Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Posts

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#26

Re: workers

Joel

>Grinder's disease was well documented - even the solution was well documented I think as early as 1840 but never put in place because of factory ownder's resistance. What is interesting in this case is that there is no contemporary documentation that I am aware of that rosewood can be toxic. Therefore my conclusion is that the rosewood in use in the 19th and early 20th century didn't have nearly the toxicity of the modern stuff and it wasn't an issue. I could be wrong of course but it makes sense.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#27

Re: Lead Maker's Colic,

Joel

>But the very fact there is no documented "rosewood disease" suggests that this wasn't an issue

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#28

Maybe they wet sanded

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>like they work nacre, as nacrosis and silicosis (1881) were known.

Stephen

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#29

Re: Maybe they wet sanded

Joel

>Again,

no evidence for that. Also I'm not even sure wet sandpaper existed in the 19th century.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#30

You can wet sand with sharkskin

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#31

Hygiene hypothesis

wilbur

>As far as cocobolo vs. Brazilian rosewood having a greater or lesser risk of triggering a hypersensitivity response, there are two reasons why that might be true.

First, cocobolo may just be inherently more sensitizing than Brazilian rosewood. This is most likely because of the molecular structure of whatever it is in the cocobolo that does the sensitizing. Not all substances have the same degree of allergic potential, even among related substances like different members of the rosewood family. There's no a priori reason to believe that Brazilian rosewood is more or less sensitizing than cocobolo is.

The second issue, which may address the issue of why this is happening more recently, is the hygiene hypothesis. Being in the pediatric world, I deal with a lot of allergy/autoimmune issues. We can use asthma as a model, as asthma is pretty much just an allergic reaction in the lungs. There are many triggers for asthma, such as dust, pollen, pet dander, and pollution. But one thing that has puzzled us for a long time is if pollution is a trigger for asthma and allergy problems, why do third world cities, which are also polluted, have a relatively low rate of asthma and other allergy/autoimmune issues compared to the U.S.?

To understand this, you have to know a little bit about the immune system. When you are first born, your immune system doesn't really know how to do much. That's one reason why infections are more serious in kids than adults. Your immune system literally has to learn what is an infection and what belongs in the body. As a result, the immune system is primed to learn about things that invade the body and figure out how to fight them off.

One thing that has changed a great deal since the 1960s is that we have gotten infectious issues under control, thanks to vaccines and antibiotics. You no longer have to get polio to become immune to polio, you just need to get the polio vaccine. On top of that, in the U.S. we have become obsessed with keeping things not just clean, but sterile. Just look at all the antibacterial soap there is on the market today. Try to find a liquid hand soap that is NOT antibacterial. It's a lot harder than you think.

So where does this leave our immune systems? Remember, it's primed to learn about what is foreign to the body. If it's not exposed to anything, then it has to find something to do. (Idle hands, you know.) So it starts reacting to things in the body (asthma, eczema), and it becomes trigger happy to substances that it might not have reacted to before (hayfever, food allergies, sensitization to cocobolo).

Now this is just a hypothesis, and I certainly am not advocating that you should hold off on giving your kids their shots. Remember, not vaccinating your kids means going back to the days where there was a 10% chance your kid would die from infection. But it certainly might explain why we are seeing more wood dust health issues (and other allergic/autoimmune health issues as well) than in the past.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#32

Re: Lead Maker's Colic,

paul womack

> But the very fact there is no documented "rosewood disease" suggests that this wasn't an issue

"Lack of evidence is not evidence of a lack"

Possibly it was just mundanely acted on; if you don't like coal smoke, don't become a blacksmith, if you don't like rosewood, don't become a cabinet maker. Too dull to record...

BugBear

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#33

Re: Lead Maker's Colic,

Joel

>Holtzapfell's description of rosewood is one of the longest in his book. Lots of information, mostly to show that the Rosewood of the 19th century has very little in common to what passes for rosewood today. Cocobolo isn't mentioned by name except possible as coco wood. lots of information - nothing about an alergy.

An absence of information isn't proof of the converse, but in this case it's the simplest theory that makes sense.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#34

Interesting post Wilbur

Dave Anderson NH

>This is something that I have had a casual interest in because of the public health and epidemiology courses I took during my training as a civil engineer. I know that this is not politically correct, but is it also possible that improved medicical treatment, understanding, and increasingly successful diagnosis and treatment have increased the survival rate of those who would have died before being able to breed? How many of these types of conditions (such as asthma and allergic sensetivity))can be passed on genetically, and would this account for increasing percentages of the population at risk?

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#35

Moses Yoder

Re: Thicker skin

Moses Yoder

>I think the thicker skin theory holds a lot of water. Plus, people had a shorter life span and were less particular about how they lived. I don't have allergic reactions to cocobolo but it certainly is a toxic wood to work with and makes my eyes water occasionally when I am polishing pens (very fine dust). I suppose watery eyes is an allergic reaction but it is not that bad. I made my fountain pen out of cocobolo; it is a very nice wood. I like the way it works and smells; I always think of carrots when I smell it.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#36

Moses Yoder

Re: Hygiene hypothesis

Moses Yoder

>I have had a theory for some time that it is better to get some germs than to not get any. This is not an excuse for living like a pig, it is just an attitude towards cleanliness. If you are not exposed to any germs on a regular basis your body does not develop a system to fight them; exactly as you said. One example of the modern attitude towards germs is the phase people went through with plastic cutting boards. The idea was that a wood cutting board would grow a germ colony and plastic cutting boards would not. This was a very effective marketing campaign without the limitations of truth. People actually believed that a plastic cutting board would not have germs on it, and they also believed that it was better for them not to get any germs. We live in a house with 7 dogs so I believe my immune system is very healthy ;)

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#37

Re: Interesting post Wilbur

wilbur

>There is a genetic component to asthma, but it's not as straight forward as, say, inheriting the gene for cystic fibrosis or sickle cell disease. It's more like having a predisposition to developing asthma or other autoimmune-related diseases rather than a single determining factor.

As far as the issue of improved diagnosis and treatment of a disease increasing the incidence of said disease because otherwise the disease would have reduced the number of people able to have children, that is really a very rare situation. So rare, in fact, that I actually can't think of a single disease that this theory would apply to. Certainly having asthma or an autoimmune disorder has little impact on your ability to live long enough to have children. And remember, because of how we are built form a biologic standpoint, living long enough to have children means only having to reach the age of 14 or so.

In fact, the more we learn about how genetic factors impact disease, the more I become convinced that environmental factors actually play a much more important role in the impact of the disease on someone.