Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Posts

LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#1

LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Alan DuBoff

>A couple months ago I mentioned talking to TLN at the Oakland hand tool event about cocobolo, it seems the evil wood for people that use it, and he agreed that they have had their share of problems, were down to only 1 or 2 people that could work it without risking some type of allergic reaction, and they also would not be using it in the future.

Well, that day has come, and LN has removed coclobolo from the website as of a few days ago.

It sounds like they have built up some stock, so if you do ask for it, you can get some still while they have it.

Anyway, if you like the cocobolo option on the wood for their tools, you might think about getting it while you can, a time is coming (real soon now) when you won't be able to get it, from LN, anyway.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#2

Re: workers

paul womack

>I wonder how this was handled in the old days.

Were workers immune to cocobolo back then, or were they merely dismissed (and replaced) when they became intolerant?

BugBear

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#3

Good question...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Good question, don't have an answer to it. I know that there are various toolmakers that have had problems with it. I hear about folks having bad cases of allergic reaction, where they claim they will NEVER work with cocobolo again.

It seems more widely used in current times, but I am not intimately familiar with the past and it's use.

I like the looks of it, like most folks, but I think I'm gonna leave it be and find another wood that is suitable for my needs. I have a mortise chisel with a cocobolo handle that was turned by a gent complaining about feeling sick, and he vanished...nobody has heard from him, nobody knows what happened, he just vanished. Before that he was selling and turning a lot of cocobolo. I don't know that it was a problem for him specific, but it makes me wonder. His name was Tom Larossa, if anyone knows where he is, or how to get a hold of him please let me know if for nothing else but to set my mind at ease. He lived in Florida when I last communicated with him.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#4

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Christopher Schwarz

>Count me in as one of those people who cannot handle cocobolo. I first realized I was sensitive while building my Shepherd planes years ago. Since then, every time I encounter it, it's not fun. My tongue swells up, for one.

The wood sure looks pretty, however.

Chris

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#5

Re: workers

Joel

>THis is a really good question I have wondered about for years. The best theory (theory only) I cancome up with is that the wood used back then was mostly Brazilian and probably dried a lot better than the wood we use today. So less oils, less mositure, less toxins in the air.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#6

Re: workers

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Joel got me thinking, the wood would have been all air dried. And as we know kiln dried wood is inferior to air dried. The heat cooks fatty acids in the lignun and convert them.

So it may be the heating that makes the wood so nasty.

Stephen

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#7

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Dave Jeske

>I use it as one of the options for my tool handles and I need to be a bit careful with it. Primarily it is breathing the dust that is a real problem. I wear a dust mask when cutting on the tablesaw (sorry I do not hand rip it!) even though I have a dust collector on it. I also open the roll-up shop door which is on the outfeed side and put a big fan behind me to blow any fine dust away from me and to the outside. When turning and sanding I have a good dust collector going at all times. At one time, when I first started using it, I would develop blisters/rash between my fingers when it was summer - hot and sweaty - but now I do not seem to have the problem. If it gets to to point where it seems to be an issue I suppose I will drop it as an option also. BTW, the African Blackwood which is also a rosewood, causes the same reactions (with me anyway). It makes such nice handles that I hope I can continue to use it for awhile.

dave

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#8

My guess

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Is that as a whole people were less allergic back then because they had not been exposed to the infinite cocktail of chemicals that are part of our life nowadays (I'm not on my soap box here, just stating the facts), many of which we know little or nothing about their effects on our immune system.

I mean, I can't recall any of my classmates in grade and high school being allergic to peanuts, now we see allergic kids everywhere, my wife in her daycare has one such child, and has to keep the nitro shot (or whatever it's called) handy just in case...

Wish we knew more about that subject...

DC

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#9

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Michael Rogen

>Dave,

I hope that you are still able to use ABW as all of my tools that you have made for me are of that same lovely wood.

I guess it's time to start looking for a backup.

I sent you a PM

Thank you,

Michael

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#10

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Dave Anderson NH

>I too use Dalbergias (sp) (rosewoods) in my toolmaking. Specifically Cocobolo, Brazilian Tulipwood, and E. Indian Rosewood. When working the Coco, I would sometimes get a slight rash on the arms when it was hot enough in the shop to sweat, but fortunately have not had any other problems. I have a dust collection pickup on the back side of the lathe and when turning or sanding any of the Rosewood family I wear a 3M Airmate powered respirator as added insurance. When I built my Shepherd kits with Coco, I was fortunate enough not to have any problems. I think it was Terry Daniels who noted on the Woodcental turning forum a few years ago that, "there are two kinds of people in this world, those who are allergic to Cocobolo, and those who will be."

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#11

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

Alan DuBoff

>Dave,

I have wondered if you were effected or not, and knew that you have it as an option as I have been looking over your site for a while.

I am curious to see the African Blackwood, so just put an order in for a set of fishtail chisels. Look forward to seeing it, I've seen others that you have done and they look wonderful.

Keep up the excellent toolmaking! Sorry I couldn't visit on my last trip, maybe next time I'm up there I will (I'm not sure if I'm going to OSCON this year or not yet).

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#12

Another idea on why it could be a problem today...

Alan DuBoff

>Joel,

I have one other theory on this, and why it might have not been a problem in the past, but is today. In the past wood was worked by hand for the most part, for the largest part of the past, certainly.

With power machines today, the dust that is produced is much smaller and of finer granularity than it was in the past. It is actually this very fact that concerns me with the dust of machines, they can spin cutting edges faster than we can ever do as a human, and has such it has some side effects. Possibly this is what causes such a problem in today's shops? I am separating out my power tools from my hand tools so that I can dimension effeciently with power tools and do all the joinery, assembling, and detail work by hand. I always wear a dust mask as I don't have a dust collection system for the power tools.

I am fascinated by the Industrial Revolution, how machines were created, and how things changed for woodworking and other crafts forever. Disston was one of the most fascinating megalomaniacs in the sense that he used the Industrial Revolution to amass his empire, but it was that very Industrial Revolution that eclipsed him with power tools. Fascinating to me. Disston was the Gates of the 19th century, and was one of the richest men in America. Mostly all from handsaws. That in itself is one of the most fascinating aspects of modern woodworking. It was handsaws that built this country, at least in the sense to get it off to a good start. One of my favorite tools.;-)

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#13

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools... *LINK*

wayne anderson

>I've sneezed a couple of times when creating cocobolo dust, but have had no problems other than that in the several years I've used it. I do take loratadine, (generic Claratin), on a daily basis for allergies though. I wonder if that has helped?... -wayne


website

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#14

Re: Another idea on why it could be a problem toda

joel

>I thought about your point on dust but all those million of handles Stanley made from BRazillian Rosewood were sanded at some point in the manufacture. I am aware of no mention of problems working rosewoods until comparitively recently. I can also tell you that woodwind players with rosewood instruments sometimes develope alergies. So my guess is not very dry wood, oil species compared to brazillian etc.

In any case most of these species are endangered and on the CITES list. (there is some farming going on but not I think in cocobolo)

So think of it as Mother Nature fighting back.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#15

Re: workers

ThomD

>One thing about the really old days, in some places, is that there was less polution (though I can't be so sure about industrial centers). (I realize there are real doctors here so this is an idiot's accumulated wisdom only) It seems that once you get really sensitive to something it raises you chemical sensitivity index to a lot of things. Pals who work a lot with epoxy and were resistant a lot to it, but became sensitized over decades report now being sensitive to gas fumes from cars, soaps, all maner of less nasty things they never considered. So there may be a wider chance of tipping over the edge today.

Even today there are people who can work with these things and "never" get sensitive. Urushiol, the Jap. Lac. stuff is very sensitizing but there are those, about 25% who never react to it. Boat builders around here specify in their ads that they want people who have zero realized allergic reactivity. I don't have huge allergy problems, but I will become sensitive to sensitizers over time. Mac. Ebony is like mace to me, at least the dust. When I worked very carafully with guitars I did react to those material, it was more a general malaise, not a specific sensitizer. Indian rosewood, ebony, and mahog, don't do it to me, but on a daily basis I had to totally redo my dust and personal stuff. Airmate. hepa filters and so forth. Makes on wonder how clean they were working at LN.

I don't think Coco is one of the premium woods. I thought it was mostly second rank stuff that snuck under the radar when the traditional woods became unafordable. And even if I am wrong on that point there is the then wood and the now wood. The source is often different. Old wood may have come from logs, new wood comes from stumps, roots, vines, and so forth.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#16

Industrial Woodworking

David Cockey

>Most furniture and tools were built in factories by the late 19th century. And those factories had a lot of woodworking machines. I also suspect that any dust collection systems would be considered rather rudimentary by current standards.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#17

Lots of Brazilian rosewood, not just handles...

Alan DuBoff

>Joel,

Brazilian rosewood was very popular amongst makers, not just of tools, but guitars for instance. The Martin D-28 was brazilian rosewood, possibly one of the most popular Martin guitars, ever. Although the D-18 is also popular and made of mahogany. I think the D-28, D-35, and D-45 and/or variants in between were made of rosewood.

The tool handle rosewood seems to be of a different type though, which is of a lighter color variety. Maybe just my bad eyes. Obviously there are different grades of similar timber.

OTOH, maybe people just had thicker skin in the old days? *lol*

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#18

Re: Another idea on why it could be a problem toda

Ernie Miller

>I like your theroy but don't know how well it works. I have been makin a plane for the last several years out of some sort of rose wood. I am using only hand tools and can only work with it for 15-20 minutes at a time before my hands start to itch and I have to go wash yo and put it away. Maybe I am just intolerant? but I am allergic to very few other things so I wonder? I really don't see that project getting finished any time soon

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#19

Too many variables

James Watriss

>I think it's a tough call. There are too many variables. I'm sure the handles back then were sanded at some point, but I have a feeling that the dust was minimal compared to what gets produced by a CNC machine turning a block into a shape.

Or, maybe it has something to do with the transporation... who knows how much longer it took back then to get rosewood to port. And who knows if they treated the wood differently. I know a lot of the wood I see gets coated so heavily with wax, it's probably not allowed to dry much, if at all.

Or, maybe it's none of these. Maybe it's some other environmental factor. I know there have been a lot more peanut allergies lately, too, and allergies of other types that I'd never even heard of. Maybe it's the case that these allergies existed before, but weren't recognized, but I think it's just as likely that somehow or other, the genetically modified food that people eat now could be triggering all kinds of weird allergy and sensitivity issues.

Or, maybe they just drank more back then, and the wood allergy was nothing compared to the hangover.

I agree that Cocobolo is pretty stuff.. but man, it STINKS when you're working with it. Given that, I think I'll go with the theory that there are other pretty woods in the world, and surely some of them are to my liking.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#20

Re: workers

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>My theory is that back in the day the worker endured the discomfort, or (if he had an option) left the trade. Most of the time I'll bet their health just deteriorated until they became part of the reason why life expectancies were so short back in the day. People had fewer options back then. Did they even have the wherewithal to deduce that it was wood allergies that was causing all of the symptoms?

A friend of mine backed off on a very promising career in cabinetmaking in favor of teaching English in a large part because of his allergic reaction to woods. He blames white pine! What person back in 1750, say four years into a 7 year apprenticeship, could have decided to do something like teach instead of to continue working with wood?

greg

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#21

Re: workers

Joel

>I would disagree. Stanley used rosewood until 1962. Those who have been effected by the allergy, it's not a rash you can ignore - it's extremely debilitating and you end up in the hospital. If it was a known illness that some people got an others didn't I would suggest that there would be more contemporary documentation of the problem - to my knowledge there isn't.

MOst important you should realize that rosewood that was mostly used for tool handles - by stanley and everyone else was Brazilian Rosewood. I don't if that species is as prone to allergies than the Cocobolo or other ROsewoods that are more common now. Then there is the issue of seasoning.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#22

Re: Another idea on why it could be a problem toda

tstock

>I am not anywhere near as sensitized to BRW as I am to cocobolo, and I've worked with BRW a lot more frequently than the coco. One of the reasons coco seems to be more of an issue for me is that at least some portion of the resins are soluble in water, so whatever is in the dust and shavings has a much easier time having it's way with my internals.

I just completed the final coats of lacquer on a coco and cedar small jumbo commission, and it will likely be the last time I use the stuff without a $1000 or so upcharge to pay for disposable coveralls, extra dust filters, an extra box of nitrile gloves (I ended up double-gloving), improved dust hoods, and possibly a better vac for sanding (HEPA Festool or similar). You can talk all you want about how well the stuff scrapes, but eventually you have to do some sanding - if only to do pore filling.

I keep saying 'never again', but the stuff sounds like the best BRW, is reasonably priced, and looks a little like old growth with a bit more brown/orange thrown in the mix.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#23

Re: workers

ThomD

>Not really on this subject, but anyone who enjoyed the series on working in the tool biz in Sheffield that Ashley Isles did, would remember the short life spans of the tool polishers. The got all the money, the girls, and lasted only a short time. Possibly a year or so, more like self-taught fighter pilots than anything I would associated with industry today.

As far as sensitivity is concerned, it would seem to be pretyt self- leveling, you would get sick move onto something else. Like having a strong back. The old guy who used to deliver my Gran's coal in a 100 lbs bag over one shoulder, and had been doing it all his life, just couldn't have had the problems some others get, not sure it would make it into the literature though.

One thing about woodworking is that it often seems like it is dictated by tools, or fashion, etc... Much of it is dictated by the available wood, both species and quality. Who would harvest the crap and send it home by sailboat or steamer, when an endless supply of wood we have only read about was at their fingertips. It's doubtfull the first wood they would harvest would be the stuff that kills on sight. but today we can go after all kinds of junk, nobody is sawing in a pit somewhere to get it to us.

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#24

Re: Another idea on why it could be a problem toda

wilbur

>"I am not anywhere near as sensitized to BRW as I am to cocobolo, and I've worked with BRW a lot more frequently than the coco."

Now, that's just bragging. :@)

Re: LN removed cocobolo as an option for tools...

#25

Lead Maker's Colic,

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Phossy Jaw (Phosphor workers) and Hatter's Disease are a few trade related complaints. Life wasn't easy.

Stephen