Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Rosewood Center Table

Posts

Rosewood Center Table

#1

Rosewood Center Table

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The center table is finished at last and here it is. The rosewood was a bit irritating when turning, it first smelled like pine then it smelled like linseed oil and turpentine.

It is 42 inches in diameter and 30 inches tall as was the original from which this was copied.

Stephen


img

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#2

Re: Rosewood Center Table

wilbur

>Very nice!

I'm assuming that when you talk about turning the rosewood, you're only talking about the center post, and not the top of the table?

What kind of rosewood is this?

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Rosewood Center Table

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Gotta ask, since you made the pine/linseed/turpentine comment - Is it really rosewood, or is this another of your fauz-finished pieces.

Jim D.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Beautiful

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That looks really good. Is that an involved process,transforming pine into rosewood?---Jack

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#5

I'm not sure, I think I would...

Alan DuBoff

>Paint it to look like pine so I wouldn't be afraid to put a drink on it...*wink*

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#6

Re: Rosewood Center Table

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>It's a killer, Stephen. Absolutely stunning. The details appear to be flawless. An extremely fine piece of work. Thanks for showing this--one of your best posts ever. Would love to see more on this piece, either here or on your blog.

Wiley

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#7

Nice looking table, Stephen.

GolfSteve in Calgary

>

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#8

I'm guessing pine rosewood ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#9

Ya so...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's not real. As soon as somebody dents it or slams a steak knife down into it, it's true form will appear...

A fake.

Granted a nice one...

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#10

Re: Ya so...Scott You are Wrong

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>That table is in fact real.

You wrote:

It's not real. As soon as somebody dents it or slams a steak knife down into it, it's true form will appear...

A fake.

The top I actually built back in 1993, so it is 15 years old and has been in use most of that time. I made another top to replace this one, it was octagonal, so I got this one back and the base was made in order to utilize this extra top. It is in original conditions, a few dent but I will stand behind my work.

What is its true form? A Fake, how dare you, who are to you to make that judgement?

Stephen

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#11

It's real

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>It's unfortunate Stephen is catching grief from Scott, since Stephen is one of the few people who can reliably be counted on to show us real woodworking technique that he practices, as well as actual furniture he has made!

Let's analyze this a bit.....Is veneered furniture 'real'? Many of the finest museum examples of period furniture--and about all of the Federal style--have major elements veneered. There are Seymour pieces where virtually the entire piece is veneered. If someone stuck a knife into one of those, it would be easily as tough a repair job as Stephen's table.

Is painted furniture 'real'? Same comments as above. Some very admirable furniture from the earlier days of our Nation was painted, and today we still try to find and use paints which capture the finish they achieved.

When the Federal makers began to use stringing and banding--flat forms--to emulate relief-carved elements found in earlier neoclassical styles, was that fake? I guess it was--it was trying to play a trick on the viewer's eye, to suggest relief that wasn't actually there. Is it fake? No, it's what it is. It's a technique that formed the basis for a period style.

How about applied moldings rather than stuck moldings. They are suggesting a continuity of line which is not integral to the wood. Are applied moldings fake? I don't think so--it's a sound technique used to achieve a certain effect, and generally they are nailed on.

So what about the practice of graining? It's an old art, requiring high skill on the part of the maker. Like veneer, and like paint, graining is a way to put a desired finish on a piece of furniture.

Stephen's piece would not fool me into thinking it is rosewood. It would just make me think--as I do--that it is a very handsome and well-executed piece of furniture. I would wonder how the finish was achieved, and would appreciate the craft embodied in the piece.

Perhaps if Stephen had done a Mission piece in solid oak, made with all rectangular sticks of wood, with wipe-on finish, Scott would say "Now that's real furniture". But I would like to suggest that there is much more art--and requisite skill--in what Stephen has shown us here. And what Stephen has executed is a real art form, of long standing.

Wiley

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#12

Re: It's real if you can touch it and feel it.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

If you can touch it and feel it, it is real. It's a matter of definition.

When we post a picture of something here in this forum, we must be open to comments and critiques from one end of the spectrum to the other. Some will be compliments and some will not.

If I were to buy a piece that is described to me as being made of solid oak and I later learn that it is vaneered partical board, it is still real, it's just not solid oak.

I suppose that one of the questions we can ask ourselves is, why do we post pictures of our accomplishments? Are we seeking approval or are we seeking some other kind of judgement? Are we attempting to show what can be done when one possesses a certain skill level? Whatever the reason may be, we should be willing to accept opinions from anyone and everyone and not be disappointed when we get negative feedback. I learned that lesson a few months ago when I posted a picture of a handsaw I wheat carved.

On the other hand, at least for those like myself who's skill level is not at the level of a Stephen Shepperd or a Scott Burr or a Wiley Horne when it comes to furniture making, can learn from what they see posted here.

I for one am constantly amazed at what I see people do using only hand tools. I greatly appreciate those with higher skill levels than mine who are willing to share. I have to keep reminding myself that most everything I know, I've learned from someone else. I say "most" because some of what I know comes from being inventive, but even my inventions and creativity is aided by what others have done or written or said.

I know I've kind of wandered off the main subject here, but I think it all ties together when viewing Stephen's table or any other work that is displayed here. All I can do is try to learn something from it all, because my skill levels do not qualify me to critique it, other than to say, "hey, nice job Stephen!"

Marv

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#13

It's art, and people's tastes differ....

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hello Marv,

The reason folks knew that Stephen's piece was grained pine is because he told 'em so. If it had not been such a fine job, nobody would have said fake. The fact that he carried it off so well--so it doesn't look like pine anymore--is what triggers the criticism.

Scott's criticism is still sitting there. But I'd like to disagree with him, without being disagreeable (<:).

There are many devices that woodworkers use--and have used for centuries--to convey an impression. Devices like applied moldings which look integral, stringing and inlays and sand-shading to emulate relief which is not there. We consider these techniques as high art, and high skill. Which they are. It's fine furniture. It's museum furniture. Right now, some of the most expensive furniture being made in the western hemisphere is veneer over MDF. Is it fake? Some might think so--I don't. These techniques are used for ornament, for economy, and to get around some cross-grain and wood movement problems which occur with solid wood construction. Fancy graining techniques fall into that genre. In my opinion.

Wiley

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#14

Ideas are real, too, and can be earth shaking.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#15

Re: Ideas are real, too, and can be earth shaking.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Pam,

For sure, ideas are real. First the idea, then the reality. I was attempting to avoid too many philosophical aspects of the issue. Thats an area of discussion that has no conclusion, like trying to get your mind around infinity.

Marv

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#16

You were successful. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#17

Re: It's real if you can touch it and feel it.

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"I suppose that one of the questions we can ask ourselves is, why do we post pictures of our accomplishments? Are we seeking approval or are we seeking some other kind of judgement? Are we attempting to show what can be done when one possesses a certain skill level? Whatever the reason may be, we should be willing to accept opinions from anyone and everyone and not be disappointed when we get negative feedback. I learned that lesson a few months ago when I posted a picture of a handsaw I wheat carved."

I believe this to be a very important aspect of online collaboration, the fact that you can actually get some feedback, and share ideas with others.

What you should have learned was not a lesson, at least not in the sense that you're using it...but that is sometimes the outcome of something.

I don't believe your skill level is as low as you make it out to be, and your work speaks for itself. The fact that someone might take exception to it done on a vintage tool, or that they might not do it, should not be taken to be a "lesson" in how you use it. It should be no more than input and/or ideas given to you by the users of this forum.

This is no different than seeing the glass with water in it, is that glass half empty or is it half full, and that just depends on your own perspective, IMO.

We live in such a touchy-feely world these days, it's hard not to offend someone with any comment one makes. Would we all be better saying nothing, then?

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#18

Re: It's art, and people's tastes differ....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

I guess I read Stephen's post in the literal sense. He said it smelled like pine. His heading says it is a Rosewood Center table. A little misleading to a dummy like me.

Very clever though, to be able to make pine look so much like something that it isn't. Now lets make Rosewood look like pine....*grin*

Marv

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#19

Re: It's real if you can touch it and feel it.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Often times it IS better to say nothing...

My lesson learned had to do with what to expect when posting something for all to see and read and to expect and accept all kinds of comments and critizism and still feel good about what I did.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#20

Re: It's real if you can touch it and feel it.

Paul Kierstead

>When we post a picture of something here in this forum, we must be open to comments and critiques from one end of the spectrum to the other. Some will be compliments and some will not.

Why? Posting something doesn't make it open season. Now I'll give you that your going to get a variety of comments whether you are open to it or now and whether you like it or not, but it doesn't mean they have to be accepted lying down.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#21

Re: Nice looking table, Stephen.

GolfSteve in Calgary

>If it wasn't for the grain on the table-top, I could believe it was rosewood. The cross-banding, base and legs are completely believable to me.

And calling this a rosewood table is hardly any different than the big furniture manufacturers calling their painted alder/particle board pieces a "solid cherry whatever" when they actually mean that they've painted on a twelve-step finish that looks like what most people think cherry should look like.

I was in Thomasville furniture the other day and they had some beautifully finished table legs that looked like antique birdseye/curly maple. A closer look revealed a translucent cream coloured base coat, followed by some Van-dyke brown coloured glaze that might have been ragged on. It looked great.

Good job, Stephen. I'd actually like to know more about the finishing process.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#22

Stephen, Your misunderstanding me.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>All I meant so say it's that it's not real Rosewood. That's it period. Sorry if I offended you. I think you did a fine job on it, as stated in my post.

Boy o' boy did I open up a big ol' can o' worms...

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#23

Scott, could you be more specific?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>What kind of worms?

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#24

Wiley...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Catching Grief? No not at all. I was just stating my oppion regarding painted wood. Is it real? Of course it is. Is it Rosewood? Hell no, it's fake, faux. That's all I ment from that statement.

I think you mis-read or are reading to much from my post.I did complement Stephen on his workmanship.

I can admire any piece of furniture that I want, it's my right. It's also my right do dislike it as well. With the right to freedom of speach I can state it as well.

That said, I respectly request that you stop putting words in my mouth.

Re: Rosewood Center Table

#25

Don't I know that? :-)

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"Often times it IS better to say nothing..."

Hey, I know that all too well Marv...my pocket-poker-nater was a case in point...obviously people were all touchy feely and didn't want to hurt LV's feeling by giving them an honest assessment of a tool that was basically an insult to toolmakers. I wasn't afraid of that and took the heat for such.

I used it as a learning experience, because LV has quite a few such gimmick type tools, and I try not to buy them.

The funny thing is that I realized I have what I consider to be a fairly useless tool that I did buy from LV. It is a plastic POS that is used to hold a cordless drill so you can drill at an angle. I have NEVER used it, and in fact, I always grab a brace and an auger when I would be inclined to use it. It reminds me that there are useless tools and that I shouldn't buy them. LV has quite a few similar tools that I classify as "gimmick" tools. I guess you could say that Rob "Got Me", in the sense that I did buy it. More power to him, and may I learn from my mistake...life goes on...

When I posted about the pocket-poker-nater, I obviously hit a sore spot with Rob Lee...so be it.

The funny thing is that I bet there are folks that actually have bought that lumber thickness gage, much the same that I bought the drill angle chiatchka that I never use.

There are several "lessons" in there for me, I'm still grokin' them.;-)