Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

fitting dovetails question...

Posts

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#26

Re: Do I understand correctly?

James Watriss

>Planing the inside of the board... now THAT is an ingenious idea.

I balked a bit at the idea of the baseline work, because it sounded like you were talking about rescribing, and cutting in some more. Your clarification made sense... I can't remember many, if any DTs where there wasn't a gap that needed to be worked out at the bottom.

Well played...

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#27

that opens a new way of thinking

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Without going into a lot of verbiage....I get it.

By diddling with the orientation of the pin board when I align it for scribing I can do the compensation that will allow me to keep the scribe mark for reference when sawing the pins. In fact I was erring in the wrong direction on this orientation which made the pins doubly tight.

Thanks.. you are right. I have never seen this aspect discussed.

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#28

Re: that opens a new way of thinking

Adam Cherubini

>Experience just tells you how to saw. I use the baseline to line everything up then I mark. I use the awl end of my striking knife, then I usually darken that line with a pencil. If I saw out the line, I get a good fit. But you can see how if you put a .005" feeler gauge down between every tail, then brought the pin board to that, you may need to leave the line. In general, I think the fit is very sensitive to that baseline. That's why I say you could just run between the tails with a saw file and you'd make an appreciable change.

Trying to take a uniform shaving off of the angled surfaces of the pins with a chisel just seems like a fools errand to me. Unless you remark, it's difficult to know how much you've taken or where.

Adam

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#29

Re: that opens a new way of thinking

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"Trying to take a uniform shaving off of the angled surfaces of the pins with a chisel just seems like a fools errand to me. Unless you remark, it's difficult to know how much you've taken or where. "

Been there, done that and could not agree more.

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#30

Re: that opens a new way of thinking

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I had to chuckle about the "new way of thinking". Perhaps it is not old fashioned 20th century thinking.

Occasionally one pin is cut a little sloppily and in that case paring is the best option. Usually you can pick out the offending pin by inspecting the marked surface. If not, I usually start at one corner easing the joint together shallowly one pin at a time until one gets hung up.

At one time blanket chests were very popular and I made about 25 white oak chests and 70 white pine chests in a three year period. As far as I could tell, I was sawing them the same. I would say that one does not really factor in differences in compressibility when sawing.

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#31

Look Ma! no gaps

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>While this tip from Adam will not be useful to professional that get their joints perfect right from the saw, novices like myself may find it useful. Hence, I wanted to post its success.

Because the pins were uniformly tight, a swipe of the plane on the back of the pin board resulted in the chest end slipping satisfyingly into the tail board, where before it would not go. Also, because I always layout so the pins are recessed before finish planing, this adjustment had no other adverse effects. No fixin' required for this joint. On to fitting the domed lid..............

Note: I chose to end this side piece with a half tail. Not sure what trunk makers do, but I think it looks better than a half pin in this application.

Note: the strange spacing at one end is where the lid will be sawed off after assembly, yielding 2 half tails. This way the lid will be guaranteed to fit. I like to avoid risk in these matters.


img

Re: fitting dovetails question...

#32

Great outcome, Bill! And huge

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>kudos to Adam for his outstanding insight and suggestion. I daresay a few hundred of us learned something from this thread.

Wiley