Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ellis

>Well, in the better-late-than-never category, here is this month's survey question. I'm interested to know your thoughts on woodworking classes. There are degree programs (e.g., College of the Redwoods), private schools (e.g., Mark Adams), weekend tutorials (e.g., Ellsworth), seminar programs (e.g., Woodcraft and Lee Valley stores) and probably other outlets.

Which, if any, of these types of classes have you availed yourself of?

What do you regard as the pros and cons of the different types of programs? Do you consider them cost-effective for what you learn?

Do you have any recommendations for other channels of woodworking education? What does the future hold?

As usual, we will grind, chop, puree and digest your replies into a column for the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. You can visit previous survey topics in our News & Views department.

Thanks for participating in our survey.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

BobStrawn

>Being of meager resources and being over a 100 miles from a serious hand tool outlet, I find that videos such as Making Traditional Side Escapement Planes by Larry Williams are the most affordable. Most classes are small projects, so they can be completed in a reasonably short time. Doing the same at home and messing up a few times is still less expensive.

Due to my complete lack of physical exposure to other woodworkers, I expect that someday a woodworker with some experience will see me at work and fall on the floor laughing. At least it won't be in a full classroom.

Bob

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

ThomD

>I have gone to courses and given courses. In both cases the best part is interaction with people. I have always learned a lot, but I don't really find that many students actually do the thing they studied afterwards. One may pick up a tidbit of info, but I really get the feeling that a lot of it is entertainment.

Of course many courses involve building something at the time, and they are succesful at that level, but again I'm not sure how big a deal any of that is. Some of the same people show up over and over again and seem at much the same level.

I learned a lot of my crafts pre-video, but when videos came on the scene in the 80s it was a big deal. Early videos I paid for and often waited a month or more to get. I did go through and practice and try to be as good as the presenter, at the stuff shown, at least. That really worked for me, and I still find video is probably the best. I can now rent videos at a much lower cost more often, and to much narrower focus subjects. In some cases I'm just watching. but in others I am pushing forward to get the skills at a certian level, mostly metalworking these days.

TV is also a factor, shows like the Woodwright particularly earlier in the series when he still had the chops were very good though not my prefered period. With all the cable channels there are a lot of people picking stuff up of of TV. Countless people have taken up welding based on all the car and bike shows. I mention it only because it is really feeding people when the shows on TV strike a cord.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

wilbur

>So far, I've mainly gone to classes that are local to where I live. I would love to take a week long class at Marc Adams or Kelly Mehler's schools, but the barrier for me is not really the cost, but the fact that it's a week of vacation that I would need to use while the rest of my family finds something else to do, which is a nice way of saying that my wife would be stuck with two very energetic boys.

Having said that, I have found all of the classes that I've taken very worthwhile, and well worth the time and money. The big advantage that a class has over the internet and videos is that nothing beats hands on experience and face to face interaction. I know that I never understood what a thin shaving from a plane really was until I saw it in person.

Plus, as nice as it is to have internet communication via forums and email, personal contact is just much better.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

"RJ" Whelan

>I have attended four short classes:

The first was at a small boutique woodworking store and the subject was sharpening: the information was pretty good but the main focus seemed to be having everyone buy water stones and sharpening jigs.

The second was at College of the Redwoods when Jim Krenov was still the director. They used to have a two day (weekend) seminar called � � a weekend with Jim�. It was really cool. There was a lot of discussion along the lines of his almost mystical approach to building furniture and cabinets: for me this resonated very strongly as I have a similar feeling about the craft; other attendees were somewhat less enthused because they thought they were going to receive hands-on instruction on cutting dovetails and such.

The third was at a big woodworking show in So. California. One of the big exhibitors had Toshio Odate building a shoji and answering questions. I sat and watched him work for almost six hours. I don�t know that I learned anything new, but observing his hand skills was inspiring, even for one who doesn�t use Eastern tools and techniques.

The fourth was at the same big woodworking show. The show had a schedule of one hour lectures by some pretty big names in woodworking. The one I attended was taught by Garrett Hack (an excellent teacher in my opinion); the subject was the tuning and use of spokeshaves. This was a tool I had largely overlooked. After seeing what Mr. Hack could do with this simple tool I was inspired to tune up the few spokeshaves I owned and acquire a few more; these are now a tool used on almost every project.

I was extremely fortunate in my learning of woodcraft. My grandfather was a furniture and cabinet maker trained the European apprentice system of the early 1900�s (began his apprenticeship at age 12). My early training was one-on-one with my grandfather and those lessons have been the most valuable and formative of my life. Not all of the lessons were about learning actual skills; a great many were about respect for the material and tools and pride of creation.

Which brings me to my own �brief� career as a teacher: I taught a two day seminars on how to cut dovetails. At the end of the first day I had serious doubts about the value of the information I had presented (especially as the attendees had paid be there). After the second day my serious doubts had changed to absolute certainty that I had botched the job badly. Fortunately (for my wallet) there were only seven students in attendance � I felt morally bound to offer a refund of all, or any part thereof, of the fee they�d paid. It says much about woodworkers that none of them took me up on the offer.

My limited experience, on both sides of the podium, leads me to believe that a lot of the value of these types of learning experiences is more dependent upon the teaching skill of the presenter than on his or her actual manual skills.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

GregB

>I guess the question of training should be answered according to the ultimate goal and how to best get there. If the goal is to build both skills and a resume' for career purposes, the range of educational institutions is pretty wide. There are some well-known extremes, such as the College of the Redwoods and North Bennett Street School. The range continues "down" to community colleges. It seems the high-powered schools, such as those mentioned above, can even be a liability to the graduate. The quality of work produced doesn't come for free; it takes hours. Lots of hours. Many employers would find those trained to accomplish tasks at such high quality not to be hireable. Too much overhead for how the product is priced. (I had a discussion with Steve Latta, a great guy, by the way, at LN's recent show in Oakland.)

I subscribe to Furniture and Cabinetmaking magazine, a British publication. It is rare to read an addition which does NOT profile a school training young craftsmen/women to make high quality bespoke furniture. I'm not talking only about Edward Barnsley's shops, either. There are many such schools in every district. It seems there is more of a market for one-off furniture there.

It seems the survey question must be aimed at we "hobbyists". So... I have visited the College of the Redwoods, attended Marc Adams,gotten to know many really great guys (e.g. T L-N, David Charlesworth)seen much video and read a ton. While reading was the initial ticket, there is no substitute for seeing and then trying. I think the best example of this is reading about sharpening a card scraper or #112. Superb test is great, but seeing, feeling and hearing the process is way better. Being able to ask questions and immediately try the advice is even better.

So the question becomes one of time/money/opportunity. College of the Redwoods would be a dream come true for many. Marc Adams is a blast! The people you meet there, the facilities, Marc and family are wonderful.

I really recommend video. You may wonder why David Charlesworth's chisel use video, for example, could be helpful. Watch it and you'll never make dovetails the same way again. There is knowledge, insight and tradition there which is invaluable. David is also a wonderful and experienced teacher.

I guess we all would like the most we can afford and devote time to. Schools and clubs are terrific. Surrogates are videos and books are always valuable resources. Maybe we should also caution ourselves against piece-meal learning of skills. We need to design and COMPLETE projects, so it all comes together.

Again, I'm a hobbyist, so I do the best I can within my own shop. If I could I'd attend way more formal training.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH*** *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I have been to three Windsor Institute classes and worked a week making a chair one-on-one with Dave Sawyer, a preminent chair maker.

Windsor Institute has a well honed curriculum and a staff of experienced chair makers who are also experienced instructors. The sack back class is the mandatory first class and the procedure is taught as dogma (actually this is true of all the classes.) The goal is to get everyone out the door at the end of the week with a completed chair. I found this lowest common denominator aspect to be somewhat annoying, but I learned a lot and thoroughly enjoyed each of the classes. One of the nicest parts of the week isthe comradery of the wood working enthusiast classmates.

Making a chair one-on-one with Dave Sawyer was absolutely wonderful. His attitude was to take as long as was needed, with ample time to discuss alternate methods, different types of tools, advantages of variations in joinery or materials, etc. There are several other chairmakers who offer instruction, many of which can be found listed on the Windsor Chair Resources Web site.

greg


Windsor Chair Resources

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I'm another one who has no access to a school.I can't travel to existing classes and there is nothing anywhere near me.I learn through the internet,mostly Woodcentral,and books.Videos have been a large part of my learning also. One good thing about videos(and dvds)is that you can go back and look again to refresh your mind of if you miss something.I want to attend Mike Dunbar's Windsor chair school in NH and I think it's close enough so I can manage it some day but I need to plan it out. At the monent it's not financially feasable. Some day.--- Jack

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I took a week-long class at Rosewood Studio three years ago, and I loved it. Partly for what I learned (I was concerned beforehand that I would not learn much given the class' curriculum, but I was proven wrong), partly for the indication on how well I was doing, in absolute and relative terms (without comparison it's hard sometimes to gauge how well you're doing), and especially for being able to spend a whole week doing nothing but woodworking (an absolute luxury in my situation). I'd take a lot more classes if 1. I could afford it, and 2. I could spare the time...

The LV mother store is 20 minutes away from my house, but for some reason I never think about checking the seminars that are offered. It's too bad because there's a lot of good instruction offered, and the price is more than reasonable. I'll have to check for those seminars more closely...

Other than that, videos are a good source of instruction, but the only ones I paid for are from Rob Cosman (two of them). His dovetail video is excellent and has had the most influence on how I cut my dovetails (Frank Klausz's video that I got with my 22-580 planer, and Rosewood instruction are the other two influences).

Finally, woodworking fora, Woodcentral in particular, are immensely invaluable as an expert resource in woodworking...

DC

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

wilbur

>One other thought came to mind about woodworking classes:

My wife and I used to go swing dancing/Lindy hopping, before the kids came along. We've taken some classes here and there, from weekly classes when we were first learning to an intense all-weekend in depth advanced seminar. In every class, there always was time spent on relearning the "swingout". The swingout is the basic step in Lindy hop, and regardless of how long one might have been swing dancing, the prevailing thought was that no one did a swingout so well that you couldn't benefit from a refresher.

The reason I bring this up is that I've heard many people say that they wouldn't take a woodworking class because it seemed to be "too basic", and that they already knew how to make a dovetail/turn a bowl/use a tablesaw. Maybe this attitude is a bit misguided. I'm not sure that anyone can cut a dovetail so well to the point that there isn't something new they could learn about it.

Well, maybe not if you're Frank Klausz or Rob Cosman. :@)

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>I'm not sure it is because of my woodworking incompetance or that I enjoy socializing with other woodworkers, but I have taken a number of classes over the last 10 or so years. I've probably averaged 1-2 classes a year. Some are one day classes in tool making such as a spokeshave, travisher or bow saw, and some have been week long classes about a variety of subjects. I have enjoyed all of the classes and learn something at each of them. The interaction with the other students is usually as educational as formal material given by the instructor. My favorite classes have been week long classes at Arrowmont School for the Arts and Crafts where there were a number of classes in different types of crafts going on at the same time.

Another venue that I have found enjoyable is the seminars about woodworking subjects. I have been to several Working Wood in the 18th Century put on by Colonial Williamsburg and they have all been educational and inspiring. The Society of American Period Furniture Makers has regional chapters that meet a couple of times a year that presents seminars by the members that also have been very good.

Lastly, I belong to a local woodworking club that has monthly meetings for general subjects and also an offshoot group of hand tool enthusiasts that meet once a month. This has also been an enjoyable way to socialize with woodworkers and learn more about woodworking.

Jim Crammond

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#12

Corey Megal

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Corey Megal

>Great question, Ellis. I have taken weekend workshops offered by our local guild, week long classes, and one day seminars here and there. Of the three, the guild offered workshops are the best value. I don't have to travel, and I usually get some pretty great information. The most enjoyable class I have taken has been at Rosewood studio in Canada. I took a week long class with Garrett Hack, and built the table in the picture below. We didn't get the entire thing done, but the parts were roughed out, and the tricky joints were cut and ready to assemble by the end of the class. The important thing for me was that I came away with the information, not the project.

The other week long class I have taken was at Marc Adams school, Garrett was also teaching that class on using hand tools. It was a great class, and taught me plenty. I didn't care for the huge production like environment at Marc's school, it seems a lot like a factory. Even still, the class was very well done, and I did enjoy myself. I don't mean to knock Marc and what he's done there, it's just a bit too much at times.

Finally, back in 2000, I took a Windsor chair class with Mike Dunbar at his place in New Hampshire. Lots of fun, and now I can make a sack back chair.

Thanks for the great forum!

Corey


img

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH*** *LINK*

CONGER - The Irish diaspora in Munich

>I have taken method and project oriented courses at a small woodworking school ( http://www.kurswerkstatt.biz/ ) here in Munich (1.2 million). This school manages to compete with the very large adult education school run by the city of Munich ( http://www.vhs-muenchen.de/ ), and the other small craft, e.g. smithying / metalworking, schools.

The method oriented courses (hand tools, sharpening, design...) were really informative, and supplemented the skimpy skills I already had.

The project oriented courses were a little stressy. The spectrum of skill levels and expectations of the other 'pupils' often made personal progress 'patchy'.

Currently I attend a course (weekly) where everyone is doing something different (chairs, table, cupboard, handtool skills...). I am building a ukulele (long story). This course is perennial, and so the atmosphere is like a 'club' where the theme is simply 'woodworking'. The school proprietor provides his skills and knowledge to those who need help... else everyone just 'gets on with it', using the workshop facilities of the school.

Value for money? Woodworking is a hobby for me, and I feel that there is no way real way to quantify value for what one does for relaxation / entertainment.

I see no immediate change for the school that I attend. It is very 'hands on' so the impact of the WWW is relatively low. Modern media (DVD...) is sometimes used to learn (alternative) methods from those who can not be present.

The picture is from my last 'course'... the 4 sliding dovetails were a bear... and yes... I know the dovetails are poorly balanced, and I often ask myself 'what is it good for?'. This cupboard was largely built with hand tools. All the surfaces are planed (no sandpaper)... the joints (no metal) are all visible (nothing to fear!). This was (still is... it is waiting for the final finish!) a fun project, at a school where I really enjoy learning, thanks to the proprietor, Roland Heilmann.

-gerard-


img

Some more 'school' projects

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

roninkokomo

>I have taken 5 or six classes at Marc Adams school. I literally cannot imagine a better experience. The faculty has been uniformly excellent

( except that Marc himself and Brian Boggs are excellent PLUS) The facilities are terrific and the food and friendliness of the staff are really great.

I believe this to be a great service to the craft.

Ron

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#15

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Some years back, when, somehow, I seemed to have more time than I do now, I went to a couple of the big woodworking shows and attended one-two hour seminars by Ian Kirby, Del Stubbs, and David Marks (the last, ironically, was then and still is working within ten miles of my house). I found them illuminating demonstrations of what was possible with tools. As a part of my overall, mostly self-taught learning? Hard to tell whether I'd have gotten there without them or not, but I appreciated them at the time, and still remember some of the lessons imparted.

Lack of money has prevented me from participating in the more extensive schooling.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#16

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>When I had a company, and thus income and business clients to see around the country, I attended 3 3-day workshops for hand tool basics:

1. Toshio Odate's class on Japanese shoji making that was also a how-to-use-Japanese-tools workshop in Connecticut

2. Isai Inomoto's class on making Japanese dai

3. Homestead Heritage's finishing class

4. At that point I worked for a while on my own, supplemented with many dvds and videos, which was fine; but I wanted to know how the experts built chairs. I took a Homestead Heritage week long tutorial on making a Mission style rocking chair. I'd have preferred taking a regular class, but they wouldn't let me unless I also took their hand tool series, which would have been a massive waste of time and money for me at that point.

5. For specific/specialized techniques such as carving and more advanced things, I've learned via dvds and videos and books, piles of all three.

6. And of course there've been all the online communities, members of which have mostly been very encouraging and informative.

Pam