Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Planing an edge.

Posts

Re: Planing an edge.

#26

Re: Been wondering about that...

wilbur

>"With the guard properly set, I would start jointing a rough edge the same way I would with a hand plane: "always be hollowing". "

I just had vision of Alec Baldwin in a power suit yelling at a bunch of hapless woodworkers desperately trying to meet their quotas or be fired.

"A. B. H. Always Be Hollowing!"

Re: Planing an edge.

#27

Re: Been wondering about that...

ThomD

>LOL! I didn't spot that.

That probably is a bit like what it would be like attending one of my seminars, which is part of why I don't do them any more. :)

Re: Planing an edge.

#28

Re: Does this apply to face planing as well?

ThomD

>It does if you are flatening the face. There can be other stuff going on with faces, like working a burl pattern from ten different directions. The approach really has to do with the longitudinal function of the plane wherever that is encountered.

If you look at it from a simple minded perspective: If someone wanted to know how to make a plane plane a convex shape, everyone would just say take turns working the ends more than the middle. One might plane the outter 1/6ths, then the outer 1/3rds, then the outer 1/2s, and then repeat. If you wanted to reverse that you would just start in the middle and work it more. The only nuanced part of it is that you can only create so much hollow with a straight soled plane. How much hollow depends on blade projection and sole length. Once you know that, you can leverage that depth stop effect. Everything else is pretty obvious.

Re: Planing an edge.

#29

Re: Thous

ThomD

>Most woodworkers don't have a palpable taste for the "thou". It is however the tolerance. It isn't a big deal to get a part with 1-2 thou over the length of the jointer sole. It is easier to do that that to leave it some variable amount. I'm just setting up my South Bend 10L, the level card says to level it dead nuts with a machinist's level that is readily able to detect a .003" shim over 12 inches, that would be crude by my standards for a plane.

The big difference is that woodworking is like massage you just rub the part all over until it is right, while machining can require a good interference fit. It is a relatively rare circumstance for a piece of woodwork to have a shaft that turns within a hole while that is comonplace with machines. It ultimately isn't an issue of comparable accuracy or tolerances, it is more a mater of how the relative standards are measured and applied. Woodworking tools are at their best when determining an increment of reduction in size (*). And it happens to be that process that also sets straight edges, so the tolerances are quite good in that function. It would be a big mistake to asume the standards in metalwork are better.

* A plane can easily remove a shaving of considerably less than 1 thou, but it is not always so clear what the starting point or ending point for a cut is. In possible order:

- joinery require machinist levels of accuracy. Even someting "sloppy" line a "sprung" butt joint couldn't be sloppy in the rate of change in the spring, or it wouldn't come together. A miter needs to be dead nuts, etc...

- Cross sections of a plane cut can be very accuratly helds moldings for instance;

- Interference fits, are very high quality like a door in a frame, not just the gap, but the consistancy of the gap. Lids on boxes that fit like a piston.

- When surfaces are set, they are probably done very accurately, or you couldn't glue down veneer. Shadow lines, or just plain suraces would be ugly, without consistancy, but the overall thickness might not be held all that tight.