Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Posts

Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#1

Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Everyone (and especially to Bugbear, Derek, Alan, Mike, Marv and Dan - all who posted in reply to my first question) -

First, a big thanks to Dan for helping me with these pics. Without his help who knows how long it would have taken me to figure out how to post the pics below.

Second, thanks to those who ventured a suggestion to my question about how to fix the broken "lambs tongue" on my London Pattern backsaw. And, for those who thought a pic would help, I am hoping that a pic is attached.

I didn't mention and now you will see that in addition to the portion of missing lambs tongue, the handle itself is broken. I didn't mention it because it appeared - based on my past repairs of plane totes - that this would be a relatively straightforward effort.

Anyway, does seeing the saw handle help any with any additional thoughts or advice on how to repair it?

Thanks for your help!

Regards -

Dave


img

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#2

Another pic

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>For those who might want to see the full view of the saw.


img

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#3

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

MikeW

>Hi Dave,

The handle doesn't look original. I would replace it. It is reasonably easy to do. You can download the instructions for the Gramercy kit, our kit, and in a Lee Valley newsletter, Alf has an article on it.

Take care, Mike

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#4

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dave,

I agree with Mike....looks like a failed attempt at someone trying to make a handle.

It might have been made by the same guy who made the one in the picture below.

Marv


img

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#5

I agree with Mike, it doesn't look original...

Alan DuBoff

>The handles were most often made out of beech in the U.K., but not always...but the location of the nuts is odd and screams that the handle has been replaced/hacked, also.

I'd like to see a couple more pics of the blade and back.

It looks like there's a larger bevel on the bottom of the back, that typically means the saw pre-dates 1850 I've been told by a very good source. The fonts could be telling also, he has dated some saws for me by the type of font used on the back. After about 1850, the makers started using a smaller bevel to save on build time I'm told, and a large bevel is rarely seen after about 1850. This seems to line up with the time frame of when Disston was getting going in the U.S., since he was one of the first to setup a production type line to build handsaws, AFAIK, and he started easing up on the quality to do so...(i.e., machined handles, mass produced backs, etc...).

Who was the maker of the saw? The larger bevel is reminiscent of Groves & Sons, which I think I had mentioned in the previous thread.

Most often the TPI is pretty course on those, I think I have one that is 9 TPI which is too course for my liking. Most of the larger back saws seem to have courser teeth. I prefer about 11-12 TPI on a saw like that. Odd since I prefer about 14 points for smaller dovetail saws, and the one I made for the toolmaking contest.

The steel on the older ones tends to get pretty brittle also, so take it easy when you sharpen it. When it is brittle it will often have a dull and/or blackish tone to the steel, in my experience. The steel on that one doesn't look too bad to me, but pictures are deceiving.

Nice looking saw, sans a decent handle. Will make a good plate for a handle, no doubt.

Good luck, do keep us posted.

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#6

That guy obviously like a low hangin' handle...:-/

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#7

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

paul womack

>I don't know if this counts as a negative attitude, or a positive one, but I'd be inclined to replace that handle, not repair.

It looks "a little funny" to me.

BugBear

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#8

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dave,

Your initial question was about how to repair this handle.

Short of making a new handle, here's what I'd do. I would make a cut just above the lamb's tongue at a 45 degree angle to the hand grip and then make another cut horizontal above where the break is in the hand grip. Remove that screw first though. Now you have two surfaces that are fairly easy to match up with when cutting a new piece to be glued to both surfaces.

Use the cut off old wood as a template when shaping the new wood. That old handle you have there looks like pine from where I sit.

Now grab a coping saw and cut out the hand grip hole and the outer lower part of the hand grip. Grab a rasp and do the radiusing and the lambs tongue. Some course sandpaper and then some finer 220 sandpaper. Sand the entire handle and finish it off with some Boiled Linseed Oil and double 00 steelwool and some paste wax and yer done.

Note that a lambs tongue extends forward just a bit that looks a little like a lip. Find another saw with that type handle or a picture of one so you can see what it looks like. That lip part has been broken off of your handle. I'll include a picture that might help. Oh...and don't forget to wheat carve it. *just kidding* Wheat carving might be like putting lipstick on a pig. (no offense intended)

It's lots of fun and you feel like you just built your own house when yer done. Last but not least, send pictures.

Marv

PS...are you going to sharpen those teeth?


img

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#9

Yeah, looks more like a tote.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#10

Leave it Alone

Todd Hughes

>I don't think the handle is original either, I do think it was probably made a long time ago maybe by the first owner...who knows? I do think it is interesting that he copied a very old design so that makes me think it was done pretty early on. Do you know who made the saw?

Myself I would maybe glue the part of the handle that is broken through and just leave it be otherwise. To me the handle is interesting part of the saw even if not the original. It is somthing that is part of the history of the saw now, while maybe not the prettiest handle I have ever seen it does have a good simple folk art look about it I think and to me adds to it's attractiveness.

Sure maybe you can replace the handle with another one but in the end what will you end up with? an old rusty saw with some new handle. Maybe it will look better but will it be better off?...If you want a saw to use go to the flea market and pick up an old Disston from 1920 for $10 ......Todd

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#11

If it's broke, don't fix it?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#12

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Dave,

If you want any help, I'd be glad to help. I also have some 4/4 QS (American) beech if you'd like a piece.

When I make a new handle I always keep the old handle so that I have them both.

Skip

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#13

Why stop at the Handle?

Todd Hughes

>Maybe this saw is a good canadate for a total restoration after all

....looking at the picture close it appears that the blade is rather rusty too so maybe after the handle is replaced the blade should be too. Then of course that back looks kind of rough and since we now have a new blade and handle might as well replace the back also...maybe with a nice shiny brass one? I bet those saw nuts are dinged up and will look out of place on our new handle so maybe some new ones are in order

Now we have a saw that would be good as new, eh? ....Todd

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#14

Re: Leave it Alone

MikeW

>"Sure maybe you can replace the handle with another one but in the end what will you end up with? an old rusty saw with some new handle. Maybe it will look better but will it be better off?...If you want a saw to use go to the flea market and pick up an old Disston from 1920 for $10 ......Todd"

End up with? Better off? Perhaps having a saw that is usable and that one already owns compared to one that would need to be bought.

Aside from that, there are practical reasons to revive this present saw. At least compared to a Disston of post-1900 vintage. If this saw is old enough to have been made with split nuts and bolts, it is likely that the plate is thinner than the Disston of equal size. Up to 60% thinner. This equates to far less effort to use.

The saw plate on this saw looks to be cleanable. Same with the back. The only thing keeping it from being usable is a handle. It is fairly obvious the owner who replaced the handle did so out of economic concern--the saw already being owned was cheaper than even a then-vintage replacement. Or maybe it was merely more convenient being he already owned it. Regardless, it is a tool meant to be used.

Folk art? I suppose we could consider it something. But I doubt the person who did the replacing considered it thus. For him I suspect he simply wanted a saw that could be used. The "folk art" that is currently on the saw can always be saved for posterity.

Take care, Mike

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#15

Re: Why stop at the Handle?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>If the guy wants to fix it and is asking for pointers as to how the best way to do it, lets offer constructive advise. He obviously thinks it's worth fixing. It might not be for you, but it is for him.

It is easier to not post anything than it is to post something discouraging and disrespectful.

Enough said?

Marv

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#16

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Thanks, Mike. Your saws and saw handles look great.

For me I was (and still am) in the middle of a saw handle replacement on yet another backsaw...and so was hoping to escape with a repair on this one. I have not found the replacement effort hard to do. It just takes time away from other things. Everything is a trade off.

I appreciate your post.

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#17

Lloyd Davies

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Alan -

Thanks for your post.

I think the maker of this saw is Spears and Jackson because of the S&J stamped on the back where the S and J are separated by a crown. However, under this stamp is stamped the name, Lloyd Davies. I thought I had read somewhere that Davies was an English sawmaker. So my theory is that somewhere along the line Lloyd Davies joined or merged or was bought by Spears and Jackson but that, at least for a while, they kept the "Lloyd Davies" the backs because of its brand identification. Just a theory. Would love to know if someone knows the facts.

Again, thanks!

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#18

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Bugbear -

Thanks for your post. It looks a bit weird to me to but I thought it was the odd placement of the saw nuts.

I'm still inclined to work toward a repair - and keep it as close to how I found it as possible.

I appreciate your thoughts.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#19

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Marv -

Thanks for the advice. It was very helpful. I had been thinking about doing some trimming on the handle to make it easier to add the repair piece. I just took the screw out last night and see that it was also glued but apparently the glue had not held. Still it looks and feels like a good break with two good gluing surfaces. Don't know what kind of glue they used on the repair. Hide?

As to sharpening the blade. Yep, I'll give it a try. I still need a lot of work, but so far they have always cut better after I've sharpened them, than before.

Again, thanks.

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#20

Todd, yer killin' me

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>After all the scraping I did to get the rust off this blade you're still calling it rusty?

Thanks for your post :)

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#21

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Skip -

As always you are generous and thoughtful. Thank you for the offer. I guess, bottom line, is that I am hoping to do the minimum possible to get this saw into a condition so I can use it to build some furniture.

If, in the process, I destroy the handle or it disintegrates in my unskilled hands, then I may reconsider and see if your kind offer still stands.

Thanks, so much.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#22

Split nuts and bolts

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Yes, Mike, this saw handle does have split nuts and bolts....and they look in pretty good shape. That is, no one has mangled the split nuts with either adjustments or multiple removals or whatever.

Dave

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#23

Re: Why stop at the Handle?

Todd Hughes

>Well actually when he asked..."Anyway, does seeing the saw handle help any with any additional thoughts or advice on how to repair it?"..., Please notice that OR in there.... I sort of thought he was asking for any additional thoughts on the saw OR how to repair it and not just how to repair it....I was just expressing MY thoughts and opinon on the saw and what I would do...if that is OK with you....Todd

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#24

Repair

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Dave,

Repair the handle, the saw sounds like it is old. (How can a saw 'sound' like it is old?).

Todd is right on this one, where do you stop? Your original question is how to repair this saw right? Repair it don't replace, and then use it, old tools fall into a state of disrepair when not in use.

A perfectly good option is to make a new handle, copying the 'original' as much as possible and retireing the original to the 'study collection', making sure to mark it so when you are gone, someone doesn't throw that old broken handle out with the rest of your crap (I meant fine quality hand tools) when you expire.

Stephen

Re: Saw Handle Repair Question with Pics

#25

Sounds like

Dan Donaldson

>My favorite hammer. I have replaced the handle three times and the head twice. It really is my favorite and a great hammer. ;-)