Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Drawers

Posts

Drawers

#1

Drawers

Patrick Wheatley

>Hi All, I am just starting out on building a chest of drawers. I am at the beginning stages at the moment. The top and sides are all glued up and cut to thickness and dimensions I need.

While I start building the carcass I am thinking ahead to the drawers. I have the lumber for the drawer fronts (Cherry) and enough lumber for the sides and backs (Ash) but I realized that I do not have enough Ash for the drawer bottoms. This leads me to my question.

Should I use Pine or Poplar for the drawer bottoms. Are there any problems with using either? I will be buying the cheaper of the two in 6/4 and then resawing them for the thinner bottoms.

All opinions are welcome, I am still learning a lot as I work in my little basement shop and the books I have don't have answers for these straight forward questions.

Pat in overcast Montreal

Re: Drawers

#2

Re: Drawers

James Watriss

>I think poplar will be the more durable choice, and in general I have an easier time finding good poplar than good pine.

Re: Drawers

#3

Re: Drawers

Dean J in MN

>Pine is a very traditional drawer bottom (and side) material. Poplar is as well. You'll have no issues with either. Hunting in the stacks for quartersawn material for your sides is worth the time.

Cheers!

Dean

Re: Drawers

#4

Re: Drawers

ThomD

>Drawer bottoms can be made out of 4mm plywood to 6mm plywood in many sizes. 6mm ply can be made into trimaran hulls up to 40 feet. So structure wise it is all good as long as grain orientation is good. Old pine differs from modern pine; they used to prefer pine in floors for wear to red oak. Wichever is cheaper and you can get better quality in for the price.

A minor point is that "lumber" is somewhat similar to "burden". They were lumbered with too much lumber, as anyone who has tried to clear a field by hand could tell you. A better word is "timber", though it really isn't used over here except in phrases like "i'm off to the tall timbers". I just say "wood".

Re: Drawers

#5

Re: Drawers

"RJ" Whelan

>Patrick ... I build 3-4 dressers each year, and my clients seem to appreciate drawer bottoms made from aromatic cedar.

My 2 cents ........ rj

Re: Drawers

#6

Re: Drawers

Patrick Wheatley

>You know i was thinking about the ceder but the kiln drying operation where i by my "wood" does not seem to carry it. However, when i am there this morning i will ask around for it, you never know.

Re: Drawers

#7

I say Poplar...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Unless your pine is clear and sap free. Otherwise you can always paint the poplar to look like pine...

8^)

Re: Drawers

#8

Re: I say Poplar...

Patrick Wheatley

>Well yesterday I went out and bought enough poplar (4 boards ~8"x10'x6/4) which should be enough to make both sides and bottoms once they are resawed.

All of the ash I have will now be used for some shelves I need to make.

While I am at it. If I have a drawer that is ~27" wide and ~17" deep should I split the bottom into two sections with a munton (or rail not sure of the term) in the middle? The bottoms will be about 1/2" thick.

Re: Drawers

#9

drawer construction suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>We used to have a high-end antiques restorer come to the club from time to time. I thought such a person was a good source of wisdom because he got to see what worked/survived and what didn't, as well as what was easy to repair and what was not.

He advocated hard abrasion resistant wood for drawer runners ( for example maple) and a softer wood, yellow pine or poplar, for the drawer sides. A worn drawer side is easy to fix, while a worn runner is not. The English approach was to use a very thin white oak drawer side with a wide strip affixed on the drawer bottom for a wear surface. The strip could be easily replaced. American furniture more often had thicker sides made from pine or poplar or cedar. A worn side can be readily fixed by planing the side and adding(gluing) a strip to replace what is worn. Additionally, with a pine or poplar bottom the drawer will be lighter and hence wear less. Use quartered sawed lumber for th sides.

When we toured the Philadelphia museum last year we examined drawers in every piece in the main period room. The sides were all soft woods including one of red cedar.

Drawer fitting has been discussed here so I will just summarize. Fit the font to the opening once the case is assembled. Dovetail the sides and back to the fitted front. Plane sides to provide a smooth fit to the case allowing a total of about 1/16" side clearance and a bit more on top. I like to shellac drawers inside and out. With a waxed runner a well fitted drawer will close smoother than if it was on ball bearing guides.

Re: Drawers

#10

not necessary

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I recently made drawers 36" wide and 20" deep and the bottoms are 5/16" pine. They are plenty stiff.

Re: Drawers

#11

Strongly agree

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>The glue-up will be much stiffer and stronger than any individual board in it. 1/2" thickness is huge; 3/8" is plenty. You could resaw that 6/4 poplar into at least thirds, allowing for cleanup; or even fourths if you're a real good bandsawer.

Wiley

Re: Drawers

#12

Re: drawer construction suggestion

Patrick Wheatley

>Thanks for the information. I am planning on using the ash for the runners and the newly purchased poplar for the drawer sides.

As you say, with 1/2" sides and back with thinner panels for the bottoms they should be very light.

I will also be experimenting with shellac for the first time. My total finishing experience is basically Watco Danish Oil. I think it is time to expand my horizons a bit.

Re: Drawers

#13

Re: Strongly agree

Patrick Wheatley

>I was thinking 1/2" because I am afraid that the wood will cup badly after resawing. With the 1/2" I figured I could glue up the panels while they are still relatively thick and then run plane them down to an acceptable thickness.

I tried resawing some 4/4 ash last weekend and the two halves curled up almost immediately. The wood was kiln dried and had been sitting in my basement shop for a good 6 months. Not sure what would happen to the poplar if I tried to go any thinner than that.

Re: Drawers

#14

Shellac

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Patrick,

My experience has been that thinned shellac for drawer internals--like less than a 1 lb cut--will leave drawers and all cabinet internals smelling sweet forever. Don't know why it is so. In general, I think a 1-lb cut is a good place to start, if you're starting out. The thinner cut goes on more easily, and will not develop a fat edge.

Wiley

Re: Drawers

#15

I hear you

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>That can sure happen. Next time it does, or maybe with your ash, try wetting the concave side of the resawn stick, let it uncup, and then go from there with the redrying. Some people lay the sticks down on dewy grass in the morning, concave side down, and let the sun cook and shrink the convex side while the concave side absorbs the dew and swells. You can often get boards to uncup by differential wetting/drying, remembering that the concave side is dry and the convex side is wet.

Apologies if you're way ahead of me on this.

Wiley

Re: Drawers

#16

making QS panels from plain sawn stock

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>If you continue to have problems with cupping when you resaw the wood for the bottoms or if you have trouble locating quarersawn stock there is another option. Look for a nice 8/4 plainsawn board and rip some 3/8 strips off the edge turn them and glue them up to make a quartersawn panel. I regularly do this to get small panels and have used these for drawer bottoms on smallish drawers such as those in writing tables. It goes pretty quickly if you do the glue up as a series of rub joints while sitting on a waxed cast iron table and then place a couple of weights on the panel till the glue sets.

Robin

Re: Drawers

#17

Re: I hear you

Patrick Wheatley

>This is all new to me. I will give it a try this weekend. If it goes wrong i have plenty of ash where that came from!

Re: Drawers

#18

Re: Shellac

Patrick Wheatley

>For the Shellac do you suggest going with flakes from a place like LV or for a novice (like myself) should I start with a commercially available premix tin from a big box store...assuming shellac is sold this way (remember Danish oil is all I know).

For the chest of drawers I was going to use the Watco natural oil on the cherry. Would shellac be a good finish over top? Or should I think about a wax top coat? Even though I have finished all of my projects with oil I have never used wax or other top coats.

Re: Drawers

#19

why it cupped instantly

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There was stress in the wood from improper drying (too fast and/ or no relaxation at end of cycle). If it was a moisture induced cup it would not have been rapid and it would be reversible.

Re: Drawers

#20

Re: why it cupped instantly

ThomD

>It could be reaction wood also. I once bought this 1x6 for canoe rails, and every single piece I cut out of it bent nearly into a circle. The funny bit was that for the most part the main piece of the wood remained straightuntil the next slice was taken off. It was a tropical wood though, so little indication of the trouble that lay within.

I think one difference in some of the older pieces, or finer pieces, is that they often (of course not always) have some very small drawers in them, and those drawer can easily be made of very fine stock or light wood. Much modern expectation seems driven (if not around here) by rather large and sometimes clunky drawers made of particle board etc...

Re: Drawers

#21

Too Late Now But Another Choice...

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>is bass wood. It's very inexpensive here in Houston, it's stable, clear and clean and its softness is not an issue for drawer sides. It can also be obtained in wide boards which can be helpful.