Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

Posts

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#26

Re: Yes and no

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't pay one bit of attention to the type of steel used, but this isn't a drive to ignorance. I simply don't know much about metallurgy (except lamination in general), don't have the time to learn, and found empirically that I don't enjoy blacksmithing; so rather than pretending I do know something, I put my trust in the makers who's edge tools I've tried and liked. Now there's a tiny bit of risk there, but I haven't been burnt. What I don't have is the knowledge to pick out the great, cheap tool from the unheard of maker. I'll let the dealers do that for me.

Pam

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#27

Re: Yes and no

ThomD

>There aren't any dealers up here so it's always a crapshoot, in many cases the dealers aren't really woodworkers anyway. And people don't tend to have the same objectives.

I'm more likely to trust the artisans. They make a lot of their better tools in white steel and blue steel. I was also interested that among Jim B. and crew at the plane workshop there was a side discusion on what are the better chisels, and it turned out that they were using white steel chisels out of preference. (I hope I have that right.)

Most of my chisels are slightly fancy and blue steel of the best type available when I bought them. A reasonable number are HSS since Mahogany Masterpieces was slinging those. And quite a few are medium grade Iyoroi from LV. The most important decision was to buy Japanese chisels, after that everything else is less important. And any chisel, regardless of country of origin, will get the job done.

Just so long a people's general resistance to falling down the Japanese tool rat hole isn't augmented by a concern that getting the right one is an Artherian quest. My general guideline is white oak handles, good maker, medium price, you have probably stumbled on the good stuff.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#28

Re: Yes and no

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>There are no dealers here, either; but I've found Hida, Iida, and probably So (I say probably because of a pricing misunderstanding which was most likely due to his web site a year ago when it was immature) to be reliable and knowledgeable vendors. I think most of my edges are white steel; but that's not because I think blue is inferior. As for Jimbo, what he says is of negative interest to me, given a really huge bad thing he did.

Pam