Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Carving gouge numbering system

Posts

Carving gouge numbering system

#1

Carving gouge numbering system

wilbur

>Hope this is a good place to ask this question, since there doesn't seem to be a carving forum.

It looks like that to describe a carving gouge, you need two numbers: one for the width, and another to describe the curvature of the gouge. So a 1/2" #8 is a gouge 1/2" wide with a curvature more pronounced than a #7, but less than a #9.

If you have two gouges, one a 1/2" #8, and the other a 1" #8, is the amount of curvature supposed to be the same? In other words, would the 1/2" #8 cut an arc that could be superimposed on the 1" #8?

It looks like different manufacturers do things differently, or my eyes are going out on me.

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#2

Where is Lee Grindinger ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Lee can answer this one for you, but from what I have seen, a 1/2 inch #7 and a 1 inch #7, don't necessarily have exactly the same curve. Also, there are at least two different "standards" for curvature, one for the English tools, and another for the Swiss. I am not sure, but would not be surprised at all if different manufacturers had slightly different interpretations of the curvature.

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#3

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

Joel

>Yes. at least within a specfiic manufacterer. between manufacterer there are suble differences in dies that don't mean much unless you need an EXACT match. and continental makers have different curvatures for the number (usually one sweep shallower than the English)

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#4

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

john j

>For each given sweep, the shape is the same, so they don't superimpose. For example, a narrow 3 sweep may share the same curve as a very wide 8, depending on manufacturer.

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#5

Don McConnell actually figured out

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>the math of the gouge sweep system, and published a chart on it, with description. But I can't find it in the archives or messages now. If Don comes by, perhaps he could point us to it.

Anyway, all my Ashley Iles of a given sweep _appear_ to superimpose, and same with Two Cherries.

Joel makes an important point--if you want a Two Cherries (or Pfeil, or any continental gouge) to match the sweep of an English gouge, you need one sweep higher. For example, a Two Cherries sweep 7 is very close to an Ashley Iles sweep 6. This fact turned out to be a practical issue for me in the situation where I was cutting ornaments (bellflowers) in a graded series.

Wiley

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#6

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>As John suggests the shape of two #8 gouges is the same. In other words they have the same angular measurement (degrees of arc), not the same radius.

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#7

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Numbering in carving tools is just as standardized as the plumbing industry, infact they both use the same standards-arabic numerals.

Robin

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#8

huh? Say that again?

Adam Cherubini

>

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#10

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

john j

>I think of it like Warren says, like arcs/ segment of a circle, but didn't think to mention it...

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#11

Re: Don McConnell actually figured out

Don McConnell

>Wiley et al,

I think the simplest way to characterize carving tool sweeps is to think of each gouge of a given sweep as having the same depth-to-width ratio as any other gouge of that sweep. There are various ways to think about this, but my approach has been to find a way to determine the radius which defines the arc of any gouge, of a given sweep, if we know its width.

In brief, I found that each sweep has a "multiplier" which, when multiplied by the width of the gouge, will result in the radius of the arc of that gouge and that sweep. I checked the results against several of the earliest Sheffield/London sweep charts I could find and am satisfied that they are accurate. The page detailing this, which Wiley referred to, didn't make the transition when we moved our web-site from one server to another. But, we have things in motion to reinstate it, so, hopefully, it will be available again fairly soon.

Meanwhile, the "multipliers," as I determined them for the Sheffield/London pattern, are:

#3 = 3 3/4; #4 = 2 1/4; #5= 1 1/8; #6= 3/4; #7= 5/8; #8= 9/16; #9= 1/2

As has already been noted, this means that the arcs/cutting-edges of different sized gouges of the same sweep will not superimpose on each other. Also, this means that some gouges of different widths and sweeps can be superimposed on each other (for part of the arc of the larger gouge, only), as has previously been noted.

I haven't worked out the values for the continental system, but am sure the same approach would work for it.

Hope this helps,

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#12

Thank you

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>I just went out and rechecked a couple of different sweep series by two different makers, and, sure enough, just as Don's analysis states-- different widths within the same sweep series do not superimpose. In the middle sweeps, widths that are pretty close together look like they will superimpose, but they won't.

Wiley .... retracting

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#13

Re: huh? Say that again?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>For my gouges, a #6 gouge takes about six cuts to make a full circle, whether the gouge is 1/4 inch #6 or 3/4 inch #6. So each arc is about 60 degrees no matter the size. But the radius for a 1/4 inch #6 is about 1/3 the radius for a 3/4 inch #6. I was thinking Wilbur might visualize the arcs this way.

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#14

The reason I asked....

wilbur

>I took a class that our woodworking club set up with Mario Rodriguez this past weekend on making a shaded fan inlay. There were a couple of #8 gouges to use, one about 5/8" in width, and another that was about 1 1/2", and they had very different curvatures. So much so that even thought they were from Woodcraft and marked "Swiss Made", I thought that since one was much older than the other, Woodcraft might have switched suppliers in the interval.

Thanks for all the replies!

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#15

Thank you--it helps me to visualize it

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Your principle--that all widths within a sweep span the same arc of a circle--is equivalent to Don's principle that the radius divided by the chord is constant within a sweep. Don's math is one or at most two steps away from saying what the arc is for each sweep, to within the accuracy permitted by the measuring and the manufacturing.

Very helpful!

Wiley

Re: Carving gouge numbering system

#16

London Pattern article *LINK*

Don McConnell

>Wiley et al,

Though this thread has pretty much run its course, I wanted to mention that my article concerning the mathematics behind the London Pattern carving tool sweeps has been restored to our website. Hope it will be of some interest.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


London Pattern sweeps