Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Posts

Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#1

Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Victor Parisian

>I'm making Chris Swartz's version of the Roubo bench. I have 4 each 8' x 4.5" x (approx)5.5" glued up pieces jointed and squared ready for the final glue ups. I'm thinking I will glue two of these together at a time and then make a final glue up of the resulting two pieces into a bench top that will be 24" wide and 4.5" thick. (yes I know the math doesn't quite work, so I have two additional pieces 8'x4.5"x1.25" I'll add to this as faces either in the first glue up or as a final glue up.

The question is in the use of glueing cauls. I recall reading somewhere that the cauls should have a slight bow to them so that when under pressure in the clamps they will flatten out and give even clamping pressure over their length.

Any suggestions from this vast resource of knowledge? How many cauls? How thick? How wide? etc.

Victor - back to work in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#2

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Mark Salomon

>I just finished glueing up a maple workbench top and I'd recommend that you follow Bob Lang's advice and use biscuits to align the boards. It really simplifies things and removes the problem of getting the two boards aligned (no whaling at it with a dead blow hammer). If you use clamping cauls (I'm not sure that they're even needed if you glue everything up by twos before hand) then about 1/32 or so of a taper should work.

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#3

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am not sure I understand, but assuming you mean to put the cauls between the clamp faces and the lumber to be glued and not on top to prevent deflections........I never use cauls for any glue up except thin strips to avoid denting lumber with the clamp face. I have never seen cauls used in a furniture factory assembling panels. What you are assembling is so stiff I can not imagine any benefit from cauls on the clamp faces. As far as cauls on top to mash things into alignment, I don't find this step necessary if care is taken in assembling the joints. But then I use bar clamps , not pipe, and bars don't bend under load.

I would have assembled this top some different. Depending on the width of the boards I would have either glued them one at a time to make the 24" assembly or I would have assembled enough width to just go through a thickness planer and planed the assembly to final thickness. Presuming one has at least a 12" planer, that would have left just one final joint to be made. It is not hard to get one joint perfect just by diddling with the two pieces to get them to mate perfect, or nearly so. Best of all would have been to glue the whole thing and take it to a cabinet shop with a big machine that would surface 24" all at once.

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#4

This is kind of theoretical, but...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As I understand it, the purpose of curving (cambering) the cauls is to exert greater force on the middle of the boards being glued up. One assumption in this, I think, is that the stiffness of the caul is greater than, or at least competitive with, the stiffness of the board being glued up, so that, as the caul is forced straight by the clamps, it pushes harder at the center of its length and thus clamps the boards harder in the center.

You're talking about gluing up 8" x 4.5" boards - what kind of cauls are you using that will be strong enough to overcome the stiffness of these boards?

Perhaps better is to figure out how many clamps you're going to use. I've seen references in several articles to the idea that the clamping force spreads out at 45 degrees from the clamp, and that you need enough clamps that the 45 degree cones of force* intersect at the glueline.

That's a lot of clamps, but clamps consisting of boards across both faces of the benchtop, fastened to boards across both edges, with folding wedges (two wedges of equal taper, sliding past each other to present a flat face to the clamp and the benchtop), would give you inexpensive clamps that you could space as closely as you could manage to get in and drive the wedges (presumably, you could alternate the edges on which you drove the wedges for more room).

*No, that's not a reference to "Get Smart." That was a cone of silence.

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#5

not my advice *LINK*

Bob Lang

>I don't know where I recommended using biscuits for alignment for a bench top . I didn't bother on the top I just glued up,can't remember the last time I used them in a solid wood top and I think it would be a waste of time and effort.

I don't think the cauls should be necessary either. The secret to gluing up a good top is to have good parts and a level surface to assemble them on. A wood handscrew at each end will keep things from sliding around. If you have to force the parts into alignment you're in trouble-either now or a few years down the road. Get things straight to begin with and it's pretty easy.

More comments and some pictures on the Popular Woodworking blog at the link below. I'll try to add some pictures of the top assembly process in the next day or two.

Bob (hold the biscuits but pass the gravy) Lang


Bob's Bench on the PopWood blog

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#6

Re: not my advice

Mark Salomon

>Very sorry for incorrectly attributing advice given by Gary Rogowski to you. I believe that Gary was recommending using biscuits for difficult glue-ups like a tabletop or a workbench top not because it adds any strength--it doesn't--but simply because it controls the bad habit that boards have of sliding around when glued and put under pressure. Using biscuits simply makes the glue-up a little easier. I agree that the past practice of controlling this creep by splining the boards was probably overkill and not worth the time; however, since the time involved in putting a few biscuits in is almost insignificant I think that it is worthwhile and leads to a much easier job.

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#7

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Chuckb

>I just finished my version of Chris's great french bench last night, and I frickin love it. I used #20 biscuits 1 1/2" down from the top, one on each end for each board in the top, and in the legs. It took 19 boards to make the top (beautiful stuff from the local lumber yard) all from 2 x 10 x 10 stock and the biscuits were a great help in gluing the top. It was 4 sections of 4 boards and one group of three. I used my Pittsburgh f-clamps and it went fine. I wouldn't worry about clamps anyway so much as your ability to butter the boards quick. Good luck and get ready to do some choppin! If I get a chance later I'll post some pics, but I need to make up some time with my wife..

chuckbeck

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#8

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Chuckb

>Here's a photo with the thing behind it moving on out.


img

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#9

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've been wondering about how useful it is to have both a crochet and leg vise right next to each other. Do you ever use the crochet?

Pam

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#10

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Victor Parisian

>Hi Bill, Just a 6" long bed jointer with so-so blades and a 13" Ryobi planer with fresh blades so all sub assemblies were no more than 6". I'm doing this out of construction lumber - 2x12x16 SYP from the borg, so several of the boards had some issues to put it mildly. All sub assemblies are (for now)nice and straight and square. My son "Norm" came over Sunday and helped put those through the jointer and planer. They form a real nice stack.

I'm mostly concerned with getting the alienment as close to perfect as possible to minimize the hand work with the jointer plane at the end. This because I experienced some significant tearout in spots where the grain reverses while cleaning off glue. I have paid a lot of attention to grain directions as I was gluing up and I still get the tearout.

Victor

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#11

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Victor Parisian

>Thansk for the post. B'golly that's it. I'm having a lot of fun putting mine together. Bisquets may be the answer. I'll post a few pics and let you see how it turns out.

What did you use for the draw bore pins?

Victor - in hot and humid Houston

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#12

Corey Megal

Crochet

Corey Megal

>Pam, I just finished my bench a few months ago, and I find the crochet useful. It hasn't gotten in the way yet, and when I am edge planing, the board is rock solid. It was easy to add, and if I ever need to, it can be removed easily.

Corey

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#13

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Pam,

I'm wondering how the name "crochet" originated? Must be a better way to describe that thing. Maybe because it's in the shape of the hook end of a crochet needle?

Marv

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#14

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

Dean J in MN

>Crochet be bois means "wooden hook" in french. Seems a good description as any for the hook made of wood. :)

-Dean

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#15

Where did the word Crochet come from...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>that is a new one to me, I thought they were called jamb cleats?

Stephen

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#16

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from... *LINK*

Dean J in MN

>http://colet.uchicago.edu/cgi-bin/getobject_?a.139:7./projects/artflb/databases/artfl/encyclopedie/IMAGE/

Plate IX and description --

70. �tabli portant en A un valet, B B le dessus de l'�tabli, C C, &c. les pi�s, D D, &c. les traverses, E une petite planche retenant les outils, F les ou - tils, G un trou quarr�, perc� dans l'�tabli, H un tampon, un crochet, & K un arr�te - bois clou� sur l'�tabli.


http://colet.uchicago.edu/cgi-bin/getobject_?a.139:7./projects/artflb/databases/artfl/encyclopedie/IMAGE/

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#17

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dean,

Thank you for that link, do you know the date of the publication, is it really from the early 1700's?

Stephen

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#18

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...------W

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Dean et al.,

So if I'm reading Planche IX correctly, it is saying that the 'crochet' is the bench hook or planing stop, H, on the top of the bench, which is tapped up and down with a mallet. Item K, the thing we have been calling a 'crochet', Planche IX calls 'un arrete'--a stop.

Is that what it looks like to you?

Wiley

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#19

Re: Crochet

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Corey, I was thinking that the leg vise would get in the way of using the crochet and that it might make more sense to put the crochet on one end and the leg vise on the other. That way the leg vise could clamp a long piece jammed into the crochet for planing.

Pam

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#20

That is how I read it Wiley...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>but I don't know a lot of French. The hook (H) appears to be what Mercer calls a Catch (Moxon also), set in a tampion or square wooden plug (dog) in the bench, and adjustable.

Stephen

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#21

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...------W

Dean J in MN

>Yes, that plate and description does seem that way to me as well. I'm trying to find the plate that Chris S. recently translated. A lot of good, he has the translated english version! I'm pretty sure the french there describes the front hook as the crochet de bois. I can never find stuff when I need it, I need to keep my notes a bit more organized!

-Dean

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#22

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...

Dean J in MN

>I'm not sure of the date, looks to be somewhere between 1723 and 1765 from the front text.

-Dean

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#23

Re: That is how I read it Wiley... *LINK*

Dean J in MN

>Yes, the hook there seems to describe the metal hook, with teeth, set into the wooden stop.

From Chris's Roubo translation:



"At the top of this stop we place an iron hook, which has teeth similar to those of a saw, to hold the wood in place that we work on."



http://blog.lostartpress.com/CategoryView,category,Roubo%2BTranslation.aspx

Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#24

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...------W

Dean J in MN

>Ah, found it:



"Roubo' bench has a large bench stop (boete) or hook (crochet); a wooden hook (crochet de bois) screwd to the front left edge of the bench; and an optional leg vise (presse)."

The Workbench Book, page 19 -- Landis


Re: Glueing up the bench top this week (longish)

#25

Re: Where did the word Crochet come from...------W

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dean, et al

Here is the text: '& K un arr�te - bois clou� sur l'�tabli.', now that is a 'wooden arrest nailed to the bench', not a hook (crochet) or catch. That is my best dyslexic French translation.

Stephen