Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Metal scraping video

Posts

Re: Metal scraping video

#26

Re: I've been wondering....

paul womack

>if the spot and scrape method is accurate when the starting surface is slightly convex--like in the low thousandths. How does the practitioner place the work on the granite plate (or iron lapping plate) and ink it without rocking it?

Proceeed like a mathematician! Scrape (or file, or whatever) a dent in the convexity, and proceed as for a surface that started concave.

Once a small flat (stable!) surface is created in the middle of the sole, expanding it should proceed quite routinely.

BugBear

Re: Metal scraping video

#27

Re: NOT SCRAPING *LINK*

paul womack

>The important principle here is NOT scraping; it's the use a reference (surface plate) to guide the metal removal process.

If the error is large, metal removal can be done with fairly brutal methods.

I have had good results using small wooden block with SiC paper for the needed localised metal removal.

Note also (on my page) the reference to what's involved (S & S) in getting so-called-lapping to actually work properly.

BugBear


bugbear sole flattening page

Re: Metal scraping video

#28

Now suppose that

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>you don't have prior knowledge of the condition of the work--whether it is convex or concave (in the large). You set it down on the plate and it inks all over evenly. It's thin ink, well applied. You know it's not concave. How do you know it's not a little convex?

Wiley

Re: Metal scraping video

#29

Re: Now suppose that

paul womack

>You know it's not concave. How do you know it's not a little convex?


Pretty much comes down to hand skill and touch when placing the workpiece down.

If one feels (or suspects) convexity one is very careful not to rock (which would generate the ink coverage you alude to).

It is much, MUCH, easier to avoid rocking a workpiece when making the "print" that it is to avoid rocking the workpiece when performing the multiple, reciprocal, forceful strokes required by so-called-lapping.

BugBear

Re: Metal scraping video

#30

Re: I've been wondering....

paul womack

>Now I'm wondering if a machinist, during the 'grinding down' phase, doesn't make sure he grinds it just a le-e-etle bit concave, and then scrapes the periphery, which is where there will be ink pickup. I.e., if you want to get flat, it's easier to start out a little hollow.

yes indeedy do. Just so.

BugBear

Re: Metal scraping video

#31

Re: I've been ... funny story

ThomD

>I'm not going to say they don't grind it a little hollow. But I saw no evidence of it on the tape and don't see any need. When machinists grind this kind of thing down, I assume we are talking surface grinder. If that machine is any good the piece is in the tens without anyone doing anything by hand at all. If they did it so the center was hollow they would simply end up with a lot of material to scrape. Then let's say they have it a lot better but now it's a little proud in the center, because they worked the edge so well. Do they now have to hollow it out again? Sounds like a lot of work. If the erors are in the thous they can find them with rulers, or light, or gages, or indicatores, or by rotation about centers.

For me a takeaway is that here is a cheap to make device that takes away visible flakes or shavings, which is a lot faster material removal than we get with most of out wood workshop tools. We can choose to reduce the amount of grunt work by using a scraper to rough out. We can use it to beautify the surface of metal, a bit like a piece of burl, or we can finish the surface of the plane. And we don't have to do it to some incredible standard since those are for the guy who works upstream of even the guy who machines perfect tools.

Funny story, I was buying a surface plate a few months back, and the guy had bought a lot of plates out of some factory. The biggest one he had was a Starret pink granite inspection grade (above toolroom grade, above shop grade). It was 6'x4'x10", around here that is about 6k new. The only offer he had received on it was from a guy who wanted one as a pad for his woodstove. Isn't de-industrialization grand!

Re: Metal scraping video

#32

Re: Now suppose that *LINK*

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>OK, good. You and Joel have both run that rabbit into the same hole. I'm convinced that a practiced hand can make a print that picks up small convexity.

Your web page is so good on this subject, that I'm reposting the link from below. The commentary by Stephen Thomas is very, very hard to find anywhere else. This is a great treatment of the subject, folks, see below!

Wiley


Bugbear's reference on plane sole flattening

Re: Metal scraping video

#33

Re: machinist VS woodshop

paul womack

>I agree; a machinist with access to a surface grinder wouldn't need "tricks".

However, the joy (to me) of the surface plate "take print, remove peaks, repeat" process is that it works at all scales.

I have successfully worked a plane sole that was 4 thou (AKA half a hundredth) out of true, purely by hand techniques.

In the early stages of the process I was using 60 grit SiC on a 2" square block. Since I KNEW I was only working the peaks, this speed of removal was safe. (indeed judging how "brutal" is safe at each stage is the key skill to speeding up the process).

This mode of working is completely alien to a present day machinst who can get within a half thou using any one of a number of machines.

To a machinist scraping against a reference is a final finishing/precision skill.

To me, generic "metal removal" against a reference is the whole process.

It has the virtue of being reliable, accurate, and only requires cheap, compact equipment.

BugBear

Re: Metal scraping video

#34

Re: One more try

paul womack

>A few thou could be quite a lot in scraping terms where the cut in some portion of tens, and will take a lot of repeted steps to wittle down a crude eror like a few thou.

Absolutely. That's why I used coarser metal removal techniques in the early stages, although still guided by prints from a surface plate (with VERY thick blue).

BugBear

Re: Metal scraping video

#35

Re: machinist VS woodshop

ThomD

>I agree with all that. There are a lot of interwoven conversations, and I must confess to not trying too hard to keep them straight in my replies.

One of those threads is what would a machinist do. Someone even asked what their accuracy limit would be. That's where this idea of grinding to high tens and working it out further is relevant. It also play into the detecting a lump question since after the initial grind it's probably not going to visibly rock or do stuff that requires a just so placement. It's also relevant to my earlier suggestion that someone who doesn't have metal working machinery might profit from a tool that cuts like a scraper does in woodworking (all be it without the same chip size)somewhere between the planer and the polisher so to speak.

In my experience with wooden planes one can get shavings in the tens with about 30 seconds work on a piece of sandpaper, so much of this is accademic to me. That said the wait for the scraper video was several months. So there is some interest compared to say when the new tapes came out on molding planes and there wasn't any wait at all.