. Dashed into the store, grabbed the last one on the shelf, paid and beat the rain home. I spend a very happy weekend using my new LA block plane, and was in wonder at its ability to slice endgrain so cleanly and easily. Over the years I would show off this little wonder to my friends.
A couple of years ago I came across an auction on eBay (in Oz) for a brand new adjustable mouth LA LN #60 1/2. I had always fancied this plane. It felt right in my hand (I prefer a smaller plane, so the Stanley #65 and the LV are just that bit too large for comfort). And Lyn Mangiameli had referred to it as the "worlds best". It went for about a third of the new price so was a very happy camper. Shortly after it came to live in the woodshop I was comparing a couple of block planes side-by-side (isn't this what we do? :) ). It struck me that the bed angle of the #102 was not the same as the #60 1/2. So I took a closer look. And lo' and behold - !!! - the #102 was not really a #102 at all, but a #103! Teach me not to wear my reading glasses for the small print. A standard angle plane had been cutting end grain so well all those years! And that popped the myth for me.
LA block plane do cut end grain better - smoother - but standard angle can do a most acceptable job, and have other advantages as well. Indeed, for years I used an HNT Gordon Trying plane on my shooting board.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#20Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Marc
Only a few are mine. Most are on loan for review purposes.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#21Short term memory....
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>Loss. I remember the evil one now..
Nasty lill'l critter.
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#22Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
paul womack
>Derek - I am surprised at this post.
You have often (in previous posts and reviews) cited the versatility of low bedding angle, bevel up planes.
The versatility comes from the fact that effective pitch can be modified by either altering the bevel angle on the blade, or having more than one blade.
Consequent to this, a low (bedding) angle block plane can do all that a standard (bedding) angle block plane can do - it's a functional superset.
BugBear
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#23Function precedes form?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Not really, since usually form defines function, it's more a categorization issue. My question is what type of planes are you talking about? 3" long? That's too big a category to compare within, there are too many different types of planes that are about 3" long.
Pam
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#24Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi BB
I agree with you - that was the underlying point of my original post. It is not the bed angle of the plane that is important, rather the cutting angle that is used.
I find it interesting that most users appear to choose a block plane with an eye on end grain, and are then likely proceed to apply it more for face/edge grain (just my assumption).
The point is moot if you have more than one block plane, but I suspect that this is but a minority of users. A block plane with a low bed and bevel up configuration is a very flexible beast. I think that it was Wiley who noted that the LA block plane has the lower profile, and that this is more comfortable in the hand. I agree, so my choice would be to buy a second LA, and hone it at a higher angle for face grain. Or at least have a second blade. But, if you are only to have one, the better choice for all round use would be the higher cutting angle.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Standard or LA block plane? Which is best?
#25A definition of the word "tablesaw" in most shops
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Tablesaw: a small, metal-topped workbench and/or storage surface at a convenient working height with, for unknown reasons, a round pointy thing under the top surface and an electric motor somewhere on it. From "table" (common meaning) and "saw" (as in, "I saw the surface when I brought it into the shop")
Very similar to "desk," except desks are usually lower and don't have motors.



