Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Planing an edge.

Posts

Planing an edge.

#1

Planing an edge.

kyle

>Hello,

I have a number 8 Lie-Nielsen jointer plane. I have tried with little success to shoot the edge on a three foot board. I am close to having the board perfect but I have "run out" at the end.

I know this as I place a Starrett straight edge to check for flatness.

I place as much downward pressure on the plane at the end of the board, but I still can't get it right. I'm out by about 1/32".

Any help would be appreciated.

Regards,

Kyle

Re: Planing an edge.

#2

Re: Planing an edge.

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Kyle,

If I understand, the far end is 'falling away', so that the joint would gap open at the far end. Is that right?

It sounds like you're already applying heel pressure at the end of the cut. So try this, if you haven't already. And this technique is true of all edge jointing IMO:

Plane the board from the 'inside out'. Set your plane for a light cut, and make your initial cuts just in the middle third of the board. When the plane is no longer taking a shaving in the middle, back off and plane the middle two-thirds until you're no longer taking a shaving. Then move back and take a final couple of stopped cuts 1/2" in from each end--this is to avoid the nasty falling-off-ends problem. Then make a final cut full length of the board. What you want to see on the final cut is the plane taking a shaving at the ends, but just scraping the middle of the board, and not actually taking a shaving. If you do that, the board will be sprung just right (about one thou), plus you should not have that bad 'high place' just in from either end.

Wiley

Re: Planing an edge.

#3

What Wiley said and .. .. ..

Andrew F in Australia

>As well, set the blade fine and sharp. The more the blade protrusion, the worse the problem.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Planing an edge.

#4

Re: What Wiley said and .. .. ..

Kyle

>Gentlemen,

Thank you for the replies. As Wiley mentioned the board is falling off at the very end. I have no problem taking a full length shaving...however when I put the straight edge on the board it is still not perfectly flat. I have taken the "Training the Hand" course with Rob Cosman, and he can flatten an edge very easily. I reckon this to how Tiger Woods hits a golf ball. Looks easy but hard to do. If at first you don't succeed try try again.

Thanks for the input and guidance.

Cheers,

Kyle

Re: Planing an edge.

#5

Re: What Wiley said and .. .. ..

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Kyle,

The whole point is--you don't want to take a full length shaving. "Full length shaving" is not the paradigm you're after. Even the last shaving should be heavier at the ends, and light to just scraping in the middle. David Charlesworth has initiated a great experiment which shows that if one just takes full length shavings from an edge, it won't be many shavings before one has planed a nice, convex banana. It is in the nature of things that the plane will take more from the ends, if you proceed naively.

The way so many things work out in handtools is this: If you want to make something flat, you first have to make it a little concave. Then flat is easy. Think plane soles. It's the same thing for edge jointing.

One final thought.....There is not a truly mechanical way to do edge jointing, even though we all tend to describe it that way. It's really all about reading the shaving. You want to contrive the process, so that your final shaving is heaviest at the very ends, tapering down to a light scrape in the middle.

Wiley

Re: Planing an edge.

#6

Been wondering about that...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I've read what Mr. C. has described, and while I don't doubt that the results are there, somehow this procedure seems unnecessary.

Yesterday, our association had its "show and tell" annual event, and not having a new piece to show I brought a woodie that I had modified. I brought along a planing bench hook and a few pieces of wood for people to play with. At some point, as I was walking by the table where my plane was set up, a young girl aged 8 or so was trying the plane and she wasn't getting shavings out. So I asked if I could check the plane, and lo and behold the plane's setting was just fine. What was happening was that the young girl was not putting any pressure on the plane, and I think that's one important reason for getting banana-shaped edges, pressure control.

We are taught that we should put pressure on the toe at the beginning of the planing stroke, gradually shifting the weight to the rear tote as the shaving progresses. I think that, if you fail to do this properly for a couple strokes, then a convexity has been induced on the board's edge, and even if subsequent strokes are done properly the plane only rides the edge that's there, therefore not correcting the problem.

When I plane an edge I put just enough pressure to have the front of the plane sit flat on the board's edge until the tote reaches the point where it also sits above the board. Then I increase the downwards pressure (both on the knob and tote) as I reach the middle of the board, slowly releasing the pressure on the knob as I reach the end of the board, and keeping just enough pressure on the tote to keep the sole flat. Seems to work for me.

The problem Kyle encounters is probably exacerbated by the #8 plane. These planes are very long, the center of gravity is biased to the front, but more importantly there's a lot of sole left aft of the tote, which makes it difficult to keep the sole flat on the board at the end of the stroke. With my Stanley #8 I've resorted to put my right elbow on top of the rear of the plane to help it remain flat on the board. Not very comfortable but it works.

My $0.02,

DC

Re: Planing an edge.

#7

Re: Been wondering about that...

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Denis,

If you have a board which is already perfectly flat. And you use the technique you describe, a skilled worker can keep it flat (there were a couple of respondents to Charlesworth's experiment--Warren Mickley comes to mind--who reported exactly that).

However, suppose you are starting with a board of unknown flatness. You've just laid it up for edge jointing. The technique I am describing is not merely a way to mechanically get a board edge straight--it is also a diagnostic to tell you about the board, starting from scratch. It ties in with the whole notion of reading the shaving and constructing a mental map of the edge from what the shaving is telling you. There are actually very, very few checks with straightedge or square which are necessary to edge jointing, once one learns to read the shaving--the shaving is talking to us, if we listen.

This idea runs exactly counter to the machine-thought notion that I started out with--and perhaps others do as well. The machine-thought is that to edge joint, you want to buy a long, flat plane (a $500 one will be excellent!), and plane end to end with proper heel and toe pressure. The right equipment will do the job for you, if you just push the plane properly.

What turned out to be the case for me was that having the right equipment was enabling and simplifying (I like woodies), but that technique and learning to read the shaving was really the ballgame.

[end of sermon (<:)]

Wiley

Re: Planing an edge.

#8

What Wiley, Andrew and Denis said and...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Keep pressure on the off side so you are square as well as being straight.

Stephen

Re: Planing an edge.

#9

Does this apply to face planing as well?

wilbur

>After reading the excellent explanations of this technique here, I realized that I was sort of doing this when edge planing. Actually, I was trying to spring the joint, but there are some good tips that I'll try next time I do some edge planing.

Is there any reason this approach of planing the center and working outwards shouldn't be applied to planing the face of a board as well?

Re: Planing an edge.

#10

Re: Been wondering about that...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I did not notice it the first time reading, but Kyle says he keeps pressure on, but does not say he transfers pressure to the rear of the plane at the end of the cut. I think Denis is right in suggesting this as the major problem. A worker who is skilled at this technique (transferring weight) can probably flatten a slightly concave edge while taking full length swipes but avoid cutting at the extremes because of the weight distribution .

Warren

Re: Planing an edge.

#11

Interesting question

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Here's 2 cents on that. There are two cases to be separated:

Case 1: Starting roughsawn. Let's say Case 1 is that you have a roughsawn board with mill bandsaw fur still on it, and all you've done is crosscut it to rough length, and rip it to rough width. If there are some big ugly bumps on it, those can be knocked down from visual inspection with a jack plane. I prefer jacks to scrubs because--in my hands--a scrub is too likely to leave some stray marks in a low place, and I'm always trying to conserve thickness, so I don't want any low places lowered. Anyway, I like to get to the foreplane as soon as possible--something with some length on it. The reason is that, instead of reading the shaving, you're now reading the marks left by the plane. The foreplane will, in short order, generate its own topo map right on the board face, skipping the low spots and skinning the high spots.

So here, you're not planing 'inside out' so much as planing end to end and/or hitting 'targets of opportunity' from visual inspection--and the surface which is left by the foreplane is telling you everything about the board.

Case 2: Starting S2S or S4S. Let's say Case 2 is where you've gone to the local hardwood store and bought a load of S4S or S2S lumber, and cut the project parts close to length and width. Suppose you've got a stack of prospective rails and stiles--sticks that are going to have to be dead straight on their own, with no internal structural members to force them to straightness. '

And so basically you're going to plane the bow out of the boards. In this situation, you've already decided that you're either going to start on the convex side or the concave side. So there's not much discovery to be done. You just need to either shim the middle a little--if you're going convex first--and plane it inside out til its flat (this is what I prefer to do). The option is to shim the ends and go concave side first, and in that case you're knocking down the ends first, until you can plane end to end.

Course the bench has got to be flat to do all this.....

But it's kind of a different situation from edge jointing, I think.

Wiley

Re: Planing an edge.

#12

Re: Been wondering about that...

Sgian Dubh

>Wiley, below is a question and my response to a questioner at the Woodworker's Journal eZine recently. Brevity is king in these responses, but I've known for a very long time that simply planing away at an already straight edge of a plank means you'll normally end up with a convexity. Corrective short strokes are needed every now and then to keep that edge straight.

I've never done any scientific testing or in-depth analysis of why it happens. I just know it does. And most of the time I use planes I seem to use instinct and experience to get the results I need. Perhaps I've more instinctive understanding of the engineering principles in play than I realise, but I've never really tried to work it out: it just happens and there's a simple way to fix it.

David C and I had a wee chat about this very subject a few months ago when I was down his way photographing a nearby solar kiln for something I'm working on.

However, in practice, who really needs to keep on planing an edge just for the fun of it? Not often, and not many is all I can really think of-- I could be wrong of course. The last time I planed like that for no good reason was probably when I was still at school, ha, ha, and that's far too long ago! Slainte.

Question Explaining Planes

On a jointer, the infeed and outfeed tables are offset, but plane beds are flat. If the plane iron is taking a .002 cut, it seems the back of the plane should be clearing the wood by the same amount, and yet it works even though that is not the case. Can you explain?

Reply, Richard Jones: Oddly enough, you�ll find that by taking 10 to 15 full strokes off an already straight edge of a plank with something like a No. 5 hand plane, you�ll end up with a convex edge. This is because a hand plane is configured as you describe. Every now and then you need to take corrective short strokes or stop shavings out of the middle of that edge to keep it straight.

Re: Planing an edge.

#13

Re: Been wondering about that...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If you really want to make your head hurt, think about the fact that Japanese planes typically are higher behind the blade than in front (using western terminology here, if I talk eastern, it gets way too complicated). Now there is some variation due to personal preference, so some will level their jointer soles.

The weird thing is that the Japanese planes' discontinuity is the reverse of power jointers; but it means that when I edge joint with Japanese planes, I can't apply force on the back end at the end of the plane stroke.

Pam

Re: Planing an edge.

#14

Re: Been wondering about that...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Talking about oddity, Richard, I have seen people argue on this forum that having a flat sole and an iron projecting below would yield a concave surface to the extent of the projection. I cannot imagine geometric analysis supporting your idea here. If I were getting a consistent concavity or convexity, I would be thinking about altering the sole.

Re: Planing an edge.

#15

Re: Been wondering about that...

Sgian Dubh

>But Warren, if the soles of all your planes are pretty flat, as mine are, even if they're not flat to super-fine engineering tolerances, what do you suggest they should be altered to; concave, convex, or concave at one end and convex at the other end?

I'm not sure absolute flatness of a plane sole is all that important anyway. I've said it before I know, but I sometimes purposely bend and/or twist longer metal plane soles slightly as I'm using them to get specific results. Slainte.

Re: Planing an edge.

#16

How flat is flat, how straight is straight?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I have been reading threads on the subject of planing off and on over past months in this forum. I get the impression that the goal when using planes in general is to attain perfection, absolute flatness, absolute straightness. I'm more of a metal working kinda guy than I am a woodworker. I feel I can depend on metal staying put within much closer tolerances than I can wood, but even when working metal there are always tolerances and allowances involved. When I make something I make it only as good or accurate as is required for the purpose it is to be used. If plus or minus .005 does the job, I will not attempt to hold plus or minus .001. The point I want to make here is, why spend time and effort making a board absolutely flat when in reality, it doesn't matter? Am I asking a stupid question here?

Thank you,

Marv

Re: Planing an edge.

#17

Re: How flat is flat, how straight is straight?

Sgian Dubh

> "why spend time and effort making a board absolutely flat when in reality, it doesn't matter? Am I asking a stupid question here?

I don't think you are. I like to think I build my furniture to tight tolerances, but those tolerances are much greater than many engineering requirements.

Overall dimensions for example are generally good enough for me if they're within a millimetre or two in about 600 mm. After all, if I make a table top 750 mm wide today it could be either 747 mm or 753 mm in a few weeks time. Even wood length changes by about 0.1% from FSP to oven dry, so a 2000 mm long top could increase or decrease length by about 0.5 mm. Slainte.

Re: Planing an edge.

#18

Re: Been wondering about that...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am not having problems with the plane wanting to yield convex or concave surfaces. As I said before, I think almost all end dipping is due to too much pressure on the toe as the plane finishes the cut. If my plane consistently gave a convex surface I would consider adding convexity to the sole.

Re: Planing an edge.

#19

Re: Been wondering about that...

Sgian Dubh

> "If my plane consistently gave a convex surface I would consider adding convexity to the sole."

Warren, I'm not sure that's necessary, and does it really solve anything? I've been doing this edge straightening and squaring thing with my handplanes for so long now I've largely forgotten what I do, that is without breaking it all down and really thinking about the task.

If I've got a convex edge I just plane the high spot out of the middle. It might only be a couple of shavings. If I'm working on a rough edge that's never been planed and it's convex then I use the same principle-- plane out the high spot, or spots, until it's near straight and then do the final straightening and squaring.

Actually, to be honest, I mostly just shove the stuff over a big electric surface planer and the job's usually done in 30 seconds or less usually, ha, ha. But a sprung edge joint still usually gets the hand plane treatment from me for the final fit. I also demonstrate handplaning boards square and straight to woodworking beginners on a fairly regular basis. It keeps my eye and hand in if nothing else. Slainte.

Re: Planing an edge.

#20

Whoops. Typo

Sgian Dubh

>Here's a correction. Sorry about the typo. I'm not sure how such a howler slipped by me. Poor proof-reading before posting I guess. Sorry again. Slainte.

I said, "I don't think you are. I like to think I build my furniture to tight tolerances, but those tolerances are much greater than many engineering requirements."

It should have read, I don't think you are. I like to think I build my furniture to tight tolerances, but those tolerances are much lower than many engineering requirements.

Re: Planing an edge.

#21

Re: Planing an edge.

Kyle

>Gentlemen,

I am overwhelmed by the responses received from my question. Your input is greatly appreciated. Spending time in the "workshop" gives me great joy even if on occassion the results are marginal.

One point I should have mentioned is that I am left handed. Perhaps like when I was a child in school and had left handed scissors, Mr. Lie Nielsen did not take this into consideration with all his lovely planes that I own. Not likely, but I need an excuse.

Regards,

Kyle

Re: Planing an edge.

#22

Re: Whoops. Typo

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thanks for the correction...I was a bit perplexed.

So tell me, what are some typical tolerances that you adhere to? For example, when you plane to make a board flat, how much of a dip or hump do you allow? I'm referring to a surface that will be open and visible when the piece is completed. If the surface is an inside surface, do you still spend the extra time to flatten it to the same tolerances? Or do you say, hey, no one will see it so lets get on with more important aspects of the project?

I'm a self made machinist by trade, long retired. I find that skills I used as a machinist are very useful at times when working with wood, but I still apply the same rule when it comes to tolerances. If I don't need it, I don't do it. I have known other machinists who would insist on milling and squaring every surface of a part whether it needed it or not, mainly because it made them feel better about their work. When I got to a level in business where I was responsible for the bottom line, I insisted that they use my rules. I've had machinists quit because of it.

I ask the questions of you because I'm curious to know if you woodworkers think in terms as most machinsts think when it comes to fit and finish, so to speak, like spending time on something only because it makes you feel better about your work, even though it isn't particularly needed.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Planing an edge.

#23

Re: Whoops. Typo

Sgian Dubh

>Here's the short answer. I only do what the customer is willing to pay for. I don't go making drawers with hand cut dovetails, slips and solid wood bottoms if the customer is only paying for five bits of plywood nailed together that run on metal drawer slides.

Getting solid wood table and cabinet tops perfectly flat is generally a fool's errand. It'll probably be out of flat tomorrow, so there's no point. Flat enough is usually good enough, which means no obvious localised dips, hollows, furrows, cups, missing divots, etc. There is always the exception to every rule, and exceptions cost extra. Slainte.

Re: Planing an edge.

#24

Avoid the whole problem, Shooting Board.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Planing an edge.

#25

Re: Been wondering about that...

ThomD

>I argue that, and pretty much got kicked off the UK forum for suggesting it, until Chalesworth explained it in some videos the next year or so. I first got the idea from the Krenov plane building video 20 years ago, which coincidentally killed my VCR yesterday. Presumably people have always known this stuff.

Planes do a variety of things, in the middle of a surface they essentially operate as mild convex soles. At least as far as the longi profile is concerned.

The power tool with it's infeed and outfeed is really most easily used the same way as the plane. Books have pictures of the power process with already perfect board being marched along the already perfect infeed, and perfectly supported on the outfeed, with the deduction being whatever the cut is set at. But in the real world, the outfeed is dropped one inch of board walk, or so, below the max height of cut. With the guard properly set, I would start jointing a rough edge the same way I would with a hand plane: "always be hollowing". Take out the middle third, then the middle two thirds, then the whole thing. Often the edge can be straightened in two passes given the amount of wood that can be removed in a pass. When the ends support the board with nothing touching in the middle, one full pass and it is as flat as it is likely to get.

Japanese planes with their relieved outfeeds are mostly for finishing, where the objectives are different. Japanese jointers have 3 contact points.