Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

I have a question

Posts

I have a question

#1

I have a question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Here is a picture of Moxon's Workbench and while Mercer and Holtzapffel don't explain the devise on the left front edge of the bench. It is marked 'f' in the engraving.

It is in the location of the jam cleat or arrest, and could possibly be one, but the hand screw on the underside has me curious.

Anyone know what it is?

Stephen


img

Re: I have a question

#2

Re: I have a question

Dean J in MN

>Stephen,

I've always interpreted that as a hand screw through the crochet/jam cleat -- sort of a primitive shoulder vise. Granted, it would be a weak construction, so there is doubt in my mind that it is configured like that. Very hard to tell from the plate. The text is what lead me to believe it was a simple vise:


"...and then the other edge of the Board is set upon Pin or Pins (if the Board be so long as to reach the other Leg) put into the Holes marked 'a a a a' down the legs of the Bench; which Pin or Pins may be removed into the higher or lower holes, as the breadth of the Board shall require: So then, the Bench-screw keeps the Board close to the edge of the Bench, and the Pins in the Legs keep it to its height..."


What is confusing is the question if Moxon is talking about the little hand screw on the left, or the twin screws on the right. He later speaks of the twin screws on the right:


"Sometimes a double Screw is fixed to the side of the bench, as at g..."

So it seem odd he would call them two different things at different points in the description of the bench. Which leads me back to thinking that screw on the left is a simple way of keeping the board from tipping when in the front hook. In practice however, I don't have that issue with my bench, so I'm not sure why one would require such a screw.

Cheers!

-Dean

Re: I have a question

#3

A guess.

Parisian, VL

>Could it be the peg for the holes a a a a is threaded and this is where the the peg is stored so that worker doesn't bang his leg/knee/shin into it repeatedly during the course of the day, but still can find it when needed.

Just a wag.

Victor - already got the A/C going in the shop.

Re: I have a question

#4

Re: A guess.

Dean J in MN

>VIctor --

I had that as a guess as well. But, I store my peg in the leg just below the front crochet and have never hit it with my leg. It is really "out of play" when left in the leg. But, still a valid idea.

Anyone have Moxon's email address, we should just ask... :)

-Dean

Re: I have a question

#5

Maybe?

Ron Bauman

>http://books.google.com/books?id=dDbKtdJAZU4C&pg=PA12&lpg=PA12&dq=moxon+workbench&source=web&ots=6eUkurNyfE&sig=iS9r1eRq8DMw3d_esRDNcOH9ZUA&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=9&ct=result#PPA12,M1

Re: I have a question

#6

I can't get that to work?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: I have a question

#7

Arrest/stop is not cited by Moxon; my best guess

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Stephen and all,

One of the problems we have here, is that the crochet is not recognized in any way by Moxon. What we call the crochet, and what the previous French text on these pages called the 'arrete' (stop or arrest)--is not mentioned by Moxon in the text of his book, nor is it labeled on the graphic. If you look at the key of Plate 4, toward the back of Moxon, 'f' refers to 'The Table', i.e., the benchtop.

Also, at the end of the text on 'Joinery', Moxon glosses his terms in a long list. Within this list, he glosses both 'bench screw' and 'double screw', and keys both terms to item 'g' on the plate. In the text, he further distinguishes the double screw by saying it is sometimes "fixed to the side of the bench, as at 'g', or sometimes its farther cheek is laid an edge upon the flat of the bench, and fastened with an holdfast, or sometimes, two on the bench." Given this latter detail, I suspect what is 'double' about the double screw is the use of two jaws, not the use of two screws. Thus, a bench screw which is not 'double', which is Moxon's base case, would be a single jaw and two screws.

So here is my speculation, from all the evidence:

1. The crochet does not exist in Moxon's scheme. He is simply stuck with the arrete, because he is using the Felibien graphic. The single screw, which appears to run through the crochet, is serving as a 'pin'. Yes, I know that single screw is labeled 'c', as are the screws on the bench screw, but it makes more sense that it is serving as a pin. (This is the weakest part of my argument).

2. The terms 'bench screw' and 'double screw' both refer to the vise at the right side of the bench. He illustrates the double screw, but expects us to understand that the ordinary (single) bench screw would have just the one jaw, with two screws through it. Moxon refers to the bench screw being on its 'hither side', which I take to be the near side for a right-handed joiner as he sets up to edge joint. I say this because he contrasts the 'hither' side, with the 'other edge of the board', which would clearly refer to the off-end of the board to be edge jointed.

The above interpretation would fit the picture of a right-handed joiner edge jointing his board by planing away from the vise and having the 'other' end of the board supported by the single screw serving as a pin. He is choosing to ignore the crochet, perhaps because he does not witness its use in the English workplace, though it is clearly shown in the French graphic.

Speculative yes. But if the above is not right, then I think we are left with confusion or a mismatch between what Moxon says in the text and what he shows in Plate 4.

Wiley

Re: I have a question

#8

Re: I have a question

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Dear Stephen,

in my opinion, the engravings done for Moxon must be taken very lightly. Many of the engravings used by Moxon are copied from F�libien's engravings (France) and modified. Moreover, the engravings appear as reversed. So the bench is a French bench modified with a Twin screw vise. The twin screw vise as illustrated in Moxon's book does not make any sense and would not either for a craftsman. The Vise has two jaws and one is not even flush with the table of the bench and yet, Moxon is describing that its use is to keep it against the bench.

Moxon was a chronicler and used images from engravings he probably did not fully understand. My guess is that he was working with F�libien's engravings while trying to render what he saw. So he probably recognized the bench built like a French bench and witnessed the use of Twin screw vises on them.

The crochet is not mentioned but illustrated and that thing we see on the left does not make any sense. Moxon's words are closer to what we can expect: pins used in the leg holes to stay a board at the right height.

Incidentally, I just received Tools: Working wood in 18th Century America by James Gaynor and on page 35 there is a photo of the inside of a tool chest done with exquisite inlays, 1790, picturing a cabinetmaker (the text says its a Joiner but I would like to see the evidence as this representation of the maker's trade could be cabinetmaking) and what I am seeing is a simple bench like the French and a Twin screw vise. The tankard of beer he is holding is most interesting, I should say! A very gifted Joiner but I feel more comfortable imagining a cabinetmaker building that chest but I am purely speculating and Jane Rees is a far more experienced scholar than I am.

Re: I have a question

#9

Re: Arrest/stop is not cited by Moxon; my best gue

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

Moxon glosses over items probably from familiarity, as he was also a mathematical instrument maker, besides a printer, so he knew the trade and the tools. There is something at the corner of 'f' and the hand screw underneath although lettered, the threads are the opposite direction, this may be in the engraving, which is reversed.

As for a threaded hand screw used for a peg, I have my doubts. The early French work has perspective problems that I don't think occur in Moxon's work.

And the big two hand screw vise is not permanently attached, I can see how it can be held on top of the bench with a holdfast, but I wonder how it was affixed to the front of the bench? With both jaws of the vise in front of the front of the bench, the supporting pegs would have to be extra long.

Stephen

Re: I have a question

#10

Glossing over from familiarity

wilbur

>I can't say that I am an expert on Moxon or the state of woodworking in the 1600's, but I do know cooking. If you look at older cookbooks and recipes from, say, the 1940's and 1950's, you'll often find instructions that read along the lines of, "Make a pan sauce from the drippings." Today, that part of the recipe would include:

1. Pouring the excess oil out of the pan, leaving the brown crusty bits left over from cooking.

2. Adding fresh oil or butter and sauteeing finely chopped onions/garlic/shallots in the pan.

3. Deglazing the pan with some wine/stock/water/other liquid to dissolve the brown crusty bits.

4. Adding some acidic element like wine, tomato sauce, or lemon juice if the deglazing process did not include it.

5. Thickening the sauce with some flour or cornstarch if desired.

6. Strain the sauce, or not, depending on what you want.

All of this was common knowledge a few generations ago. Today, it has to be spelled out. So it wouldn't surprise me if Moxon left out descriptions of things that were common knowledge back in the day. (I really should read Moxon's book someday.)

By the way, if you do the above steps for any dish you cook in a pan, it will completely change the way you look at cooking.

Re: I have a question

#11

Re: Arrest/stop is not cited by Moxon; my best gue

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Stephen,

Maybe the Felibien original would be of some assistance. However, I can't find it in the archives. I thought either you or Don McConnell had posted it in the past year, but I can't locate it now. Do you have it? I'd particularly like to see if that singleton screw at the left edge of the bench (near the crochet) is in Felibien, or if Moxon added it himself.

Wiley

Re: I have a question

#12

Re: Arrest/stop is not cited by Moxon; my best gue

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

I don't know who posted it but here it is again.

Stephen


img