Re: Don McConnell actually figured out
Don McConnell
>Wiley et al,
I think the simplest way to characterize carving tool sweeps is to think of each gouge of a given sweep as having the same depth-to-width ratio as any other gouge of that sweep. There are various ways to think about this, but my approach has been to find a way to determine the radius which defines the arc of any gouge, of a given sweep, if we know its width.
In brief, I found that each sweep has a "multiplier" which, when multiplied by the width of the gouge, will result in the radius of the arc of that gouge and that sweep. I checked the results against several of the earliest Sheffield/London sweep charts I could find and am satisfied that they are accurate. The page detailing this, which Wiley referred to, didn't make the transition when we moved our web-site from one server to another. But, we have things in motion to reinstate it, so, hopefully, it will be available again fairly soon.
Meanwhile, the "multipliers," as I determined them for the Sheffield/London pattern, are:
#3 = 3 3/4; #4 = 2 1/4; #5= 1 1/8; #6= 3/4; #7= 5/8; #8= 9/16; #9= 1/2
As has already been noted, this means that the arcs/cutting-edges of different sized gouges of the same sweep will not superimpose on each other. Also, this means that some gouges of different widths and sweeps can be superimposed on each other (for part of the arc of the larger gouge, only), as has previously been noted.
I haven't worked out the values for the continental system, but am sure the same approach would work for it.
Hope this helps,
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR