Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***
GregB
>I guess the question of training should be answered according to the ultimate goal and how to best get there. If the goal is to build both skills and a resume' for career purposes, the range of educational institutions is pretty wide. There are some well-known extremes, such as the College of the Redwoods and North Bennett Street School. The range continues "down" to community colleges. It seems the high-powered schools, such as those mentioned above, can even be a liability to the graduate. The quality of work produced doesn't come for free; it takes hours. Lots of hours. Many employers would find those trained to accomplish tasks at such high quality not to be hireable. Too much overhead for how the product is priced. (I had a discussion with Steve Latta, a great guy, by the way, at LN's recent show in Oakland.)
I subscribe to Furniture and Cabinetmaking magazine, a British publication. It is rare to read an addition which does NOT profile a school training young craftsmen/women to make high quality bespoke furniture. I'm not talking only about Edward Barnsley's shops, either. There are many such schools in every district. It seems there is more of a market for one-off furniture there.
It seems the survey question must be aimed at we "hobbyists". So... I have visited the College of the Redwoods, attended Marc Adams,gotten to know many really great guys (e.g. T L-N, David Charlesworth)seen much video and read a ton. While reading was the initial ticket, there is no substitute for seeing and then trying. I think the best example of this is reading about sharpening a card scraper or #112. Superb test is great, but seeing, feeling and hearing the process is way better. Being able to ask questions and immediately try the advice is even better.
So the question becomes one of time/money/opportunity. College of the Redwoods would be a dream come true for many. Marc Adams is a blast! The people you meet there, the facilities, Marc and family are wonderful.
I really recommend video. You may wonder why David Charlesworth's chisel use video, for example, could be helpful. Watch it and you'll never make dovetails the same way again. There is knowledge, insight and tradition there which is invaluable. David is also a wonderful and experienced teacher.
I guess we all would like the most we can afford and devote time to. Schools and clubs are terrific. Surrogates are videos and books are always valuable resources. Maybe we should also caution ourselves against piece-meal learning of skills. We need to design and COMPLETE projects, so it all comes together.
Again, I'm a hobbyist, so I do the best I can within my own shop. If I could I'd attend way more formal training.
Cheers,
Greg