Sargent plane question
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>Any guess as to what the price range is for a Sargent VBM 407C with 90% japaning and an unrepaired crack in the original tote?
Robin
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Sargent plane question
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>Any guess as to what the price range is for a Sargent VBM 407C with 90% japaning and an unrepaired crack in the original tote?
Robin
#2 size planes are pretty hot
Neal in San Jose
>I checked the 'bay, and they had 4 completed sales in the last month. Two went for $145, one went for $100, and a parts plane went for $50. The two at $145 were pretty nice, no breaks in the wood, but not "C". I'd deduct a little for the broken wood, but the "C" may make up for most of that. I'd guess between $100 and $140. If you are lucky enough to get a "bidding war" going, then all bets are off.
Re: Sargent plane question
Bob Demers
>According to David Heckel book: Sargent plane identification and value guide, the avg price for a 407C would be US $400-800.
That price range is given according to the fine tool journal condition classification of a condition 75% (good) to 95% (fine).
Your description with the defects listed put it in the fair category, depending on the severity and location of the crack (could be even lower)
Long passed over by collectors for Stanley everything, Sargent are making strong comeback. They are also excellent users.
Bob, vacation over back, to work, sigh!
Re: OUPS Sargent plane question
Bob Demers
>OUPS, I missread the crack location, I tought it was on the plane body. The crack tote only, could make it higher than fair, with an increase in value.
The only problem is that not everyone use the same condition grading system, nr interpret it the same.
Bottom line is it usuable, and/or in 'show' condition.
Bob, sipping his morning coffee
Re: Sargent plane question
Jay Hanks
>I picked up a #2 sized sargent last year at a flea market for 80.00. A nice smooth bottom complete with paint splatters at no extra charge. The guy I bought it from also had a #2 Stanley but I could not afford both, he wanted to make a deal.
Re: Sargent plane question
Todd Hughes
>With out the crack I would expect to sell the thing on the ebay for $175 or so. Maybe even $200 or more if talked up well.If it is a crack that can be glued so doesn't look bad or stand out maybe wont affect the price to much...lets guess $25 or so. If a bad ugly crack could be alot. Will not be easy to find good original wood for this plane
In my experance these Sargent no. 2 are more common to find corrugaited then Stanley no. 2 Corrugaited planes. I think I have two of them including one I paid $5 for at a flea market
In my experance selling more then a few No. 2 Stanley planes unless they are near mint [and even then probably still true] you will get much more for them by breaking them up and selling them as parts. Think last no. 2 I parted out brought me about $350....never would have done that if sold as a complete plane. Don't see me selling any complete no. 2 planes again....Might be the same with a Sargent maybe even more so because thier parts are even harder to find. ...Todd
Like Todd said :-)
Bob Demers
>Very true, you often get more money for the parts than the complete item.
Thats because, there are lots of planes (or tools) out there to be had for a cheap bargain price because they are either incomplete or have broken parts. There is of course a very limited supply of original parts to pick from, hence the high prices these parts command.
In the end its cheaper to buy a good example of a plane complete than to buy a project plane and hunt the parts required. DAMHIKT :-)
And lastly, anyone, if you have such a frankenstein plane for resale, please be upfront about the replaced or repaired parts.
Bob