Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

historical joint question

Posts

historical joint question

#1

historical joint question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been reading inventories of cabinet shops from Chester Co PA, well not a lot at any one setting. Incredibly, someone searched the estate and bankruptcy records of the court house (which are complete, no fires etc) and compiled inventories of cabinet shops through about 1850.

It is interesting to see what they had, or didn't. (Lathes were expensive) What I don't see are clamps.

So, were edge joints made without clamps, rubbed or whatever?

There is a hidden agenda here. The staves for the trunk lid can not be clamped with typical edge gluing pressure for yellow glue.

Re: historical joint question

#2

Re: historical joint question

Dean J in MN

>Good question Bill.

In my shop the only real use I have for clamps is for panel glue-ups. Otherwise I have little need for clamps with hide glue and M&T or dovetail construction. So, I could see a shop with very few clamps, especially compared to a modern shop with the "You can never have too many clamps" ideal. On the other hand -- were clamps just so mundane they weren't mentioned in inventories?

No question you can rub joint an edge joint, and I would think it would be the best way to deal with a situation like yours. That said, I have trouble with rub joints for panel glue-ups. I use rub joints for glue blocks and the like without any issue. I asked the guys at Williamsburg how they did it, did they add urea to the glue, or some other magic? Nope, they stack the pieces face-to-face, quickly run the glue brush down the edges (which are atop on another), flip the boards open and clamp. Yes, clamp. There are a few wooden clamps hanging in the shop. The nice thing about hide glue and a little spring in your joint is you really only need one clamp in the middle. Or maybe three on a big piece. And you don't have to develop the clamp pressure you need for yellow glue. I've been trying this method in my shop, using unmodified hot hide glue and working fast. Jury is out so far.

Probably doesn't answer your question, but my 2 cents anyway.

-Dean

Re: historical joint question

#3

Re: historical joint question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

You are just going to have to bit the bullet and use hide glue. Either the hot or liquid version will do the job just fine, really, give it a try. I have heard about your aversion to hide glue and would like to take this opportunity to encourage you to give it a try, you will be pleasently surprised.

Stephen

Re: historical joint question

#4

pinch dogs

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>This is the type of joint that pinch dogs are ideal for. It is a bit of an aquired skill to keep a joint allined while hammering in a dog. one trick is to drive a couple of small wire nails in the edge of one of the boards and nip the heads off close to the surface. this will leave a litle spike that will help hold the other board while you drive the pinch dogs. the disadvantage here is that there is a wire nail in the joint if it ever needs to be ripped apart. the second trick is to use a wire nail toenailed on the end.

When using pinch dogs you need to allow about an inch on each end that will be cut off to get rid of the holes left by the dogs. If this is not an option you can cut small tapered pegs and plug the holes. Of course if the ends will not be visable then there is no need to hide the holes.

Robin

Re: historical joint question

#5

See any striking knives? Marking Gauges?

Adam Cherubini

>Those inventories only included items of worth. They aren't full listings. It's typical to find items we know were there, like gauges, or saw horses, skipped.

Clamps may have consisted of beam and wedges. The Dominy shop is probably a better example of what was there.

Certainly clamps in a preindustrial shop were probably used to hold things being worked on, not to hold things being glued. Modern woodworkers, using slippery white glue and then screws really need clamps in ways preindustrial woodworkers didn't.

Re: historical joint question

#6

typical inventory

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>John Baily shop, 1797. I don't know what some of this stuff is.

1 lathe $10

hand saw 1.50

1 tenant and 1 compass saw .75

1 hand ads and howel .75

1 drawing knife .37

1 iron square and 1 compass.75

12 chisels and gouges 1.50

1 glue pot .25

10 moulding plains 1.50

6 plains 1.50

1 froe .25

6 shell augers 1.50

1 screw do (?!) .50

2 wimblebits and 2 gimlets 1.00

1 turkey stone.50

1 hand vice two screw plates and 1 brass square 1.50

5 large screw plates 1.50 (what are these?)

1 lot files .50

1 claw and 1 riviting hammer.50

1 nest of crusibles .12

1 back band .75

1 branding iron .25

1 hand screw 2.50 what is this pricey thing?

1 lot gold leaf .40

This inventory is typical of the tools. Most of the others have lumber listed also- pine, walnut, poplar and occasionally mahogany.

Another has a "lundastan stone".

Re: historical joint question

#7

I think a screw plate

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>is a thread-cutting die.

Re: historical joint question

#8

'do' is ditto

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: historical joint question

#9

In 1997 screws were expensive

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>Bill asked:

1 hand screw 2.50 � what is this pricey thing?

It's my understanding that until about 1850 (or so) all screws were cut by hand (with a file?) and hence expensive

Re: historical joint question

#10

my sloppy fingers, the year should be 1797

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>

Re: historical joint question

#11

Re: typical inventory

Dean J in MN

> 1 hand screw 2.50 what is this pricey thing?

The clamp, it was hiding in plain sight all along! :)

I'm guessing this is a large hand screw, I have a big hand screw I made, used more to hold things while I work on them, not a glue up clamp.

I don't have a photo handy, Adam, do you have a pic of your large hand screws?

-Dean

Re: historical joint question

#12

No one has asked if you're willing to

Chuck Nickerson

>share the source of the compilation. It sounds like a potentially fascinating source of information.

Re: historical joint question

#13

Re: historical joint question

"RJ" Whelan

>Bill ...

I have built, over the last 20 years, about six domed trunks. Knowing that I was going to build at least two matching trunks I decided to build a clamping jig.

I stacked 3 pieces of MDF together and then bandsawed (yes the kind plugged into an electrical circuit and hooked to a DC)a set of three, matched cauls (three lower and three upper). When completed I discarded two of the uppers as I only used the middle upper caul. Everything received a few coats of poly-urethane and wax (to keep glue from sticking).

1. In use the three lower cauls were layed out on the bench and strips of waxed paper were placed over the caul surface (further insurance against the lid being permanently glued to the jig) and the first four boards were placed two to either side of the center line of the jig (three glue joints)

2. Next place the upper (center) caul (with waxed paper insurance)in position and lightly clamp in position (two deep throat clamps)

3. Place 2 or 3 clamps across the glue-up (with appropriate wedges to protect the edges and apply enough pressure to bring the four boards together along their length.

4. Clamp the four boards to the outer (lower) cauls (8 clamps)

5. Let the whole thing cure overnight.

6. Place the final four boards (2 to each side in position) and clamp as in the four steps.

7. Scrape the squeeze out and plane to final, fair curve and saw and shape all edges to fit into the frame that completes the top.

This is not at all complicated, nor is there a high degree of skill involved - it's just kinda slow due the cure time needed after the first and second gluing session. The jig really does all of the work.

Edge treatment is, of course, a different story.

Good luck with your trunk .......... rj

Re: historical joint question

#14

Citation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Furniture and its makers of chester county pennsylvania, Margaret Schiffer

isbn 0916838056 Schiffer publishing, LtD Exton PA

Re: historical joint question

#15

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Thanks for the assembly description.

How did you fasten domed part to rest of the framing that comprised the trunk lid? A picture would be great.

Re: historical joint question

#16

Probably a bench vice hand screw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: historical joint question

#17

Re: Probably a bench vice hand screw

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Stephen,

Do you mean like a big twin-screw or post vise? I seem to recall either you or Don McConnell posting photos out of Felibien showing huge vises which could either be mounted or dismounted--and which could be effectively used dismounted as well as mounted.

Wiley

Re: historical joint question

#18

Prices

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I remember seeing a bill of materials from when my mother and father built their house around 1940-1945. A claw hammer was still $.25.

Re: historical joint question

#19

Re: Probably a bench vice hand screw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

It is difficult if not impossible to determine what was meant by the probate inventories. I have several early nineteenth century Inventories from the Midwest, I will have to scan them and post the contents. There are vagaries and it may be from the probate officer's recording or the families listings of what was left over.

Prices will indicate value, so that price for a hand screw indicates it is probably not a clamp but something more substansive and large threaded vices would be in that price range.

But 'lots of tools', 'lots of planes', lots of saws', or 'lots of chisels' only lead to one ask what is a lot? And many items would be unknown to anyone but the originator and much was I am sure discarded.

Stephen

Re: historical joint question

#20

Hand screws

Adam Cherubini

>The hand screw could have been a clamp like this one. But judging from the rest of the inventory, it looks like this guy was a clock maker or jeweler? That's probably a jeweler's lathe listed. And the hand screw could be a hand vise or a small appliance used on top of a workbench to hold stuff.

Adam


img

Re: historical joint question

#21

no, I'm wrong

Adam Cherubini

>I just looked at the inventory again. No he wasn't jeweler. But the screw plates and stuff seem to indicate some amount of threading, and screw making.

I'd better get the book!

Thanks for the reference, Bill.

Adam

Re: historical joint question

#22

Re: Probably a bench vice hand screw

paul womack

> I have several early nineteenth century Inventories from the Midwest, I will have to scan them and post the contents.

Might I suggest Gary Robert "Toolemera" as an appropriate host?

BugBear

Re: historical joint question

#23

correct.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There survives a clock and a desk signed by this cabinet/clock maker.

Re: historical joint question

#24

Re: Titebond

ThomD

>Titebond, the regular stuff, will make a very good rubebd joint,normally invisible, though the joint prep has to be absolutely flat, it won't overcome spring. HIde glue has more tack and other characteristics, some of them a little mystical, but if you don't have it TB will work also.

Re: historical joint question

#25

Re: question

"RJ" Whelan

>Sorry Bill, no pictures are available - technology challenged.

The lid was formed from a dovetailed frame (four pieces) and the domed part.

I, basically, formed a tenon on all four edges of the domed part:

1. Layed the domed part on the bench and scribed a tenon in the same plane with the bench top and planed both long (lower) edges flat so that I had a 1/2" long tenon

2. Used a 3/8" spacer to raise a shoulder plane above the bench surface and planed the upper part of the tenon to just over 3/8" thickness

3. Scribed the curved part of the domed part to each frame end and using the lower caul as a guide routed a 3/8" dado to 1/2" depth using a tailed apprentice and guide collar.

4. Refined the fit between the tenon on the domed part and the dado in the frame end using a shoulder plane and a sanding block

5. Cut dados into the two long frame components on the router table.

I know that all of the power tools kinda' violate the spirit of this forum, but I do this to make a living and I have to use whatever means the proves to be most efficient, timewise.

I hope this helps ........ rj