Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Rosewood Center Table

Posts

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#26

Interesting Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>"If I were to buy a piece that is described to me as being made of solid oak and I later learn that it is vaneered partical board, it is still real, it's just not solid oak."

I'd be pissed off to find that out!

Please don't put yourself below me, you don't belong there. I feel I shouldn't be placed with the likes of Stephen or Wiley either.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#29

Scott....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>If anyone spoke to you the way you speak to Stephen, you'd think it was grief. Your words are not collegial.

We can disagree on the nature of wood graining. That's OK. But there's no misrepresentation on Stephen's part--the piece is what he told us all that it is. The confusion we are having testifies to the success of his artfulness.

Wiley

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#30

It is what it is and I like seeing it.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Real Brazilian Rosewood (Dahlbergia nigra)? Of course not. But that's the point. Scagliola isn't what it appears, either, but it can be damned fine scagliola.

It's rare that I see a piece of furniture on WC in a style I like, or I should say, in a style I would choose to furnish my house, but that doesn't mean I can't appreciate it for what it is and what went into it.

I like seeing what others do and I hope postings continue. It never hurts to be thick-skinned, of course.

As for its functional 'tableness' while I won't go as far as Pam's well-stated Neoplatonism, it would seem to adequately intercede for gravity.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#31

Do you really want to go there?....AGAIN??

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#32

Re: Rosewood Center Table

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Nice table Stephen.

That species of rosewood that you work in can certainly be confusing to the olfactory senses!

I gather from some of the posts on the subject, that there is some question as to the authenticity of the subject piece. Seems to me that it's 100% authentic and appropriate, it meets and exceeds the criteria for an on topic post as far as I understand it. It's made by a woodworker. It's made of wood, It appears to be well executed, and it has initiated an esoteric thread of art vs authenticity vs woodworking vs ??????

Well Done, I say!!!!

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#33

Just figured it out *headslap*

wilbur

>"The rosewood was a bit irritating when turning, it first smelled like pine then it smelled like linseed oil and turpentine."

I didn't pick up on this. Doh!

In my defense, I've only used rosewood once when I turned a bowl out of a rosewood blank. It also was a bit irritating while turning, and it did give off a smell. My wife says that my sense of smell is only second to my level of common sense, which really isn't saying much. :@)

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#34

Me too...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Wilbur,

I feel much better now....I interpreted it the same way. I think Stephen was testing us. I deserve a D-

Marv

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#35

Neoplatonism?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>As for its functional 'tableness' while I won't go as far as Pam's well-stated Neoplatonism, it would seem to adequately intercede for gravity.

I don't think of myself this way, particularly as the neoplatonists were very religious; whereas I'm neither deist nor theist, my reverence resides in nature. I realized that I viewed ideas as real when one day I found myself thinking about what I did for a living: software development. I briefly thought it would be interesting to make something real for a change, like a table; but then caught myself. I knew at that moment that software was real, real electrons lined up in a certain way, "touchable" by others, etc.

Thanks for the conversation.

Pam