Re: Been wondering about that...
Sgian Dubh
>Wiley, below is a question and my response to a questioner at the Woodworker's Journal eZine recently. Brevity is king in these responses, but I've known for a very long time that simply planing away at an already straight edge of a plank means you'll normally end up with a convexity. Corrective short strokes are needed every now and then to keep that edge straight.
I've never done any scientific testing or in-depth analysis of why it happens. I just know it does. And most of the time I use planes I seem to use instinct and experience to get the results I need. Perhaps I've more instinctive understanding of the engineering principles in play than I realise, but I've never really tried to work it out: it just happens and there's a simple way to fix it.
David C and I had a wee chat about this very subject a few months ago when I was down his way photographing a nearby solar kiln for something I'm working on.
However, in practice, who really needs to keep on planing an edge just for the fun of it? Not often, and not many is all I can really think of-- I could be wrong of course. The last time I planed like that for no good reason was probably when I was still at school, ha, ha, and that's far too long ago! Slainte.
Question Explaining Planes
On a jointer, the infeed and outfeed tables are offset, but plane beds are flat. If the plane iron is taking a .002 cut, it seems the back of the plane should be clearing the wood by the same amount, and yet it works even though that is not the case. Can you explain?
Reply, Richard Jones: Oddly enough, you�ll find that by taking 10 to 15 full strokes off an already straight edge of a plank with something like a No. 5 hand plane, you�ll end up with a convex edge. This is because a hand plane is configured as you describe. Every now and then you need to take corrective short strokes or stop shavings out of the middle of that edge to keep it straight.