Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Metal scraping video

Posts

Metal scraping video

#1

Metal scraping video

ThomD

>I believe Rob Lee has comented favourably on scraping as a process for getting hand planes "flat". I just recently had a chance to look at a copy of a video by the dapra corporation on metal scraping. It covers both hand and hand held power scraping techniques. I found the hand techniques looked more than up to the process of doing plane sized objects.

Metal scraping is the process used to surface components of machine tools. It both establishes the machine tool's accuracy, and leaves a relieved surface that can effectively carry oil. In woodworking technology the faceted surface could be used to relieve friction. Another option would be to roughly scrape a surface to relieve non-essential surface areas, and then lap only the remainder. Scraping also leaves an aesthetically interesting surface with Pye like "diversity". Machinists refer to this as "frosting" It is certainly nicer than the dead surfaces one gets with grinding, and more accurate.

There are a number of books on metal scraping, a yahoo group. As always seeing someone actually scraping is the big advantage of video.

I do have and enjoy metal planes, sorta. Really can't think of a single good woodworking reason for owning metal planes, and I am studying scraping mostly for machine tool restoration reasons. Still, there are lots of people who prefer metal planes. Maybe hand scraping will catch on and be the next must master thing for woodworking tools.

Re: Metal scraping video

#2

Scraping metal surfaces

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Thom,

I use a scraping process for removing most of the rust from handsaws. A lot of people use a razor blade as a scraper but I found it too flimsy. It has to be used with a pushing motion and with some of the harder rust, the razor blade is useless.

The scraper I use includes a sturdy handle that accepts a box scraper blade. The blades are cheap and can be used for quite a long time by merely flipping them around in the handle or holder.

The best thing about this type scraper is, it does best when using a pulling or dragging motion with the blade nearly straight up and down and dragged at a slight angle that gives somewhat of a slicing action. The box cutter blade is stiffer and wider than a razor blade, hence faster removal of rust and you can bare down on it more.

Once I remove about 90% of the rust I then resort to sandpaper. Mineral spirits is used for both sandpapering and scraping.

I have pondered using a plane scraper but I haven't tried it because I'm afraid the slurry will gather underneath and will slow down the process and also might scratch the blade. The box scraper pushes the stuff forward in front of the blade and I just wipe it off with a paper towel.

Marv

Re: Metal scraping video

#3

Re: Scraping metal surfaces

ThomD

>That's interesting Marv. I do similar stuff to get rid of loose rust.

The scraping addressed in this video removes shavings of metal. Here is a book on the process that shows a picture of the tool:

http://www.lindsaybks.com/bks9/hscrape/index.html

And another supplier of tools and videos:

http://machinerepair.com/index.html

Re: Metal scraping video

#4

I've been wondering....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>if the spot and scrape method is accurate when the starting surface is slightly convex--like in the low thousandths. How does the practitioner place the work on the granite plate (or iron lapping plate) and ink it without rocking it? Or to put it another way, what is the practical limit of accuracy for a qualified machinist, if he/she is starting with a convex work piece?

Wiley

Re: Metal scraping video

#5

Re: I've been wondering....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have a machinist friend who insists a good machinist can work to tolerances of .0001" with a scraper.

Bruce

Re: Metal scraping video

#6

Re: I've been wondering....

ThomD

>This is a very subtle process so if there is a big honking bow in the plane it needs to be reduced by some other means. So the starting point might be grinding. This part of the response has to do with the degree of the topography. Within the scraping range it is probably going to appear flat to most cassual examiners.

As far as the technique for spotting the bow is concerned, if you dropped a plane on a surface plate and then grabbed one end and wiggled it, the bowed plane would rotate around the center point. If it were perfectly flat it would rotate around the 30% from the end point, and so on. With the right ink there should be an ink print as well.

Re: Metal scraping video

#7

Re: I've been wondering....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Thom said:

"As far as the technique for spotting the bow is concerned, if you dropped a plane on a surface plate and then grabbed one end and wiggled it, the bowed plane would rotate around the center point. If it were perfectly flat it would rotate around the 30% from the end point, and so on. With the right ink there should be an ink print as well. "

___________

Thanks. I think I follow you. Please check me. Let's say the machinist has done the grinding, and there is an interior high spot that is ~2 thousandths. He's put the work down on the thinly inked plate, and 'wiggled it' to locate that 2 thou bearing point. Intuitively, you know where the high spot has to be on the work. So you pick up the work, and much of the bottom will have picked up ink, but you know where the high spot has to be, so you look for that dab of ink (with an uninked immediate surround) where you know the high spot has to be.

So, if I follow, if the surface you're working is a tiny bit convex, the ink is an aid, but you're relying on finding the bearing point mechanically. You're done when you get an even coverage of ink, and the work (by feel) is dead stable on the plate.

Now I'm wondering if a machinist, during the 'grinding down' phase, doesn't make sure he grinds it just a le-e-etle bit concave, and then scrapes the periphery, which is where there will be ink pickup. I.e., if you want to get flat, it's easier to start out a little hollow.

Wiley ..... speculating

Re: Metal scraping video

#8

All my plane soles are scraped

David Barnett - SW Florida

>And yes, you'll want to attrite the bulk of protrudences by coarser and faster means. Files and so on*. Then go for the surface plate and Prussian blue. Scraping is kinda fun and kinda addictive. I like basketweave frosting but snakes are cool, too. I've even seen artistic scraping that reminded me of Van Gogh's "Starry Night".

My favorite method is to hold the scraper at a rather high angle with my left fist on the surface, holding the edge of the scraper where I want my next stroke to begin, then with the heel of my right hand I jab the handle sharply (which moves the business end towards me). A short strike leaves a 3/16" to 1/4" diagonal mark on the plane sole, lathe way, whatever.

Once you get into the rhythm, it moves right along, and if you get your right brain into it along with you tongue (in my case), before long you'll have a pleasing pattern. Oh... don't forget to alternate diagonally every other course. Of course.

*Files are rarely flat so will usually have a concave and a convex side.

Re: Metal scraping video

#9

Re: I've been wondering....

ThomD

>If the surfaces are produced on a surface grinder they will be flat, and probably not manipulated to have hollows and such. Whatever their accuracy they won't have the points and percent coverage required for proper contact surfaces. So that is another reason for the scraping and inking approach. It's a lot like hand planing: At times you can rely on the cut the plane produces to get your geometry, at other times you have to go in there and identify and remove specific features on the board that aren't consistant with the shape you want.

You can get very high levels of accuracy with scraping. Monarch made lathes that held parts to 0.000030". Presumably this was done by careful scraping, not sure what other means there could have been.

I don't want to promote the idea that scraping should be used to provide exhorbitant accuracy in our craft. High accuracy is required, but going back to my coment about wooden planes, a monkey can make a wooden plane that works in the .0004" range, and very few such planes are ever required for our work. So the objectives are different in adopting scraping. They are getting into a hand tool mode that is relatively clean, fast, aesthetically pleasing, and shows an understanding of appropriate means. And possibly learning a technique that keeps us growing in real directions that something like bits of paper glued to machines probably won't.

Machine tools are designed to rapidly produce high accuracy parts all day long in careful hands. And then other machines are designed to maintain those machines, and still other machines exist to make those machines. And in the background there is some, guy hand scraping those machines. So machine tools are/were both different in objective and force into production sub-catagories of even better machines. The guy just looking at a hand plane for average work doesn't need to have all those levels in mind.

Re: Metal scraping video

#10

Chris Scholz

Re: I've been wondering....

Chris Scholz

>Many years back I spent some time in the teaching shop of a large machine tool manufacturer. Occasionally second year apprentices restored and upgraded old milling machines (usually a complete and always an addition of optical encoders). They always called in senior mechanics to scrape the linear guides. Never seen anybody scraping anyting in the production floor.

By the way you can have your plane scraped for approx. $50 to $190 (no affiliation). The also claim that they can scrap you a 0.00078 in curvature in your plane.

Chris

Dallas/Fort Worth Metroplex

Galoot-Tools.com

Re: Metal scraping video

#11

Re: Metal scraping video

Joel

>I've scraped to sruface plates by fair share of planes and I've even given a course in scraping planes a long time ago. It has the advantage that it's easy to do, the equipment is minimal, and you can scrape to whatever accuracy you wish.

The problem I have with lapping is that it's easy to go convex from side to side and with longer planes it is a lot of careful work.

A few years ago I discovered that if I use a bit of wet or dray sandpaper in a hard sanding block I could trivially flatten the high spots in a lot less time. To check accuracy I use a straightedge. THe method is very easy, requires no special equipment, is very fast and while not as accurate as scraping to a surface plate it's more than adaquate for planes - and if you want even more accuracy you can scrap or lap the last bit to finish up

Re: Metal scraping video

#12

One more try

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Joel,

Still looking for help. Maybe I'm asking a dumb question, and if so let me know. I still can't get my head wrapped around how scraping cures a small amount of convexity. Say someone has put a slow 1-2 thou convexity on a plane sole, sideways and/or longways--but the sole is also very smooth. And hands it to a machinist to be scraped flat. What exactly does the machinist do? I can't believe the work can be laid on the reference plate in such a controlled way that _the ink_ would reveal the convexity--wouldn't the ink instantly be all over the plane sole?

I understood Thom's explanation that wiggling the plane would be a good test for convexity. I buy that story--but is that what machinists do to detect slight convexity?

I'm not even questioning where reference plates come from that are good to the 5th decimal place, as claimed somewhere in this thread.

Wiley

Re: Metal scraping video

#13

Re: Metal scraping video

Tony Zaffuto

>Joel,

Can you describe the shape of the scraper you used for flattening the sole of a plane?

T.Z.

Re: Metal scraping video

#14

Re: Metal scraping video *LINK*

Joel

>I wrote this years ago - I didn't really review it before posting the link and I would guess there are things I would not do differently or phrase differently now. I would even change the title to scraping the sole of a metal bodied plane. But it should answer your questions about geometry.


scraping the sole of a metal bodied plane

Re: Metal scraping video

#15

Re: One more try

Joel

>THe hard part of scraping is learning to rub out a consistent layer of blue paint because the thicker the layer the less accurate is it's reading. The second skill - which more addresses your question - is learning to put the plane down on the surface plate consistently. when you have lots of inaccuracies wiggling is ok, but as you get closers you have to touch it down and pick it up without rocking etc. that will detect a convexity if you put it down the same way each time (which is a skill). However the point of forcing a concavity and then removing it is a good one - it's easier to do - but I havn't tried it that way. the first plane I scraped - which is still my favorite smoother after 20 years had a convexity from side to side and from front to back made by the dealer flattening with a belt sander - it was not fun to remove.

for the past 5 years I have used the selective sandpaper method I described above and the result is more than good enough.

Re: Metal scraping video

#16

Re: One more try

darin

>This goes back about five decades but I don't think they always started on the surface plate. some parts were started using a straight edge or another mechanical reference then after it was deemed good enough the part was placed on the reference plate or in some cases the plate was placed on the part.

Accuracy of this process can be phenomenal with average surface flatness measured in millionths of a inch.

Re: Metal scraping video

#17

Re: One more try

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Thanks Joel and Darin,

Joel, that answers it. You are saying that in fact one can learn to set the work down on the plate in such a way that even small convexity can be detected. I kinda like your other idea of not getting in that situation in the first place--by forcing a _slight_ concavity.

Darin, I can certainly visualize that spot and scrape is the last thing you do, for fine tuning of a surface you have already gotten 'close'.

Wiley

Re: Metal scraping video

#18

Your thoughts please.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Loel,

I was taught many years ago that when flattening something such as a plane sole when using sandpaper on a flat surface to have a large enough surface to be able to move the item being flattened in a figure 8 motion. This motion is meant to counteract any tilting in all directions.

I can easily imagine this being successful with something smaller than the sole of a plane but in my way of thinking, a plane might be too big on a standard size sheet of sandpaper.

Your thoughts please...

Marv

Re: Metal scraping video

#19

Re: Your thoughts please.

Joel

>if you take something small. say a spokeshave iron, holding it with a fingertip in the slot, and work it in any pattern any side pressure of your finger will have very little leverage to influence the plane (as in geometric not hand tool) of the blade and there will be no effect.

However doing the same thing to something larger, like a plane, where your hands grip it much stronger - will influence the cut and the slight rocking will slightly convex the sole from left to right. The longer the plane, the more time is spent lapping and the more convexity can occur. This is especially true if when you start the process you are trying to get rid of a convexity. remembering of course that folks are trying for very high flattness so a tiny error is important.

Now a convex plane works a lot better than a concave plane but in general I think the method is fraught with potential problems and my method of selected sanding is a lot better.

Scraping of course - takes the most skill but you can get whatever accuracy you want.

Another point is that a plane which is flat at the front, rear, and just in front of the mouth with the rest a little hollow will work excellently and blindly lapping doesn't give you the control you can get with the other methods.

Re: Metal scraping video

#20

Re: Your thoughts please.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Joel,

The scapers that you use, are they a pull type or push? Do they have a handle or are they just flat pieces of metal like what might be used on wood? Might they have carbide cutting edges or just HSS?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Metal scraping video

#21

Re: Your thoughts please.

Joel

>the scrapers are all push - see the link posted above.

Re: Metal scraping video

#22

Thanks...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks Joel,

Well written instructions....Sometimes it better to read the instructions first....*smirk*

Marv

Re: Metal scraping video

#23

Re: One more try

ThomD

>Just so it is clear the moving done with the plane sole on the block is lateral like a top, not in the vertical plane like a rocking horse. If the plane is placed on an inked (therefore lubricated)plate it will rotate about various points depending on where the contact points are. This might require a little care, but not some big skill thing, it's physics like a bubble level, you can screw that up but it is easy enough to use. The ink, of a correct type, is applied is a translucent coat so it is extremely fine. In some cases the scrapee surface is first prepared with a contrast ink.

A few thou could be quite a lot in scraping terms where the cut in some portion of tens, and will take a lot of repeted steps to wittle down a crude eror like a few thou. A few thou is easily distinguished with a finger, like a register receipt or a feeler gage.

Speaking of feeler gages, Lee Valley sells sets with gages down to a thou, and they sell or sold surface plates, I think that is where I got my small one. You can go at your base with a feeler gage if you feel like it. If the rocker is extreme you will be able to measure it with gages.

Sandpaper will certainly also knock off high points. It does raise the question of why go down that path again. Didn't we just get off that merry go round with our planes? But it is a good method, and the way monkeys make planes that take shaving of a few tens. That's all anyone needs.

Back decades ago, I think Ted Chase had an article where he was preping the planes soles with a die grinder. You could use a disc grinder too.

Re: Metal scraping video

#24

Re: Sen and sensibility

ThomD

>Scraping is not resigned to slow acting tools:

http://www.dfoggknives.com/photogallery/MakingSen/makingsen.htm

Re: Metal scraping video

#25

Re: Your thoughts please.

ThomD

>True, though flaking is a motion towards one, and sens work both ways.