Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Looking for some advice

Posts

Looking for some advice

#1

Looking for some advice

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi,

After reading Bill's advice about sharpening using a grinder followed by diamond paste I've decided to take the plunge and buy a grinder. Diamond paste I have - but I've come to the conclusion that my hand grinder isn't going to doo it for me.

In looking at grinders there seems to be a pretty wide array out there - but I really have no experience with them. I'm sort of leaning toward an 8" variable speed - but wanted to see what anyone that had some hands on experience would say. I also don't recall which stones to buy or where to get them. Any advice would be appreciated.

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#2

Stones *LINK*

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Skip,

I have found the Norton 3X (I grade) very cool running, and they cut quickly also. See link. Another recommendation would be whatever Bill Tindall recommends, but the Norton 3X are outstanding. I have the 60g; the 46g might even be a better choice.

Wiley


Norton 3X Grinding Wheel

Re: Looking for some advice

#3

Re: Looking for some advice *LINK*

Dave Mount, NE Minnesota

>Morning Skip--

I don't have all the answers, that's for sure, but I can give you the perspective I've developed from the things I've done and mistakes I've made. I think a lot of one's opinions about these matters arise from the path one takes as well as some personal convictions that vary from person to person. As you know, using hollow ground edges at all has generated a lot of intense debate here over the years.

Before I get into my own experience, I'll mention Joel's article on grinder sharpening in the last FWW. Even if you don't follow his exact path, I thought there was a lot of good stuff to think about in that article.

My "grinder path" started with a Tormek I received from the widow of a woodworker friend. I'm not sure I would have jumped to such an expensive approach otherwise, but it was a generous and appreciated gift in return for some other things I did for her. Point is that I backed into a dry grinder after I already had a wet grinder. At that time, I thought of a dry grinder as a shaping tool for rough steel, not really as a sharpening tool. I bought an 8" 3450 rpm grinder on the "more power more better" illusion, then equipped it with a 1" Norton white wheel, again with a "wider is better" mentality.

As time went on, I started using the dry grinder as a more refined sharpening tool. One good thing I did was to buy a Veritas grinder rest set up. If the grinder you buy doesn't have a pretty good tool rest as stock equipment (and most don't), I'd strongly suggest getting a good aftermarket rest. I like the Veritas a lot, but I don't have any experience with any other, so that's doesn't necessarily mean it's the best one to get. My memory is that Joel's article kind of downplays the significance of the tool rest, but I'm not sure I agree, at least for the period where you're learning to work with a dry grinder. I've had mine for a while and I still like it a lot. I think it's like learning to work with planes; if you have the chance to use one that's well tuned, it enables you to get more out of a poorer plane than you could if you just started with a poorly tuned plane and tried to improve it. I've also seen pictures of shop-built auxiliary tables people have built for their grinders and those seem like they would work well.

You're already thinking variable speed, so you're already heading off one problem I have, and that's the high speed of a 3450 rpm motor spinning an 8" wheel. It's easier to burn edges with it. However, there are other disadvantages to an 8" wheel -- they are more expensive and tend toward wider sizes. While I thought this was a good thing when I started, now I don't think it is. Most of the grinding I end up doing is at a narrow point on both the wheel and the workpiece. I don't really grind across a whole 1" width. You end up grinding straight not by registering the workpiece to the flat face of the wheel, but by orienting the workpiece to the overall plane of the wheel and then moving the piece across. Working this way, you get a straight edge even from a rounded wheel face. Working with a narrower, rounded face you also reduce the chances of grinding where you don't mean to by slightly cocking the workpiece and having it start cutting somewhere else on the edge. With a wide wheel, I think you end up cutting away most of that extra abrasive with your wheel dresser, not removing metal from your workpiece.

Another thing to think about is the size of the concavity you create with your grind. Since you're going this route, I'm assuming you're already past all the arguments about less supported edges. That being the case, the larger the concavity, the more honings you get before you have to re-establish the concavity. That comes with a smaller wheel. I did some calculations and, if I did them correctly, a 1/8" thick blade ground at 30 degrees on a 6" wheel has a concavity 0.0026" deep, while ground on an 8" wheel it is 0.0020" deep. While neither one is very much, there's more room for honing before your hollow is gone if you use a smaller wheel. The difference is much more on a thicker workpiece; for a 1/4" thick iron, the concavities are 0.0104" and 0.0078" for 6" and 8" wheels, respectively. As long as you don't feel the concavity compromises the strength of your edge (and I don't, I'm just acknowledging that others disagree), you get more honings from a smaller wheel.

I have a white Norton wheel, and it definitely runs cooler and cuts better than the stock grey wheels that come on most grinders. However, I've been reading a lot about the purple Norton 3X wheels and the talk is sufficiently positive that I intend to try one in the near future. What I haven't yet decided is whether to get a new 6" grinder before I do that. I put a link to one source for Norton 3X wheels below (no affiliation other than customer).

So, my advice, for what it's worth, is to get a 6" grinder and equip it with at least one Norton 3X wheel. If you want to spring for the money, get a slow speed or variable speed version, though I'm not sure I think that's necessary if you get a 6" -- this was the recommendation in Joel's article as well. Also, buy a good quality tool rest such as the Veritas (again, there may be others to suggest here, my experience is limited to one rest). This setup is not where I am, but it's where I wish I was. The 6" model is cheaper for the grinder, cheaper for the wheels, has lower surface speed, you can get narrower wheels and I think you end up using more abrasive on your tools and less wasted dressing the wheel.

Best,

Dave


Norton 3X wheels from TFWW

Re: Looking for some advice

#4

7" diameter grinders... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...offer the best cutting-edge support with sufficient arc for plenty of re-honings between re-grindings. At least that was the informal concensus in several artisan workshops in the Western Massachusetts mill where I studied woodworking. While honing was a personal preferance -- oil or water stones to diamond on iron -- 7" slow-speed Baldors and Hock blades were two common items found in most workshops reliant on handtools. I bought my Baldor in 1994 and it's probably the best and most-used tool I own. It shows no signs of wear whatsoever.

Bill Tindall offers more advantages of 7" grinders in a current thread on the main message board:


The case for 7" wheels

Re: Looking for some advice

#5

mostly agreement

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I agree with everything said, especially the importance of a good tool rest. I recommend a 7" wheel.

Re: Looking for some advice

#6

wheel selection, the story on 3X particles

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The attributes you are looking for in a wheel are described in my article in the Articles section.

If you don't want to put a lot of effort into buying a wheel, the LV white wheel has good specifications. The surface grinder wheels from many sources are ideal. I prefer a Norton 25A ("pink", which I see are now only available in a US made generic version in the MSC catalog).

I have come to the conclusion that narrow (1/2") wheels are better. Also, one does not need as fine a grit as I once thought. 80 is just fine, maybe even 60. The scratches from either are equivalently easy to hone away. 60 makes metal go away faster which is good if experienced and not so good if learning.

What about the "ceramic particle wheels", "SG", 3X, etc. The goal is to keep sharp edges on the abrasive particle. It is sharp partical edges that prevent burning, more than any other factor. The brute force way to keep sharp edges is to embed friable particles in a soft wheel matrix. To that end one wants a white or pink particle and a H bond. Because this wheel wears away relatively faster it does not hold its shape well if you are grinding pointy things, or ginding on the wheel edge for some reason. The shape holding is not an issue for plane irons and chisels.

The SG particle originally available from Norton and now available from everywhere (I have no idea if there is equivalence), solves the sharp particle edge issue with high tech particle structure. These abrasive particles maintain their approximate size yet fracture at the surface to keep sharp edges. Hence, a harder bond can be used which enables the wheel to hold its shape better, yet run cool. Bottom line, the SG wheels deliver cool running sharp edges in a more durable wheel.

The 3X wheels have 30% of these SG particles and the remainder friable alumina, probably similar, if not identical, to the white particle. If you go to a tool room supply place, eg MSC, you can buy a "SG" wheel and it will have 50% of these SG particles, at a higher price of course. Places that grind a lot of metal have found these SG wheels to be cost effective. They cost more, but last longer than "cheap" wheels with soft H bond.

In my hands the SG wheel ran about as cool (which means its particle edges remained sharp) as a H bond wheel and it held its shape well, just like one would expect. It required a bit more dressing to remove dull grits than an H bond wheel , but I didn't consider this factor to be significant. It takes only a few seconds to dress a wheel unless it is out of round.

If I was a professional turner and ground my lathe tools constantly (as they seem to do) I am sure I would have a SG wheel of some sort on my grinder. For plane irons, their advantage over a soft bond wheel is less compelling. But the fact that they are readily available from places that cater to woodworkers may be a compelling factor in their favor.

Re: Looking for some advice

#7

Re: Looking for some advice

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>Skip, I have a bunch of grinders. A Nice 8" DeWalt down to cheap ones I found in he dump. I hate to change Stones so each is set up with different wheels.

I've also worked with a couple different grinders at work. I haven't tried, won't spend the money on one of those expensive slow speed one.

I like the High Speed Grinders, the key is to get a good adjustable tool rest that most of the WW'n Cats have, and Practice, Practice, Practice on Cheap Chisels. You just needs to develop the fine touch and you'll be fine.

I have a Cheapo 6" that I put Fine, Cool Running Stones on and it works just as well as the expensive DeWalt. It may not last as long, but how often are you going to use it and how hard are you going to work it? Put your money in the stones and the tool rest

A coworker brought in a set of Cheap Stanleys the other night and I ground the Geometry into them on a course stone and my tool rest. The Craftsman at work did a great job. I ground decades of poor grinding out on 7 chisel in under a 1/2 hour.

The last thing make sure you pick up the correct tool to dress the stones.

Re: Looking for some advice

#8

Dave & Bill: Does speed matter?

Tom Colligan

>For sometime the slow speed (8" grinder) was the most recommended. Is this a correct belief or does speed mean less than the large nut behind the toolrest doing the tool handling? Tia, Tom.

Re: Looking for some advice

#9

Well, how interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the grinder I inherited from my revered uncle is a 7" Baldor; I'd thought he was just being (typically) eccentric in choosing that size, though I understood immediately that choosing a Baldor was the right move. You can't tell it's running, except by touching the wheel, and it runs more or less forever after shutting off. Great, cast iron tool rests.

Re: Looking for some advice

#10

Re: Dave & Bill: Does speed matter?

Dave Mount, NE Minnesota

>While I can't offer personal experience, the theory is that a slower wheel speed generates less heat and is therefore less likely to burn your tool. A 6" turning at 3450 rpm has a surface speed of 5419 feet per minute. An 8" wheel turning at 1725 is 3613 fpm and twice that (7226 fpm) on a 3450 rpm grinder. So, an 8" slow speed grinder has a slower surface speed than a 6" regular, which is that much again slower than a 8" regular.

Hard to put that difference into tangible terms. In his recent sharpening article, Joel argues that a 6" regular is sufficiently slow to avoid burning. However, an 8" slow speed would have that much more a safety margin for sloppy technique. However, other issues with 8" grinders would still be in play.

Best,

Dave

Re: Looking for some advice

#11

Surface speed of a 10"?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Dave

I have a 10" grinder that spins at 2840 rpm. Could you kindly calculate the surface speed of that?

Why 10" you may ask? I had this (crazy) idea that I could begin on it to remove as much waste as possible (when restoring or making blades), then finish on the Tormek (also a 10" wheel). It has a white 46 grit Norton wheel. I bought it after I began grinding D2 plane blades. I will add that the presence of this machine terrifies me - I am not sure if it is psychological or real. Some real data would help.



And alongside the Tormek ..



I still have a 6" machine, which now feels like a toy alongside it.

What is great about the Tormek is that you can grind right up to the very edge of the blade. Then it is possible to hone a micro secondary bevel - just a swipe or two across a stone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Looking for some advice

#12

Tom..your email address isn't working.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Tom,

Tried to email you a few days ago and it wouldn't deliver. You have a new email address?

Marv

Re: Looking for some advice

#13

Thanks and a further question

Skip in Falls Church

>Thanks everyone, what great advice! OTOH why the heck didn't I look in articles section to start with? I have to say that I've never liked the hollow ground edges - but I'm ready to try something new. After all if I decide I don't like it I can always spend an eterinty flattening the bevels. :) I also have little experience with grinders - I've heard too many stories about exploding wheels. However, in neglecting woodworking the last year or so it seems that all my blades are dull and need sharpening.

I do have a hand powered grinder that I've used for removing large amounts of metal - but the necessary one handed operation and the wobble in the axle of the grinder would seem to tell me I need to go a different route. Love the advice on the wheels - I'll definitely go the advised route on them likewise on the LV ginder rest.

I do have one further question though, I've seen 6" and 8" ginders commonly advertised but I didn't recall seeing 7" grinders. I did a search for 7" ginders and it seem that all the ones I found were in the $300 range. Would it be okay to buy an 8" ginder and put a 7" wheel on it?

Re: Looking for some advice

#14

wheel, rest and experience matter more

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When I began using the grinder for sharpening, control of metal removal and avoiding burning were the main issues I worried about. To help in these matters I used a very soft bond 1" wheel, 120 grit, slow speed and a Wolverine tool rest. As time went on I realized that I could do just fine with 80 grit. I found that crowing the wheel led to better control than a flat wheel so a 1" wheel was a waste of money. Also as my proficiency got better I turned up the speed from slow to faster. (I am continuously variable so I don't know where I am at but I could grind at 3600 rpm if that is all I had.)

I still use a H bond wheel and I think the pink does better than white on the very abrasion resistant steels we use (CPM 3V). I think the Wolverine is by far the best commercially available tool rest, but making one would not be difficult. I used one made from plywood for a while till it caught on fire while grinding lawn mower blades. I regard the tool rest as extremely important. It needs to be big and steel needs to slide on it smoothly to maintain good control.

To give you an idea of how important the wheel is I have an 80 grit white Norton wheel, K bond(fairly hard). It was custom made for me to try for sharpening. I can not use this wheel without burning if I grind to the edge of a tool. I don't worry about burning any more with a H bond wheel, especially so with 80 or coarser grit. But it does take a light touch. If you have a proper wheel the issue will be control of metal removal, not burning. Slower speed is good "training wheels" for learning to control metal removal.

If I was starting over I would buy a LV arbor and mount a good wheel on it and a motor and pulley that would result in 1000-1500 rpm . I would make or buy a big tool rest. I would run 1/2 or 3/4 x 7" soft bond or SG particle wheels. Note, that I consider the grinder the lest critical part of the arrangement.

Re: Looking for some advice

#15

you will love them when you hone them

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When you see how quick you initially hone and then later restore the edge on a hollow grind you will see why some of us find this format desirable. While diamonds have their attraction, a hollow grind surface hones so quick about any honing technique will be quick.

In a shop that does a lot of grinding an 8" wheel soon becomes a 7" wheel. So, it would seem that there is no downside to starting with 7" so long as the tool rest adjusts properly to it.

Re: Looking for some advice

#16

Calculating surface speed

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>To calculate surface speed in Ft. per minute do the following.

Diameter times (Pi)or 3.142 = circumference, times RPM, divided by 12 = ft. per minute.

As your grinding wheel gets dressed down, the smaller diameter will change the number of feet per minute that passes the point of contact of what you are grinding. For an accurate calculation of surface speed, accurately measure the diameter of your wheel.

Marv

Re: Looking for some advice

#17

Re: Surface speed of a 10"?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Circumference = pi (3.1) x wheel diameter = about 30".

Circumference times rpm equals inches per minute of grits flying by.

It is not gong to be much different from an 8" wheel at 3600 rpm.

Re: Looking for some advice

#18

Re: 7435 sfpm

Dave Mount, NE Minnesota

>Hi Derek--

Bill's right, very similar to an 8" at 3450 rpm.

I agree that the Tormek is a nice thing. Necessary no, nice yes. I only use a dry grinder when I have to take off serious amounts of metal. When making molding plane irons or chisels, I've come to prefer leaving more metal at the bevel before hardening then taking it off with the dry grinder. In addition, for other than straight edges, I kind of hate to get the Tormek wheel out of flat.

Best,

Dave

Re: Looking for some advice

#19

Yikes! Baldor prices. High.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Bill, I just looked up my Baldor 7306 7" 1800 RPM grinder and the best price I can find is 376 USD (retail's 489). That's a year's worth of double cheeseburgers at McD's for a normal person. Knowing what I know after fifteen years of use, I'd pop for another, but it's a steep entre into sharpening for someone starting out.

Yeah, I'd have to recommend a low* or variable RPM 8" import with a OneWay wheel balancing kit and 7" friable wheels. We're lucky we've got ours. I paid half of the discounted current price in 1994. Tempus fugit.

Aside from woodworking tools, the 7" wheel has always been highly popular with industrial machinists as it offers balanced geometry, relief/strength, for lathe toolbits.

And you're right, the original iron toolrests are superb. I also have the LV rests, which I've raised and braced for greater stability and mounted for quick changing. The original rest can be swapped for the LV in a minute or so. I tend to favor the iron rests for most work, though, as I freehand grind a lot of narrow tools; gravers, 1/4" bits for my Taig lathe, and so on.

As for vibration, maybe a snake could sense some. My grinder freewheels silently and for a long long time with those OneWay hubs. I always put two radial stripes on the side of each wheel to help me see if they've stopped -- asymmetrically, as I sometimes use fluorescent magnifier lamps -- strobing can trick you.

I also covet a Baldor polishing lathe for goldsmithing and jewely work, but for now I can live with my Leeson.

*Lower RPM motors are more polite when addressing simpler, easily-burned tool steels. One can learn to grind HSS turning tools at a more leisurely pace, too. In most cases I'll feather an edge and go directly back to the lathe. Sometimes I'll strop in between, for good luck.

Re: Looking for some advice

#20

Hollow grind. 6" good. High speed grinder fin *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>Skip,

Without reading the prior responses, all that I use is a 6" grinder at home and a 10" grinder at work.

Hollow grind edges.

All grinders run at 3600 rpm from memory. Full speed, 2 pole motors.

The trick's in how you present the edge and think about it.

Don't push the edge into the grinder, think that you're trying to shave the very surface off the wheel, while moving the blade sideways and parallel to the shaft of the grinder, to keep the blade edge flat and avoid overheating. By doing this, you shouldn't burn the blade. Having said this, you'll burn a few before you learn the necessary touch/technique.

A well dressed wheel is a necessity. I use a white wheel, although a well dressed grey wheel works just as well. The grey wheels tend to burn unless they're dressed. (see link below.)

I've linked to an article below.

There's a lot of thought/discussion on how to sharpen/grind. Don't get sucked into the train of thought that says that you need an expensive machine, and that a slow grinder's better than a standard one. They are, however, slower and more expensive.

Ideally, the grinder will have a smaller motor diameter than the wheel, so that you could put a straight edge (piece of wood) onto the cutting face of one wheel and have it touch the other. On wide blades, this is a huge advantage.

Technique's the key. I once put together a simple video on this for someone who was going to host it. I don't think that it ever got off the ground.

Cheers,

Andrew


http://planemaker.com/articles_grinding.html

Re: Looking for some advice

#21

Blatent commercial ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>There is a tremendous amount of knowledge in the articles here at Woodcentral. I am sure that you are not alone in not looking there, but I would definitely encourage all to go over and peruse them. You can learn a lot.

</commercial>

Re: Looking for some advice

#22

I'd sure probably never buy one on my own

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My uncle's only child died young, and his wife 20 years before him, so he had no one to satisfy except himself...and now me...with that grinder. I remember when he bought it: he was busy showing it off to us whenever we visited. Yes, mine can run who knows how long after power is off; I've never timed it. I also like the cast iron side guards; no exploding wheel's going to break those guards.

I purchased a REALLY cheap import grinder (Horrible Fright variety, some importer's idea of a trustworthy-sounding company name) when I was first starting out, but gave it away, as it could vibrate itself right off the bench (should have given it to a boater; not much good for anything except anchoring small rowboats). My next grinder was a 6" 3450 rpm Delta, only a little more expensive and made no doubt not too many miles from the first one, but I never bolted it down, as it ran smoothly enough to sit on the bench, even without balancing the wheels, and my shop has no space for a dedicated sharpening station. Having it sit on its feet, loose to roam, encouraged me to use a light touch. I don't know what current brands are good, but the Delta demonstrated to me that a well-machined grinder doesn't have to cost Mercedes money.

I also own a Delta 10" wet wheel grinder, which grinds beautiful bevels, almost mirror-like, but very very slowly. I found that Tormek's angle setter works perfectly with it. I need to spend some time re-learning how to use a bench grinder, to get the rough shape, at least, before grinding on the wet grinder. Of course, I need to get some time in the shop, period.

Re: Looking for some advice

#23

Re: Tom..your email address isn't working.

Tom Colligan

>Thanks, Marv. I've made the change.

Re: Looking for some advice

#24

Re: Blatent commercial ;-)

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Dan,

But of all people ... I've written a couple of articles so I should have thought about that first!

Skip

Re: Looking for some advice

#25

Re: you will love them when you hone them

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Bill,

Well, I ordered a grinder last night - an 8" variable speed that comes with white and pink stones at a really decent cost, about $120. I'll take a look at it when it gets here and then order some 7" stones to go with it. I'm looking forward to giving this method a shot.

Skip