Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Looking for some advice

Posts

Re: Looking for some advice

#26

Get a Belt Sander

Todd Hughes

>Ive used them both and I think a belt sander is much more useful for sharpening and many other jobs too. I have a big [72 X 2 inch]one I made myself out of mostly scrap but I have used small cheap ones too and for sharpening stuff like chisels, plane blades etc. they work very well. Easy and cheap to change grit size

I don't use any rests or anything like that but just sharpen with the edge held vertical on the belt and even with abused edges you can get them sharp in a matter of a min. or so. I normaly finish up on a old oil stone but I know guys that do it all on a belt sander and get edges sharp enought to shave hair easly.....Todd

Re: Looking for some advice

#27

No such thing as a single further question

Skip in Falls Church

>A couple of other questions now that I've committed myself. Any suggestions about a wheel dresser? It looks like LV has a couple of types of diamond dressers, a diamond coated bar and a diamond single point and I know there's star dressers. Keeping in mind I'm a total novice at these things is one any better than another?

Is there a source of cast iron lapping plates? If not, how about cast iron griddles? They come in round and rectangular and it seems that it would be relatively easy to cut them up and flatten them.

Thanks everyone,

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#28

Re: you will love them when you hone them

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When your grinder arrives look at the wheel label and determine what the bond is; it will be a letter. If the bond is K (likely) the wheel is too hard in my opinion. If by some miracle it is H then use it and see if you are satisfied. There is not that much difference between 7 and 8 that I would buy a new wheel just to get a 7". You will need a wheel dresser so that you can first make the wheel round, and then crown it. I like the kind that look like a diamond studded plate on a short stick- about $7.

Re: Looking for some advice

#29

Re: Get a Belt Sander

ThomD

>+100.

I use grinding wheels for sharpening metal bits where accuraccy in setting myriad angles is important. I use wheels for turning tools.

I use belts for any roughing, and just about everything else. They are also powerful for making stuff in metal that needs to be a different shape than the piece you have to start with. They swallow metal like it's not even there. I use a 1x42, and a 2x72.

I've had the same 1x8 wheel from Taiwan for nearly thirty years. I have the oneway ballancer installed, but frankly it really isn't necesarry or really all that useful. Mine is only 1800 which I prefer, at twice the speed and 4 times the energy I could see a ballancer being an asset.

The good stuff is on ebay and craigslist, like the Baldor sets mentioned or even fancier grinders that will blow your mind.

Re: Looking for some advice

#30

1" x 42" is a handtool-making workhorse in my shop

David Barnett - SW Florida

>My little hundred dollar Delta 1"x42" belt & 8" disc sander is one of my most versatile tools and is going strong after years of demanding work. I use it for sharpening carving tools for wood and stone and it maintains the edge on my old Collins machete when the jungle encroaches on the lanai and pool enclosure. However, it really shines when I make small handtools for woodworking, stone carving, silversmithing, and so on.

36 through 1200 grit belts pretty well covers grinding/shaping, sharpening and honing. There are leather belts for stropping, too. I like the blue zirconia belts for coarser work, but the gold J-Flex belts from Klingspor and the 3M 967F series are amazing for fine edges and run very cool.

Beyond tool edges, though, 3M Trizact and Micron belts can shape and polish all kinds of materials; non-ferrous metals, bone, plastics, horn, and so on. I use linen and felt belts from golf club maker supply catalogs and 3M ScotchBrites for satin finishes. Although pricier, the Klingspor cork-backed belts can handle wet finishing ('damp' is more like it) and perform some very special tricks.

I faced the platen with graphite (easily done), but most of the stuff I do is slack belt shaping and polishing (easy, fun, intuitive), so the platen's usually detached. I sometimes wear a Kevlar glove while slack belting awkward or largish workpieces, but usually I just control the belt and pressure with my fingers or a loop of leather over my index and middle. This is great for shaping pipe stems and the transition from stem to shank, and it's superb for shaping hammer & mallet heads, handles for chisels, files, and rasps (I'm not a big fan of 'round'). smooth arrises, reshape and polish hammer polls and stakes, wood carving (roughing, smoothing, finishing) and I'll just stop here with the nearly endless applications.

Oh... another useful mod is to replace the top wheel on the three-wheel models with a neoprene caster wheel, allowing for contact wheel shaping. Other mods, too, of course.

And then there's the 8" disc with the tilting table and little mitre gauge... but I'll stop for real, this time.

Re: Looking for some advice

#31

Re: you will love them when you hone them

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Bill,

I'll be sure to check and if the wheel's too hard order a 7" to replace it. I'm sure there's differences in the pink wheels as well - any thing to look at there?

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#32

Re: Get a Belt Sander

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Todd,

You might have noticed that I've already taken the plunge on a grinder. I do have a belt/disk sander but I've always used it for coarser applications. I've never had much luck with sharpening on it. Since I'll have both I can try both. In any case, thanks for the input.

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#33

Re: Dave & Bill: Does speed matter?

ThomD

>I think one should manage speed and size separately, though in practice it's not so easy. Basically though, the smaller wheels cut a different profile, and undermine the edge more. You could also say the smaller wheels might last longer between regrindings. But whatever the reason I choose the profile for profile reasons, and not for speed reasons. For most stuff of interest to this group, I would prefer a larger wheel right up to say a 16" contact wheel on a belt grinder if I could aford it. Better still is the falt surface of a belt grinder, though it is a little harder to ride.

As far as speed is concerned it could be set up on a variable speed arbour which is the right answer, but it's also a lot more expensive. I have variable on my belt grinder, but my 8" wheel is slow speed and I have been fully happy with that for just about everything from turning tools to regrinds on delicate tools like Japanese tools (don't sharpen under power but occasionally have reground). Speed mater because energy varies to the square of velocity, so double your speed and your ability to burn something goes up by a factor of 4. So what. If a wheel explodes though you are at much higher risk.

When it comes to delicate tools I dip them first in water and grind until the water evaporates at the edge, then repeat. This is a little more agressive that some, but you basically keep the edge under 200. The tool may gain heat as it goes to the point where it doesn't stay wet for long, in which case I rest it.

Dry grinders aren't really designed for us. They are the kind of thing designed to sharpen a HSS cutter in a machine shop. They work fine as long as one keeps the wheels clean and proceeds with caution.

Re: Looking for some advice

#34

Re: wheel selection, the story on 3X particles

Skip in Falls Church

>My grinder arrived today - with a white and a pink wheel, however, it appears that they would both be too hard if I interperted Leonard Lee's book correctly.

The white wheel is a WA60N5V which if I have it right would be an aluminum oxide 60 grit N bond and the pink one is a WA80N5W - an aluminum oxide 80 grit N bond as well.

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#35

Re: wheel selection, the story on 3X particles

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi Skip,

You got it. The '5' toward the end of the string indicates a dense bond, also.

I've been looking around also, in light of Bill T's discussion of the 3X (30%SG) and the 5SG (50%SG) wheels. I've been real happy with Joel's Grade I 3X wheel, but I notice that McMaster Carr has the 5SG wheel, 7" x 1/2" x 1-1/4", Grade I, 46g, right at $50. Like Bill, I think the 1/2" wheel is just as good.

I'd like to stay at Grade I or softer, even with the SG bond.

Anybody using the 5SG wheel?

Wiley