Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Posts

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#26

Re: Leave it Alone

Todd Hughes

>As I said I would probably just glue the broken peice back together that way retaining the "original" replacement handle. No reason it couldn't still be used even. I imagine if correctly glued the saw could be used like this ...After all many saws had open handles where the handles are simular to what this one would then be like.

Maybe the original maker of the handle did it because it was cheaper to make a new handle then buy another saw or maybe because it was more convenient...I don't know ..maybe he just liked the saw? But with good user backsaws so cheap and easy to find nowdays even in the old tool hell I live in I don't know if the same could be said now

I believe that true folk art was rarely thought of originaly as art by those that made it... Todd

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#27

Well, ain't that how the inet works though?

Alan DuBoff

>I mean, a guy comes along and asks for sage advice and someone offers him some of the honest stuff, only to be looked down upon for possibly being politically incorrect.

I was going to suggest forgetting about the handle, mount it upside down in a slotted table, and sell it for $1k. Somehow I think people would not see my humor...:-/

I saw recently the reaction people gave me for giving an honest opinion of what I felt was a useless tool.

We sure live in a touch feely world these days, heh? Next thing we'll be having some group hugs around here...

But there is humor in the inet itself...how about the folks that post the same message to 4 different forums, and mostly the same folks frequent most of the similar woodworking sites anyway...everyone is searching for identity...or looking for a pat on the back...:-)

I've seen similar posts on Wood Central, Woodnet, SMC, and Family Woodworking...by the same person...the same pictures, the same text. There's gotta be a better way to waste time, IMO.:-)

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#28

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Dave,

I sincerely doubt that you would manage to disintegrate the handle. :) But if there's any thing I can do just let me know.

Regardless of the back and forth in this thread I still see value in repairing the handle and gaining or improving a skill as opposed to simply opting out for another saw. Saws can be bought but you have to do the work to gain the skill.

Skip

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#29

Re: Leave it Alone

Raney

>Todd,

The thing that you never seem to understand, though, is that while your posts are applicable from the point of view of someone who make his way through the world exclusively by trading in old tools, it's almost completely out-of-touch-with-reality for most of us who don't do that for a living.

Just to give you a little perspective: you may live in Old Tool Hell, but I live in the suburbs in western NJ. Other than those I own, I see approximately 0.00 backsaws per year. The amount of time I have on a weekly basis to go tool hunting borders on nil... Because of this, any backsaw that is in my hand is essentially rare. It's usually worth fixing. Besides, I quite like doing work on old tools - that's part of the hobby for me. Judging by the number of tools out there with user-'adjusted' handles, profiles, etc. I'm not alone.

I can understand your perspective, which almost always runs to "It's worth very little - I see 20 a week for half that. Replacements are so inexpensive it's not worth monkeying with" and I know that's true for you. But for a lot of us, we literally inhabit a different world than you, where the only tools we see are online or in our own shops. And with full-time jobs, families, and time-consuming hobbies like repairing tools, we're not likely to start getting to six auctions, fourteen fleamarkets, and eleven tool dealers per week anytime soon.

I think you get 'jumped' a lot because folks can;t understand your perspective, but maybe you could also try to understand ours. To an auto mechanic any repair is cheap. To an accountant, though, even a brake job is a burden. Capiche?

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#30

Now THAT's funny!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#31

More humor.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>You wrote:

I've seen similar posts on Wood Central, Woodnet, SMC, and Family Woodworking...by the same person...the same pictures, the same text. There's gotta be a better way to waste time, IMO.:-)

Your last line...."There's gotta be a better way to waste time"..

You must be going to all those forums and wasting YOUR time or you wouldn't know about the people who go there wasting their time. LOL

Now that's funny rite thar... (Larry the cable guy)

Marv

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#32

Re: Leave it Alone

Todd Hughes

>"....you may live in Old Tool Hell, but I live in the suburbs in western NJ. Other than those I own, I see approximately 0.00 backsaws per year. .....But for a lot of us, we literally inhabit a different world than you,"

Western NJ, eh?...I live way out in the country right on the Chesapeake Bay so guess you do inhabit a different world then I do ....and that is why I drive about 75 miles to go to a flea market every week in Western NJ which was where I found this older open handle back saw 2 weeks ago for $7 ![talked down from $10].

... While I wouldn't want to live in NJ myself it must be nice to be so close to such good tool hunting grounds instead of where I live and not have to drive such long distances to find stuff.

Please remember in my original post I said I would just glue the handle and then in the follow up post explained how a saw fixed like that could still be used probably...after all it would be simular to the open handle backsaw that I recently found in your "backyard"

I think if sombody posted about what to use to cut a board in two very few people would ansewear him with directions on how to make a saw but rather that he should buy this or that saw. Why ? Because we all make a living trading old tools? No I don't think so but rather it just makes more sense probably for most people to buy a saw then taking the time and effert to make one. All I am saying the same is probably true when it comes to making a handle for an old saw that less face it isn't anything all that special as it is. Now if you like making saws...or handles...that is great and more power to you but please don't tell me that is what I should do or that I am wrong to think it is easier to just buy another saw or to just repair the old handle and use it.

Oh well to bad it is raining or I would be western NJ right now doing my best to make sure your record of seeing no backsaws in the wild remained intact !......Todd


img

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#33

Re: Leave it Alone

Raney

>I am not claiming there are none here - I am well aware that there are wealths of old tools in my area. I am deep in the heart of one of the most heavily woodworking-=populated areas of the country. Yet I still see 0.0 backsaws a year in the wild. Just like I see 0.0 strippers a year, 0.0 crackpipes a year, and 0.0 ultralight gliders a year in the wild. I'm not in a position to be where those items are at.

I have a family life that precludes 'rust hunting', so you can take them or leave them - I still won't have time to find them. Why this is so hard for you to understand is beyond me.

For example, a 75 mile drive to hunt for old tools --- figure 3 hours in the car, 2 hours hunting... that's more daylight 'free time' than I have most weeks. I do my woodworking between the hours of 9 and 11 PM during the week, and from 9P to 3 AM on weekend night. Spending two hours driving and hunting to save money on a saw is ridiculously foolish economy for me unless I happen to enjoy it. I don't. Fixing an old saw, though, might be an enjoyable project for one of those evenings.

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#34

Re: Leave it Alone

Todd Hughes

>"....I see 0.0 strippers a year, 0.0 crackpipes a year..."

And you want us to believe you live in New Jersy ? ...[grin].....Todd

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#35

Yes, not only mine, but everyone's!

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"You must be going to all those forums and wasting YOUR time"

Actually, I don't go to all the fora ever day, but do through the week, and yes I believe it not only wastes my time but others as well.

Seeing a thread on something someone built placed on 4 given foras, yeah, to me it is a waste of time...not only for me, but for many people that I imagine see it.

Quite honestly, I feel I have wasted my time some days when I just read a single thread on a single fora. The more as time moves on, the less I use online foras...go figure...maybe I'm trying to break myself of the habit.:-)

I'm just as honest to your face as I would be on a public fora, my kids can tell you that! They will never believe that I would give you anything but an honest opinion...poker-nater a case in point. *wink* And I have seen similar threads where people like Todd give someone an honest opinion, but get shunned upon as if they're being condescending to them.

BTW, kinda similar reason the company I work for hired me, I tell them WTF I think, wrong or right. I got hired at the company for telling them how f#@$'d up they are. They must like it, they've kept me there for 5 years. Good thing is they continue to get better, so I stay...it tells me they listen.:-) I've made a living for 25+ years going in and cleaning up after companies. They pay good money for doing such! *wink*

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#36

Actually, I have seen the opposite...

Alan DuBoff

>Raney wrote:

"The thing that you never seem to understand, though, is that while your posts are applicable from the point of view of someone who make his way through the world exclusively by trading in old tools, it's almost completely out-of-touch-with-reality for most of us who don't do that for a living."

Funny, but I have actually seen Todd give some very honest advice in the past only to be spoken down upon as being the sour grape in the bunch of life...

I have grown a lot of respect for people like Todd that have the guts to tell people what they honestly think. It is a rare thing these days that people can be honest, especially on these touchy feely foras.

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#37

OT......I heard....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>that the company you work for is or is about to layoff a huge number of worker bees and the stock is going down. What's up with that? Is that purely a cost-cutting move or are sales way down? Or both? Will the company also be laying off some of the non-producers, like middle and upper management folk? That's usually where most of the bloat is. They are usually the last to go but should be the first.

BTW...99% of all companies are f@#%^&%ed up, it's merely a matter of degree. "IMO". I've done a little consulting also.

Marv

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#38

Am I the only one...

Raney

>that finds the continuing poker-nator joke really annoying? It was a gift - there was a subtle private message to state that some of the behind the scenes folks who worked so hard were not so amused, and here we are 2 months later and it's still popping up in every third post you make?

Perhaps unsolicited honesty is not quite the virtue you seem to think it is.

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#39

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

Raney

>and as I stated elsewhere, I think honesty is often absolutley beside the point. For instance, would you tell a random overweight person on the street they looked obese just because it's honest? Is it too 'touchy-feely' for you to have a bit of respect for others?

Because personally, I find such behavior in extremely poor taste. And this is not a matter of political correctness, it's a matter of social skills I thought we all got straight in junior high.

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#40

No, you aren't the only one, however......

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>you just added to the annoyance. It's really not worth mentioning ever again.

Marv

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#41

8^) Totally dude!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#42

Hmmmm...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Maybe paint a nice farm seen on it... Or better yet paint it to look like pine.;^)

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#43

In other words,

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>ignore it and it may go the way of the "pet rock" and mood ring. (hopefully very soon)

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#44

I reccomend more fiber in your diet!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#45

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

paul womack

>I have grown a lot of respect for people like Todd that have the guts to tell people what they honestly think.

The real art is being honest without giving needless offense. Some people use honesty as a cover for being rude or offensive, by accident or design.

BugBear

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#46

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well, the question was asked and Todd et al responded. It's not as if he walked up to someone using a saw and told him it was junk. What's more, Todd's opinion is rational, certainly not an off-the-wall approach. Now, apparently some take great offense at the least provocation; but that's not really Todd's concern. Imagine if we had to state every possible caveat just to give one good piece of advice.

Pam

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#47

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

paul womack

> Imagine if we had to state every possible caveat just to give one good piece of advice.

Indeed. Some people are too easily offended.

I guess moderation in all things is the answer.

BugBear

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#48

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

Raney

>My apologies for bringing drama to the board. FWIW I was not at all 'offended' with Todd's comments - but I have seen an ongoing situation of he and others talking past each other from a complete lack of understanding each others' POV.

Annoyed? Very. But not by Todd.

...and for the record, I have been called many many things in my day. I can safely assure you that 'easily offended' is not a label anyone who has ever met me would apply. Outspoken, though, might be, and when I have something to say I will say it, though i do try for a modicum of tact. Part of the 'social contract' so to speak...

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#49

Re: Leave it Alone

Raney

>That's why I specified western NJ... it's all horse farms and 'quaint' towns around here - we don't even have 'the accent'. 45 minutes East, though, and there's white-lipped nose-wiping pole-dancers to your heart's content :D

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#50

Re: Actually, I have seen the opposite...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hey, no apologies are due me for drama making, I'd like more of it, makes reading the board more exciting; but I'm in a minority, too.

Pam