Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

Posts

Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#1

Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

wilbur

>"I think that the whole japanese chisel issue can be summed up this way.

If you were to try to use a japanese chisel to chop a dovetail on cocobolo, you'd be up $#!+ creek after the first mallet blow. (much less lignum vitae)"

I got curious after reading this in a thread about chisels in another forum. I finally had some time tonight to test out this proposition, and I thought you all might be interested.

So here's the test set up. On the Japanese chisel side, a "delicate" 3 mm Imai bench chisel (oire nomi), about $50 from Hida Tool, which is the same cost as a 1/8" Lie-Nielsen bevel edge socket chisel. On the cocobolo side, a cocobolo bowl blank 2" thick. If you look closely, you'll be able to see how much I overpaid for this bowl blank. ;)


I did a quick touch up of the chisel on a natural fine waterstone before starting. No chips here.


I sawed the sides of the dovetail.


And started chopping.


Close up of the chisel stuck in the cocobolo after a good whack. Notice that the width of the place I'm chopping is actually twice as wide as the width of the chisel I'm using, so I'm really doing twice the chopping I would if I were using a properly sized chisel.


After getting about halfway through, I started chopping from the other side.


All done! Total chopping time was a few minutes, not counting the time I took to take pictures.


No chips in the chisel after cutting a 2" thick dovetail in cocobolo.


Here's what I think is the impressive part. I took a scrap piece of pine, and did some endgrain paring with this chisel, without any additional sharpening.


Hope you like the test and pictures!

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

Moses Yoder

>I am not sure why someone would say that about cocobolo. I find cocobolo to be a fairly soft wood. About the same density as maple I guess, only a nicer color. I feel bad about that beautiful chunk of cocobolo being wasted in reply to a fool :)

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#3

Not to worry about the cocobolo

wilbur

>Well, no worries about ruining the cocobolo with the dovetail I cut out of it. This is a bowl blank, so that part of the blank is going to be turned away anyway.

Of course, there was a comment about "Does one dovetail really put anything to rest?" I had nothing better to do last night, so I did this with a piece of 8/4 white oak. I used the same 3 mm Imai chisel that I used on the cocobolo, without resharpening it.

Japanese chisel and white oak

Given the width of my 3 mm chisel, I had to take 2-3 passes in each notch, so it was at least twice the chopping I would do if I used a properly sized chisel. If I'm calculating this right, the amount of chopping I did here is close to what I would need to do for all four corners of a dovetailed box made of 1/2" white oak with a properly sized chisel.

After I finished the chopping in the 8/4 white oak, I made some more endgrain shavings from that same piece of scrap pine I used before, which you can see. Again, no sharpening since before I chopped the dovetail in that cocobolo bowl blank. And still no chipping.

It felt like the chisel was slowing down a bit as I got towards the end, but maybe my hammering arm was just getting tired. In any case, the chisel was still sharp enough to make clean endgrain shavings in pine.

I've never really done a test like this before, but I used to be happy with my Imai chisels. Now I'm REALLY happy with them.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#4

Imai chisels are great

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>But if you get the chance treat yourself to his sword steel ones, they're a cut above that (pardon the pun)...

DC

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#5

Wilbur, did you pull the chisel?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I just had to ask, you dodged the bullet here, they went after you on the other forum.

As i imagined, you were correct, laminated tools are better (maybe we can open that can of worms here). No one offered any defendable response, but if it goes to court, I probably can't be an expert witness as Japanese tools are not my speciality.

And apparently you didn't listen when they told you, you couldn't do that, I like that kind of thinking. Not only did you defend your position you did it so eloquently.

Good Work.

Stephen

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#6

YUP.....definite agreement here......

Brent in Montreal

>

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#7

Re: Not to worry about the cocobolo

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Wilbur,

NICE way to test out that statement! Very scientific and to the point. But your multiple dovetails in white oak test REALLY sums it up nicely. Well done!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#8

Re: Imai chisels are great

wilbur

>Mmmm...sword steel. One day, maybe. :@)

One unexpected bit of fall out from this little experiment is that I used to dream of the day I could have a set of Imai sword steel chisels, especially after seeing pictures of the ones that you and others have posted here. But now, my obsession with getting the sword steel chisels is a little less, since I found out how far I can push a regular Imai chisel.

To be honest, I didn't think it do as well as it did in the white oak test. That actaully was a nice surprise for me.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#9

Re: Wilbur, did you pull the chisel?

wilbur

>I used to, but then I was told that I would go blind. :@)

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#10

I quite when I needed glasses 8>}

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#11

OT - did you buy anything yesterday?

wilbur

>Hi Dominic,

It was nice chatting with you at the CRAFTS auction yesterday. How much damage did you do?

Wilbur

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#12

Re: Imai chisels are great

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I actually asked Kayoko about the difference between the two lines when I was shopping, and she told me that beyond the mokume "eye candy" the sword steel line has better steel and Imai-san puts more work into that steel. I've yet to doubt Kayoko's advice...

Does that help greasing the slope a bit? :-)

DC

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#13

Nada!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Wilbur,

It was nice speaking to you (and your son!) as well. I didn't buy anything other than the tenon saw I purchased out in the parking lot. I bid on several things but dropped out when the prices went out of my range. But my friend Mike scored big time! He got a huge tap and die set for $50. It's worth about 10 times that! All in all it was a cool time.

HOWEVER, next time I know to get there earlier and bring something to EAT! My buddy and I left because we were both starving. And those hot dogs were not cutting it.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#14

Re: Japanese chisel vs. hardwood

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Great job, Wilbur, very effective.

Pam

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#15

Wilber!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Whadda doin man... Cutting DT on a mitre box? or is that a TS?

Kinda looks like one of those Martion dovetails Tommy cuts too.

Never the less, insteresting test. Thanks for posting it.

The only thing that's killed, well lets say tortured one of my Japanese chisels was a unruly piece of Jahara I was putting some mortices thru.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#16

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Wilbur

Thank you. Of course, now I also want Imai! Damn.

For interest, I spent the weekend chopping dovetails for cabinets. I lost count of how many. They were all in 3/4" thick resiny pine. I was using basic Iyoroi bench chisels and Matsumura dovetail chisels. The thing is, I did not stop once to use a waterstone the entire weekend. When the edges started to cut less cleanly, I stropped on leather. And then back to chopping.

This pine is the Devil to cut cleanly without breakout. Your edges need to be sharp. The following image was taken near the end of Day Two.

Pine pins chopped on one side, wedged under a fence.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#17

Re: Imai chisels are great

ThomD

>It's not what they put in it's what comes out. I don't think that the real Japanese craftsmen see it the same way. They seems to put a lot of emphasis on conditioning the chisels, and features that attend different steels for different purposes. There aren't any ultimate steels. Different guys seem to prefer different steels.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#18

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

ThomD

>That's total crap, as I gather we all agree. The Japanese probably see a lot of harder woods than we do. What about the Ebony planes they make for the tourist trade? I can't think of any chisel that can't cut hardwood. You might not want to pry with a Japanese chisel, but that habit normally doesn't survive learning to sharpen.

I have a couple of metal working shapers. These things push 2 dollar HSS chisels through STEEL all day. Where do people get these stupid ideas.

Another thing that normally impresses when seeing a Japanese craftsperson work (and generally true of the real deal in a lot of fields): They wail on those chisels like you wouldn't believe, if power cutting is required. Most people have little idea of what those chisels will take. How many of over-here people's Japanese using chisels does one see with serious mushrooming! If you take the average Japanese chisel and look at the thickness at the thinest point above the shoulders, it is noramlly a much stiffer construction than on Western chisels. These things are designed to be beaten like a rented mule.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#19

What is an (oire nomi) chisel

Wayne Carson "TX"

>Is it a particular type made by different makers

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#20

Re: What is an (oire nomi) chisel

wilbur

>An oire nomi chisel is the Japanese chisel equivalent of a basic bench chisel. However, there are some differences in the overall size and scale between the two. The Japanese bench chisel tends to be shorter (mine is 8 1/2" long) and has a handle diameter that's smaller than the western bench chisel.

This is one of the reasons why many people don't like Japanese bench chisels -- they're too small for their hands, which is perfectly valid. There is another type of Japanese chisel called an atsu nomi, or timber chisel, which is scaled more like a typical western bench chisel.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#21

Yes and no

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Yes, makers seem to prefer different steels, maybe because they've developed an expertise with a particular type. Yes, despite the apparent trend towards blue steel (and variants), Imai uses white steel, and trust me, he gets the results. Craftsmanship still counts a lot in getting a quality chisel (or plane blade), but in the end even the best maker in the world can't push a lower grade of steel beyond its capabilities. Unfortunately, the less expensive chisels are pushed too hard in order to get high Rc numbers, and they're brittle as a result.

It takes both good steel and mastery to produce an edge that's both very hard and very tough. Imai does it, he's one of the few that manages that feat.

DC

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#22

Imai & Inomoto at Hida in June

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Just received this announcement:

HIDA TOOL & HARDWARE

KEZUROU-KAI USA

&

WALTON'S SAW 55TH ANNIVERSARY

Come celebrate with us

On Saturday 14th and Sunday 15th, June 2008

Featured entertainment

Blacksmith demonstrations by:

ARNON KARTMAZOV

FROM JAPAN:

CHUTARO IMAI, MASTER BLACKSMITH (Fujihiro)

ISAO INOMOTO, MASTER BLOCK PLANE MAKER

ADDITIONAL DEMOS

Michael Laine James Wiester

Japanese chisels/ Japanese plane sharpening

Japanese plane setting

Planning

Joinery

Knife sharpening

Machine and Tool Operation & more

DISCOUNTS ON ALL OUR MERCHANDISE 10%, 20% OR MORE

Sign up now, ATTENDANCE IS LIMITED

44 Woodland Avenue, San Rafael, CA

www.bitsnblades.com 1-800-425-6433

http://www.hidatool.com 1-800-443-5512

Bento Boxes and BBQ & Soft Drinks

$35.00 PER DAY

$60.00 FOR 2 DAYS

$40.00 PER DAY AT THE DOOR

Doors open at 9.00 a.m.

Looks like good fun to me.

Pam

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#23

Re: Yes and no

ThomD

>Interesting,

I was thinking of what different users like, they don't all gravitate to the one steel. A lot of people still like white steel. I have a lot of Japanese chisels, been adding to them for 25-30 years. I can't say I particularly prefer the blue steel, it's kinda an A2 experience if at a higher lever. In general those who prefer white steel seem to prefer it because it is less fragile or tempermental, the O1 of the litter.

There is always tension in designs. "Improvement" in one direction will almost always be at the cost of some other feature if several features are prized. We have a tool culture that is driven by endorsements and the occasional test. Chisels that can vanquish other chisels are not woodworking tools anymore than a car that can win on the 1/4 mile is what you want to drive to work in the morning. Anymore than the sleeping bag proven on Everest is what I would use for summer camping, or even winter for that mater.

I would actually be a little worried about a brand that had a range as you describe, it seems like pushing white to be blue would be a stupid approach, when there is very little difference in the cost of the raw materials. The only reasonable approach is to push each in the direction it wants to go. Even western knife makers do that with often a fairly large number of steels each may use. I'm sure the Japanese tradition is of that sort also.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#24

Re: What is an (oire nomi) chisel

ThomD

>"This is one of the reasons why many people don't like Japanese bench chisels -- they're too small for their hands,"

Heino Engle details in his book (I have no idea), that the main difference in Japanese and european stature is leg length. That a Japanese man from the waist up is fairly equivalent in stature to a european. (comes up in his analysis of japanese homes and the Tatami based measurement system used to design them). If there is any truth to this, then there may be less truth to the observation you report than might be otherwise imagined. Consider for instance the Japanese hammer hamdle. It is far thinner is diameter than an equivalent western hammer, than could ever be explained by size differences. On that basis it might be designed for a grip half the size of the european.

Re: Japanese chisel vs. cocobolo - lots of pics

#25

I'd love to go there!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>