Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Restoring old rusty blades

Posts

Restoring old rusty blades

#1

Restoring old rusty blades

Bob Demers

>Didn't want to hijack Wiley metalurgical post, so I tought I started another thread

Like I said many times before, I never seen a lump of rust I didnt like :-D But honey...it followed me home...

Regardless, I tend to be selective when eying a new to me lump of rust. If I don't believed I can put it back into service, im not interested in it, unless is a very special lump of rust!!!

When looking at picture of plane on Ebay, I pay attention to the relative position of the adjuster lever and the amount of blade sticking up. A full lenght blade should stick further than the lever, a lever sticking far out the blade, means a pretty well used up blade. Next come pitting versus surface rust. Not always easy to spot the difference especially in pictures, but the darker the rust discoloration or the appearance of darker small spots means pitting as started. Depending on how deep and where located, means the difference between a useless blade or a recoverable one.

For example, here is a pictorial progression of my SW Stanley 602 blade recovery.

First pic is the blade condition after most of the rust has been gently abraded with lots of WD40 and a myriads of progressively finer sand papers. Severe pitting along the cutting edge on the bevel can be seen. But how deep is it?

Bob


img

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#2

Restoring old rusty blades pt 2

Bob Demers

>Any ideas how you post more than one pics in a single post???

How far do i go with rust removal on the overall blade?

First I do not use electrolysis, for fear of changing the metalurgical properties of the blade: Hydrogen embritlement comes to mind. So instead I use lots of elbow grease and stop often to check on my progress. I pay particular attention on the logos making sure I do not obliterated them with over zealous sanding.

I stop when I im happy with the overall condition of the back especially near the cutting edge. I cannot have pitting near it or I will never achieved a sharp edge. The question becomes then, how far up the edge is it OK. Im not trying to have a gleaming blade, just one that will take a decent edge to work. And also, keep in mind that both the back and the bevel will received constant stropping during its working life with me.

Good enough back for now. The pitting left is far up enough to give me lots of sharpening time before I worry about it, and the back will received umpteen stropping, polishing it further and further...

The more polished it is, the clearer the camera reflection becomes

Bob


img

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#3

Working on the bevel or bezel

Bob Demers

>Once im happy with the back, its time to give our attention to the bevel. I will work on it with coarser grits (80, 100, 120, 220) until ive gone past the pitting. Why that sequence of grit numbers? It just happens to be what I have the most on hands at all time, thats all :-)

You can see the pitting uncovered so far seems to be getting worse...nah, it just means more elbow grease required

Bob


img

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#4

Abrading and abrading slowly

Bob Demers

>My bevel is starting to come up to snuff, the pitting is receeding nicely, getting there


img

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#5

But don't, FOR ANY REASON . . .

steve mackay

>lay it on the bench sander with 80 grit on it ! STILL sanding with 220 grit, by hand, to fix THIS mess ! OOPS !

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#6

A Tad Da momen t!

Bob Demers

>After much elbow grease and liquid refreshment, working on old tools can be soooo thursty... :-D

The bevel is finally good enough to stop.

The idea is to go past the pitting and leave a surface smooth enough to jump on my waterstones (1200, 4000)

Quite a jump is'nt it? Yes and sometimes I will work it up with 3M automotive sandpapers from P400, P600, P800, P1000, P1500, but I always finish on my 4000 waterstone which I used with a nagura stone (a must) from then on, its strop, strop strop until Its time to touch up the edge again.

The camera reflection in the pic, is a good indicator, and no, i did not stop there, but was getting tired of stopping and taking pics :-)

The final edge is still not quite straight, you can see the upturned corners, which seems to be distorted by the camera, they are not that big, but good enough for now cause with repeated sharpening and stropping, it will become flatter, besides, I do want to relieved the corners anyway

If you compare the first picture with that one, you will notice that I did not removed much metal to get there, the blade is not noticably shorther, as it would have quickly becomes had I used a grinder to go past the pittings.

Total time involved, about two hour and a half including the pictures taking and fetching the beers :-)

That was many years ago, from there on, it has been used numerous time to make fluffy shavings

and the back and bevel have becomes more and more polished with repeated uses, stroping and sharpening. Hence why I dont go too nuts on the firts time around, it will improved as I go along

Bob


img

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#7

Re: But don't, FOR ANY REASON . . .

Bob Demers

>Hi Steve

Yes I have done that in the past, but had a small oops on a chisel, abraded a small portion on the handle :-(

Yes, its a slow process but I do not mind it, the beer help with the boring part (another reason to stay away from 'lectric tools :-)

But seriously, its not that long of a process. If I get impatient ill go back to coarser grits

Who me impatient? :-)

Bob

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#8

One last thing

Bob Demers

>Hard to see in that pic, but if you look closely, you can just make the tell tale demarcation line of the laminated tool steel. The line in question is going thru the letter O of the words CANON in the camera reflection. I would appear very thick in this picture, but thats only an optical illusion caused by the angle of the bevel pic

Bob, who just prefer old rusty blade to new fangled steel ones. Maybe its because of all the sweat and blood I put into them, wink wink

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#9

But when I FINALLY get . . .

steve mackay

>that perfect mirror finnish by hand its always a wonderful thing. And lets face it, if we didn't like doing it we'd just buy a new one.

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#10

HOLY CATS ! . . .

steve mackay

>When you can read the brand of camera used on the bevel now you're showing off !

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#11

Re: A Tad Da momen t!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bob,

Can you get that good a shine on any and all irons or chisels you do or do you find that some won't shine up that well no matter what you do?

Marv

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#12

Re: Abrading and abrading slowly

Michael Brady

>I have a method for dealing with pitted cutters and chip breakers that I think works better than sandpaper: draw filing. What I do is clamp a piece of 3/4" stock, about 8-10" long and the same width as the subject iron, in a metal working vice. put a length of double-stick carpet tape on the wood and adhere the plane iron to it. Adjust the iron so it is at least 1/4" above the vice jaws, and firmly stuck to the wood support. You are now ready to draw file.

This work best on the part of the iron above the heat-treated part of the iron...basically from the bottom of the slot up to the trademark. This steel is pretty soft. This is usually where the pitting is worse because the chip breaker prevents moisture from getting to the lower part of the cutter.

Draw filing is done with a medium-size mill file, available cheaply at the borg. Use a handle on it. If you don't know this technique, draw filing is holding the file 90 degrees to the direction of the stroke; kind of like using a spoke shave. Use light pressure and let the file do the work. The file needs to be sharp for this to turn out.

I like this technique because it keeps the edges square and results in a very good appearance that looks original. The best final finish is obtained by using a de-burring wheel on a grinder. Be sure to do the edges too. I have been able to bring rust encrusted cutters and chip breakers back to gently used condition using this schedule. The added bonus is the the blade will be flatter when you are done; and many Stanley cutters are very wavy on the non-bevelled side of the cutter. Don't forget to but a nice flat edge on the leading edge of the chip breaker before you do your final flattening and edge preparation.

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#13

Re: A Tad Da momen t!

Bob Demers

>Hi Marv

I find that most, if not all, shine pretty well the same.

CS seems to get the shiniest.

Mind you I have a lot more 'Old' Carbon Steel than new fangled iron.

Could also be that I spend a heck of a lot more time working on the old rusty stuff than I spend on O2. And certainly not because O2 doesnt take a while to sharpen, simply because its already almost there from the factory (LV, LN).

What you saw on these pics is what I do to all my edges at least once. After that it's a lot less work to maintain them.

Hence why I work on them initially until I see reflections in them.

I'm basically lazy, so I'll dull a lot of my tools before having to hold a sharpening marathon...yes I have lots and lots of cutting edges to attend to :-)

And once you have worked with a truly sharp edge, nothing else will do. My secret to go the distance between sharpening sessions, besides having lots of planes and chisels :-) is to strop the edges often as I work.

Bob, the closet collector

Re: Restoring old rusty blades

#14

Insteresting!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'll have to give this a shot one day. Thanks for sharing this!