It's real
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>It's unfortunate Stephen is catching grief from Scott, since Stephen is one of the few people who can reliably be counted on to show us real woodworking technique that he practices, as well as actual furniture he has made!
Let's analyze this a bit.....Is veneered furniture 'real'? Many of the finest museum examples of period furniture--and about all of the Federal style--have major elements veneered. There are Seymour pieces where virtually the entire piece is veneered. If someone stuck a knife into one of those, it would be easily as tough a repair job as Stephen's table.
Is painted furniture 'real'? Same comments as above. Some very admirable furniture from the earlier days of our Nation was painted, and today we still try to find and use paints which capture the finish they achieved.
When the Federal makers began to use stringing and banding--flat forms--to emulate relief-carved elements found in earlier neoclassical styles, was that fake? I guess it was--it was trying to play a trick on the viewer's eye, to suggest relief that wasn't actually there. Is it fake? No, it's what it is. It's a technique that formed the basis for a period style.
How about applied moldings rather than stuck moldings. They are suggesting a continuity of line which is not integral to the wood. Are applied moldings fake? I don't think so--it's a sound technique used to achieve a certain effect, and generally they are nailed on.
So what about the practice of graining? It's an old art, requiring high skill on the part of the maker. Like veneer, and like paint, graining is a way to put a desired finish on a piece of furniture.
Stephen's piece would not fool me into thinking it is rosewood. It would just make me think--as I do--that it is a very handsome and well-executed piece of furniture. I would wonder how the finish was achieved, and would appreciate the craft embodied in the piece.
Perhaps if Stephen had done a Mission piece in solid oak, made with all rectangular sticks of wood, with wipe-on finish, Scott would say "Now that's real furniture". But I would like to suggest that there is much more art--and requisite skill--in what Stephen has shown us here. And what Stephen has executed is a real art form, of long standing.
Wiley